High Court Karnataka High Court

Mr Nazir Hussain Qurashi vs Mr Syed Ahmed S/O Syed Abdur Rahman on 16 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Mr Nazir Hussain Qurashi vs Mr Syed Ahmed S/O Syed Abdur Rahman on 16 July, 2009
Author: Anand Byrareddy

3
{N THE HIGH C91} RT if}? KARNATAKEX 2%? Bi”x}~§C}A§.f}RE

DATED TFHIS THE 16:}: i}A’x’ GE }U}.§’f’ 213%’)?

BEFGRE:

THE H(13N’BLE MR. }US’T§.éI31E ANA;sx::> §s#;*RA;RE§§¥” T

HOUSE RENT RE”v’ISI{}N ?§”1′:*:’i<::N 2~z4;j%;i35%<3'1¢2i3:;§_"3;k

BETWEEN :

Ekrir}-1a;¢ir Huggain QuI”d§’}”££,”~..’_ _
“‘:’:3.i,at€ M:3_i1a;::m’;ed H§;de’:’r* ‘-

Aged £:§3e’:1;fg5a’i~.j§ié;1§*:2:_, 3 V *
§.es;i§§§;_jg- at ‘£\§§>..f%:’.i , E”1’fVVEV*’i:>_ii:2*_,,V.”‘
Opg P T {i0!§3 :}f;.*;?JVea:*»j .,
Gem. Engi§3h’– S::E3:,sg31f’ if’ . b V ~.

Nggavzgra Nizifih Raaii ” .

Venksztsshpuré ._ ‘

._ B.%s,:;5:;é3}:1te’–» 56ff}’iL”*«é£;*+2;v_ %%%%% H J ,. PE€Ii’Z’fi{3″£\EE:iR

Shri_v4R.E$i;€i§x_a::na ikeiaiiikmjnzza Swamy, Adm, }

APE

. ._ _’ ‘ ._Evh: §};e::-e’§ zaghfiifid
Sfr>;.S;;$<§ 'Abd"s:r~Rs-.hman
V' ' — f5x§;$d"gba§ul 3?' ya-airs?

. S%z::%1p”N0«3,, béew Time Shay,

Gfoutid ¥73§:”r{>:”,,. §§¥mf: §§ui¥t 0:: Site ?~§0.23 _._

.'(§’a§rEé£)n of Sy,’Nu.§6,r’3)
‘ fjlpp. P & T C<)E{:zx}-2

Nata! (Sam 'iizégiish Sc§1L

-‘NJ

Nagavam Main Read,
Vefikateghpura,

Bangaiun: M 56% 945. .. R§:sp:)1~z2§§}:2~éT _

{By S}1ri,M.A.Huma§zu:;, A¢§v.,_)

Thite House Rm}: Rcvisiug i’r:ii f.§Vg_>z*’£’.i;_:.~: ;5§1e.:.£_j;;fzc;i?:~r »V1*”§;4′:.ié:iiV:é11VV
45(1) ef the Karnamka Rent 153:,” ‘–£999 agaiarést ‘theVV.j’::d.g;mez1t ‘

£}t5€:I”£’:f¢ eiaifid i8.1,28{}7,, §asse:d”‘in”3’:~'{RC ‘}E»;.;.1’t3=3_.?;£3f2vQ¥3S an fixer,
fiie sf {Em XV Addiiianal SI’¥i&i§___.£T.1é:”..:._:$:3r:.-;;;__._ h;:ige.VE%€Ea;;:§ E-£313 unit
Banguiurr: {SCCHTNQi§}},’~~..;ii:s;1*ii:~;sii2g223$-._p::iiiim’:A flied unésy
Seeiism 2′? {2} {3} 635 {r} sfifi. , .3-Ea’: j.s€§.–,ff: ”

Tfiib: piziiiiané ;:{3I;1i:3g;’13sri fbé’: §ii=7§% ?§ay, the; C1mz’i mafia

the fciiswing :~»: ‘ ‘;;j,.- -. .L

Hsarif C:;é’ufiée§ i iE:f:*”§.hé pa:iii2.m:«:r zmd iha respundcaé,

.. «§:I”3V}c’~;:3-r:::s¢:i:§; gzfiiéiiug is by iizrs, iancfiorai zgmzking Ea} cixafiengtz

Eixgfixxxmivssaé’2s,;_£’i§;c r;wi;:iien ptziiiiezn E1; éhe irizgfé cuuré,

‘V2. Ti;-r.%:_ :i%:;:¥s arr: £329.: L325 ps:%.i§<,§nc¥-Eagzziiurai prsiérreai 2:

. 'g:;st:i.iiiam" p:3fiL;%§r $£:?§.:~§§{)I1 Z7(2){:;{} am} if} :2? 31¢: Euiamzaéaiaa Rem Azsii,

{ixc-reinafitzr mfsrrtzé Eu 3:; ':§?2c E999 Ac? fur hrreviijy} . 1?; was

case mf {he peiiiiuzwr iizai the rs:-zpendszni, win: is $2: Egnané in

" rcspesci {sf ihcs paiiiiun sat-hgiuis prtzmiscés, an as munihiy §'t:}'§§ mi'

3
23,325.54-, was 2; chmzsic defazziier in gayzncni :3? rrrznia am? ii}:

pciiiienczr was z;m1s£raén1::(.i in $36 a case in SC iS?§?2C§f2{EG2

whzircbga ii wag: Lie£.:::rm§t2ed ihai. éim mni. Wm: aé E?.s_4?,.’i.»’:_~ ‘;;z;~::i’ ~I'{“VZi.§V§”ii:FI

ané fin: pciiiiuncr iilcrrsibrts Wm rcsirzkziing his 3;? “$53: i?..§ ‘~Rs.r13Z5’5f{- h’

per munih ans} éimé Lht: respsrndczné [wan jg!’ ‘£..1ff’E’f*.’31j§!’.H.j{:Ii§.’,?3:’if2
25.1 2&3} sgnxvards $31” at pafiarci 9?. fifty mgmihs.

