M/S Royal Fragrances Pvt Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka The Prl Secy … on 10 April, 2008

gui

BEFGRE

THE HflN'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.5 BDPAHfiAv ::":"«

WRIT BETITIQN mo.1qo12 as saw: {Gfi~fiiEfiEiW i

BETWEEN :

Hffi RQTAL FRRGRANEES PVT Lwn'.]

a CflHR%N¥ IHflflREflRE?Efl manna ?HE.'. *-- ;
PRDVIEIDNE my THE Iwnxnm cmmpgmzna Am? 1955
PREEEfiTLV'fiRfi1fiG 1T3 "~T%', %; "*"%'r

HEAL uyrxcn HT n~3a, smuwa ,"" ._v_._,
Exwsmaimm, PART ii, HEW fiELHI.ilfi fidiv'
HEREIN REFTD.EY'1Tfi HflTHDRflSED"[flu_ 5
napnmsnnmnmxvy. ij ;~'~ =2 , 3. 'W

nn,s E Gama; a;ED"AfiflUT554»$Eafis-T

SFU.H L sHn3MA*1gn _=."5~A" j
gsafiamgagag-3&9 C fiSfl;13TH'MH3fl; HAL

awn 3TAfifi,1xmn1aaga5An;<_ .'

ERfiG%LflRE*fl$ ' .9. PETITIUNER

:3? Eva g.a gay}, anv. FoR.M;s %%H3TEL .A.
A3$0EIRTE3, nflvs:

71"KTHfi*fi?amfi"bF xmnwamaxa av
f THE PE$EflIPRL SECRETARY FDR
"usvnammzmw
, gr Iunugwnxaa awn ccnnnncs
n, {1HflUSTRIAL nmvmnnpumnwy

'h.3uEflIhBING, DR.fiMfiEBKhE.ROAD

'~EflfiQALDRE~01

KERHETAKR INDUSTRIAL AREH BEVELOPMENT
EKURDP BY ITS CHIEF EXEfiUTi?E
flFFIflER AND EHECUTIVE MEHEER

I
'L
I'.

$$w"L«



V1LLR§E# 'fERTHUR =H0Ba:, Eamaaboia fifiuTw.u

Is' I F i'.zE3G}""1,. "'r'\'.'-'-'aflT}"x'C'a'i"?."7L"1E'a'rJ'$'u. E~'F:H'.'E ST'IP1'I'H
E11131 LI}! L'-JG-2,. NRUPJ3.T'f-i'UN(.31k ROAD
E:".7\3G..'-7': [:*=W'=':"'éJ.

... nsspomnmurs '? 
{HY SR1 H'M MEMJUNATH, GOVT. ADV. FOR R1, "
':':ii}7~:§[ 'E' V l3HA!iDRAfiHAEKP;R, ADV FCIR R2?

THIS wax?' PETITION IS FILEB uwnER.flAnTiCLfi$T

E36 ENS 23? GE THE ¢flNSTITUTI9NWflF IEDiA"PEAYING
TIL: lJ1I4:f:1E;'.T RESPDMIJENTS TC! CCIEWINUE'ANB-:'Cf0PiP_LVE'l"E

THE P£flUIfiITION FROGEEDIMGS In '5fiPEC?.DF £$fiE3Vg 
cmvgasn mmnga 3Y.mes. 10x1; 1aJ1;F2;Q;12E¢"1Q!3§;»
131, 11x2', 1133?, 54x1T=Tu 59/6, :54z19_ G?

