. - A S1;-:i;')1'113z--'i:1_: Nz.-Q1211'
1
IN "1'1----11:: 111011 c.:1.11<'1' 01' 1-\'.»x121\1A'1'A1<A M B1'\N(..}Al.(")RI'C
1)/1'11-«:1:') '1'111.; 1s1'H 1_>m' 01-1' 1_.1A1\11.:Am' 2010
1.s1::1«'(>11\1'1-=-31.-1~: MR. .1 L1'S"I"! C'. 1: 11. 1\£.I{I£S1
C1-a1.\/11NA1.A1--->1->1s:/11. Nc)_874/2908; %
I--3I£'1\VI-EISN: ' "
IVi/S. Sri Vi(:1yz1 F1111;-11"1(r€* [§{c.'p;c'i.).
Ucgiupi. I-{C13, by its (3.1--'.A.
Hoider I'./\1'1e'11'11.!"z2'11'e1j R2-10
Aggpcl 36 _\1(*z'11's:s
S/0. l.,z1i.(' E1'. Ra1'1'1z11("-3'1zmcil11:1 Rem '
'S1'i1';1m', 9-4«»70 " A
Nee-11' MESCOM
M2-11111111vee1l'1i§y sme; ..$31511.-:'151¥;.;1 1*-y2é'.; .'.gx~1'>ci ;_=1E.3.1.*"é='2'_1t1" X31 112.1.g1:
Sha'n.E-:2:1.1f2}i.p1~:.1je1_ Past
" E.Jd1.1}:)i "f'--2.1'.j}-11.: Ii . . . Ri:3S1'ON 1.) EN '1"
1:1.-11;j(i)
'Fhi.s' (.';1"i1'11i11;»-11 1'-\p}')(.*a11 is; fiizrti 1.:/s. 378(4) (f,'1".i7'.(f,'.
"tI"11"211t= fur 1.111(1) 21ppc1I2==m1 1'31';-.1.3..-'1'1'1L_5,?" {"0 set" zitsécéc?
E1126_§1.I('.iQI"1'1t'I}1 ci2.1E'c--'('1 1_€i.fii.201'.'.)8 p21ss1:d 1:331 1.11112 IE1 Acjldl.
-VCi\«-'1'I J1.1(.E;.:1* [1_}1".I')1':.) 81 J§\«'1I-*'('I.. 'i.}(i1.1pi in (.I.(2.N(>.L3929/O33
:1
£1
2
z.1('q111'1't:i1'1g 1.111? 1'0sp(11'1(§c"1"1t./z'1(tré11sec} for the (')f'1""c-'1'1(tc~.
p111'1isl'11;-11311.' 1.z1'1(':¥c-*1' Scct'i(111 138 of NI. AC1 2:.11"1{.¥ c()111\='ic*.t
the I'(:.1S}.J€')1](1t,?1"}i/i}.(T('1..ISCd.
'i"E"1is azppc-.'e'1I <:01'1'1i1'1g_§ 011 £1.11.' e1d11}1'ssi01'1. this thy. t"l'1c=;*
C0111'1. delivcxvd [',l'1('", f()H()wi111g: V
JUDGMENT
This appeai I”iEed 1111601′ _S.<.3.(':1'_:_iQ11
by 1.11.0 (".0111 pIa1'_112111E. is cii1*c=:("rE.:%':1
and 01*c1le.1' c:1a1e'.('I 1E5.6.2()(3§5: FJ?¥5$sc1:Ef' Vf'1<1.ci'i§E.ir.11'1.2-'1'E:L'
Civil J1,1dge (J1'.;_.I'.)1".1.} L§(.11:;)i in
C .C . N(.). 3929 / 200 5 ($0111 / 2-1(,t(.:1.1s5e.ci
of th e (.)i"i'cé1:1C':_Cf f:$vV{:vvi1'i':i011 138 of the
Ncgdigizxble E 1'1–S?._:~:1f.L_v11'21131'1i;jS';A(.:€' -{'N.I. Ad" for sE"1o1't].
