High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Sathya Granites vs Mysore Mineral Limited on 18 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
M/S Sathya Granites vs Mysore Mineral Limited on 18 November, 2010
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar


.

1

3*? TEE MGR CQUR? OF KAR£fA.’§T&E§A A’? BEN

BA.’§’*EE TEES $32 332%: my SF’ 30%

THE Hfl1§I’BLE anmrsrrag 1smHé;;.?;§

c.m>.NQ.?3%y};..%F 2 c:::_g

Bfiififiz

ms sA?H¥A <3§.:&.NE'EES' _
HAVING Iris cw-"1ckE_A1: PK ,?:.m* ; .

5’*°’«?’*93?W-»i~%’3»–3A5§3*3F€’Tfi¥i-UR’; ‘ ”

ggudgggg    =   
5? f'{T.':3'?'{2.§£3E'»'r7£?--5E'§'Q;R_    %
389$'iié<A;?:3éJN?«:§3%T%» LM4 A_  

 ?E?I'Y"I@?4ER

(33; s:~%r:k%Vr:a;su::e:;£s[L§é;.}pagsm, mm, mg
L :4 .CHE$fi;€_¥3§!§§3AYYA )

% $1?-scasTLM2azEaA;s msrrgn
* A HEY §;::I~{&iRM§?si ANS F\§A¥’~£A$i£*K?§ fiiR.ECTQ¥i
gqmsg :»1.$,mAs,
§z’3′:%§G4;§LQRE~1
w RESWNDENT

% T V%.%{ag¢ s;R1.:A.x:. vssasm-5, A§?V., Sm.

MfSAi(VA$ANT%§&A%TS 3

wwwww -an

TEES CEVEL M§S€.PEE”2TIC}?é FILED ¥..§fS.i1(S} GF ‘¥”HE
ARBIWTESE Afsifi CQ¥§CIi.IA’¥’IfiFé fisifi’, ifififi, ?¥%AY’£?'<iG
TO 1'sP?G§¥%¥'¥' AH AREURRTQR Wfifi IS WELL ACIQUAINTED
WITH CQfiTRACTi3AL LAW ARE LAW 0? QAMAQES ANS
?RE%F3;fi§L\" THE RETIREQ HIG5 CQURT 35.3565 €.'§F THIS
i-13f*I'$§.E €Z$%.3§T $2 REYIRES Jifififié Ci? YE-iE H{Z'J!\i'B§.E

2

E§.§§§aE?*§§ Cfiiégg?” Q? §’i?%§E;% 37% §’§:§}§.§§Ef;Z§%’?’§ ‘?§”§E §§§§§.§?§
§%”%E%§?=-sé ?%€E E§§TE”§'”§§?t~§§§,, éfiég ??°§%§ §§%:%?%E’%§§§5§?° Efé
“§:”‘§§?¢’é$ fig §§§ §Q£%£§?§%f’%”§” §§fi;§°§§ E21 §_é=E§fi?fé ?§%E
E §?E%§§’? fig §i§$§$§.$ 5

T}%§E% aw _ _
mg ‘a2%,vv_%;”f?$*%;a?22m£:;:§ m:*::§w;§’s;}§ §;%’i£;;:E:
ififigiifi ‘§:,%:§s*é::fa;;:»#=g_’§;A§”§L§.”{$:*§ €:§:”$ E%”a%€$ §Zm:::.§ $2? §;€;%,€I§§

3:1? ii? é;;:§i: %:?’§*é2:z1V’%z§i”§;<;:a3°a§;§a§m%:a§§§ $392: éima fiiigififig

gzeéiéiétfigtézf "was $a;:%5§u§ ?%i§Q§§',:'»:f: Z%§e wag Qaikfi §:::=::'

eamgfiééziazz £35 §3:**£::s§:@$$ rgf :::&g::§§§at§:;:::g

' " €.:s:%°siz§@e§;;:'%£:::*§.§§,g sa Eéiisy 43? igééazéi wag éfigiéfiii §amu2* :3;

:}"§$""%3§§,._'%§@§': §:§:f§§§z*mms' in fa?-5.312;?" fif" iiég §é:s€'é;z:£m:ez* aria?

S'

.' fifiééégner §E;§::%?;:;:r% %;.,%~§?fi$f;3 mgfig %:s::§§,§ as? éifirz erg

"§!;%&§€;§ iizgmy $2: fiéa raza $5 §'2f:§§~ gfif maéxés Essa

§?fi§§§?3 éfigfiaaim haw fifzgkfizi figiweaa fix

"§"';%'*;¢:"§ 33$» fififigfiiiifiiifi mé €3s}:;:°3;§',&:* aiéagaiéazzg, "'§'E':e:*%

K/3

'%¥§f& fsgizéégagagfi sf z%~::a%;i%;% éfays §§g.::*::§»;-:3: Rflwawgg

aiiafgmigfi §:;§;:%;;§f:: éfiffififi %a':%*%:'§. £215 am :19": iaigvfifizékfi

iémzagiz zgziziaaé Eiéfigfiiiififiilfififig §E§%:.é.§3$;%;$§3g g ::2a::fi:.*;_:?§:aVV"€.:;s%;:?3.¥as»-.

is hfi :§.§§:_2m'§ fix §&€;:2%;§g2°z@r 2% :E":;$ Emgsmfiégfié .

