High Court Karnataka High Court

Mr.Ramesh vs The State By Cubbon Park Police … on 20 April, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Mr.Ramesh vs The State By Cubbon Park Police … on 20 April, 2009
Author: Dr.K.Bhakthavatsala


ifééii, §’~=§;T}; f ZZ{Ei)*?2*

3%: “FEE”: :Az§-;; {;:<:z§;~"z'§ 9:9 §=<;i§§%2;'éS:'E';%§{2'2 53$
§)fi;§'§:1£} '§'§§§E% T'?-£5: 29%: §;§§';{{.'sf§-1" A;%:é:':; 1'
Sax/j;§s§2:' A ' 1 ' . 4' V
mg: z+§<:;r~:'£a':,.§'~, 53;: . zss%§=;e::§: 3;.'V:53;;%:4i€§«;;§%;é;*;j%:§§:;g%; .
caiéégfigg ?E'?*:'?E{'§?»g §::s,§,2§8,*"

Bfirfiwgm: ”

L §s;’§r.§{‘a_m€:sh, ” _ .

S,f0.ia"ir3    _ 
fig-ad abaut 35:? };'s?.r«:.3:i:**;,  2;   A V  ~ 
§€j2':.i¥'§at      
Amaia Pra.:i=ia.:§ _$§;3aT:€'::2e::Iig;- "  :

B33} '33€mpEwa'=.fiR::";.:a€3_,y '  "
€:"§§"19.m§E!7I'a§::2€:.?..,if, ' '

Bangzéiara. _ V

M3: Sa:;':E'.:::2$i1,
S;'€}'?V§'fi'?;ffi3§I§'_;Qu§ 
_ .¥€ffvi¢;.~:fsicg;6j2i2§  _____ 
" - 4%? ':17:-0:93, SL2 Psiiaixzy
 '§;Z:a:c§;aa«ga:7,,"«v_  _
' -._ $§r;am:52.,:fég§§é:,  . V V 
BjaI3ga1Qr€. V.' '--.  ,,,?a:?:"r§::>re:§:§e:5s

%uLL'»

{By Sz'>:i i3§*3i*.§§€:'*::. :§".iI, fiii¥._}

 __':"~°E1é.st'a%:§e,
   Cfiuijbon Park Pciice Stating,
 . V .. _4€L:u'§::*13s::%z:1 Park,
V'  . _ ffiazigaiait. wE€E§;';§E'iT}P§E}§§?€'§"'

($3; S§i.A.¥.RamaEirish21a5 E5 {_T':{"%P}



 

*’?hi:§ {Z:”a7;mi;’:ésE Pmitiazi is: fzészi m1:§.a:* E1§ea:?*é%i;é:?;– ‘v:§’f+£3:*.:§’;
prajgsizzg to erziarge tim gsetiiirjners gm Ezaii in ihaf; _§;a%fr;:3;t.g-;>:§”‘ih23ir s,é.r*:j:~”:*:§'”‘;._
:3: c:rm-m gm rm-zgzgsaa sf {izibhan :>a:}g:..§%;:::§g:€:_–‘3:,g’+:::é:::g;_»3 §:ie:>§s5=§36′:;£§1?:z>g *
befera tbs: {Smart of the VIE} A§:ir§i:i(jv:’;.:–2Z iifilififi’ “.¥?s§§:ii:”$:z:;:s<}'1a;'§2«7z.:'1__

Magisfiats at Bangaiarfi: far E.%fg§~ :2§'§;é::<:-§%5A. [2-;.f s~.4;:_;:§; ~ 5;? " J

{:12 P.€'i,, i'j2x;.2?§e:£%.Z%'?§ e§'%P{"; .;:»:.::2€§ 5;<:c:s:g;.:j;s'*:3;"§:"3, 2V:*§§,A;2z";.':;§ ;2;g;::%, -éaas,
s:[:. * ‘

