M/S. Subha And Prabha Builders Pvt ... vs Income Tax Officer on 24 April, 2009 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court

Karnataka High Court

M/S. Subha And Prabha Builders Pvt … vs Income Tax Officer on 24 April, 2009

Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar

    . . 

LGZ:$G\3Gm. Ea. .342 $309
mm? ..w<Q mam. dmmmmo mom ZO UZHEOU zo_,E_mm mm?

309$ Q24.» WEZMEDOOQ mmmsa QZ< 923000.35 WMOOE
amaznomﬁm map. no zmnbmm miqmmzsz mom UZEQQKO
are bmﬁomm OE Uzcnmmm £52" mo zomeptemzoo mme
«MO Rm Qzﬂ cam mm.§,E< NWMDZD mmdm mm zoE,En_ mm?

...% 2 ...:m .5." .;%E< mm mm.
Ezmazommmm So Sm - mmoﬁoim
2<©x mzmmﬁg

E mxQ20z<m
Na? m..§O0ZM mo mmzoﬁmmuzsoo

{xi

M mmo.EUz«m
m<om <mm
¢z¢m,8mE.m<m Mooﬁ mi.»
$2.02 .3 Q mmaa

mmoamo XE. mﬁooé 4

93¢

as

.._.%< .383; mama x ﬁm mm"

2 0 com I mmoﬁmuzwm

5.3200 qsommﬁzouzd iooaa M
<zmm_mH.22& mmmmﬁnm

<:m<mn_ D72 <mm:m .m\E

uzauaanm

 ,_ ._._   kc _mm_mw .34 ._.___.§..Bm ~55
£422»  ....§m"zo= any
 _. ..  A 1  .
econ émmd no .55 Ea nwﬁﬂ  <1 4
a.mo....:m .6 wax. 2: an gmﬁ mnsmomuﬁ sac .§$ 664
at. team 8.: "E3 ﬁé $9 0385 am .8 §=m.§.é
ﬁoﬂovm avwﬁs vvmmwm uomuo mm mi ow mﬁ,,:&.:a
moom.o.m..m wuumw ._Umz.o mm 5,33 wmmmﬁ mm? hvmosuwa

m5 H83 3935 .35 gvmomwem 23 mo §O...,w.H®> 2: mw .: .c

.5. wmouava Ev ,Mv.mo§.umm $5 .8 mum'3,$.§
wommo Q2 Esau maﬁa. maﬁa $03 was Suﬁ? wwmaﬁduom.
wad wvmw .6:.:wu om: Fade." Ba 3% .83 wuwgouom. .3 wmoon
emomﬁ n$>o wmﬁﬂow avommo E uqawaomwvw wwrﬁ mam 233 63%

mmﬁoﬁﬂnﬁm meg was $053 was ,6§ow.:_._®n 33 5:5 ﬂow

..  .  moﬁma mucﬁouoa mo mxooa mwmunmmdvp um». 5%,. mmomm
 .. . mm.m..w,xmm....%ﬂ_w.._..wun,Eo .. uﬁvwayoamwn $5 95 wmomvn ©v.~m§a,m

 .....H_.:.¢..nnwmm  ._EmoﬂﬁuQ any .3 moHm._v> vmﬂ E : gm

A E eaommmﬁmm
ﬁaom  _&_.m.mEm.mmS~L.obmmmm 4&3 dz $53
a3$o.H%%..amH  .3 wage 3: E
adv wxmm 3.6, :o...@>3w   ammo ﬁmwvvm

E: vosvoam B mvcoﬁﬂuom Ha?  .mv§.