- V .i'- *2" y . ,, ', .-.~V'~ J' . V; V'.  V 
DE$fiEflBi$fiNRH%LLI AME 3?.flu.2%;1,- E3fZ, ,3Gf1,

fiflifl, 3131, 31;? Ann 32 (N? KARIYEMMENA AGRAHARA
TELUK,
PUREUANT Tm THE GAEETTE jNQT1F1caT;oN nT.1fl-12-
3001 IESUED B? R~1 vIDE'aMN;Tfi£mn'ET¢;~_

THEE FETITiUfl Qfinimé; §wj»3ofi.¢fiiHAL 'HEARING
THIS D,v, THE Eufifif MREE THE Ffibbflfllflfi:
         
Thfi =pe:ifi£mhe:KLia"before thia Court

fiaakinm fhp"avfi;#ectiQn ta the respondents to

:Sy@N$amiGfl;a_1flf11; 1flfl2P; 19×29, 1ai3?,

lifigw i1E2P;}”i1J3B, 54:1 ta 54×5, 54:79 of

jfiavaEabiafififihalli and 3urvay’ No.2?/1, EQIZ;

3D}1L’3ér2? 3111, 31×2 and 32 cf Knriyammana

=f%fi:aEw*a flillagqn V rth1r Hubli, B

run, 4-“: ‘n 1. ‘
«5par., Mavanaasasanahall; and 30!!

Kariyammana Agrahara, Varthur Hbbli, Eangal¢me

v

Swath Taluk undar acquisltian fro fiéifig

fuxthax encruached. The petiticnar h§#.aifid:”

awught far a diractinn to thé”r%£ficndéfitaxtfi

pravanr any furthex- construfiticmi frbni bai$g_

uarriwd :”t an the lanfla a$m§:ised 13

y;u 15

km
<3
db

i
"*4.

I

{part}, Dgvaxahe3ganah&1i;’ 2 afid”» ~ ‘fi
Kmziymmana.AgIahar§;V?aifififik fi%h§if;3angalore
fimuth ?aiuk¢ afifijthQri@fifi fib§g;@d£fifider Survey
r.ma.3.s::,.r1,. :1′:3}f%1J;;%%r{,;1_t:: 10×32», 13.11,
1.1..-“29,, 54:79 or

mevarahiaanahallia *j-,4Eurvay Fm.29fl, Efiffi,

%a:~_.!:L.. _;3:::~_.~’..”-.=”,.-«.. :a3.,*_:._,A’~.;j1;!~’fi and 32 at Kaxciyannnana

x”Agxahfir@: ¥iliége¢~’varthur Habli, Eangalora

*fihufihgTm;uk;’

4′:

V7 ¢;”‘Tha patitimner has aisa sought far a

‘%ixegtififi ta the Banana reapcndent not ta deal

t with°hr allwt ta any mthar parson or antity

m tht Laflda gmvered undax Sy. Nfla.1flfl; lflfll;

. _ . Iv » .a 7
f 1.’:-%ff3Pp

41

tm Eéfh; 5%??? of Devarabiaanahalli Ema

E’
‘!

_¢..I-I-::~.EE9.r’l, 29:2,. 30:1, 30..-‘1, 31×1, 31/2″i’:’s.:i;«5{“»

32 WE Eaxiyammana Rgxahara Village, fia£tflfit:°

Hnblir Eangalora Swath Taluk”whidhLha§§flfiéén

natiiiam fiat the puryose cf axalfiaifiw use by_=%

, 31£1,_31x2 and

£5

.. o

-I.

1.1-

U:

thfi EEfiifi’fiuE

l’

y.N¢fi;3fi#:

32 mi Kariyamanfi ;Egraharfik fii1;ag$}”*?a£thur
Hubli, Eangmlora 8¢fi£h E&L£E;:fifii@h have been
nutifiad, fa;~fi@e pfi¥éé%a §f a3h$fibive uae by

cm 1;Hz=.-t it max ‘E. 5 ”

73u_-ffié ;§ati£ignar claima that tha

patitianér has afifigfit fér allatmant af lands

_ in. gfifi ,la§mufi to be fmtmed by the KIADB

I . V ‘ I g ~. 3 I
.lI3.7.”E?~flt«m%flt as dsaaided us. the F.-.}1-gs-lg;

iflvEgt¢r7m3et by the Gmvernment af Kmrnataka

v_andR&a<$uefi, the patitianer has also applied

a"fiE:ough"fihe Karnataka Udyog Hitra and it ia in

:§thia' anntaxt, the patitioner geeks for the

– ‘3;i@ prayagg in the writ petition; mince

‘%
all-u
V.