2. Ti’,h(‘¥ .(‘(_)’1A1_1}:>Vl;;;1..i’1121.111 ~- M/ S11 V i(‘1y2;1. F1’1″1;-;11’1(t1:
(Tj’~’;c~’3’g_.{s(‘:111{. I’11;3le’;1i11″é’j_ 1.§’11’1dc.1′ Se(:t.i01″1 200 of C1*.P.C. 21gaé11sE: Em?
1’c:spr11’1’c}er1t_/21<?1:1.1scd a1lcg1'1'1g 11112 (;1!"i'<;?111’r<'1we(i ex 31.1111 01' Rs.75._OO()/M E10111 1:116 compI;«_1i1'1:§s.1'11.
@
3
on 1Sj}..’__>.2()()I3 e1_](.>:1;__>_; with mu’. Mr. Abclul I”Iu1m’11c(_f ;1.1’1d
CxcL.éu1″c(“i. 11(:(‘rcss;11’y lo;-m (f()(:11111c1′:”1t.s in that’ 1’e;_{a1′(i
.2’L.gg1’cr<:i1'1g__§ to repay the foam 2'1n'1ou1"11' with i11t:c:1'ess1. 23%
p.21. I~f<)\ve?\.'c%1', {ho e,u':(:1.1sc(1 1'ai_1cd to keep up hjsvv_p.;_%}j.:11v1i.$(%
:;':m(.1 in spite' of 1'cépc.e'1I.C('E dcn1a;11'1ds by
H16 21ccuscc:E failed to 1*e;.)ay_,.1iV}'1'§;?' lQ2ifi" e'*',1g1ucI»
13E{.iIT1d1(_.'1y t"owa1"(Is 1'cp2"1_\/1'11c11E:;'aQf :1:._}1Tc'~*:V
with in1e1'es1,. the 21L:(:?L,1'}'ia'.Lj'3d…. issucrcl .21 VC'ki'£§C['t;:c: (E2;1t.0{£'
19.3.2005 cE1':;1\.v:"1 on Syngf1'iv::ei."{:»x,j' 1:3;-i'n1«:_ _Y€I'1;€1'£_gL1{'}CEL*'.
Branch. Udupi for aH'o.\;veve1'. xvhen the
CheQv£.1'Gi"'\.v31:é; pré é:31{'t.~\d_"'E'()1' &h't%V21£5}'11n<=r1'11, the sauna CE:ti11€
to }T)\Q': 11:1' L11'.:'1.e(;1' <V1i'1=1.;jV.§1éLj1..–~ with He111l<:c:"s c11c'11’11@11i.
‘3c(:Qm11″ a'(‘:”.(V)VS(?(‘f;.’– a1′;.d ‘ih1111¢-?cEia1.cfy. the (‘0mp12.1i11;11’11 g(..)1′.
is;Lsi11c:i(L 2-1* Ecggztl Vi”1″(f’)’E”:i(‘,L? (‘1e1£:0c.1 2.4.2005 10 rho. 2;u%(.’t..1sL’c:E
“infb1’1f;»i.V1’ig VV h_i1 1..1 exboui ijlw (..1ish(,>:”1t_.)1.1ring 01′ I’1’1c=. (:F1m’1t’ co’verc:c_1 1..mc1er
A {.110 <.t.;1"c'-tc.;1,:e wi1.l1i1'1 I"'E.'1c: perzkzjd 2i111()\ve.c'E 1111dm' Paw.
"i4.n.révc:\»*c:1*. in spite of ;~':e1*\4~'1'('c oi' 1;}'11's 1'1. the a<"c11sec_"I
–f1’e=.1ifcéc’I 1’0 pay £110 2-;u’n0um. (*(>\:*e1’e:(.l 1111601′ the &sz1.i.c.1 c:f”1
4
as s’;u<:l'1 1'31: lms (.'<)mmi11(.'(.} $1114 ('.:}l'I"(.;*1"1<".'c" }.:)u1'1is}'3a1)}L= {.1H(_1L'l'
Soc-.t:i<)1-1 '1.3é:§ of the N.].Acrt.