Ii swag fizz: peiiéimrmrks 4.:-aim’: £§”i:_:«.:i he haei”i–:-:;;A:ze'<.i 3 Eegai :m%.§a:t:
daisd 22.6.2&f3E, caiiirz 1' émaférx fim fr;:;-;rm":'–:.¢,§»:::*:"i;~E.–.:::i?a:i by Eh: mspuneitzni. in:-z§2§iJ.: {sf

haxsing I’cs::§w;:& ifie”‘;£;:is§ “::Q§.%a:s and inspéie :3? Eiruz p£:§i§i{:>m*;r

_ é€m,a_§3dVin’g pa}:;:£;::n; uf arrears. 32$ §3m::r at,-iaimeai iimf: his had

€v{.Ii.:r«. ;§augi1.iVr::3j;§”~–:«z_z2-:3 ihmtz 59:22:; ami ihai ii: fast, his incumc is

it:>;A:ii§7§.i£:i:,é11i.’V.i;:2 Viasétgi 3 capgnfgériabia iifa and ihwrsibra, Em rcqagircs

iim :s:2§i.$7c§xezi::§s pmpsriy Ea augnzeni §§§:~:: i§:s.:uz:;e $3}; r;::;§ab§§s§3.%::g 3

~ E.~L;3iL1*:z:;3s and pmpzjss-mi fig’) gm:-up a Puhfie: {fig x

“3 “flea ms} éizgrsziézre,

” ‘ ‘ ” £§1 a; psii.§3¥=.:n.

Tiztr raspuzxzficni izaxfing {zsziermi a.§:;;2@araz2<.:::: hmi rczsiéatémi Q25

geiéiiain and the rt:spm"1&€:g camégrrnziaai lhaé. he was: e:2§rz"};i::g a:-:2

3:…

w2ai.::h 11-:p;~:£:’ war}: in 3 smafl piaaazc than 23122:; 343% §_m~__}§i::}*.’g:*:{i

been payirzg an exsrbiiafii mm {:25 Rs;.i’Zi.E;{j§i’.’…’.3}’?s,’E’a5Ek’£§I:’i ~£S

manaiaimryr itfldflf srscfiezl 2′}’:f2f2§§§:, w-5;»; .__mé:.;;r ” i137E’:’i~~’.,V.1vé{:i”‘ iv; ifaéi’

respajndeai and ihaé Eh’: {3€:£iié;.2:’§£é;f-. Vtaking 3:?»-fanifige cf ihe
circumsiansc ihai has End 22¢’-.>’.T<:§" iS::tie-gi r§;:.2i£:+£_iv.;€:x:{:ipis in parapet: (sf

333%: rtrni pafii £0 :§*:i;1:§.V§_i't§¥::¥:i;z1: kite ii«:n€: aha: {hertz its an': aaixramzez

of i?.§;,?,€),~C¥3a;'3;r'- .:-é;.§_s».z§.~;¥.'2&–_r;<§§'é'2g %w–:::';.s %f::::;" pt:iéi§£3fi£?f~E£§II£fl£)I"£i and

iE2cr2:§é3i:;: qgassiiézi.Vs.af"arr$;,gri:-..sgf–rmé {Eggs moi a:r"i:~:c:. Furéixtte", éhai
fin: gsiiéigzrisiztr Ems $:%c,*2,H:":;:i»–:«;f?i2;z1;':J:~; {E§iL§*:I" his :.i§::~;ps,:»:s-:a.§ anci Efsémzgix

samgfiazfifi ii'3§E€:2é"2<ac2mi fimm iimt: Em iimrs, his has éraeiucicai Rash

';:;§:§an§_s_..V"'§'§:i;:AV"wg3::§:.é izgdicaiez ihai figs pciiiimner hag my rsai

3'€{;ui*:*§n3m§§–§–@3f iiiqe psiiiiun prcm§:.-$55

€}n}_E,§:e bask; sf QR: piésaziings, Eh: Eriai cmzri §}fiS aéémsseé

'Vibe §$mz2:: xwhsiiser the gcéiiizan was hm} 133:" wani :.:-1.5 a xmgégsze Lazéziczr

: Sefzaziimx ,?.'?{2}(.a} :3? figs ;'a¢.:i.. A5Q%;:i;:»I1

pciitiurz bttibxrs this smart in CR?’ 3é,r’2OG4.

