EN "FH¥§ HEGPE C3{}{§R'F (FE? AT
Ci£'¥<3C'!;§E'I' IBEN€f)f£ EX'? <3-z.§1,;a3ARC;§f'«j.VT:A'
;'f)A"i'§%;Z§3: '§"§-HS ':':e+§':: 25m my i:':§w%;§{,:
."8E*3'%?'{}'i'l%«I:§A_ A
'm;é: HN'£3:;s: ._
am m.s1449;2w9 :1:z;
BETWEEN: Q Q
M/3 zéanash SaW4§;§»*EVi3§: .
E\!§pZ.'No. 12-» .1--0--9'? ,, _'
§€Ai{3HU§22'--'»v.5'84 1,91, ~ ;
Ray}. By. 1113 §fijQ§).~S:*i G__}:?a,:>a}§}.f1a V PETITIGNER
{fly Sri. fidvacate}
mms% ~
V '}"h:3 Sfitzite Qf__}§..ar1"1a.t.a3§a
_ Ré';j3'. Eyits Secratary
, ' " .. B'0:fé::~T.'£' «I_f)£:partn1€nt
E?'.T;:=:>¥§':§§_f§.:3;'?'S£3L1d§1a
'*%rw~:;:§;;.:;@R§.
"'}T.'%:a£: Chief' Canseivatsr of }¥'{3I*é3si
E}é§{art111ent. of forest
V V "~'f'Ara{1ya Bhavana"
" --7Ma}Ee:shwara111
BANG~s%L{}RE -- 5560 003.
3. <'3<):1servat<:~1" 01° ¥*i" fi§~?':9/Q12 0;} the: fik-3
of Hi midi. Civil Jucigc; {S;;Dn...}€}3;1.ibargag 'ggartig;-3 ailowmg thfi
refertsnca pefitisn fGr__ é:~-:1ha:n{:;eV<i" z:om;::er1$a{i01": anti Sazei-ting
fL11"§;hf:I' €;{}haI1(:*SI3(1€:':I'11Z <55'co:z';pzi:--:1Vsaii:§1i2». %
This app;-7;a}._is cfjiiiiflgi o§ré=f{:j;rV_fi::a§. i'2r.~3arir':g, firiis day, the
C0111": cictiivezfed fa?-iaxiiiiigz " _
. 7 ) E R
E3".:'*:.his%x£7'1*i?::Ap€i+'i§{'§'L§{i;'<f3f:i3Z{.i:):'1€r i$ Seeking 23; {'.3;§E'€C'€i€}§"§ :0
r:3§;3 . f§'--._m"*'%§i$"§30st: <3"? %:;h€: ap§3§i€:aifi:§€}::': _§i_k:<E far
:'€;f;é§'%5£é;I__n'::3f }§C€§f£Sf3_...QE'i ;28.{}9;Z€§G=§- in terms of {ha <§§::*€<:{i0_:':
. 1;-s$,1i6:d_ Es}; %;%jn~S €jZ<:}:,:_§*i: vzéie iirzfier i'§£%3.'{'.€E{i E01} E,£{}{}::: §;3a_sS<:{:§ E1'?
'§%';.T'§?.E%E:'::~::' $133 3130 sozzghi. a f':az":;E*:ez'
<§§:"=s%=4;ctf.io;1;";. £;{}4j'..-fiérafraixz r€sp0I';<ie.11t:~:.»1 {:3 5 from im€I'fé::'%1':g and
<i.i5e;{.'zfi:'If;i::g the §}<:§3::f::if1.1§ w<3_1Wi{.%.:1g of EM': §)€"E{.i'{'.§GE'1€I"S $z1W:_1'1i£3;_ hjg'
.'_,
1131135: M /S. {.':ané3sh Sawmifi llfiffl ciisposa} Of the a:pp}i:::a{jc«'t1
filed far E'€:.I"i{:W8.L
2. Brief facts relaxant, far "v§2':i:1t
pst.i£?.§<::sn staized ix: mitsheié are th.9Ifi4'*« . A
Pe:*?;i'i:ion€:I* was perrnitted {.3 2 at A
R3jT<:h11z' as per R11ie- 163 {':;3,}:.V""{A1} of 'fjrie; Féfesi:
E31533 $969 Viéfi PsI]§1€3'§"=2?€f§0d {Sf 't."wo" I:1c)I1ths from}
3(}.(}},2{}{f}3 to :%1.E)3.i2{3f'}.3 was s11%:>seq11e:1t..§y
1*e§1exxjéé§i'--Vi3i1' a% fiii;fh::;' pfiriod sf one year fmrxx
{3},.€)--4, 2§.3{}3 1;;Vi?i';{}V3»..2{}!}%%V.__w.}1ich iii': evidatnt fF()I1'i .A11m:-:>mre~
D. .H<}\«'sE§§37'.4§':{§§I',_ 333i 2'%;:z5::;x::::ii}.T11*€:-E'; :§1oi.i<:e: ciateai 1é.12:2{'}€}I3, the
saigtjég }'ix:$:'1$<e *e'2.2;.SV ctagfizcsileci on theta §'0uz1<:i_ $313? as per iifléz
. 4.;2fi){34- 0bse:r'vi}:1g that as the kicmzse
Z Vg3§1§£AT1t.ad fer the: §3€Z"iO(§ f:*:3:I3 {'}1.{)4.2{){)3 {:0 31.{}3.2€}€}4 hat}
~*'*"E"*~.
