High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Manju Engineering Works vs Assistant Labour Commissioner on 31 October, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M/S Manju Engineering Works vs Assistant Labour Commissioner on 31 October, 2008
Author: H N Das
'¢}KIUf'0b am-wan -mmrwvma wt mwamaurmavfilflwfi Muwm MWWWNE KM?" Wflmfififififlm.      

3%'  :--§£:«2~: ii';f§'£.IR'§ £2?' z«:&§s%p:§:am gr sAm:éLa§§2§¢%   

§;3.'§'E§ "ms was 3?? am 5;? amsaea     %  A

BE-FQEE

é"w§ %~:$%é'&aE m.3:.§§"§"::E 3; 

 Pififigfi §iQ;;¢2*§1:jgVk'jAg% S424 ;L§!1§:*m  

......¢.....u......

E53 i?'s:%fi....%§Ji} E=f§GE*€;E?E~E§3'§%;'}'  " _ 
mm rz::t;%€:%&§_, :?:&R}3E§§:'--E§"~E'$§g§   ' ~ 
Sffifaifififi :£f§*;?« ""  "E1: "
$I~1"§2'§fi;iZ3§§~fi§I$'§}§§€»i7_§*3'-,    
§E>Pm$§;%%'£'E£JE¥;¥§'_i'S? .  
%::2=P..§»:m..e_"*:%§L.;E°{,§fi?a'3.?§~'§L -  " '
$§{§E%»?£L?§":.§{§E»$=}{§ " ~.  
§ifi'§§:}_fi:§*?:§j%:F_§:'§7°'§  é V

am' $31:  fima,
my    %;§§~;:::@:: 5%   

 

" answuinsmua I

  :A  < Sfififififi
_  ,§';§;?.fiE?E B§%?ES}'§Z€

   

 

 

 %3E'§-'Ii:-fifi  2;  , zgmgierry
€f.:$§'% {§§I£?§.'§'£ fifi

C7[_L./xx

SQ

 



....m.. ....«..,m wwwfil mm" #u%mNMEm¥W<». R°¥§%%%"% %;%':}&M"§" W}? myémgmm §-RG3"; Caum" fiw mgwfiwfim Hwy cgggma

I*fl§%§%§§§;:§ ggaag 3 gm?
'm$;v;%§§:§gg~%§3 Sgmma $53'?
g§§..;%§.:3:"§§a 
3  ::fi%§%;"§a§fi E%?$?E 3mg

2'; €;"';Z%T%£=$§Z..F; 2; 'mm aamg

 532;?

fifizkfifigfi §I$"§"§E€;'i"'§5'

a.  Tssgggzmm
gmgaaga Tami:
$r§2«%?aiR.:'ii'I§§ m;s;;kA%     

 "s£3I§"3, ;i§V.t*§'§§:§§R'2$:ffR"*1?I£E}E*;S: 2% & 22? £3»?
 :.%:€;:§%§ :%'1"§'§"%,;§""§"1%5§E 32%' §€;E3Zéi;.F'§3§i:';f'£§£fi TE} QEFASH 'EH3
::'3;%$§E%.  §;a:'«:§.§.:&Lzfg::~*z«%?:fi%';$$§:¢%§k§?'%x' 3-3 mg   x-D,

 

  «§Q'§_'&  323% $333 the fiaurt
mafia ah: §"3éi%,t.:g¥*'i;*:g:%."L'A  

_  Eéziiég =arré%:"  'aha gafificmef Ema. pmyvad far writ

  1.

23.? mrtissrafi ta éfzbfifi 31% sxrtier dam

A’ by fix fim: zmpansixazzt as {amid at

1;- § gag: {}5£%2.:§£§:’..3€~ mssasd by m 2%

rm fifi §m§.nd at fixmmzaam -~ E4
pa

} 3 gym’

gut-we-amum:rwnrrIII\:l'”k “mum mwwwm vi wmwmwmesmmm Hawm Kmwm’-mi mm” mmmwzzaagamfi %””‘H¥»;J=«%”i ¢¥».~M%.W€§ QM” ?fi,&é’~i¥:”a§§~3$’%’.£%€§% HEQM QQURX

4′!

shsmqa “l”‘aw:1; Sn £’3*’.fi&.2tI§G2, the am

éfiaxirz fimgmsmfi tha waré: amp
fauné $1351: timy have 9, mar.

Q3 :in’=.ra$I:%z~*ati3z*;3 tam :3:-:1 km mw that
the pe§fi£1}32′::am h.a%%’a :£1:t,’.f.’t m the
finilci zabaaa and me:

wtiiimners § ‘ha
:is.ma.£x’i a zfisgmfl 3:1$§_w ” paitir:-ma.” no
éapfiséz. 3 3:22.31 3%” R$.2§,,{§@,:’_VM-A fizz’ vioiafion

cat” girir-w:.ri.sis:::$ fiffi

‘ A 41; meg ubjegqjgm

is: ihaa $31: rwpaneiant am

‘I’1i’e§.frrfi rmmdmt aitmr hearing both

an srdar 93:3 maazmz m hum at

$3 W}? 1I}’1E ‘ R

2;, %’E:I.$%m3m is rumxim an eng,in:aexf5*.x§-~§…_’–AiI1vL_’4 V ‘V

V_,….,’,: mwmwm WWWWQ W mmwmm mum WW: W mawmmm amm cww W mmmmm HWH WW

a “am am: mponaant aim initiam
‘aafusm gm :5ms*’gEd xmpczfient c the I.
paymafi sf’ “wag-m fir a