During that przrzdency mi’ Sim: rcvisimz p£.;E.i£i~;:;t; “£.§:g:.T}3éi§§§a:ierM”»

herein had siaicd befurc this cmzriv-iE1é:1′–¥%1e’ pr;ii.¥j§}5:z%;r Vzn.:§§; Be ‘

gmnied i§%3t:ri§f in 333;: 33:; c.vic£iun pcii§,_§:3s–3_ L1Il(i’:3.I”‘~v.iii¥3.

having regard in 231:: Ecgai pQsi£ig191; ;:i’1a:,% an h;i3ii’VV($¥Jl’§i(i Iml

have been enleréz-fined Srr:’:§’§ Having bani;

deciarcd. Hence, {he pc:{i£i<.)1*i Q23 juaigmeni 9.?

the Szmiii C.3u:ié:iév.*{3;;_£i,:’i sva 3£”:s;Vr;:§~aA:¢:§;it:. The psciiliurwr was grzmimi
Iiberiy in ;:§1=:i?3;<' a1'1"::%vi'?s;:£E:.:-.13."p§;:£iEicm_

_§'?I*:<':.iriai Cmgéi ubsezrvcd ihaié sitxse £312 §t::é%im:$r ha-:1 isxucsi

2:. 'ieggai _Vnuii£:,g«–._§vU pay armars mi' mm r:2»,:r§§::r, nanzuziy, as an

22.3208} 'séiiri 'i§*1£§:"<::2:I'ie:§, haé fiisd :1 Smaii Caamas Suii gcaiaifig

j ejcm:E3i3s:znVL.«Vi§'::.e 53223: {if aaziiuzs {hat areas purszzani is iizc nagiice

'.. ;«:§;i}:,¥i:E«–i§.:sc:§f {mi with EEK: judgmené and ;§<;:<.:r:;-.2-ct :25 {he Smaié Causas

' Cigziri. Thur:-3 was hence no eausra a:s§a<:.$.i;3r2 undtsr Eiw i§'§§' in

flu: abaciaw :3? as fmgfi rmiizsrs; zmciiar zeszciiaan 27(2){a} emf tire: E§3§§

Ami and Ems accerdingiy ?u::§d fihai ihe pciiééun see-iiifig cxxiciimn

3

£3

purcizastsr ufiizt: gri..>pe;:,ri§; was zzegaéczai ?;;vy’ ihv: “;:L.*.LEI’L em firs: gmamsfi;
ihai no £}:sih«;~:r sigzps had Emu}: §a§n }Z’?f:§§§§€}.’-.–~’i~-.’+4~”‘e{‘i§§:’-.’ “§:§§.§,}€h5f.?£§..

IE, it: this which is under cimiiczrzgcs.

3. Sri Subba Raw, wmgici azazigiszzi-a_§ 322: L323″;

ihuugh the maiéer was p«t2:1<.§iz:g,'f:%g:7"'=:2~:t:r 2-,2.21«.yé::;..tr*,{ _"i_:§2é"'$3t:iéi§i::+z2a:z was
me: affurdeci an wpp<3§§.:'h:;iiy :2?Er:r:e§2j§s§::'g;._c:aéi;§m1éi¢13:; i..hr.-.2 fmyéing

ihai flit: ;3¥:'§%i.i.g;':«:;s:§ i§?a:;_seg'king _{L€7<§§h§:«,tEs ii}: ynaiiar. Wixcza as per
this L?!'£.ié;§'{' Sheci; VE3::{%;~:::.s:i1 ihai. éht: p<.:E§i§;enm" was Srsckizég an

a&j_ has resuiimi is:

V ‘ .miSs:a?:*iag§éjLa3§ice azeaupimi wéiiz fin: Else: iftmi {he paiiiiunm” haai

.pf;3i§;.:;;.gg£§._i§1§;{“mt’§gé§:z:§ agmemcni 9.3: gait: beibm §’§§:’§.”:£3E£l'”§ éuring

E36; gciaéafit:-ztéig-I :3? ihc §2§*:-xcaé §Z9£:§§§.?;€.}§1. §?\f§1<:z§ ii 'W233 fmzzzéi Ligazi film

" ;::c:,';§E§:}sier imii moi pgigi tile :°<sa;£.¥é:;é§£- sézasrgg» aizgijss an ax": agyscaxgni,

A"–Vx:£?£'£ch illifieéiiéfiii iha: p<)s;~:t;::;-:5im: was zigiitrcfegi :m::§a:§ ax":

agrsanzczné, fhés C-sjuri fiazsi ziirccied fizai animss giuéjg mé §.~§:2a§§jg are

paid an firs éw:;m;:::nL E12: same: umuiai gm: a:.:<.:c:§:§s:<§ £12 I::'ez%g§s;z1:.,:€: gr

23

‘:}
Ezemn sci Eihiéiiiii E3}; {his Lifiiifi ami E.E:.’«,2.E havézag zzééaigieai finaiiijs, a

fissh neiium W33 2; xziusi uzzaier s.ee:ii~:m 27{2}(::1} ami 232;: 32iET§if.i”~§;&£§§S£’

izziu ezffrzzi fimrn 3?} E.2§{}E, ea.-;§1§<.:§2 £3 nxzgezifi L?'/$4:-.;é§.""§E,V:§'_£':-?:~E-.'\
this ncgiice 25; EXEIEFQEE i1'-='3~.