233$ $§E:sé"%.m%:§;§:': i'.."'§%;'i%A§;$-$4; E3 $:;%é:§:{:a§*%'.as;*§ %;::~..V iéjgé-I ':4:-e,§$1§:::;s;§§§§£'2::"'.

in' at a mifirfi fiaaéga ;§§§* Iggy éaatééé Egg" '1;;Q::3f?::i;'*;',:'%'=–4

§§;%;*g:2:*i€s&$ Efiiwmg {Em f~;%é%;2s%;§:a%é;:2%é§ ragééaé

in figs fiaifi as "3,$.,§§:§

333% '{"§_§;f§"1$5é §:'2;§%§§ éiifz-_e.§ s§;#:'"' –7§%:é%,i¢:':&§° far
aywéiltiig sififi ;.;:}§gs&éV $3' 9"' ~*r*–%'.i§*&*;mé is :_

e:§%3m* 3&5 fiz;~*i?,§i}:;:–t.':§ "E;':*€?§:1§i%*;;;f;;i;§. éizggigzizfiéz 313$ fiéfiiéfifi E23 $3"

éfizfl ygfiééiéfgégézfifigé' tfzzggé: 332$ éaiagmifia 3.1% m

'$3 a§:'*%";§;%z§ §":'L."7'§*=.§Z;:*%as:':'$§-g Ei<'§§<*%§i'§ r§§@

.. .. _ $}§;§;$–§;~.;'::%§~: af; 3: 3&5 :%:*'§i§:.:°a.t$:"V

2:? isiéfg :%::;=i3-:.,:§3§;:§% 2"§&iL§;3% %;,"§*::.2g:~

,.§%%3§§:§?§$ §§'§%%%§ §§§:2s;§§§°*§ fig §%:'?:i$§; ii §%:§§% fig
"~&:.-igiiéazi §§'§;§'£éi§§§E sgrzsiagaé §§$$%;§§§${'% égi §Q@§£ éfaétfz,
%%*22§§§';§§ izémaifirg Etiéfiii £1}? fig aggaigaiag §§3a%% §&

%%s$ §:3§aE §§*§%%§§%§-§* 2%? fiéé §a;%=§$£$§¢

P'

«$3.

$§’s:::*s~:%:’:”:%:’2*§.:*;s}:*:,®ai «_{§.–«*a;$§:,z:&w”:§:§ites«. _::s:’€:’%:§*£:.

fifiififii §E”zE”§f–E.;ig§”§ maiug

§§z’$s*%:s:2:** ‘ §§% V§3.§z1m§ £13

§’§§.’%?% figffifii :42? §§§§§T%:§:%%’%iV fiirfgitifir €33″

Ewggzggrg §_;imié:a.;w;§;i§y:§’V$fié§§; §a:§?%’%:£€1s*§§m* 3:3 zmfiiw E232

:£§§§u%;££g~?%:§i’~:1%;é’%i3. $8 $322 ;%§%}§::*a%g::§ ‘aa

1§”%$§§%*’.’£i’};%;E siéagfiuégfi; _ ”

; {E23 fgéiawgzgg fifiifié’ fig pa:3§a~:i:~

_ ~-.i’§’§§g §:?m::”:;::*§ Ezéygeszfi
§%1.*:,;§%% Eéflgg E§§:g&§.§r§~
27% figgaésiéigé; fig fiagig fisféfiéiifiiififi’ “fig
flag :§;i§§3:.2.§,§ §§§?E%’%§E ‘§’%;$

AA §;§*E§:’.§*§;*£f2:; Qfi zesfigéu if & mg? 5%’ :E3:’s
:;§:*:§mf~’, fiiézaii gmcw 2,-*;§§::§ §”%§fi’ §3’2§:& éggzzgfi zggsfim ‘Ea
Eéfi §’§§,_7€’fi§Efi gfiéfi ‘%:/fism gzaawi ‘€25? §”‘$§€§§F§’§ this
fiiéggzzgifig fiéfiaéféifififiifi 3%: E-‘”§;%?’&’%’?i§i::}§i’2:fi af ma

g%:.§§_?§7{ffifi§1:sfi §;§:f;s;s’§. figgaaéfiiaaiimz ,§%.£:«i§ .§.%§%«

W

£35 ems fm é.ire<:t¢»fl :9 am a mpg
this mag: in the leameé Arb:::;:2;a:;~%%% %k%:% %
fmxmm. agm £3 further é§x~m& 1;;

$33 the nrigfiml papm, fimgfiaga     k
the gaming in the peaagzggr Fagagze

arbiurator,   '    

Petizéaan 'm  -{Sf  

*§'§3.§'E§';"'; 'V