High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Master Micron (India) vs Bangalore Electricity Supply Co … on 19 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M/S Master Micron (India) vs Bangalore Electricity Supply Co … on 19 March, 2008
Author: N.K.Patil


|ni’.. P. 510. 19514 . 2007

W “I’I”1E Hirtiirl-i IZIQURT OF I{AHNPLTAI’ifi fiT E-AN

3;:wrE.:a THIS TI-IE wm mm: 9? MARCH, ~

BEFCZIRE

mm: LE 1:{?…IUS’£’?_£EE ,

T_@£13iE;T…-E.£FJ_EIm€£ELPl§3.;l¢§_$;j.f_2;Q§hH£3LP£:£i.E;E§ ‘

.-E

M; E mma x««i:r;:r+=eo2:r%% tImLas%fj%&j: T k___ _
I’I|-3|. §..’Ii’:’ &1.4,BfJh1MASHNI:~”Rfi IN’FJI,I5’I’li’IfiL ARE-A,

EEPRE aE:!qfrE:.w :33!’ MAMGER A

1=ETI*I’I<:mER

my :*~;'~i:a.t: Lm-1:-;:?£:11~;1iz*'r*r'.*5ijsir»;;=;1~'2, A12:-V.)

' % 1 .":'.Fh.iE$1:3fEAH*£"§EiZ;R.'EC-LVFNE ENGINE-ER,
% L-'3m1'¥'%S':.#|1LflRE }EL}'32~Ef:'Tf'F'r:IC:I'1"n "-1.: "'

Mk%*H¢a:5¢;":mIx;aHE"

L..|..? – .nu.;-¢.uIJI*I|–II.

‘Wm’ ‘ ‘1’

‘ms. %.a7:a’.3tr* EXEEUTWE ENGINEER

.. __ -unnlulluln.

I+.a#Mc3+aLmEtE ELE.cfr1’*mc:é11T ‘.’§fiP”PL ‘ mil. 1 .

323* 5’15 M 31,13 If3’I’~v”I5.’~IC)N,
1:3iHM’IE3A.PLJR

:’£FLIPE:RINTEEm=’IHIG ENGINEER {EL}-3]

.a%LPPE£’.Lfé”w1L M313 1.”:P’PELLA’I’E ATTWGFITY

.H:E.3£3QM5£ii.,’r,HgQIRQLE’,
}:”§:..¢!L’l&l’-a:I’n’z.fkI.’I:I:|aRE: .

EEESPGNDENTS

W”. P.1T’J’:3. 11352114 .. E2007

t[B;-ii i$’3’nx*’i: N 1:74: GT_IP”‘1″‘.?&, ADV.)

‘I”H1Ei*E3;”W..f* H»; F’T§I..EI£s’1.mDER ARTICLES -1.325 :3; A

‘ ‘I

{.ifi-midii3i’E”I’.f’E;F”‘}?iZ£’:fJfi =I’.i.’r’1?+’TEI-i’D;%.:=’a Pfifl’xfi€G__’–1″*’J _
P.”.’;sI?}:«I’w:’f£Mi:’iZ3I LE-‘§a’.”‘.FEE 1IIJ’!i. :2é..3.f&0£3I7 ISSUED BY R3 _
wnust. =»m’mra1E;::»m., &’;;51{.lTA$H THE ‘I”H1RI.’.I Rfa:»sPt3I€DENT E ‘
.»s;L”I*;af,z–sT::::E~::.:*:*a,*’s:~,;m1-‘2.I:;a :31′. 1.&;%12%.%19Lg-3′ 1!I!.;iE- I
;rama2£:.:»::J=* mm t5.::».1;m:e:.’I’ THE R1’E§3?DHDE§l’TS»v
«:.t::?Jm~;=s:i;¥;3;§3;1{~a’ TE-ifj; EE’fEPRE_SE-TN’fPgTEfJfi’ _.¥!:;?F’ ‘ _
P.E”;TI’I”};%.t:l1mE;.E%’&E A1111?! F{E}%«”I.1i’l[:: THE . ”

m’+::.L’s’t::iI«a:%1:<:%z.f:n '1w;:2w;a;:s::1:;::;~'. RE.I=*.:¢&m.r;_'.VT.'.IE' fm.aHs.FoRM§:H.

