High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Great Southern Coffee Pvt Ltd vs Deputy Commissioner on 5 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
M/S Great Southern Coffee Pvt Ltd vs Deputy Commissioner on 5 February, 2009
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda


EN’ ‘E’H§: HE{§%§ {.”Z(L3’U§2″‘”§’ cg}? §{A_R§\EA’FAi{A, £;A§a%:§§;::;{§:%,§:

E>éx;’§’E§1″3> ‘I’H§iS THE: D5391’ ::::«* ‘§*;%:§3§€:;;§f;§i€V’:*AJ

BE:F{f§§fi§§

‘m;§: m:a:z~:*}3m: MR, an;-‘:§’z1§%§=%:£«:}3S’:;s:.§:E:§:x{A’SE”::”;:s§ ‘:’Jr:> §1_Eaiia €315’ :2<;:::;?';3:::«:a¢:4§%E3}

EEFWEEE _

Bsifis. Swat Sfilifhfilfl <'3::gf:E%'€V6VP§I"£w–~Eji:d};g,.

Ha}s§akka}'a*€§1EaS%.;"'    'V 2 =
{§11fi=:a.1'§1agg:£i*s_:§:,_."    ~  

R::pr&s€_1″1–f;:s:»z_§ E~_é.”ai’_:’;z1gi:f;g E?2iifc£:EQ3″

E}N:V€n§:ai3f’%§$§ Pfiéiiécxiisr

{By .§\E’éai£;j.1,::’1{ias:..§;;$1;afixii

1, ‘£’2<:"{p.1;__:iij_=,2*%M €:":<.';':.f:1:r§L':':T~:%=§i'<f:£T;i€.:;',
Cihika-3i11gaiVu1?_ D§.:s{;:§.:it,
;'€§ih§k:€sfi1aga§'i;:1". '

€'V'i_5§i?1§:'€»i" """ 'A A

' * –. _V Qafififitsv R':':_CQVt31'}' bziazmgtznzzezzt Ei£'a;1<:h,

V «AV, ";E33_{::;i«:i€:3ej«; Raaci,

" '–..%'Ba1;; gaia'j.;–e;»55::3 (3233.

_Q.}

.. T353-gé.:’;§11;£p€f’§MI”i’€.¢3I”i€§€i1§.Cif Peiiczi,
{.3h;E§«:ka3:z1aga31n’1: Bisirici,
{?h;§kE:a31:agaii_1:*r:. RESPEENBENFS

3: ~$n’st:¥rai’

‘ ‘{i?;j§’ Smt, H. Samjiizi §\i§:1′:’h:a_n::1a AQEA fag’ Re 1, gain’;

.3’…

Eviagisiraié: serif’ {ht-: §.}:}.$iria::%:. tat} tafgzé ;T;as<:;:-v*,s<%:,§g:<.<:;':;3r_r"*V;" ' séé.' "i;;'g:r::

p§*0§.r€:1*€;§=* giveie as 5~:.€:c1_:f"i'E}: x¥E'1'?§e av2';:ifii3;§g"'§§1€: A_Ea5£é3T':

::h::2*ef£;r€: '!;h€: i§:i.i.:3:r A:1::§exi,_1:1~:§x (:a;:_3":t:«.i.s:j:_ i:3_$:s;:§:{};'"fjjg 1:316 '

§-1'ij}A 52:3': §::«:%":i':aE'f 0:'? ihfi i?}§;:3:§1*it:§.'%§" §\f§?:gT§.S§'.3'3§;fi g3,':€§'~: ffi %i€§1"é§0:'€ it

3:: act:t~::::'<ia.:'3;:.i:€: §%'§'E'§"§._.$fiC,VA§Z§ '
'?, ":E'fae Eezezrzzééi :'fE:<;2%:::ii(::::'%::;'§§§5 . _i¥':€3.Vacaf.€ :«;:1';:23:2<::**i€{1
:i:s.<:f: $1,i§f}Ii}§.$Siié}"§$ Eizéiiifi "'?z2iT§'€i_ (§{}2i1'1Sf:E§ €91" the
Baifig, :_.':2'*: :§::f' -,.§Z§t"f7£1?L;'f'§£"i'?_iiii¥;¥';§;VVV'C%§' fiat: pa:*i_ic=:s, ii is
:":€€£Zf€$§vé':11'§f 1:.;5E;v}i'§.'§T };:4- ihfi AC1; °;¥hi{:h rtzatiis
tizzgéé: V'
V ' ::?1'§§¢'e2irap9Iitaa Efiafistrate
'=3§' * §§;$t5:t%iifii:.. ~7 biagstraiaa to assist
$eé':§=mfc__§______. ereéimr in taking
§£§$5a$$in§ emf aeeurad asgets:

