Loading...

Mr Subhas S/O Balavantrao … vs The Assistant Provident Fund … on 2 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Mr Subhas S/O Balavantrao … vs The Assistant Provident Fund … on 2 July, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil
$2?

32%;: '+.fiswai1.a%,%1,

Sf :53 Seimarma §{;a£'i.im:»1I3i,
Agfiii abazrsui 451 3-'2:*2:1z'3,
{f}<7cr: Retired Artisan,

R} <3 éhiibarga,

Tc; 32'. ffiigt' GuF3arga..

Mi'. Shivasharanappa,
S} 9 Somarmza A'we11akki,
Agfifi abozgt €34 yezzrs,
(T)-:::._$;1;.;V'L_A ;  

i'-lZ;s:.,» ("}11ih_v2,--rga,  ..,_ ._
'I'c_;. an Efiiest, G1if.".:T$;.fga.

Mi'. Eiaiasvhissvarg _    
SE0 Shamaflac Kaiagfiiafiy _ 

Ageéi about f::{}4.};€:'anfS,'._ A V V .

€.§<::<::: Rvgfifilfiii S,§f,<f;s:"«3"S§3:1p::;:t%jzz?;€1t;dm:1"i:

   ..... 

V” p_ ‘§’Q, E.z;”‘E7fiis”i Afitafharga.

. E’-a1;r; %IiiVsi§§aj;., = u

S; G §’5}1*;iI1§*§'{«zT;*§_ ia gi,
Ag€{i.__&bG11″{ .62§§;i&a:’S,

V . Occz R’efi1″€;:i Si1penris0z'{AE}?vi}§
‘R_,!:::: iéizfijaiiga,
” 3: __D i$’t’.” Gufibarga.

IQ. ‘ 5&1’-.._E’i§:L–}3’asin1E1a M’m’t%1f;,
‘ S10 Lakshxnaiz Rag}
.V _§’;_gevz:i abimi 641;? yeara
{“,}<;:<%: féfitimci A<rc:t::'t,1.u.E.:-: E§upié:<*s2:is€;:*,
' 1%,! :3 {}':1§heg:'ga,

'?q¢. fir; Gist ifiizibargaw

%'£§" 40824 f ZUQS

EL

E?»

3.4.

v. fGv–{§ii1:£}3:’g;’§,
‘T€§;A (32: E}§3’€,. €:§fLi1ba2″ga..

Mr. }<IasE";irzat'i1,

3/ 0 Ramacrhazzziraa Gavaii}
figed :1'm)'u£ {)3 yE:ar£5,

OCC: Retimci Afiiaarz,

Rf 0 Québzzarga,

"Tq. 8:-. f}:is"£, Gtxibargat

Mr. Rajashekar,
0 {'}u1*appa,
Agird abimt § 1 jgéara

C')a::=<:: R€"3ti1'f:(i Assistarni. Afi;i$a:1.}

E12 3' :3 ihzlirarga,

'i"q. 3:, i7}isi., {}uib:a.rgz;z.

Mr, Jagadfivraofi

*E§f<:» §3a$av:§:1:"£'a{}, ' _

Aged ajbafié; iizgé _"s,i'_£:az":~3",'3'_V

(3:20: ?€e:tire& J;11i3ir;«':* A "ui'-iiS<§E;'i11xfE4,._ "

R! Q C§:i§F::a:~g,a_,"g. .

“‘§’q. 53:. iT} 3ls’L GE1ii:¥;2rg:a;’V

M}: C”:,Ba$ss3v:–:tra:§,’ ” ‘
S£0A:r-‘:>=*a??8.~; ” . ‘ .

Ageifi a.?2{:rui 6′? :§_7’€i€x’};’?i§,’

Ocrc 1.. gfiatireci ‘E’r;afE§.::t« {‘Ec:»ntr:3iE.6;:;

. §%.§r§’ Ba3″@.;:’*aé&§.,;_’£a;~*.*a:::%’,

$5′ 9 $§;i’vaI*aQI_ Biraiiaxg
Ag:éd«..a’::c;_«_’u1 E3-£3 ye§31*$,

€300: Ratirsci Effiriver,

W _.

Pia Guéb-eizga,
.. 7’§”q.’ 58;, Bist. €I§1.:£ibarga.

Mr. ayffagzna,

Veeraflpgfiex Bekinai,

u Hjéigzzzi aboui $8 _’_'{€éiI’E§,

€7}c<:: Rv5:'€'ir{~:ci ikévar,

RE :1: fiizibargz-t~:§
Tag. 5:; Sist, ifiufifsarga.

aw 4{}824;’:;£(‘é{§8

W? 4932:: {£898

‘YE’. Mr. Vagzmi,

S10 Vsnkatesh §”;1V3}{8.1″.E1i,

flgad 3’m:3’u?; 62′ gfeam,

{Beet ‘f€e’i:i1′::d fi3si.$I’:an!:,

§€j::> G~u1b;a1’ga, .

Tq; 5:, ‘iT)is’i. G’u§fbarga. 1

E8. M;*.Mal§ika:ju11,

E3; 0 ‘;’§§hi;vahngayya

“1’c:t:kasaim:5th,

Agefi about 63. §;£:%’am,

Rio Humnabatii, __ j _’

Tq. &§3iSt. Bidm’. ~ ¥E’I’I’I’IONERS

£33: M{s.R.B.Annep§a;;a*arg: A$.*st:s;.»,.