3. ‘1’1T1(-‘ 1varm.*(.1 E\z’i2.1_§§i.<;t':*e1t.L_' who Ifook (T()}-,'J'}iZ§,.1l"1('(' of
the c)f'fo.1'1cc 2111cg.;'c~c'l. afi.c~.r 1'c==:m1'(1§1':§.§ 1119 svm_.)n1
0f1'}'1e=- ("-.cm1}.')lz==1i:12.=u'1I.. c.1i:'o('1Lr(.1 iss:T1zu1(*(-'
the 2;1(tn?1t.ssL:c1. U pun scrx.-'i('c-* ()5 ~s&u.1'14'111'1::'.i:_151" '{'_JVfj1~:-' VVé;':t."_'.'_(';'v1.:.'91.f;?(]V'
e.1ppc:arc~.(:E !)c!'or<' rhc trial C()1%I"I "a-111t»."._ }:jEba1C'i'e_(;1' ram E'
1':.11L'-: E-1(',('1…lSd1.i(')J'1 nlzulc :;1§.3;2.vL.:'j'Li'I&::.1;_A hini ._;'1.nr1 '<.j12=:i"i.;V1'i'(.*'(:E 'V 10 1'36'
t:ri<3c'1. D1..11'ing,§ t,1"1e t.ri.—:«.1.}._ I*I<;:r;'12'»;1:i1"11 uR:«,m \vh'o"13r£%é;c11£<;('1 E_.}"3c
cc.)mp}21i1'1t: 221$ Gcncr2i}V _P'c;\.ve.:* :31'__At;1jf'c).;'i'1–3y holder of the
(:cT)1{11plaij-1.2111%-"i'il«L*(fi'.l'3i':'-«;_ (£=v._i__ by vmy 01′ a_!’fic§avit’ e;111(1 it
\\-T21-5 11*(.*§11″cL.i ifa.ii(i1c§i”;-r._f_éé”OI” PW. 1. I”1.c>\vc=:x»’e1′. siaictc he (lid
not 1T1,1r:L1″~,u}’:) VI’0′;_’ (~’–1′<")VS;-5-:-ix;-1mmeni01"1. }'1§s t–*\Ii('1CJ1('v \-'V'<1S
c=i,s:.¢§}'1<:\\*L:c1 2:17";(:1-..L13e:':*c=%z-1.I"1'.m" 1.11:' (.1311iplziirlz-1:'1'i'. cx21mi1u:c1 o1"1c
' '.AV1:"11–11??1E'1(1;;2i{j_' R2.1.(..) ..e;I"'e,1':'L'=;*.('i 1.0 be Tlltf Gc1'1c1'a§ F'0\v(:1' 01'
3'['.fVtInf§'1z:_}?"}':ic::«1(':1§:1* of 1110 Coanplaimarli :15: PW.2. Exs.P.i to
* A15."-E 4 wtL:–:
If um rkaicil. W
’11
4. I..)1.11’1’1″1g {.110 c.\e1.:’11i11z-1l1<111 1.1.a'1<1c-:11" Sc.'(.'[i<'111 311.3
C1'.P.Ci.. $111? 21(..'c11s@ iI'”1(YI’i]’1″1i1’1&.H’.i11;;
(“IiFCUI}}5%'{’21I”i(‘T&?H 21ppee;11″111g–.;’ 21gz1111:”+1. 111111 111 t’.1″1c ma’.iC.§r:3_1″1~ff(‘2 of
1.111: C.<.)111pi2-11'z'1z11"11. 111 (.1cf.{§.__ §_ j<'1iCj'i'*11.111';3§*.1f