:3. G11 ihcss rig-£33 £:£!I1i§11ii§}I§1S$;.._§i”£f:éfL§é”E” i§§::”£§n{;:éng sf éim

iriaf esakgifé E.T§V::’:’%.r§:::ia31;, us: £§;a:: m2g:££3zzing, éhai

by xsiriug 135;’ ihé géatéiiégaef havizzg fikai an ztariitr ¢:’t.r’§£.’§§£,§§} pwsiiifign,

1?;-1:’ :§:aI:zéi’L1i::«;§§A~.§;pc::! éésésif am: am} ii caéaié :m{ be §§{€:”3:§€:i€§ Ema

Lé;*:r:s’.i’g.;::A¢E§::;._2m§é.,;§.& reagmzns its Em zzraégfizézzésai wééiz rsifiyazégca Eu» 32¢

¥i’€.3′:”i*;2°§£3I”1.;H ‘;’:§i:::i.i£m §.?{2}{a} $55 fiféiracieai Esrfizinaiaiz’ E2}? §’§i5.é§:3*’

” .,;%e§+,%::;:z2;:§

(2)
{3} tizai fiie 1&2:-Eiaiéi Eras ::e§:§se;’ géaié 2:9: §:::m§c:~.:*e€E I:._§:§-.

wizevée zzrf me a:’3t’~::a2=:”:-.: §”.”i§r:a !”r.:”:ifi aszé e;>*:’::::;1 isimzgars

Z

Eegaiig; :=am;>a:sr:*aE3i¢ %’§’s:>:i§§ Fgim zviéixési iwa mtj’,-:”§’&.*;~’:
fi*€:>::: Ilka giaie «gm w’§:i:;;:%2 a s:::>?;ic:: 1:3?” éaixzaiagi ‘§?;>§’
pa;§gz_::::::1′: ‘am. Emiéx §.é§?!”sf€*.1t:”:;i in
iiéfi m;§;1:’:e:”‘ p2*:::=¥i:;Ee::i in §§€s£:E§{>i’: §.€?n’5:- {pf £326 “?:’a;:2ai{1:f

L3f?I”!.}§}fi’§’j£ 335.8715 E832:

Pm”siiz:1:a.<:§. that a iezzam sfiaié mt Eta: ezxiitieci * '

ix-r:ef.§i. cf :i%c.¢ £33: zizr; i3$§’1£i§4.}2’s;§’.4′:ii::s;§s~;e§*:’ 2]’

ihig ciazzsesir mixers, fiavizxg :;>Et}?;:1iz’2e,=;s;i s;s;::e;;§§V.é”E;>x;+§iif:ve§§tww

*;3:¥c€: ha :’:;::’sr,”x’:e;=: if 311:: g>femi:~.sés,js. a;;ij,aii*s»:::.2:;’§<:s;:r:«{

cie2fa.u§i in fine fg::z:eym¢::i e§ fflfit ':';_1::iV. -a::si§*:azj

pa.§ia13E&i:;r"i::=;§e2:i I;3f€',§T:tI}:'éé:':. ;.. ' —

?.r:::"a2i':;§%.i:s;E _f'£::*L§'m:f fi1?_:£s.i ::~«2§¥s;<::'e in 2: :.s:':;:»e;e3:;-'.».a'i§_:<:" £2522'

Weviéiiimz Egézaégéi'~-e.i;é:,iE::: §§,§'I§:¥.§:1§§ :sg§ee:ifie::§ in f.§'ai.;a:

€'§?5;E1_§:§€,< iéxe-fs'3i:§:':E'.§$::L' 'in; in: aviciegi, six: (I<;3ut*§ :'~é§:£s.§§

'~:rT:1;2:.§:e:V'&;::_V:;::*<§e::' rgiimzzriizsg '£_§';:.a-…'§;s§2a§':?; ii': mcaie fthe

V' '::'é2::i:§as; titzigxsas Exes ? 32%; '£43 éfézsat Ea;§€:'§.::::*6é.§iS.:
§ ‘ A, E

§:é§§i§’§ witiésiz: me m_e::§::§*: :3? *§:§’§¢ z;iz::i’.r: egaf €31′:§:3:’,

3;: ‘§§T§:§13t§i ;;:3§€:1;§:fie:i 3%; ‘£§’§s*.”- gate 33; §’§5§§§£LZ§”!; it was-, East

gyéiaifi f?;* iixe ;>$§’§«.}(§ far §*§?:§§;’-E {Egg a:*:*aa:1:’; of ‘§’€2″§€.

‘ f&§}t.’§ aéiixgr §I.’ha§’g€$ warm iegaiify :’=e;f;e;:’2:c’r:a3:§¢ §§°{s§:”;

hitia, i.§1siu::§§::;;; ihe g}«:::’-issci saéhseqaezsi :’i:s’::*a~3::> iifg} is;
filii em’: caf zine xsmtltiz ;::’::sv’i;:zus; :0 ‘tiizai §”f¥ 2s:§:ic§T:

payzxiaxxi Q1’ <§¢§3«.::s::.i'i E5; rmztsia; "

8

-nub
|i\J*

azan jwsé be pressed ink) :sn ifiéi£’££.xa»'<3:tz§£}.aiE%§;":§ 2i—-é§:au':'=;§:

<21' asriiun fix" ihis cxsuri uniy if ii is is-.:.::;m:1:,§__ v¥.r'i.£_h :"c:i'e::f;;:z§::: firs: {§1:e'–~:'«':£:E_

is 2.1 uarruw View is.) wizish ihiséx,L§€;2;2rE aazé:!..:_i;i"ATn'=;3i .";1d§:=::2°s: ms:

subscribe. file pmviss-0 m;~u~§;_i Ecgigi Qézeg i;,S'§.§1é::: ssisw, :ia:n:~:§y, $313.:

if the itznani ha$'5§§–;~:<3; fizz izwgiisféi mi a m}iis.:r:, n':;¢zi-zflézxg a damésné Fm"
zzrrearx mffizixi ai argy }:1%mi'::%,_ £3§{i1r2?:c:. ié is; 2:0: warmzzémi iiéai {hats be