‘?h:§s {.Z:é:3;2;2’_:”;aE; E~’€i?;1iiaz2 {:::2;;:i%:.g: .§ls=€i11g:–‘-1. * ” ”

‘§’§’:6 g3:3.%;i’£i%>:3s1*&:;5 i§c:s:>13 §55é::*E§..%3;Q§i%::€ 33;1:;£%;§.;}::,,_ 5:3: %3s:§0;”€: {his Cauzf 2.;.:”::’§e;: ;i§:::<:{;§m::

¥%3$ af €;Tf?::?'i€:,,' $a%::.§§;§:1g"-.§:é'2*:§é*:;§3a"£s::2.:jg ézaié {:1}: '$.26 <;f§%:3::{::: uyzsiar

Sécticzzg 4:{%::~j; 2,92 97%; C;¥'~'{p.c., mazi wiih gm/{gm :a:?: 9:” gm am:

‘v._§;gm€;5:as_’–T2553 2:’§§:%,”‘gaaé, 455} 458, 4?}, M2, 423, 4:?4 am} eggs

zmgaj :z.?ité:{jSc§é’§::§V::–.;;4 0§}’E3′{7i,

2. ..__*§’h£~%”Zi§z?;€f facts sf tbs {raga :3? ihfi 3}”-f3S{‘:€’Ei5€§=3,§’§%, may $353.

‘ é ” – ._ V$in;::'{;(:€§ a$< vfiZ1d€f':

“f’he §§3§§C€ rsgiséfizméi 23 Sue meta: érogigzgfiézzikat ::1§.:3;%;’:5;%: .?%c:a:2.z5€é§

” §§<3s.2 :9 1?' afiagifig ii';-at {E25 5.39593 r{-:{::~:i2z:t{i s:::z"::&:iE:;E£=:: iazilgrzzzzafiégszz

that $31 Laazfiiée Ea.-aé aéjaézzifig '£5; Baizgaiafiz {L'-hzég €'{"}fii}3{}?zE;E}.€§, gamés

L_

A(f V

jévngggsaa

Tazziiiiiaiiu §.3;::m§w::2" plgzfzs and *i.§":s.c::}; wa-:3"? '§'1z2:;<:E:;;.*;zg:'~;f:§:§z'; 3:'; <:t§::::'m.::%%':

some <:2§§Et:§{*5 eaxzié Zhfi n’:§:.Eg:%z222:2% 2:25:-:.:’:’£;V..€.:t;A }’I.’3é;:» §’§§§}i}?i’-£}§{f%V§’}-fg Ya-‘:Z.%”}.:. €;%i:%:;:_ :

8331?? at iE.,:§{} pm’, 3.12:} fm:;::;.T,’__. ‘§”2:§9€%3j:%§”‘ ,4’
A{3~fii%é%% Egaé baa: yaidzed. zmé ;;:«i:1″:;<;:13 ';.».;.~:::'€:
géifiimg amé 'aha: ¢:'.'§}'iVE3E' of z::a;_:'4A Ax:-mé €<i.'€'§1fEKi§'3'E".i':{i
':3 6:3-::*ap£:':. "E'.h€ pwiica. c:§";aVs;eVi<%'A';*};3.;:%V'§%iéf;; BEE} {Em §1'.':I'€ff
pamozgzs, viz" $159 '3Afi..'§%-'¥;;='€5.i7€'LT __{%§}§F€j£EfiE3.§€€}is "§'}::€1»; "iské

E2131: they W:%:'E<i§1§j.._fQi*'–.§}::§§'E*a!E£é}.':2£§ge:;»é"ar:–2 '?ra1;s§oz°: §;§€'§,iaéi5i{§ at