e3xz11'1'1i1'1c(:l 2'15 DW .1 2.111<1 g<::1!'. l'1'}21!f}£L..'.('f Ex._~s."1'.J : -I f1;'.<1"D."3. '1.'jl'1'LF»
(1efe1'1c'cr of 1.11:; e1cr<:11scc'1 1.112-13 '£.11i;:.l. we1.s"$('1111'c~-X?'111<311L%y
t.1'z111se1(:l.i<11'1 1:1e1.\.ve-:c%11 1'11'1'1'1 ._2'.'1':..;(1 01.'1"cfi 11/! e.1c'1L.1s1~z:C.i'e1»1.1 "I'211'1t:1"E V
who 'W'(.1.5 {he c1'.Si\1,'}"1i.l<=j…..M.2'11i1éIg;i11gg p2.1.1f1'1'.1£51" of the
C<1mp1ai11a1'1t: and in ai'é:S'p('§C.IV. X11' E,i;121._1.11.11.1*-3. 1'11.s:s21.c.:t.i<.1111 he had
de1ive1"e(i 21 }f1§.§=1.'1 1.14. <:1'j1 ec11..1'ey1.<1_ .._Sa:1'i(i»'£1/I.21c'11.1s11(112111 T21111'.1"i
andV'l"I1'é'ii."!.}1£.? $21161' I:)'Ie.1.1:1'i<: (-E'11"(§Q'i1c? 11215 1.3661': 1'11is~1.1se('1 by
1.110 (."('.:'I11}')1€:1I.E']3].'"i'l": '{.(5"!i};1V§"1'k1:? 2-1 fz1.1.st-~ (*.1211'1'11 111 111:? p1*ese1'1t
c':2rt3U: It 111-"':.-1.,~_"3v e1.1és'<'1 1"1.1's E11-*i111"1('1* l'..1'12'11. ha' h2.1d 1101 E:)(11'1'<.)11.-"c-mi
. £'1"1%1_\[}' r1'1–.1'(..1.11i;*:_y i}'<.11'1.1U1c. (.:(11'11pla'11'1'1a..:11: 211116 he 11-12.15 :'1(1i. Clue-. 01'
..:;11'–1.1(.)111"1!_}~'1.<1 tho. (.:<.11'11p]z1i1"1.2.1111. a1"1d 1'1'1c:% (.'.1'1c:q1.1(': £11
<.1u__est.vjvc11'1_vfswas 1101 i:s:'~111c1}’1c-.21′ 1i21bi1z’1’.y” as r::.1..1<fi%1 he 11218
'=. 1"1e–*;." <.:02111'1'11'l'l..e?('§ a1'1y <11'fb1'1<.:e }')1.11'11's112"1b1c* 1111(1c1" S<;*(..&I'.1<11'1
38 (.111 1"l'1c N.I./3.111.
7
‘j11(‘I_;_-;”a’1’1c:::”1:’ 2–11’1(I 01’c101* of e1(.'(}1.1it”I’;2’11. tho e”1p].1c:-111211111 11;-1s
;)1″(>.s3c111′.c’>c’1 %’.111′..<s a.1p1.)(*21I.
6. 1:1 spiie of sc1*\=’1′<.'('-1 of' 1'11i<'c of 11113 ;[.:1"_1}:,1§¥e"111, the
1'cs}.3.1.:,1v_1_’ss»::j}V 2-1ji)1..1_c’-1-(1 1″i”11.gg;
£1.11′ I:’E’1c–‘ ;”1ppv1 121111’ .