5.-It

»:;r2a:”.c;.::..;i’z:;a:1 ta ting petitifinez’ tlzeyr are entitled
ta time: alltz-tnwexzt emf the plotaa in the ae.~.;*7._s_:i

landau

, . ‘ I
*3 . L’I:1fiTJ’I.lI’§h zzsi.-11rr:a.Lfil L’3i.’i.L1″L’.’.’vE’I11L~.T;;i’.?7’3.i’:” ha” .55

been raiw-ad in the wxzit ]§iFE!’t$_i1Ii.-£?,I§.:’fiflh’-.!:3§3I115’§Il$i’~:, A’

tlmt tha 31’El.’.!9}_’Jl.’lII1s’I3.IE]1’Ii~’1IZB ax-9-.___t:3 ‘1:.ae° ci.i1¢va”‘aVt%:’T{;«é@’:V1_. fin

p::~=::~~:ut~.ev5.-.d. a11<:1 complete "'aa11
jpltmzaa-a;u:1i:t1g’.=. an i:ha.t–‘_pe§–t.”,it–i’m’ie:Ar would get

‘ “1 ‘ . .

~:-;r1t:.i:wv:i 4.20 *.:he:._.aa.ll.r.;st:»m4e .

an i.i:.e% ‘:::z’1::;ai;:_:1:.:’s:s:;;’L’V’ f:;aV*pa_rfia;:.<;}'.::-'i-a. h*vé filad a
mama 1:-;e::":'-:;«1:ev«V..V'L:':.'h:i;'g:: -.'ir.:§11…t:xt': _' irid3Lc:é;t.ing the list of
2:'?-we-.3, 'w1*L&%1:aAi.fi'Vt;Vh'eze% <2-'i-r.;1r.=.=J:a have quwasticz-ned

true amc;11iiu:3i1':i¢:1:. Vp.rc~u§ia.z§'dinga initiated by the

V G:n~:rm:3§;i11r.gen1: :fuT'J'1T__ ViT;f'J;*-=3 ?:mnrafit cf the I{I1P;DB-. The

"};:=e{t.1'V;+.t:L.mf_;s in +.:-.«.i5 regard, which lumra ha-an.

14.:

a:f1’I’J.I:”‘1*. .34..’

:%:”‘:i…’£_.r’s:-:; .32:-“e::.’;»’E”r”.:~.,:_mv.T’V”‘i:i’1:La Court are aa fitnllows:

z.m:»~ur_r~rc=;;’:r3»:a9;2x3u4rxmrmmng – S1r.Nu:::a.54_I’E.’

E’ I

‘ L:

…2*

“uff2Vw.p.No.17541!2floa {LA-KIAnB1~ sy.No.54f1

}3 W.P.Nm.1Tfi43fEUD4 (LA-KIfiEB}- sy.Ne.54/3

I
£1.

‘YJ 1’91 .’.»-I. ”
¥”3uJ’.’n-1.Ju–L«’

g-.

and 54KB

5 W.P.No.E556f20QE :LA–K1AnB)- sy.Ne.54/qf5? ‘

a W.P.No,173E3K2Ufi4 cLA~m:AnB1~ sy.No;$§/3 f5’V

v w.@,nm.17324/2904 qLA~KIAm3y=-sy.3o,ib}3x

E E,P,H

1:}

aiiril 3. {S 3’ 1 1

9 W.E.Nw.3O979/EUU4″tLA-EIfiD§)¥VSy.fid}32f§

lflfihEmNm.3fl980f2flD4 t:a+K:fius1§ fly 39.30/2

11w.P.ma.aogaakéamagayfiexzgnsyg’gy§No.29/2

5. In ttizifir Caurt is said

tr.:s 1?1=”:’=[‘1.1’:%’3_ e:1:2:=:::%r}.-‘sVw_=.s;i”‘.<::fi.__"i=32jfe. fmattazr: and the name

'Emma 1*a«*aer;=..Lr-*am.it*.t<§'ri' , fr;:;_1i'V :r:e=.ac:::a1r:.sic].a;:a.1:icun. Be

vthat.»»4.;jés£zsL.. it V' The fact: that the writ.