21 3m:;§152£i {i{}§i£;t:"'3:1';_SV{}faf as gush a demand fer arrears :3? mm. is

£::.!m:en3t;{§;..§<§t$ia:s;«:, i§:r.:: View 22139::-n figs éim Erizé ezmeré £§;;«;E ihezrcz as-*:;:$

IR: fmiicév §;u3'I'-._p{§rg§Gscs '43? Srsciian 2'?"2"'{a} azazzmyé bs stugiainézszi.

j Tfig j§£»;§.gf§:;@z:V§w:s:
“fhzr appcriiani in Ehaé gzaszz wag; c,:ee,:m:=,:§jg§§2g a image: as 3

ififiafii. :3? iht: rt::g;}a>n&sni. Titer: §2c=e§ssa txsas g,cwc2″ncé§ by E22:

8

‘£3
1
1

prazexzéaissns cf {hes JPi’§’§:z11purar}i}C-a}::§m§ £2? Ram azgzgi §?:’4,:”;’¥..’:-§§%.’§°E}

Ami, i§3«=’I=?. A mwiécc zms iggutsei $33 5:23 fssar i’:,3{>3; 2:_?.!:3:§£.§’§,*%’£§’:§:’~S§ii’i*%”f:’.;é,_

am Eliza. B. was :3. §.§£_}3§§p£’.?S§§f:3 ;m§%a.:t: :.;§};{§;;; ibis $15-%§’é” ‘:1:::!i’§;é2:;; 3;”

é::man.e:§ fan” é£3’§’*::£1I’:<; 0? mm ami :,::'2z§r:r:"5s$s:;'§:§§~:" i{§éé_ fi';€:VV '§z=%g:§'$:§_§:r

{sf Pmpatrijg Asst, E882, §crr§:i:33§.i_z*;g,.. hig é{:n;am::§g 53:1 ~~:::<:j§:éz"}-= :3'? V

31:: reqiaisiéc;-: pmiuafi. fifac éic:i§%x;a§:%,f2§.~§i;g;ps:§§a§§i'{v§£.<i..;§a::i s.:-;:mp§}x'

wiiia Eha: nuéicc. A suit; w::isT'J:Ei¢;i.7}§::*:r ;§€;«s:§zf;'1é;%::<:?i smai r<:a:uwr"§: :3?

arrezirs. 'E"§1¢ :;;:§é§»..x».«;";g;3 :i€:~a:r«:v.5é&V§_' .i'§;¥'i'éip§Vi§t;2;§ {fled against ihai daarrse
by if}: &c.fé:_tv.}:c1rii-x§is::s"c§is:'I3Vi§:£:ss::;E; .'§"§2erz:a.£'is:r Eher: ;_i:.m;i i2;3<.w:n in éhcz zg.;3pu::a.§ 21:-gs T§.§";;§§

;'r.:*::3ei',E_:};'*.§:"V iE}Q.rI"€ flax)' '§.§1,¥"9';.'€v Ifzumizzé W223 magi aim; by him wiwn fin:

:1£::'ai§-st; ::%;rw.:{§.<;:ér§i_1i:r1 in Q}: fimi énsianceg, 3%.}, éfizre wax no eiefzigzii

x.%.f§¥:§1i'::§§:<:'s:§'§;3;1i§Iig £3? file §;':2xsi§ie2":s of 'he: §3i2:~;i;:s3′; §2:.-Lei Erect: §:?§}§::i§§1f.”:£% by ihiz: pi-c2§:}iifi’–

rczepozgzitzrzi in exmzuiémn cs? iim éccrw. Afistr if}:-: €:;:zz;:z:§{‘s z2,;f2p::2:.§

@

-…«
«fie.

wam aiiuwr.-xi, an appiécaiiun was fiiicazi fer :’é.:;~:i.é§::iii:zr; ;2;:3}.{§4:§’ ::z:;s:.i§;>;2′ é

biz}; of file Cmic: mi’ Civéi }}rucedz:re,;’;i§i}SL« ¢_’s?%§§_1§i;’: Z?;.§_S’-:-:Vgs§§§’£a3f¢é§i2¥z

was pcmiing, {inc piaiz3iiiY£§i3:(iT.a £}::5§:..s:££§ aga§;¥.:§.i.£§:’a: éc:f::z:’:i:«if1’£’

seeking sjmtimeni zgai’ iiée: :1s}fc:n’§i’a:g:..§’i§;{>ug§1* .£}fi§::.€: W110 iezgai
ncuassiiy and prragmi fiérifidig ;:;?_;;.;§§?:ééV;§§:..V__:§s;~;rgin§.ng”35;; eiafisredagzé
fmm gesiiing resiii;;_§ic;m {if 5.3:’ éhez £i€:£:§S§i}f§
in iiw seczrnd uv§2′:;1f’:¥§: sgsugizi iv E3: gcsi €3″:.”£:I”
on 31:: g3:r;2§:§2€(§…, Ezszui, in a f{3§f§S§§}I} §§§rr.:-if

tzmicr :;£’.,ci§c;§32– “?¥i:7′.g:§i§:~v:» ‘_A£_.;.i;vv«-;g;’::2::§,e:.§ pe:m’:i§:::~;i:_23z is; EEK: Eazzgiiayrai

undrsr its Lsziigr :;§;:.§.:i;§ i§,3f;=

Mi A

,_ Etaii 52:: $53}: :§:.:»£§§::: zszéajiaz 3-:r3£_:i§i,.-E

lié 5.2? EEK: ‘f€’1’an$£3;::3″_g_3£’ §*’mp<::ri}; X5252, 3832 wzig g,;'§'2:s;2 is/2 £15

'._é3§1V:'2*:4;V§;::1.iV_i::3T£3.§§i'a:i§:2§; his E<::zzan;:};., zvhicir w:;;.~.»: sgezmgfii Ea i"§: gjecimmi ami ééxai he ‘W’é:§&-Z Emgaiijz sniéiied is z”s:::;£§is:§im1.