7. S11′.S.K.A(_él’1a1’yz19
Magg_isl’1’2:-1i.(? is 1101. _}1.1:3E.%1″iu(?’ci_b .1’u1″:. l’1o.Ed111g E 1’11:-11 t’:I.’1c
comp1e’1i1’1a1″1t was r:_11:{.i(-;’1″‘._ 1-1::;_1= <')"k1'I'ivg._3;'2'1:1011 I10 p1'(.1vc 1'.I"1cr
(-éxis1:(é'1A1"('c° xiii t.E"1{?:?1(fI'¢fI§t.~.111' (11'i"1_L€1"liability .2"11'1(.i 111 this b@E"1z1EI'
1E"1(: I£t.211'1"1.c*t:i –]'x/I2';1;z.'§:i:sj1"': 1"'.=;.:1._1:é.*..1'1..s.:s {£1111-21.1 to <:'i1"22=1\.v }')1'esu11'1p11(_111
111"1<j:E§¥1" Si.-.~<_*1:'iV('111'1V.51I32} '£'11'1n1 . of ctlmqmx 111 q1.1e.e;1’.i(‘)11, the
1;-%é_1’_11*:’1:é-é11gI’11 to E’121v1-=2 c<..11'1vi("t1".etl the e"'1(t.;f 1E1r¢.-~r:)1’fT1=21’:1(‘(: p1_11″11’sE”121bEo 111″1dc1* Sc(“l.1’o1’1 138 of ?.\T.I. Act
AA s111<.tcv..;..£Il 01E'1’sE1v(_’i 11.1}! 1E”1c..’ c.:1111)I211:’1;:1’1E. 111 {.1118
-TE.)el’121Ii’, 1″e*1iz111cc is }:1Ieu..tec.1 (111 21 dcrcis1′(..11″1 of’ the $111.31?-111112
8
C.?m.a1*t” in 11:0 (.”as(*. of P.Venug-opal Vs. Madam P. Sarathi
1’L’})<.)1'1c-'(.1 in 2008 AIR SCW 7702.
As l’I()H(‘.c.'(‘1 z=1I)o\«’c, it is Iht’ Spc-‘(‘if’i(‘ §’ 1110
(:()101’apE:–n’1:12u11 10112.11″ t’l”1c? resp()1’1(1c1’11 21i11’~_ Ii
(:’.o1’npE201.inemt and ()X(,?(‘.’L.H’,{.’.d 1:L;§(.%(>s.s;1A1fy310313′-c.i(;{‘:’u_11′::;;;a’1is
arid s1.ibse’:q11ei’1tly Ihe e01_(.\’:1.-1_$e(i fe:.i_ié<:¥ £_():'i*(*:'p3.y_H Ehlc sa_iVc,V10»
2'1.mm1m_ and inxmxmis ciis(:1'1e–ii';;{c% of 'i1'1C':+:a_i('I a_1?:f11.::1’é. H10
accusecl ESSE.l(:Td H16?”{Ti;;L?C{i;1C? {:1} “c;~1.V:’es1’i<):'1. N0 doubl…
per S('.(..'[.i0l"i 1.89 (')fV.f~.'im.E$}.0Iv.*A1,:1.. (Z(101.ii5[1 has 1.0 ;')1*cs1.111'1c
t'.l012-1EV':__uizlcss"Ur:-3V'(=:Q'1'11_};é;1~a1\-" is }')i'()\-*'(":'(,§. 1110 h(')1L1ei' 0!" the
cheql1e':fp('civc:(.1_ 1011.0 g.()1'_;~11'1c' (:iis('101a:11'g_§c in \-V1"i0iL~. or 1' n pa.11'1'
0,14 zzaafii (0ieI*)1'"=.rn' <_.)I_;'}L-rr iia.i'.)iEi11y. 'I'11(=r qL.1cs1'i(')n as to
_ ….. ..
» 1’w1′}Vc::.,lV’1.c:1f’E,h”c> p1″eirs11n’1pt.i0n m.’1(l<:'r Sccrtioll ESE) of the NJ.
._}§r.j.§';.. C}{5TT1t?.I_'1(}S"{T\»'C?}"1 1,0 rhcr existe101()c of Clem or ii2i13ili.EI_\'
a.i"0ssc=..Vfc.)1*v (3.i’1si(‘l@1’2-1ti<..n1 })cf<)n-? the SL1 p1'c?n'1c Cm,1r1 in i,1"1c=
.. <';r;g;.scé "(if Krishna Jcmardhan Bhat Vs. Dattatraya G.