Tine Assistam; ?1’0:zi{i€;z’;.i §==’1::1§?:i?ee;;

Sahilnd Rfifianiié ¥:i’ox_m;-..,:” %

fiiaxid Raagi 3i;V_{§1;iba:?ga;..”– ” _ 2 ~

‘£11, 35 Dsit. {3ui’t:a rg.a. . ” , RESPONDEKT

{By

1% fflaé; uaéder Articitzs 226 5:; 22? of the

{“:Q:as%ii€;i1ii01’i ‘§§ié1§,a, pra§,I§:”:g ta {iérsct ’tile afifiggxadant is cansidar the

;e.p:gsé:s.ta:¥g§a::;””aa:sd zssageééa, 1i§.},1.”29@5, 24.4.2988, 2@.4.:?«;§§8,

: ‘f§§’.<§»;2QfiS;._.i§?§.3.2GG8, ?;5.3.:2fl§3, '.2';9.§é.2§68, 29.9.2008, 2{}.'§.i2888,
' ' 38.'§~';'.2{}G8_, 1.}O.'2{}Q8, 1.}€'}a2UQ8;, L}{}."2*I3{§8, 1i.1.2{3®8_,
_""3{){£:%.2.Q08 95$ $316 petéiieziars, refipeittiveéjs 'prQ€§;z1ceci as .-5§flIi€X13I'€S-'A1

~ 'ts':§* R1'? asrxii to fix thfi §_;°;e1}3:§m1 ii: a{frCO.{'§£iI1€€ 'i.?EEi§h the prmrisions Qf

" * Eflmpiefgesg §'§:m3§o:3, Siihfifiiii, $995:

35%? 4%l}8i2*'%;'i2{3G8

fiais wgriz piififiiéfi i3 éfiififilifig at: far E'r<:§i_mi*{1a;.?§%_ ":iée'z:§:"§gV 'B'
Group, figis ééay, flazs fiouri magic 'me f<:=i}€:«wi£:g: " ' .

fl_}RD£R.

1. ‘T316 p<:ti'i:i;o§1€:1't:s am affi mtiiifiai ftrxxgaizégfgzcsg sf V"i"_?_:g€}-*

a::§:i-Aim Ea 'bar we msmbera :2? {ha E3i;3L;:§e.'a§:€:t=:s §?:'1::a%1o_%1 S~f:héme having

izyziiviézxal a{"3C{3'§lIfi §1.:1::sb:::*"i:;_. EA:"W1?s.. ':'i1%f§:* ctastéy/ffggaf 'may have

<:{mi:"§§:m{&(3; is 31$ EZ£t3:§§}o:,;c:e:;*_ '£'€:11:;;':i{:'«:1 _S<;*E'i'E':. 5:, E995 which was

.i::'§r<3€i':;:€c::& w-'i;ih Ezifimig i9g§»}E*§'.'_-.._%"é'i<3;;* xiheraio, 'iihef; were the

hfliififififiafififi ':'i1:i{i:i§f_'€T'§.§.;%: "E:.,5_"5fi§)'}{3'*;–T_€i€"*:~$§V Pézisésisfichsme, 19? 1.

'§'}:€: z§Ls;e;{:§fi*.::i:9a% thV%*V:'§* "haw: fihif righi $0 ctiazim the

"bsizzefié sf pézifii 3§§f:11?i$€ iéiiiriéisajsfi'w'i:%1m:t' 331}? §}I"€éi§{, Em: {Em purpesfi sf

c<)mp'u'£¢£;iQm of $3335: 'i'za=.z%a§j%'- '§3éx.2:$im3. in this; ;:t:ga_z*d, ihej; have made

r:é§s:%:T§:”Tg,ri€%.saz;<:$: ia mat 'zhmzgh éhasfi :*::p:*::se§z§2ai:i91"1s are

as "§1'§8A§;k as an '2::{},8E?.2{}{}8, Ehfi rasgégndeni has net eofisiderefi

' iiéfifr aaééi';ifigaagsiztatiazig.

-. E–{sewing Ezzmzé €315 ‘é¢:ar’rzé:§. £153? ‘£35 psgiiiimxagzs 311$? fhe Eeaznaé

“if:-<ra:m$~;:*.i gesmgseaiéizg far iixii .i'é"':S§){}§"i{i€°:Efi§ E f333:% it :::me€:e:$sar;: to ants:

mtg {mi éfiiiififiififiiii 2:3? Ehiii ;_;:s§.%€:§{3§:e1's; fin' 'fin: 3u,%3$,ta:';"tial benafii

'A? F 46824 {i2{?GS

,5',

sought. E': is fag' {ha aufiiority £~::r;;:::€§';";€{%; is go £1133 the {:}9j:3;;: KE3{§€:".,

eifiizimizzié {ha 331123 23122 iézazi _%,;}.:a1s§3 {3:*{§;:'::'3. Siam: 1:316 §€}§r:%5:.€§;.§a¥i?i{§:1s

2223?: made wag: T£;sa<*?i<: it: féiazi }'€€~.%E' ;§é§€;}{}8, 1;hsz: r&:s§<;::{3s–:i:_'£" ~:i:":§é§.dl<:.tf

zizié s;aé{i I'r:§;}2.%:':~;é::3ta'€ém:::'»; ami §{}EiS$ ::*::'{i£:z"s'~_i ~'.a?i%.§t1:§;;1 2; T§}e1fiL<)€%v.Qf §3:1:ir:£:~

mazzéixs fffiifi *%.':}:3 date 0? ;"t:<:zi.%;3i 253:" a <:<}p§%K:<;:":3ii§;gE§ §3o::€:{§: " "

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information