pagzafila fir: fix firhifi éawr Ammlmmar’ __ V 3

rmpsfignt xéfisas mweier éatmi

afi €i:fi’€»<1"€&§ the petifianmfi " in

waxes, in an wtan9.:.;::;f Rs:.Egf;332fV-" hhcr

ax {maxim at fimxexzm 2 'V 2'

gt; by these we
arzisafa as fmamikga m%%m% km % ~3~& E is be:§0r%.=: E13273 mum in

this' $33' wziitiaaaa " V

-~ an bath the side and pwmxsaé.

fiéfém gm fiat mspefimt, the gtefitéanmfi

{hay have mt erzgqufi the chjfi fiabor by mm
323$ fim: tmm 5.8 m mastm” and smvant

The mm flaw amntsexid that the mans” r

aflizi mm: ta amt war}: slmp in search sf him

ow

nwrwwetm rz a»\Ar”‘Mn¥z vM”‘m2.3}-“-M°Y2ma**°w. tr. ElIVm|’R $1

wwwemw we mammaw-mm-=auu-1 annuru wwwma mm awmumawmwmwmw uawww wwwma Mr mammammnmmm i£””HW&”vl wwmwm WW Wmflafimflmmfl WEWN “L.-‘SJMKH

maifirzzafi; um}: $3: Kama Armugam am hg was
iahcsru En maggzeriz Bf ‘thém mntmufisng this ~ 9

fiamai azzgr $’§§§fiT.I.1:3& Rfim the firat

.;3:*§ rasgamriaxat «~ Elabflf
mgr’: am”: :r.:’£§w dacumantg tfm
ham amzgagai & ,
‘§%m mm as ‘§§od11:.:aa their
$fi$fi fiuocumeztztze
they have not
amiaagreaci “inf: case of the pefitinnqezr
tlzaé: the am: Impecmr ma may
that éhere was any ill:-will

a 3§ tiw tzndezr

m ma Iii-fifliafld mtim
by ‘gémnfi rmpanfiem ‘rim ‘tn

mmgmsafim amam: s.->§ Rs.2a,9w;- is in

“with kw and E am 1:15 justifiabie flzzld m

§_”:’x*3.:§r§’3§”% wag ma aama.

ow”

*”~*’-“*-“HA fs-v’.*f’-Z Iwwmwvmwwwmm Hw.’wm Mwwwfi MM” mmmswmtmmfi NEW” MUMKQ WW Kflflwfiifififl Wig” HUUWN Q? KflmW%£¥”fiKA

8, Eaélzsra the aawm rmyondam, the

éfimpuée fiat Ezmfiama :%e: aemné rmpuxfiemt, .’

. mézwr skfiid

msé aim 13:13 amgkarym mi namaa ”

gmpzwggi gram, the aamaa rmp¢na§:;:r:adkVa§1yk%%:§1am into
mxmiafimafimn £235 mridexme {if

Elia §&}§vz’}$§’?.§;§I”1 0%’ aisglsm-i_ by the

Wagam fiat were It is V «

pefifiianezr. 6%} evid% amflabh
am zm:£:x3:*::;.i by the aemnd
‘:wmp§§_fi.e§3.:<:r {LEE qr-dear passed by

am ;$$r:}§3<x2~£ ;é$§L¢::§:m§% {3;&*.»fQ}.;.zid at Axmma — E aim liable as

m -. stated afiaszrw, the £::%'evEmg:-

GREEK

mam tn tkw impuma mm: damd 1ém,2m4

— fii yamefi ht; 33:3 firm xmwndmt E hmaby

IHJWIWR ‘ufll §’|’%s&”‘€5W’§.§\M”‘%It:h”‘$$€’%tfl”% i§IK’%E”|B& wwwma ‘M75 WaJ”\I’MlVll”fili”%I’\fl’Q !Ili\’r)’I!€ VHWNFWK Vfifl §V.£”‘II\fi’lzl”6.&.!”‘nl\::I”%\ Ikilfiifiiifflt WWWWWV Wall’?! fi’%.é”*’¢¢?’M|”fis§’*’3$.?§:¥”‘Kx$”%o.¢””& i!5l~9I”ku3″flW wwwmm W’? 53.*flfi”‘Q|’tKV££.W”%¥Ui”°|.R’&§”‘& It”§€|%%n’eE’9?|E mwwmt

rsgcwfi am ma axrfiex af the fzmt rwpotmient is

afi,

Em impmgzzed order mm by the

damé *¢:”35.§.%E.’-.E’12€I§£iV1r fixmexurcs – E 13 3

mam is –

T 9:’ Ra:.}.§}mL3,f-¢.*”i1′: Id.éppgit’ é..b:é§§éé’. rm
ilfizmré; éfi tcr kw mittw Child

xgsm

Ek E3ai’£a’vm::¢ .’ 139 he -rlcpcmftuw by tha

wtifimmsa? ‘ark E2131. ‘ &_ §2*-1% ‘ V wm% fiam mfiay.

Sd/-t
Iudqe

: £01″ fimk éispnsai