'.1E'h=;i;a1 W'ri;It. p.:-miaui-1kL%« agArm~ PRELIMINARY

-t’§~’I.MZ1TIi#’fi ciimu tI&3a§z’C’m:f»t:»vnlad_¢;A31:22′ fa:r11u::wi11g,:-

}2:’:2’ti5L#;i::’€;1?t&*:r1’5 ‘a§s1%i£i.’iJi1§»:VgV flitte mrxfictneaa of’ thfit

daztnlmimfgl % K 25.03.2007 in

‘I*I<:n..fi.1:'éf }-E!'. E 112'-11:."'.ZI+}?')' Jisa-isuaui by 17113 E" m3po11dent

1ar3…fl.%=.=: Vgr.a~1*::I:»sn::e_.si.:£..,..§; t;1'.1vz.a i1"u:a:1_'a=_n;._3. !¥:'1'i'l; He

.}":Lm=a_ :a.'%.§::.m::. s:;z9:é:2;2I,g;g~;}1t jfm" acgguaahfixzg; the cJrr§i».=;sI' cnf 'i:':1c':= 3%

1f'!'F.f%.f41:£'i%TE§'if}I'31rt%§Z'iT~I§g1a &:.a:z.th:ar=it3* r::a1:=d:.=2r= elated 13.121993

in Z B«::mpp¢a1–1;'1..»-2:33: .QE5fAncka1,4'2493–9?

A .. f V. .,!"l4.'s'1*II€I1lE{JC1LT&]f"I55'A–F'.

;;;::n:raéti11"iiu:k:¢.1t-gm rmanaiflng 'the r::u1*m::t11m3 of

imrflc "t:-i11§.a:7u;;g:.#' .';"£,'1".'.i.|I3. clwrmatmfl lfieifi-iC€3 ~i:a.~:¢u.r:.d 1:13.? the Ofiim of

% 2735'" 1"c~::a:gJrJ1a.u3%m1?;. 1'1.aa fil£§a'_'& the 2a.pj§:urm1 befiare 1116.: first

_V I"t:'._'g£it}I?a:I-:£L!tfli%itj.1t. vifie £'s.1'm»e+x'u1'¢-ix niattmfi '"2

lat'. P. 51%. 199114 .. 2007'

E42

éifiipttlfifltfi .m.11.tld;:3r'i.tg.r datxad 18.13.1998

ww.:z;m; 1wa;Ts=umka1/ :?w.3–g'r. The ma

cmnrxw ':::.:.p fT::xmr cm-ca*s:1as«3":»:i¢ra'n;i43~z1. 't:mfi::aw thfi

the, ¥3L}i:I]f.%t3Eé.1 film 1:33,: 1:11-:2 g1c:tiitif:1<nua::g¥~..,_;;s11co1di:*.g A "§1'2I}j.9.\.{§i{

Lwimlinga, E¥."i.E'E§."I11-£"a.12'].IE13. zmticma ialaueeri u§:i5t'_ 1f}.'J1B 2'13 Vida.
ihnrnI1w|:1..11*{a~'E«', IZ3'u.1«:aa:a1;i:s:1§§ézf}g t.'_E1ec£¢in::r.je~:;§t1"1cr3«s; of the nrdcr
1::aJ3.:smflE_ 1;;hg :fi1f&1§._ _ ' dated

-H |’,’!I

“fin

4|” V L.’S.”_. ,.- J…-.. …-…{Il .r4..n-I .15.
am 1

“u”‘u£’?g j;’V|i;__ _ V !.i._l;:’, 1.- ..’.’V J1… ,. 1.. – .. .. L ,_ V
. ‘!:”‘:1″l£’.21r,,_V Eg~§a:= ;–1M;fL1 w;1.1I’.’;.I 11113 =.a.1u:5u. um; :5 ,. ‘mum

f.-“-

ml fltana ‘Ei:”i3::+ »r.ts£.*E.;§.-“I.:.~”=.’$.;_: Auflmrity. ‘I”.he aaixi
St5>£3ai’:1ft»fii5§:_ l>3,:r:”tv§1_ca– 1:«a€=t:”a1t.ir::11a3r bnatbrc the Clhief

II3r&I1te1′.r;a1.;1. Ii!uI.ca.rua=sg;=t=:3f~” Thfiafi beern cliasmir-wed as nut

by ‘Rhea iérra.pu_’ngn£-aci clemxand ncntice, back

bfiéiliiaggg it%’;m:§E *:*;Ii1+rs!; «:»1*drr;tr passed by ‘Wm r-mp-Mmlenm 2 85 3,

V. J’QhEI.§WK”LL1fi%”J& $5 F9. 3_;’aafi;i.fion:ar Ema ptreaented. the

uunn-8$u-u;.s.-n+- «,¢–_r- ».