0′ *.._0I*Ie_zjde rcp(::)1’I'(*d in 2008 AIR SCW 738. In 1′:i’1c=* saicii
f7
H)
9. ‘E’11c1*c=–1′<)1"1". 111 t'I."1(1 1113111 01' U161'. law 1211c} <'I<)w11 1:13;'
11:10 S'{I].)I'(.'.1}'1(.'. C()1.11"t' 11': 'i1'1(=-' ;1f'<.11'(:.=;e'.11d (iC(t1s11')11s. the
('01'11_;')1e'111"1a==1111 111 i.I"11.:<; (121511 \\-'£-ES 1:11(1('1' 2.111 <')!:)!1g_;".'e'1t"1.<.')1'1 1.0
p1"\.rc~. the (:x1s’i.c¢1’1(‘rc of dé-.*.bi s11’1c’c {.110 :;1*(~t–:..:i.J1′:;:(.§fl? .I’é2~1(1
(.115p1.1iCc} the C2-(i.’:5I.E’1}(.'(‘” of (’11-=;’.1.)1″. %3x(.:(=:p.1., p’17.(_)t.i1.1V:'(‘z’.11g_»j 111:4.’
(.:l1equc 111 q11es1.1(..)1’1. 1119 a p}:)clIL;1111. ,~.. _(.§(:)I’1:1-.11.)18111″?-£111?V”li1’3:1_:%£ :1″1k’>1
p1’oduccd any dOCLE1T1(‘f1’1’i.E{_1’y efv.1v(1″c:1′}(:(: ;”t’c’) ._§511(;)w V1l1_1Véw
1c11c:11111g__{ of 1116 1n”z1g§<.:1.;.s;cr(:i."'E'T1'j11<j11g.!11} a(t('.o1'c1111;g
1.1.1 the <'ro1'1'1p§.a11111'. VE'1"'«.~"_('.:',';'I"11C'_111';?'1_:»'.V 1110. }'1*1'é_;t1.1sL'c1 2.-1}(i11'}g \-'\-'i1.1']
211'11hcé1″ haci .v.€?XC(.Y1.1.1’f3’C§» . :’1’11C<.1r:.se;,$:;a11"_.\f_ a1.i')2:i1.11 (..!<i)c1.1r1'1cr1'11's 11}
1~z1\~'()1;.1'1"(")i'- 111115;: (':€5f%f'1'1'p1é1~1.1V1'2'1.1'11. ._'13(.5Vs1.:c*!"1 (1(.)('.{I11'1t',1'lt. h2.1s 139011
1)1″(.)c11’1.:.’r1″0f1.111’c%«..C01..1..1-‘:’.. TE’1(;’ (“omp1e.11.1’1a1″11 is 1101′ an
1111U11\_»*1ci11e-11. 01:1 11v1’1o”‘: 01}’1c:’.1′ 1’1;mc.1. 1:1 2’21 1”g._{1..=.:’.1<'-~.1'c'*,(11
1' H.111':-11.1-(#1211A. ('.?<111*p"<i)'1*é.11.1011 (r;'11"1'}-1111;; on !:)1..1s1111<)sss 111
1f,1.(:11*1'r.f):\:,»='.1&11g«.g=11{.1c! I.e.1'1C11111g. 'l'I'1e1'c£'()1"c;'. the ("T(')11}}i)I&.1i11E.1111'l.
Ac';:.».-1_1'11'1o1~ (:xpc?(r.tc(.1 to (..1isb1.11*sc the 102111 am1.1111. 111
A 111 13115505311111 of
1 V’1-1.r:%c.§(:sse11’3,* (‘1<")c11mc31'1'i's to ::e;1'1ow how IP10 I(..12,11'1 2-1m01:11'11: wms
f(11sb1:1'"sc("1 e'11':(§ also 1.111' (§<:.)c'111'11}<.'.11I.:"-'3 ex-'1('1c11.<é11'1g' I1.-'.11('h111g.