—. TE”m? saéi sf Eize iiaznaiiegarii was éismiascii mainiy «gm éiry: gmamzi iéaagé

\. i§”!t: §:~:in§£§}’§1§;;;sc3§ arms in Q:~;se:~:si{::§ LE {:2} £313: ‘Lima amf gm §§€”:
I3 ,

m§;§c.i’:;§° cjmfimczzé wag f¥.*;{,§§%{}{i’:E§!§.h ‘E’§:t:: _g:§:z§z2{§f§ Eiittii an 3p§5¢*<;§.

8

‘£5

Vflxéie fin: appesrai wzzs }Z’}£.”l’I’!(i;fIg,.$ iirzc :i::i2:r2:,§:;mi 13:-«T223 sL:e:e::’…§{.~:–i_1:’§VV in

ubiaining pmsscsgicrzg if ihzz hI,?1%E_~’.S ix: §’.i*1″{.?§I’d§t’J£_i§f}$£_§g5~ ‘iifliiijf'”Z£§€Li§é;}E} V’

§44L>i’§i1c Cuaiaz of Ci»,-J§§ Frzra-sdum, ‘:”l’§:3’3′. .5’~1§’£é;r £_§2a:’i’§§i:a* fJ§3§.21iEi7f

with {he pcr:n§a?siun £3? Ehs Cmgzi. a§1i:.;ni§–:d Exit! _g72L#£i~::i’. :42:-::.:*§«:§;;’§;_;~,

cjcazimcni an ihrr ggmuzzd 3′}m§, £h{~;–«.L»Eéazm2}! Ezaé’V-hr:.m'”.§:r:r:%:mEes.i

umicr Seciiun 186 of ihé*7Iran¢$i%r”m{ ‘gjrepariy .»’~’é;s:{, E832, ‘§:::§;
means ufa izuiicc ciaicd 24.6, §’§é4 hafléi §:é’6».§afiVV_’é,}§.V~i§3t: Faszi 323:3 been

mmm-ed by ‘L335! ;i«i:g:i;11i’s:~::i.01I i g’I*’:»,:m€:& i>§2″ Sam {3m=e;Si:>;i7€.n a Seesufié Appczsi. The cmsré Eras

_ kc-ié §3f3_§:.’::éu iizs: }f}:’t:§zi:::t;;:s sash. far cjm:-imttrai was cm: iiéts gmuzgei ui’

V_ar:*§:2..i:’§ sf :’e:;:§§’«i§:§rv gram”: iixan Eilreac zzmniiés whiezfrz {Em giainiiff Exaé

faiiézrd ac ;:3,:;s,§/§’§1:s;;*2’s§-is {sf sartsicc of nuiiga: ami ihaei his ic:z”::;2:1s:}s Ema?

‘féisxrz i§1i:’§3i§;a;§Ti.c<i 'E:-js; a zzaiiai méiiagss zmiier :,~:m:§is.::': Eéfié of ihii

é :3f?r0p<::riy 25:93:, $82. $323: gaii hatsirzg fimzi 22$

:

2

azmaiai fr

K .._ &ist:}1i.s~.f:~;sd, nu frtzaiz Sui: can be fiieszi 0:2 éiztz iaasis mi: ihs: :.~;a.::;t: £23£3.’:~3t§

j:3fz:c-i§z.>n. Effcgzursg, 2;. flesh suii ma}: hrs fiésd £13: gjccignezxi am fa.

6

-u
E

asuuri éeaii wiiil Eire m.zs§,ir:r. _

Th: éiffsrfincc E~e§.we::.1*: iimi 3223:: :E.§’it5VV’~}T}I;5E.*$;?1€:§k’3i.VVa;é§;fiV:*?_f3§§

‘PU! ” X P ‘ $_. 3,» , ‘ ‘ £2; x ‘ X s E’ , it ‘I E E9′
J’…-i.’:s£1 La:£l§”:J;”.? {El &€.§I{3I1. IE ii: 1}} JHE ‘s=§’S§!.’£ i§eiE ‘EH22 §:t’:%,i:’§L§_§ m.§_}§3_§§;r§.u

hanci Ea ihm nuiict: as regards aIT6E!.If§’~~§3f féilii.’fw§113.*§:-El’;§*£§§$Sii§L§: is; §’3t:a ‘

1″z1;:;nL§a,i.urjg Lifltiiizif :~.%e:ciim’£’ ‘efliv:,:1’:1z€::1;i–..A§E_:z:§ arrtzars: {sf
ftifli its zmsiainad agii is, tzzfi ssiéix Eatmzni iésai
hm had ugmpiieé ‘§i<:r.:r:12§1«:.:-i{A:§;¥§:i'=;*s3:*.Q? arrcaw; ami fiaai he:
had gaié ihg pzaié 2-:w.;:§: armarzz, iiw
nuéicc _i§':.-Wag:-;;s~:vv;:es.:-E mffizai pm:-:z:i3::::: am': :39:

r::§a1i.u:1§m§:¢@3§ i2az3s.i§a':'¢£:i giiai "i~:;§12.!n§. havifig ezizggiénasez-Li. iii: zigéiézsié

