High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Skanda Enterprises vs M/S Mysore Minerals Limited on 26 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
M/S Skanda Enterprises vs M/S Mysore Minerals Limited on 26 February, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) And S.R.Bannurmath
-1-

IN THE IHGI-I COURT OF KAR1§A1'A.l{A AT BAHGALORE
DATED THIS THE 26"' DAY OF FEBRUARY 2809

PRESENT

THE I-IOWBLE MR. an. nrxummn, CHIEF   ~ N

AND

THE Hownm mnausncs s.R;3A1erzu£z1\I.a.':§i§i   A  

WRIT APPLEAL No. ;__.?,54 of 2003 1 

BETWEEN;

1 M18 SKANDA ENTERPRISES  h
A PARTNERSHIP FIRM '  

REP BY ITS PARTNER K_s;:.e_1N1vAsA
NO 201;..AKRISI<INA}*lILAYA._  ' '
63TH CROSS" -- _ "   

5'm BLOCK RAJAJ_INAGAI {~
BANGALORE"-5{.s'0V910  

    APPELLANT

(3%. Ms:. PRASAD, ADVOCATE FOR SR1 L M
CHlDA_N2'§hI'DAYT{A;,   

  L'-ARI) :

.1. 7._M/s MYSQR}:-2 MINERALS LIMITED

 _A..GOVER'NMEN'I' OF KARNATAKA
- _ '~._UNDE«RTAKING
' . ri_Avm'G rrs OFFICE
   A1: NO 39, MG Rom
  .BANGALORE-{)1
 REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN AND

" MANAGING DiREC'I'OR
 RESPONDENT

$3,.’

0? fix’: iétiiiéir 0:” ‘£11%,c:m’. damé Es.3,iZ{}€}4 which wag Eilifiiiéfiiifi 0:3

§§.3.2{3{3€:u

Thai };ea1’n:-36$ Siiigie Judg€ £'{§f1E€?;fEC§_ ‘ :53: “€3:r§5{§:%;%’i:;é3″iii”

abave ‘s£{‘i?; g:}€ti:i:}:1 311$ disziaiggzzci {E16 ‘§.§.};”,’.*€:3fiT:§E.h’A'”‘3;’;{};VVAiv’.A

the a’p§3€§ia:’2£.j p€3?.i’$iOI’1€i’ :0 ‘§é§:.;;:*E for
a;’}pmpr’§.a’E@ miiiif if {§’iff’:}-” 3I’E2 b
fiéznce, V ”

1%. ‘?h@ }€a;”}:”:§{%:_ 4:§’:§g’».§ é;§3§ss:i§a::%;f g,3€~:§~;;%i&3:;<a§\
::eii6:§'a€.£:<.i '£25: §:':3é:'1§."{?;€5; Sissggiz-3
gimigsz i:1V§{i§ig' .?b §€i?fi}”8}. <:{}r;*i§s;;:<:::1d&§1<::~:5;
%;3:=:t,v;€:&;:A 'fig:-;–v _;23:§sfl;'§'?€:E§Vaf;3:§"3;i"h,'i }3é§"ii;§.:I$:!£'1€Zf and the r€:spa::a§€:z3'é"~

£§£3%'gf}§:*%:.2*:i<§f: the (M36? Gf {ha _'£}§_visi{m §e1fzch 01" mg

{3::«:_::~'{': :2{}{};"~§ made in ifirié. zipgseai,

f:}§%}(}E":»..__'{§a33*f£fi.1":3:i:1g the Srdsr {sf i;§':§ Eaamaéi ifiingie

fifiifgad Jame: RSS5 mad: :3"; Wiii §}§§:§:§::m

" L ' * : «°%.§'§ ;%;;{§z";a§r.

5,»: 2′

‘5

4.3. As we f’€§;)GS€ cszifitiémce in mi: Siam .

shaii €xar(:is;€ Siiilh p{)’§?€t?:TS with ummst. cam €il{‘E{L}. (:{3§I’2;_§{::3_e:23;.i;~é:’ ;ii’:{» —

{ha iarger EIZEEYEESE at’ {£36 Stats, but sa§i§.:i,la?’e.f}:§f€%1_€:§ :1§;:i§§,i§t

{l’§€333€” aha: the Cam’: $3333; not _%:esi€a:é:__t5-_j:1’1t€f§:V35§’ -in

2’§:a!;E.<"-3:', in the éighi of j1.:d§:::iai aci)iviS:rs11i," if' so 1s2';:1:V';;at"§é:;ezi;»i1é'tEza
iargar éflierast 0}! {ha Stzzm, $6 ~.pré:$s:3§s%€' Lfi;eV'V"z1,a.t:1ra§"reéeagmea

:31" the ijauxiujv much iafis thfi Stalk. ' 3

4,3. in 1:316 i31'1ZSE ;";'i_.§"£3;'.T,_{f§?;S€35 §;iT.__'if5'i_313?, C352; '@«.:~:§23:'<: 125% 2:3 1:0
what ig 39ugi':i.'«':0 be' S–1,£§}§}iEi$;C§'«.}{§f:'~.§§Tz€ :"€3T§:ae:'1{is:i"3f:«~{3Q:'p<::*a:§;;,
$25 firm} {HE in {E13 {>f§_’ iz\.–<3%*§ mad. Since the; §*iavam:e
{sf :Ef::a 9;pp@§;a;3§,5peti%ie:1$:* a:::3.s:1 'aha résiisf saugfii fer, gesg €33

E§'1év§f{}g{} E'.«{}§; L"i;?"}f"' §.f$;S;ij*'c:_, E': may :13': E33 }}§'@§€iE' €31' {his §.".Z0z:r'§. is

. gra.:;t "{;E"1é':°éii-3:?":33' ;§:?afg.s:& fag' €§{fiI'{'t§S;§_?{1g afzéé §.'}€}E%?€§' Q? j1.:::1ic:';*

'§*€:?;<§§:w a,::':r§é':" figjiifiéé: £36 {ref 23326 {§0:"as;°§ii":§E;¥a:1 a§§3::a{£§a.

4.4& it is in {hi3 c'sz::sx€,, Eimiéng :19 §z1fi1'1:'z逧?

®i'{i€}."$ of €325"? .§é:ar1"1e:% SE11 3:: Jacie im 31: T3:<:{§ i1"1.._t_%".'{3§ 3-*r.i§';:«::aE,'

mt: aggpfiai $'£3B€§.S <fii$mi$:§:%z:i.

%[j’f%ChIef3’ust%ic&é

Emifix: Yésj Ne _
z ; _