{1} ax;-‘”‘£1<Et:'€t E316: {;»:;:«:-;sé:$S:§<::'1 inf 3:35;
:$_€€::?1"§1'fiii'§ 3.s*sa€:i; is rfiqziérfid 1:0 ha iakfifi
§i:jg zhfi tiiiiltiffitii <;:'&dé%:@§' gr' if 231}; sf the
SEC"?/Effifi asset is reqyiiraci 1:9 said or
E:1'3.I:sf<'::"'r€;<i ':33: thfi: seizzurfié Isreiiimz'
iifififif the ;:::'<::vi3iC;1"::~"; af @3235; Act, me
ssr3{:1:1*@(i ififfiifiiifii' may, fa" (he: p¥j'£'}f30$3€
6.3.? 'zakiizg possesaian 25:1" czzzztfczi af an};

%

"§'E:1%::*s:f€;:1*€::§ fiiifi {;t3"i1%:'€::'fiiGf{: 8%' the §€.i5:§'§'".".'£."";i€4ff§._ ' é';é:<§"e.~:.?n'3€JI':

appéaqfizig far 'the Ram}: '§,§'1.8;i..v'i'LE;ifi" }::i:i:.sfi:' j

.i:=;su€<t§ $316 .'§~:%,€;%A 01': behaéi' €35 £2-"–2,_t.+:z §T}i:§'§:ifi<;t£'..E'»<{3§g§§§sfi?a1?,€

€.Z3;fl§}tI§§f 3:36 a(:ae;3ix::€i, fer' "i,'§1'Ei ;'3=Z;f.31f{33E€fi 'I'§'€1'SQ.if£ f"§?i_ai"'t.'£1e1*:é is

'11:} 33535:: =::31Er:':(': 32:; {Q}§§:iir:i§:§e:§'¥E':'E§iagisffa%,€; }§€_"}'i,F:»"{iV§:E"'

'zzjg perusai Gf ;%m1€TXtH::f€§'~A;–vii.fis;_.¢E&31:'* ihat if: is I10: fhft

Gm: "1SS13Jfi(:i –Tii"1as_§: z::Xe1'c:isi:1g 'nit;
§§B§¥€1f' 1;I3~i'{'e3,f_ if .§;:f…f;h*3' 58?. "§V'ir;eI'ef::«3"@,, I havrss: EEG

i)f_’;i§Gi1 §”£:’a5€. ?:}’}!3r3V¥’;’_’.15 1::%%2i=E§:* AIm6x1.:.:’€»«A i3 WhG§}”
iiiegéi éf law £=3:1s:1 is; 3;i:–f:.%3}€ :6 b6
:<.;x?:'i: ziéiiéei; % _ V

§§{éi.:r}:'<vii::gi_§:',A'._V§§i':§9 '%'z%'1"'§;i7 ;{3€':i'E:§;(311 is aiiéjmizai. 'E'h<:':

é7{::i};;mg:":€{:i ::i:’&~A $5 S-361; aside, E””§Q¥¥’€3i€1′ it is

A ‘.§;p’§.:-” ‘(ha Qiairici.

Magis§i’;:”a’i:,e in a.<:<::f;sr<tEa1":<::€: wiih Sat. 335% :3? £116: Actt,

913

31:22, ii, Sarajini 5:1 i_13j1aI1I1a3 {he 1’f§aI’I’_TE.fii{E .£”aj»:i::j1:§*£’:i[;f:3’4::.~ai

1:’. V,

€3<;sv€1"I1311€I1f Ativocate is p<:n11:*3ii,e<::i it: .W93":'%3Vc1;–.i11«f;:1:¢€' :3?» 'V

appezarancafi

Li'