Léx-"e,raga§.z: 12:66-. ._;§~::2i. fmfisrs Eisfin rzzéacii E}? a i3r::ts§': z3a;§.§z.:s:.: istzégzg

'§$Sa!;:i.§.. '?E§£; '$§3"i~§§ pyaysrigz} fig: fiiseiimn :3;'?{_f3f}{a} wmziai zaziaii Q3:

giitiiéibnéf—'V§a.ni§:§VQrd ix: scszsking f::_;i:-£:EII'!C?§1§ on iim §.§,E"£}{£}¥§£i off awsarx;

1:? mm, in 'aha absense §3§"ma.§;e:'é:;:i R} §.:1;.'§;§s..:;:;.§¢ éizaé Ehe r:::~:pm::icn§.~

i,i;.:nfi;¥2iA hagi paieti ranks ii": s:-sgmpiia. xaeiiiéz iifxt: m§iia:s.: in iiéa: fizsi.

ihsiarxm. fin Sir: asziiaer hams}, fits iriai C€_'.%%i§"§ ham {mi <:m'§s:a:'i<.:-;:& zipaguz

an enquiry Emit.) £325 arrears u§:z:-tz,E.. Since fix ériai if-€.§%,§§'i has taken a

%'%i$'«fi: fimi in fix: r:xr§:::§, iizcw wab; z:s.,:~ gwiicc iiizgicf :s:tc:i;uz": i7:?{_2='}{a},

6'

….

as

lite furihc:-r qmzsiiun mi? exaxninaiien <2? ::::'r«;::m"3 w<._§:s?§«:}. A§§<;;=€ f"a:"i§s;::,' .

Henge, £ht: 233:: ciiazd wuuid nail aééi §1=:e;1d:§ni -s§:s?1;§;%§z§f*;.i;_”_’»V

In the act-z.;nd cassg £21}:-zilzfizgzczrz E3i:§_v§3–._ fbfxi.{:?’z;2r2r,fr:::i2{§’§.gsfizrg

others, 2§fR 39,75 £11.32], ihc 25¢ ”

The piz:i11§%E7f»:::sp£>%:; §ié:fni VViV’;’;KE§§.;£.i.EL}§’%’3. prestzéssa
again guvemeei tiara: 05 Rm; 3226
E\,=iciiua L2? firm a};’spai§:.«m§
xaiag haé faiiztn Emu az”;2’e:§r:=:

amfi 2: :~”::£.g§i E};)1″A2:1«§1€§’~é3, :§::azA::: 9;? zmzi wa:~: ifisrii 2sga..i:1:~:i éaslm.

T’ » g i .4 .« g , . A ;

as Mfii, W225; {;€:e,:*t-,-<2-gi :«,c:;»~ axttzam; :3}; mm: mugs-. 1:. appsam ggai me:

= V. A_ &¢;:£jr'e&.§.ai }:§2nunni"1*-:m_a.i:1§:d unpaégi fur :;€3ms;: iirw: aimi fin: i§£«i§§é§£_'é§*I-3;

V L5 izazmgsiaeaiis nu,-ii¢.:v.: unaim" :_~:t:§:£§€;m 3 mi' 23%;: Ami ami smzéion

E§'§s é§§ i§1®"§':'lj:_;s:i:si'c1" uf'§}re:;"mri}s 25s.¢.:E,, 33%;, iarminafing Exig §.t:nana:y

ami réqgfiring 'ném is; gay ihs: {§f.*:»€E'E:'£§.ai ;-2,mmm§. ax; aim» 'd3'§'€a§":~i. Eizc:

" '£'kf_&:~§i';'£:£}t1i}"t:£§ iv xiagzaig {Em pmmisss aifiiar fiat: §~f.2§"i€.3L§ L3? ficfiiifitfu Tim:

_..ii€~i:f€§§~£§ azgznszzai, ii apgfisars, wag aéistpafiiicai ix: auzzri is g2s[zis§faa:§é:::z

9? £316 {ice-me. T§::; Eazxaiiuré }¥L'?'*J»fl:.?'éf:t§'. ffieei a mi: an figs: ggrémné

ihai Sims: i':§:: amemzzi Ezazgi {mi btzzzgz §§z,%.;§.§ gag Ezina Egg: 22.13:: in iicééagié

Es

ctwhtfix

3 V .

3.22:3 Eiaéic Em e_§<:4:§§'nz:.§§§. "i'§2:::* suéé zsaza aii:-gmés-;:s::d; E335 334;: _é:?i:_i'§'~.._g;T::;2rL

2 . ex; _2 .E _t H _ Egg, ,. _. .~-~§, . V' 3-«ii
fmi aingfssaz ,} 2 12., szévvay dppfii gym, :,;_:~am_ 2. :2 a2 ':*_-»iiyi.$.;:§.z-{.a z.§'f.'.?§.3'7".3a'.:'.', ms, –.