8121} Teriipié Raészé, and '£3/1&3; Wars: :20: is p<;2$3£&;::§ée:rs sf

a13}=' €%a<:i";."i3::€:31ts –.%.n""%:§_'"x: 2-'ascazgaai Z'~§Q,i% 2'§Sé:?';z.EE;:.2. @5233 ii:

pGS$S€€SS§0§i} .”??§~~{}Ef§§EZ«

” v ‘::1r;{:i: £3:}:E’:£:§ V”{ig:;:-7233:” E’€s:>,§-§§~2~3E§; if} fiffifiééw The ;”§.<:r;'::§.a::{i §'%1%:m’:m€fi%

$6;-3§é;–.,”§’Zr:s .§;s:%{.::z:§é§; iské ihai £31635: wars: .’F.i€g:3;§};§.i-‘ ‘::’°::§33$§§:}r§i§::g 3p’;2’§;%;

— {mm C%a3’%3;a3:g3 £0 §’:”};€i0E’€ zamé 3330 ssfiéfig apiaét. if; §~i3r::2.:;{i2:§~::;~:., Tamié

?3?.:>:a:*;;a:..’za:2s:§i” Eécz/333 553:” higher rt-géaas. ?}}§fjg* 3130 a”§§$€Es::$€<i 2323:. :'%":.€:§,-*

. '_.£x?:;1"$"":é5;i::gj faiész <rh€c§f *2:-3%}

.. “§”%”:*a1*g€s. ‘F%im2*z:3fm”:~?, ‘ififit _g;:§:{:;§:i.0::ars~; ms: %;2€f:’;2::’: zisis {7im:.z'”§.

” Vapgmhenfiéfig :’.§”:ti§* a2*;”T==;t E3}-* {ha §.§.3.ve3″§%gz§i::’;.g {T}§§:?{::::

A

3. L€331’I}u’.’3{§ a’:@%.ms{:?. far that §§€¥;iii{;:1§::*s €E’1:;«;:.-%._ §3;;-xi:

}i}€’§’:’§:i{}§1€.E’S 31%: 6§«’i§–‘E:€1″‘ azaii f’\{§g:;:1ag<i:"jgf;§ V:'f§:i3«?g§:-s$:;3:;1<%s§&*<:a;':?§'E':*a_3:é;_;::3’s’::«:5$’–@:§$€;_ .ma}*«’$’:;:~:3§i1_£31:*g3{% {.231 223i},

4. bsaznefi Gavin HI%}éé’.§§CE’: 5%-V¥_33{‘é§’;%:”?:f§’?.v§’s”~V…:?Z.3;”;;ia’i £316 p€§i’§’;:32:1a1*s;’
Accuseci §€a3.4;’a;é’1:_ .5 aétfa %13s*é:1€’:” a§;1%i’-?%§s:1z§.g€::” :3?’ 131%: é3’2:z2′:~3s3§& Q3″ ” J’ ‘ zzsf flit:

{raga agizii if file §}e§ét:’.:a::i2::”$*~2%3*& rz2§§:3.Seé {:21 $313, E”: 17′;-‘®’:i§.d sigma Er;

” v jibe V_.?’§fi§;:* ajf v§1;*,?€$’7£:%gé’ii{3§§.« *

A E31 ‘§T}ie2;3ai§;éiii§:1€rs have }:};=:§’i ;;1~r9§a .’:”:%_T€:’9 SW36: ami §%’§8fle9:g€§’ zcf figs ?_rans§:;m'”i :§5:”€~;

‘argii mafia? affaizaé is gsuniaiiafiis ‘iEE.’§fiT} imgmis-m;::ne.:::€ £32″ Ezifa, 3

:}f’3€3fi’,§fEG gs-3:2 grmzxxfi ii} grajafi a§:’fi(:ipa.t::3ry Ezafi is ‘$35: §2€rii.”:is:;:::s:;:s;V

::_:§% P, §-;%<..:.T:. 3:23,; :2.':::t;%»:s

éfé. Ea $33.6: I'€S§Z?ii, EEK: §::&'é.%%i:Tm ffaiis gmgi ':§";e::_–'5:s:;131f§:%* —-Efé.:':*.%?:.§';3;

:;§i:-gmimazisi.

‘:>;3.v”*