\4
€3X'{3i:i'{id, C0:'1si(i6I*afio£1 of the: c0rrecme5;s of thxsz :1<:;*t:i{::t datsd
16.12.2003
Callfiéflilig E1316 Eiceizaséi was 11;’:;’:§:t:e$sa:*§:,
However, as {ha ap;”J}.i<:ati0n for renawal <31' tijaé 331-:%fi;1$:=: fikéd
by the }}€ifii.Of1fi§' an i,}.,'8.{)9n"2€I}s';7:-4 czarzia toé~ _ b(:« 0_1i1
£}1.Ti().2{}04 Vidfi A1'}I1€.X3JI'€:~C} :is§i§i7g:1¥1f';'g §:~2:a:11{: ' réasoga VL
stating inter aiia that wi;;t10u¥;. ._pi*iQ r pé'1_*;i1'is;Si0'i:.".fig?'etheA
Tfiesntrai Elmpewer {:(;1m:r1itteé:';.1Err} 1i(:e1";s:3€é c:0jt_1iciFbé gz=a11te(i as:
per the dimctioxx issxicgi by;*ti'i€'; {E€s.;3é;~;._ C{)ui"t"'arid thatv as the
iicerzse granted earlier -hVad'j 'be.§e:1.._LT't;%i;1.C'¢_:}_ie<i assigfing the
sam€:'VV1*ééSeIi; fi'§'f1é:':€'~.§$2'as fii:s""pI*0visioI1 to }:*e:"1<:w 31101;: 21
iicensé'. Thié; §§'21i§%€i.}C}-~1. 1{):2{}(}4 was czhaiiezagfzd in Wr:':.t
?6'?Ei.?;.i¢:}n 1v*2.Eé/ Thfis 001111 dr::C}im:(i E0 iI":t:{érf€:1'€
V' _ aii'{».{§f{' ti};-::%. <::+;'ij~:3€::£' iiiipfigleii fl"1é:r€:i£'a §":<';3€iii'1g that; i;he:r€~: wag £1
:%§s:af,i.iA?§_}5I'§,%M ~:3£}f:;;)¥é;;i1 pmvizied aga%:'1$'t mi: said €)I'{'1fiE' :0 am:
_Ef)Ai:{iVsia:13.£ _ L I1%'a:éVr{~:st Ci)fi';.{:e:' arid :0 the: C3Gf1S€ff"i.Fé:1'§'.€}1" sf i¥¥"(:=1:'£~:S'£.
§{<)w€§z?€;_§*~, Sizxce, the i1};lp1Eg}'1€§(§ Order {iatsed GE. }G.'2{3{}4
_;.';:;a;_(_i:s;: 3%". {:1-star thai ii, was 0961: for the pe:%:i{.ioi1m' to rziakez
Eesh apgfiéézajiierz aizyrgg wiéh I'f3(;'i.E§.Si¥;€t d<)<:L1'm{:IT1t.S and that if
s:,1<:%§ am appli<:ai;i0:;1 is macie, the résgpeiidé:-r1E,s wm.1£:i
k
K' .
<:(:s;'1s;§d€:1' hi3 case afresh this {§m_.1r't issneé a c%i_t*{%r’itie;s is COi”.}_Sid{“:}f’ ‘E;’:”1<é appiicaiiam fzkrd 1:sy~~€li:3:'2.§::§fi.i§:ip’i_i,r::::’1_A'{_’1’Qn Af:;z:_ @*az;:.1:2 }:§’f_’._
£i<:{ar1:*~;€: and pass a;3pr<)p:"iz3tc:: 01'd»::rs ;i:j';'g;::£:Qf%}a11Ce 'v;?i§;fE;:T_ j
3. The gfievafica cf ._p€til§i§1}e;f_§V$ !fii§.§{,”‘<i<::§;;)it,e'{fie
ereiei" passed by this .~iTi§}1,.1:*tA,.Vi1': as back as
on 10.3 f1,.'2{){)5 vicia .§*§éSp0r1d&nt:s 1"1axr€-: 130$.