.!..|.;.LI:Hl.~l:flx.l.J.l.- w. ~

I 1*I::;.r-:;s.ri::==1’1m1″u:1 tlma 1-«mrnzvszi (5II.’IL1I’Jfl«fi1 fur the: gmtitiunner

aiwnwi £~u1s’~*us.*a 1,sr:2.1a:x”1″1.-.*sn1iE ct;u1un.::1ae.’i fezar the respnndanm.

/322……

W. P . N-:3. 10914 . 2007

4… #1: ‘limit cmrenfxfl lraertzuaaal mi.’ that nzsrdar paaaed by t}1£=’:~.3rd

1f1E’.E1CJu11i3c’Tlfii:§be§*.11’lZ Vida £”L.r1n:5a1c1m’e-~F’,, it #4:. manifest c:13….1_:}_1e:’_ 3

of amid .12-;w3é.:s2zr that, tgl-13 3″! 1*cea§:n:-r1~:1-3111:

1-. -u »u1..–. -n:g-:1′-I-ml: 1- Ilkwi ” an ‘

::§J»:._ LA ‘

t”e:aa1;1E?.:¥im in r”$t’.’hI”iI3111:Efi minis-««:rm::?i5_:ge: §f.ju3tir::s=_.ii*1A .a:La”mi;1e{h L’

5105,. 1:11»:-:». neeaauiri m1t1wri’Lf}r proper
ra::r1u2a:75’L2.’s’r-m hm: p:a*a::=cne»cac1¢§”:t _”c;: _ p@&V–_ in
jmstice. In
tirfiaaw tstf” fliiii in:.1’§’x’;ri*»:’ii’:’@
pstaad by the 3rd
I’mp:»’n’fi:Qfim1:1t~A and harm it ia liable has
be 15.25%. int-w further zmerits turf the

-0105; E IE5
‘o..nfl:JI.E!lt!’Tv_u-

at’ “time above dixem-utm-inn, the writ

in part. ‘I’&1u.=: nrder passed by the

E:;f1.I’Et,’+afll#Iil§¥’fl’y1H.tE Authmritgr dated EE.12:19E?fl be;a@ No.

an ‘aha ii}:-:4. sf tha 3!’!

V’r’evspcm:ha1’1t its 1″1r.-:.=.1*a=.=.~–‘Fl:by sent aside. ‘The: matter” its 1’emitteti

hank rm» :3-Ni rm”apr:xndmnt with a diramtiun to plane 1:11:52

a.ppe:ura7′:. fifififl ‘k:r§.r the pne’titi:m:3r befnm the flumpetent

/

r

W. P . Nan . 1’.’J5’114 . I100′?

{Fl

fiap;3es1ILs:it:5. ;¥5:.1.1″th2r.:u»:rit:3r wit3:nfi1:’1 1&1 pemémd r.:sI'” four Wfisfitkfl

the a;¥’;a:”.~:.’r::ra: -mi” 1n:’»r2:;.*a~3:s’t1:1a’fl: cf ‘|;1’1us.- copy ran? this V.

c»:m2cg;t»::=::’!:r:.;z*.¢-1: a:;a.p1:»::aBlate ai;h.’t11«3r’it3:” ia :;-1ix’e5=a’;-tad! >r_1i3;d_§:s~a¥:. nif

u m c .” ‘_g H ” ”

.. I4 .. . . . ‘ 1 ‘ . .. 1
um.-. a;»~r.L.::.1.*;% .:«m::.:’;:.:=::u…£=..*a’.”:+.=r.:% 2,-ar1’L..,.. 1:;=*.sr.-.1; ;2–t1″.:m.;3g’ «u’.*.»a:;:e.*”**._…,=;.€5..1…V=-1′”:.*..’*.e ‘

wziflm t:.’E’1+:t+. ¢a:7i_e:ta.ra;sm.1t. m.1m:a3t;.r $flC1fi5y.$5?1’1§§3i’i_fi’i” appjié-able V *’

iimziras rnfflrave ;gmu=:titE:m#ii=:ar_.: if

mm % 311599