– V:L.t;L:::«-31$ _1a-.}s-rag’; heaean .f;L_3.aci hf; the ,,:-mars r:.~.’E the

pJ~.:.»._:;g_-.’.g_-L5 _::t:”j;,r V in ‘the as aid wri is p at it icsna , the

V_3_::»=sa?;i;’*t–i«:.~:%1§2§rv”””ftxerain i3 alsrza implaadacl as at

:;”a:-a;:s:;;nciViair;t is not in rziiteyute. Further, as per

‘siii-ataaila fuflaiahed. relating to the said.

–« “r.’«’n.*::;”;!i_t: pfl1′::i.t’:ia::I1E_. the progswrtiea bearing

1:.

9-

0′

.4631!2flfl1 :LAeKIAb3j+”:s§;Hbs.10{v[°7

£y.Nm«54 along witfi ita athar fiubanumgars ara

alsm flflfifitiflflfidu

9. Eurthazi reiatlng t¢ th% secondjprayars

made in the writ pafiitian fie ;iia¥t’%taa

rnapcmdenta ta prwvent13 gang g .futtha;a;

aanatructimn in the mattar had beén cdflaidarédv

“ray” 1:21.13 II:u:»u1:t; in View of”‘«.§1 r;.VVintt-miiri pfzayar

which has been fimughf ffir bf tfié petitioner.

J’

55.;-L’u:t }:=*:,*.. “1111;
rejewting ‘tE@ :§%a§§;€ @fJ §fi$u pétitionar ta
diremL thy rfi%@§$$@fi¥§st§ §r%V%nt constructian
ix; théx _$éié£ ¢#:9p§E§3<. had some to the

<::u:a:ru.':3.u.:ai»é.~3r; r:1'1&1':– izsézi . '§ai'*3',L§:1i§:'itss are: firmed up and

V mry5tfill3aed"in"favfiur af thfl yetitioner. The

.' ._I d ._..H I ' '
aVaa;fi yuaitxmn ramaxns unraltaxad as an tedaya

. _§fl $#é:f9in. re$pact wf tha :first prayer

"ska "sama nalatafi to u directiafi ta thfi

"w te$pwmdentm to cmmplete tha acquisition

ufgrmcamflinga and since that is an issua which

1
J2

3′.

II1.arI- \p\rIur’Iv- ‘r~ v– —- -7 4

1.; t.;

“éfiflifi” hafara this Ceurt aw pa: the ab_va

P
said liat wf petitimna, T am wf the View fihat

the guayar made in this petitian is premafiufarv

at thia fitaga and the aame canfict» %éJ”

amnaiderafl by this Gaunt. in any-fivafif} Eha

patitignar herein is impl9ads& daza ré$ponfiufifi_”

in tha pemfiing w”it yetitigns w”e:e’th¢ ¢wne:5

have quastianad tha_ aaqflifiitign and waffiéfi

diapmwal mf the aaifi wrifiEpefii£;§n§. if tha

raapmmflents _ vam. 1 ngfig *$:ccaBd further

axyeditimuwiyf ih3_£m;fiing “the’ lay-cut even

1

a.*E+.:eJ:- “mi-aa”:._1,a’1:.:i;s;’ to them, it 15

n-

snly atythat.ataqéL ;fi; pa’ tiona: wauld ha

51
{..a-

entitlad.tfiaaeak}f&:”ahy reliefs in the matter

$”aa *fi’th§ natufe grayed for in this petitian.

” fih”‘Thar@fib:e; Gnly’ on that qrcuuu, the

.p$titiafi.*i3 disposed cf at th15_ stage
f%aa;vihQ liberty” to the petitioner ta

:}a§firmhch this Caurt, if the grievance subaists

Janna: stated abnve.

I
12

1;

‘-1?

2=u.:::rux.x:~:iir1g13r, tlmza petitinvrx stands diapoaeci

of. Im <3J.'.'»:Zi-E1? as ten cm-5st:.*s.