§"§ig§3 {fmm iiizmzésscé iiac 32551., mi ?:§':§: *:§E2}.£__ié!}' Ii

12

..r

;.a

52212.’ ‘§t:€’;*-§”i’:V’ 112:0

aiiaélzuié am ifia 36232 ;-sazazming ea.§”iz::” %Eéi.: Q’=-;.:£:z3:C x%::»:_:é –.%;::;:%;;”‘:§2a:

iamfiemi wisiia: £33: £35 u’m§a::r fits: 2:»
wuré. IE aggpsars Etzai «iv:-i:ve..§* i%:.s._::”§émT:z.§é::-?¢Tzé’}:.gyf é?:*:a;:VV:%-::.,%a:r;émE 2:§;§a%:;a§*

i.§”;t: iazxtiiwrii flag} aiizzii and w.°:T::»-p»; 5::%§§:2′.;S;§i’§§,;§a_:_(.§ Egjés Ezzsifs am? Esggzaé

‘ .” Y. (I9 in J. ” »a~ %
?*3F3’I””.i._’§{3i’§§.,Ei£§.’i~”‘:,”‘::-‘5 ‘§;’V=.”§3′}-2§I*$ {3’§§£’3′!}i.§éi’.2’iib ‘§.§§’v§.3′}§’.§..§él§§§, § ER: f:§§f.}€3Ei§ ‘$-‘*JE};f’5

}’j3§{,}:$€3i.i{i{!t.’.3-‘(Q2 E..E”:%:m:”‘-:¢.:;m§_ “%;§.cé.1;”:t wan; g3:>::»;:::e{§ in ifzzzriz” EE2:4<.:»a:§'
Aifiéay §§1:.: :.§§:~;;%;:§:;~:.::sz:§ mi' i§'-i:&iiv ;:~;?;xéiT éaé a .*:és.::a:«;:¢m§ $:§§}§T?:_:1″§, am

iim ;;?.§’§p:::”é”§g_35%;s.:§.,;§$82, he remained :4 :«;:;;§ai»:.}r’y ienzmi E§}t:g'{:2i–E~L€:3M

v_a=’§:i;:h .’1»xias n:.3£. hé:r§L:;é:blfi in Eaxas. {;:’m:3§::;s,;¢:§:§§§§:__ fizz: :§;:§::m.’§;»:’§:é.:~;A

.V Eh: dcaih of ihe: §c:mn£__ axmrz: ‘;:=rr.:;~;psa;~.~’.::-:=:2″rt:~; itfiw Eéxg: §?”§°£::§1§E§$f§€

Vanad Eiabic 1;} cjsciantrzni. fixis cargzzzééiayzi was; §:*::g;:»2.§i*¢+::i;

v

E’i’2§:~;

§:’4.:::: %;v.=.:2«;§ irgaiézzé :£§*;§;§{‘%$E:§é’,£i £13

19
cieuisigan aiscy ws.>u§<.§ 3§..':tflL§ on zcz aiiiifiarrzné éégizsai mzséréx. §.§1§E ::<;:u§:§

net be prc:-igtcai igzém sézrviasss in $25 pm:::2::':i p<::E.i£§<.m,

itzsufar as fits: grmzmi under :~:m:ii:m ..'»E"?{_?:}{:"i§E;~; aigas-}s.i'::;+§§_3€;i:i;'v.

{bar izéai szmzri Ezassimg, made: zmsafiz £,3*§§'E:A4iAi"V E':5§.TI!3(;§*;§S:I§Q§'% §v"\a~*'eg -3; 2&3:

Ebert: wars: 3:; space amiiabic Eu fiizgc exit:i1f.__<§§_3§E:ei §;>i_§9§1:”;§.g;2:..§ “s:%¢i2;g.§év.sn’,A rfizéc-E’: E3 3235:
cungtcdsd 312;: ii, giiei n;;L_Vj§§:”<:§.;§22§_§a:: £.'i?;£:~. §:xi};:§.§i;3r:§ ihayg sagging

gciiiécyza :*ss.:ht:<i:§_§€: :§;;'crg:§$::;s ifiif hi:-:._ {2::»é<1t"*—-:»:-;n<.§ s3=;.a:upai._is_3z2. "figs:

iazzéieyrifiv §§.1{L£§€_§V§§§{'j§2{'$"?"'fi§§§fi§i§£;(§' 3:: aim ares: whiasii is; a.2r3i§:§$i: £2:

hitn am} %.§2?;:L§.'§aV:::::;§iiéj.;:2'2 £2? w::§"-gfiaizggtg raiaiivc §;u.r<_§:»:§§f:;2 amé E322: %<;%nam

.v _ f£if;.'.»ET€j;q%£§§'ffi!§2€£§§ ;'–.zv2[;~; 2:33;; h.-gssa Emma 21 ;%:.:s;::;:e:;1;:"}s' iz2gm§§:;3§ :..:m§:::"

'gsxm-<i§;;§o:};;_{§;{' .§_§'z$ Ka§"§3:»:§2i.E«;;§ Rani {:i}fl§§'£_}§ 2%:-E. i'}£':3E, £1»; :s's:§:€,2§§}:

– v.

mi: 5211 pizza:–:’:*. j_ Efiizzzxceg Eire: yvsasgégsigzg 95 gm ?i$L’3££E’§. £§:a.E iissz §::m§i€.:=z’§

xjhaai zmfi. smzéa msi any cam umitssz” égtsgziimz 37€:,?L}{§”} 4:321:29: his

V’ ‘ — 3;: a¥.:~;§ai’;;:s-xi.

6

2%}

AL:t:ur;§§ngiy, flu: pciiiiun §:~.: ::z§§t.:2,x.:c&. “fizz: razxggéélagi-2:3:E;-«–§Lé;2.2§é:i

is ggrr”./,::;£t:~z3 ixw mumizs iimtt Eu aguii. a1:.£i”A{i::i§w,:r..fa2:g.:::§§2’i’ ‘fJi,?§%S£§§.=,;§%{_’§?.1

vi” {he prcmégtzs from fizz: $316 :5? firzigg u3″s:ir.*29.”,_

.