dsU nzh; lwp uk vk;k sx
Central Information Commission
2 ry] foxa ^c^ / 2nd Floor, 'B' Wing
vxLr ØkfUr Hkou / August Kranti Bhavan
Hkhdkth dkek Iysl/ Bhikaji Cama Place
ubZ fnYyh 110066 / New Delhi - 110066
Case No. CIC/LS/A/2009/001059/SS
Dated: 25.10.2011
Appellant : Shri Naresh Chander
Respondents : CISF, New Delhi
ORDER
This 2nd appeal dated 20.08.2009 is filed by Shri Naresh Chander against
C.I.S.F., New Delhi, relating to his RTIapplication dated 30.06.2009.
2. Through his RTIapplication dated 30.06.2009, the appellant had asked for
certain information pertaining to reinstatement of CISF personnel who were
dismissed from service for their involvement in Bokaro Mutiny.
3. CPIO, vide his reply dated 15.07.2009, declined to disclosed the information
on the grounds that the CISF was an exempt organization u/s 24(1) read with the 2 nd
Schedule of the RTI Act. The CPIO was not bound to provide such information which
it did not pertain to the allegations of corruption or human rights violation and does
not fall within the ambit of the proviso to Section 24(1) of the RTI Act.
No. LS/A09/1059/SS : Naresh Chander vs. CISF, New Delhi Page 1 of 3
4. Comments of the respondents have been obtained on the appeal petition. In
their letter dated 16.09.2011, respondents have informed that the information asked
by the appellant was regarding reinstatement of CISF personnel, who were dismissed
from service for their involvement in Bokaro Munity. A similar petition of the
complainant on the subject matter, had been heard earlier by the Commission and
disposed of vide CIC’s order No. CIC/WB/A/2007/00424 dated 14.07.2008.
5. On perusal of the RTI application and comments of the respondents and also
having regard to the facts and circumstances of the present case, the Commission is
of the considered view that the information sought by the appellant does not pertain
to allegations of corruption or human rights violation. Therefore, no interference is
called for on the part of the Commission.
6. Matter is closed at the Commission’s end.
Sd/
(Sushma Singh)
Information Commissioner
Authenticated true copy
Sd/
(D. C. Singh)
Deputy Registrar
No. LS/A09/1059/SS : Naresh Chander vs. CISF, New Delhi Page 2 of 3
Copy to:
1. Shri Naresh Chander
S/o Shri Gopinath,
Ratan Pur, P.O. Dyodha (Umdi),
Distt. Kannoj (U.P.).
2. The Public Information Officer
Dy. Inspector General (Admn.),
Directorate of C.I.S.F., 13,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road,
New Delhi – 110 003
No. LS/A09/1059/SS : Naresh Chander vs. CISF, New Delhi Page 3 of 3