High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Shivashakthi Enterprises vs Mr E R B Nikkam on 2 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
M/S Shivashakthi Enterprises vs Mr E R B Nikkam on 2 December, 2009
Author: Dr.K.Bhakthavatsala
IN 'I'HE I-"HCEH COURT OI' KARNA'I'AKA AT BANGALORE

DJ-\T§£I) TI HS TI-iii 2"' IDAY OF i")EZC3{§MBI.CR 2009 

B E31'-'ORE

THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.  "

W'RIT Pi€TITIOI\§ N035 I97/iéOOE»3_:

BETWEEN

M/ S. Shivashakthi E11terpr1'ses.
Rep. by its Pa1't'ne1"._

Mr. R Jayaram,

S/0 Sn' T Ra.ma1ma._

Age: 29 years, 
N0.198. 25""? Cross.  

7": B Main Road.   1. 
II{B}0ck.Jayanag=ié1r,  
Bar1ga101'e~«56O 01   

Rep. by P.A. Hoidefi
Sri Nanda Kis"hor':j. '

[By Sri K N I)a1y21xh;,V VAd\»f.  -Ebf._vfic%i:5i7i<)11e:')
ANII     ..... 

1.

3’v,r;~; ‘R .13 ;\I;jkka::£:v
S/0 N_1.1EEkké1mI

< 60 years.

Smt. S11ué1r1..1Fi};E2iV NiRKarn.,
‘ ‘ –‘N’y’0. _ ERB Nikkam.

, Age: 3:

Mr. E3-9.n’det:*p Nikkam.

£4’/-e IVJRB5 Nikkam,

‘ 1 . V _ Age; 30’ years.

tTGM%*CF°¢1%%%% %

. Pei,it.ione:’

‘4 4

Rs.8._OO0/+ per m0m:h ‘$111 the c%cfo1’1ciz111t, dclive1’s posse;-;$i()1’1 of the

suit” $cE1ed1.1le pI’Op€1’I._V. etc. The clefexndz-111i” has fi1§%.dVV”-E?}’5}’Iii€I1

st’a1.erI1m’1E. A1 the. sstagc <)1'2:1:'gL.1r11c:1E.s. the pe't'1'I,.E.()1'1mi_f_I;i.I(€ci§_'.i';–Al}«7XV_

under Order XXW Ruie 9 1-/w Section 1.51 01." C '3f:3P*OiIi§"3". 'V

C0nm11'ssi0ner 1.0 rm3as1,11'c: 11:19 ssuil. s:echeL:It,1le…p1fi;:1niseS"a1id'*sL1b:n1t
;'ep0rt,. 'I"Ir1e a»1ppIi(:2:11.i<.m was c)p;.)(:)sc(% by Ihé'._1'e5:-;)o:.1dr:'

Court. afier hearing arguments. 1'ejcéo:i]'e::dV 'f,A~XXV. 'j{he 31'n1pugned

order.

3. Learned C0z1;1Es¢_1 fQr'” li-5″L;bJT]l’iS that the
responden1:s/pIa1int.i1″1’s::V the ground floor
as 190 sq. ft. i’i:\t.::,fIVé::;g:f all meamlring 600 sq. ft;
whereas aL?c:()ri%%iI1g ihks meassurerzlent nlentioned is
wrong. T}1e1*efo1 é . an appiicaijion for appointment
of a COI11I11i$;SiO’1 C’.I” 1.1’1v(.* suit $<i'.heduie property and file a

rep Q1't, 'buti""the:" T:rie{E~.C0u1*t. erred in 1'ej€<.r{i11g "the same. If is also

. C0nter'11(iev$i._}~i?iat: i:hé :"plaint:ii'Ts 'are texkirlg rem of Rs.8,000/~ per

7 ,;i4m'm11.

Np :ji;r(Jr)£’\.xr21s produtied bcxforc. the trial Couri 1:0 prove that

N ihéé ;–>e:{i1:ioi1e.1*s are pz1yi1’1g rent on the basis of sq. ft. ff appears 1.he1’e

15. ‘;. T t.Vr’i:–1_Ix ;