X?
W”
H
N01″:–pm(‘I11(_t1E011 of 1′(~.Ec\»’z11’11 <.1o(.'111"1'1<.-':1155 w1'1i<.'.}'1 is s1.211cd
to b(' in [.)c)sseC.s:;s5i<)11 01 E111' 1'('m1p1:1i1'1e1.1"11 c-r1'11.1'Ics (.'1:.'e1\-\-'i1"1g'
of" an e:1('1v@:":'sc i11§'c::'c:1"aL'*L' 2.:gg2i111s1 1111* ('.()111pE'–:._1_i1'1a1'11.
'1'I'1(ir:'cr1h1"c_ 1'hc Io211'110c:i Ma-1gis1:"a11c is ']'11s1.iI'icgf_"11,1 "}11t'… ;:i§11f_{
111111 1111: (:o1'11pI21i11'.1.:11. 11113 I'2u'lc:c'E 1'0 pmx-' (:=._@xj':sV11c5:11<¥C~j1′”
debt or ()Th(:’1″ E.iaE.3i1iE1.y. ‘I.’}1Lr fcré11’1«1{:d. 1\i’ie[1gi.<:;.11".;11:'(" 1'1 :I1s
rig_{h11ly ]'1L:rIc:1 1.11211' thc prcs1.11111.31.16») 1-1_n<'1L:1f b'b;'7{=?1A31'E<.511a 39 bf
11110 N .1. Ami c:22u11"1o1 be C'i1"'(:1V"V".*'u£.)".»THCV&i~{j('%1E'f?3VC(f1 £41": his ()1"21.l
c\rici(?1'1(.:E-2 has 1"eri1v€§1'e*11crci_"A . (§{;'T§L'1.1(".(':.' 1"c?g211'cii1"1g lhe
oi1"(~.1z_1ns1.am.tc:s 11111101" \.-v'1:.é_("rE1 _111¢: «'%'i<1»c':q§1_.'1;Vc: -W215 ("IcIi\-'€:1"c(iby
111111 ""1"(5 "€;1:1"I..=1\"v1.:h"i'1ei? I\"/V1'éi1'1z21g{E111}_.g P£1£'I',11t.'I" 01' 1.110
(t0mpI_2:1E'1'1a11E._VV ~:f'i~'1.F.1(i=»_Sajci _. dcrf'c1"1("t(" is 1101 :'-';h0wn 10 be
i111p1_'ob2'2-:b_l(:: v()1' '1.11'i£i('(?L"fgi.2"1?i)I(', Cm 1.130 t’f’1
1.11:5(T0111p}aiz’1;ii’11: Ims 1’1(..>’1′ p1″()(‘!1..:(..’c-;*(“1 zimy (’01″1T’.(‘:TI’1’1[)(j))’£:11″}?
1(I'(‘}1I’11(_~.1” c’f0(*.11n’1c1’11’. 10 Show Em1(ii11g_§ of
-:x.’€s.f:’s1,sS,=:~* ; gm-
. 1.h<* ' 1 the (::i(?fe1'11(:c of 11111:
z1(‘:«<,é11st._:éC1-.i~S }.'1ig_§}1ly p'1"(.)}.'Je:.11)Ic 2.1.11d e;1<r(tcp121blc. E1. \.x.-roll
..3t='1.1.I('c!"law 1.11211": 21(*(_'1..1s('(i in 21 (.'1"imé1'12.1] ("?E.'1S£'. is 1101
V.:fc-%q'g«.1i1"('(::! 1.0 }.)1"(_)v(' I'1is_:e dc-='{v.1'1('.<:t i.)<:==y()1'1('! ail l"L'.£.iH()l'1£1I1],)I(§
….