§:sa$s@c;§ a113,? u’€’I*1e petitioizer inviiieci
my attenéisiéix $:fi€:’ ._¥’€i§)If{%.$;f%::’}t4i:*_ti’t}f1.t3*L1’I}I}}.i’€.3:f:C1 wide Amwxure»
J datfséid . A;:;nexu1’e–K dated H.O3.2é}0E;
w}t}.e§”6:i§1 .i.t’ is *s;i”a?:<é<;i»_ "i'§.";:é§;: Griginal d0{f1,iII1(*:fi?.S have bean
<::n§:4E§3St-xi to 'thefv Said rep3;'c:Sr§_t.ie$ faiied {sf}
‘i7?{5i.31_$i<i"€'~::5""_s':I*?2_€:'égfifiiifiatiazz.
“V x’:i’his; Ciourt, on 28.E)4.200® directed {.*{‘:(«:
V»15e’Spo3T;cE&I1I;s ‘£,r::: stats: as to what action was takari an {.1626
é»;§pp1i:::3_ti§}:”: of {$155 p€i;ii,ioI’:<=:r am} as {Q Vvilf./' théz <:rs*d<ér f32E2$§Siff{3.
by tihis €7i0t,1i"{. an I€).{)1.'2{)€}5 in W}-"{4€3 1,25/2{}€}¥§.._':"'i5gas mzet.
C{}IiE3..§§1i€{i W:i'{.}*;1.
E3. Laaineti *s€:r11m&:m: A§§${}cat.€,” “<"::;=.'2.:'_.i31$€I*t__1;:t…§mi" §:«§._?'
the a11marit,.ié:s submits that the :ap.§§}i€:ati<::1§' fiiéiéé 'i;:f"»_; t.,hé*~. *
;3é3ti'gia:1ci:" has been foixvardsgi to "t;E"1c:;V '3c:i,":t:§<iz1E«–. _Emp0wa<:f€{'§
{1i<m:mii':t:e.E:f:.
fs. it has to b6:”«-:”;i’>i_ic:r+:d ;_E’;{~’:f”£&. ivt$€:33″ that 110 (ie’E;a’ii$ arc:
‘§(:r1;1″1c<3mi:1g as to E"1.gi;i :E=;a;_{§};3£éne(i to {Jim mid
?i}3}3§iCéé{ti€331..xi[{3fl{E§'?}§£%.f2{pf3i§€fié;fi(§I1/}f'€t}3}'"("3S{~3I'J£«i'{.§{)f1 is fiiezgi '13};
the p€ji;§'§i£::§'1r;=:=1", i'i:fisV%':;hié=.di:£§; "of t'r1:":: a'§3'€.E10:'i.%je3 Cflilciifflfiffi to
pass; a§3§;:r0p:"iat=%2 é:t:1ei*séif:ci <:11 f31<:<§{ ' ;3a:*i§£:1_1Ia:*}y, Whflfi this (."i<}:._::"%: has in 016333"
»i;;<–':'z*3I1;$ ..;_i'i:f€::i::E,<i§_. Ei§'1€:"£"i'.E $113 <:<:::'1$i.<:i€i§' I316: iéairi a'§;pii::a€;i{3':: éifiéi
pa:-é;_:;. 3"i}7;5';{;;;:.{i€ii4e ()E'd€I'S in &3CCOi"dai'1C€ with law, if has K}
bé-.._a§$i(::- ~t}£:}.ri:e: in fflifléi iimi. <31": <:ar::€'1.1E $§{§I'2,fi'.iE"i}' ef ah:-2
<:{:r:1:::~:ui;i::afi(;.rs c:1at.<%:€§. O E. }.{}.2£f){)¢?'+ 23$ {yer i&I1§1e:.:»n..2z'€:-€§T, that
.. {3(§'i"Z.§§€'i"i"§?éiE{}I' sf E%'<§r:-zfit, §'z.2ibaz"'g.<i {i'iir"<:1€: hagi :':':a<£€: ii, {7E<i~a1°
' P'
am
ma
tlxat: if f1€€€S$a3f'}f a§:p}._i.ca'iir1g’ zvi>f;% 2″‘.;”<:r£&:'a::m¥::
d€Z}{:U§'fi€%E'1i.-S, the same W'i.§} be f1’t=va3.”ci:=:c£ f ‘.1′-C.T§_%;;r1’i:.:*;;:TE
§§II.1§}OW’€FEI1€{}C f.T3{>:1r:::;:;1i3:t:”-:5: far #23 p:::’111i:~;§;§c}:’;_f’~–., ‘
3″‘. Maw, the Eearxatitd {§()’€}’;§3I’I1II17¢fi£f.1{“§Xd§g'{3€€§Eifi -I§1;i§::g_ 1″§f1a{£:’3_ j
.21 :s1_1′:T:missi{m ‘:)t3f<3z'*i-3 this Q£;1.;_§*t '§.4_1:i.»';{§g ¥€\1'1€'i " 2.23'
the pi~:tit§<::;t1er has b6:€:1"1. tmi: (iZe1i;i.1"a§
}3n.1pc3v:em::er1§i €7{)'Ei}Hiii§'§.§?€3 ;3@:'I%}§.:§ si<)z1. {_.f:_1rt’:E&>%V is; 1’°€:(;uE:’6,:(} to bifi
}32″§SS€€§ is {.0 {§i:”§§;;;,i.’v1’E’::.%:.Qrcéggésaréii631i’:/z;u;:i1′:0rif.i<=:s in{:}1_:di.§1g tine
',{:m1'é:',% -_£%§z7<3.§3i°::;€,<<§::*1:r1§%'2f:¢j{'*2. €Z101m:p£ic:;a£::5:}11′<:%f' '*r1"2¥<';~.r §_';<=;7*{i%i§€;::':§§;:*. in a{:{:<':«:'(ia:':<:z?<:§’£’=..,’rr.3<:z.7e§pi' of 'z5~:{i:ie3;:§:-1* «of iihis flfdfifj'. 'E'h<% 3'<:sp<';:1d€'m:/
L.;;:£;sV:j£i::r§%ii€::AS"$125; '{.}i1'<%c€.€<:i to :7~2e1'1d f1£3C€i$$£i?'};" <:<3:11:1:11::%«.::atfii{;:": :9;
'E.1r:{:m«:r::1en€: iiamznifiiiee @n:i:Ec;$£;:1g the Copjy of
_th;1$ e:*;1~’~’«.r.iz:=,*;;_*. Pfifitiorzer is 8134:; at 33′.§;i2<%:1'*t._j;–" to Submit: necessarjz
'f72*:%:.5r::§i':.{§<t:z*$ in aha (l"Eé:r:t:rai Em;30w1′:1r:1§i,{:ee E3326
‘ i3§1§,€§IQS§.§1g me c;3§; z:>f €1.35; magi” to <:<3I1.<5_i1d6:z' Eiiid <;iis;p0s£=: 01'
'4 ijigi :3.;:a}::s§§mi'.ii)r3 §§€E(3 E2}? him. "i am S1.£E'f_": thzat: '31:: €.ii<mt:3'aE
"
wzs
EmpGwcé:”111r::1″1t (‘3<)mmit.t€.<:, havirzg 511.1%: :'c::g;a1"d 1;.) {ha i';at'.ur<;=:
cf 3:116; <:fiSp1.:*a;<=: vaixd. aim the t:§§:('e(:*;.i01'1 3;i:"€aw:iy %s$i;%;%:–:ii E3}; t,E"':§;<;
Cur{T as {mark as 01″: }£},<}L2{)€§5 ::i'1**;*s:::?;:Z.:":g t;h;.2-:rA;..a_;Tz§f§;{'§;'§:{i:::s {.0
c(:a11sédé:r mt: €ipf)h{I8f§13:Ofl filed by _:.}_;»:§"~-..g.}:%_iiti4<3:i1€r<32;
28.{}9.:2{}€}4 c§31′.1si}:ij_cf%1’£’.i<;é1T.1_
$1,1bn1.%_i,i:::i1 i':s}; the p€:ti{i0I1e:":f:)';" §.i<:€f3;'iS§i..V':4'z£?§fééészifiéiiiigai"
'Shit Same and isass 3;I3iJ:'0}3.i;i¢*;%§?;e Ofi"Ci(:'¥§'E§V. ' ':a<,t€::*:§::r<éa:{1<:<*: W.i.E,I"1
law within téiae time §7ff3V€i. H
The mg-*1*it _p6:£:i'ii<§A:?;._V:S§a1L§t§%;i,:L off' £21 £125: abczvs:
%%%%% JUDGE
'.ޤ_'.?Ev3.;-_ '