moécmmma m



33. 3. wvﬁmmoan: wumwaﬂuoc vmm mwﬁwoouw .3 mmﬁﬁ um?
ﬁﬁvu Q... gvommo xmm. uﬁounm 25 3 Qo_mmEH5m wvmﬁooww
6&5 avmowmmﬂmaoo 05 umwu wmﬂmomuﬁ d,Mo?.wQ,m.m
;:-e.Hommm§mm Jam. 3:993 .3 pemowmmgnaev man
we wmaﬁwm _Q-..w.max,.vc.§E ﬂaw
no mm .92 am am wﬁwmswm Em v5 .5 umwu was mm mm wvwmm wnm

o._._.n.w.J,._.. .m.oZ Am um mmtﬁmu 05 mo ammu ES 3 ma mwmsm m «moi

.  .. ﬁoama E50 wmm Sauﬁﬁocw wgﬁmusoo Em ﬂown
   menus ohm wuﬁﬁgommm .8 vunnﬁwa mama ma
 m_ﬁ..._mamw....ﬂ-E§xuQa$ um $03 :oS.muE.B> Hvztﬁm

&%%%,§ .u.a %.§:o . E2 8 wvaumﬁm emsxogﬁ Ea

mm  .95."  was .5 3: ma Qoﬁumw .Ew.:§
330%  .65.. ~mm....@Qm..._E£ﬂu.wum.wH®.> .5." woﬂﬁowwﬁm
ES Eamon wuaﬁcﬁi __m.8ww......,H.m_£w umﬂw...._,JuwNEo__m@>E

swan can mum: «Em  .  . ....,._mmeﬁ_Euam _. was

mum." Emﬁvo nmoomawom no gvﬁoﬂﬁum ®£.w._,,wo.wwmﬂmvmm @030.

®¢.+.©m©.n§> V



ma am?» m .8." 32% em» mﬁvsvwxu avﬁowmmnﬂaoo v5 .3
wvﬁmouum Qomwaudnw omuoﬂea Q5 wars mownomwmm Ede mg;
avdowﬁom v5 u_mTv.3xvc.ﬁ< E .300. moomé 4 m muewwm .MvH_.£
gum mm ww ewvsvea nozm mmvmmm car Qua Emeasoow zdsm mo
Q.5.,_v.H .5... mﬂmmmmvgnwea no 503 pvaosﬁvnm 05 333 .m.

.rm-v.5xm:ﬂEﬁ.u,H mwmuﬁﬁoov ﬁoﬂm mo ﬁoﬁﬁvwvu .H£_ Emﬁom

..ww_%w,.uﬁmaovEu@ unu mo wwonﬁmm van mom Eﬂﬁvmmu Kw» as $53

..._   .850 oﬁom 3 mﬁwﬁomvn ommm mumvﬁvam
  ..  ._Emuaou P850 ummacﬁm mxavmndoom
    mwﬂoﬁmoou .©o_w::om:E any

_ .m.o mownu§.%woH  wWEwww.Tmmyv,"nnxu§ aw macaw ©o©m.m.©m

@vw'mn.._.E.,mv~..ﬁ_. @wm.wwnwvs_.._.%.§M wgmummm Hm ,Eﬁo_.w.mwm _ m
T ..  . . . .mﬁ.EEmwm..wmm
we mcwvﬂﬁoo woL .%om.Bm%% an mﬁw %§.§§n§.\m:E8%

mo mmocm >wM.5> 8 mm»: ..E.v..8 a_.moﬁ§vw®.~ ....mo.M_, :_omww.H

95 ES uwwmummg mag : .moom¢.m.Hm %_AW,oEw%%aHH ,e.w

$0 ..%mc...§ m.



dmouoaﬁo own 8 mgownommva Eu wﬁmﬁu 8 m.o©m_.¢.mm,
B wugﬁoaum. map» maﬁa? 2.: was vvwﬁﬁvw mars ﬁowﬁva
ecu .®oom.¢.w mo .mﬂoMmm_.ﬁo.5m momma 8 Maﬁa .mmo:os..5m§
v>weo.u.H 8 wunvwaoawuu "V5 mom mvwnﬂoo wusawﬁ we $9333
mam um ®oom,¢.w 8 cmx,§mo_..wm wma HM ..m©0m..¢.m mo Emio
3235 we aoﬂmuomxmwou now an momma mm»; .5_:m..E 2.3.' .2

Mwmﬁmou magma" ﬁvﬁbmmﬁ wmw ﬁwﬂabﬂ. muﬁmamwaawm
wm,.H$Sv wan: cam «$4.302 no ma Sven. van xmrw @502:

 __.ww.ﬂKmmwSEoU I Hwmwvnoamwm vmaomm mm... was :12 dz

 498  .x.w,w @5005 E .E@m.soQmu.m _§,..:.H 9:? .m:

 j  %§.%.§£ «muwwzwxo gmmhgs Q5
_.   ..zu,.E._3_ bmmta aoxm wmcn. mama. ,3

A  3: ma wumaﬁuzm mxomd
3.2.5

_.&.£mwth£._..LT.m§mu.n.: 3: ha gmcaﬁumm.
H..m.m_.w …~o.._._…..oaB..,m .3. . ﬁ2n….. ﬁammutoammt men
wm_…$ﬁmﬁ_. mxnmmﬁmxm . ….Nu . mzwmoaﬁm

rr;

. giﬁuén @§%[§~M~m%am
.3: K0 :ow.Em~m.m w:m:wumamm…§»__§ m,m.S..mﬁ
Szmﬁaooﬁ ESQ wan. .m..§.m.u…§_. .3, wanna. LE .
mawnaxoasw SE5 .2: £3 “E: mxtatmm %

gr’;

_ _ _ A .m»:mE.3n…ow. .

550 «E3 HKSQQOU kn .ma~oon Bmwﬁaoawﬁ ,. .. .
mﬁ as 553 ﬁcadmﬁza Lona. _.__E,mLwmu.5.

mo.$men§. ..M..

.mun~.~mom: ﬁts Emﬁmmtmm
36w as 38 mﬁﬁmﬁﬁou ma gewﬁm N

.ﬂ:mEm..mE3
33% ac 38 mswtwcucoo ﬁt. Rmwmwﬁ .~

.u.mwu.z= ma $96.3 £0.33 ﬂzowwﬁmm “ta;
m5 8 mnvmczkmﬁtﬂ um ﬁmonﬁckm mm. umtonuma
mew ow Komxmﬁ E8 6 ~umém..~E:.\ ﬁsh» mzmti
83 385.3 ﬁsowzmaﬁ Q5 kwa. ma Bmugmmuwnm
$.83 mﬁzmﬁxooﬁ mummuzaomﬁm mg

ﬁmw:§.o&§ wwawﬁxocﬁ was EEE

S Etoﬁzﬁ mﬁ EQES 8 w.=Euﬁﬁ§: ‘Mo HES» 8
K0 mxmmw Lek, mﬁnxmmm gene m..~.£ ﬁwzuﬁckmnwa m..§.A.
nmwmsmnu mm =3 s wmmux 353: “mag 3: kc

~25? .3: 3% was moomgmgom $0 mu. Bmﬁssoaﬁw
ma 8 mﬁou 38: £9.33 ..m,.,E.mE:uomu vim HEEOUQG
R0 maaoea m30§wE3~0: 3: «us.» Em .3 Stsm

.. . 8 xmnums mﬁaoﬁ mum.» was .$,:o.§.mm mnk.

k .3 m5 ..to:w Sh $3 “Bag msooﬁ 2:

. .. Mo.m£_8mw:o»& mﬁ Lamar: mmwmmmmﬁ :6 cm? m… 3:6

. ….._HkT..k§§_mm.& manna 96 mm.m$m.S_..~ mﬁoﬁ m=.cmE8

,m.§§.# mwwngﬁ 5 my .$E.§mm E3

moea.§..4
..5u~m$o.a

.®0mm…w….©~ _. no w.m.3 _.Ew§o wmﬁ5o:.u.__ 2% mﬁﬁaﬁmemmvg
95 mom.._.Em.wm.duu_ .._m….vw…Hwmm n..@..,wm>w..H”3.mmoaonAw_eV _He}%Tw§.,§§

mo..v©mmm3 m

hnm 8 owwaca any nbmwﬁﬁowwmwm «nQ…m_>o.5 m.Hoﬁ.S3m

$5» H0635 wvﬁumﬁm @059 mm 8mm6moQwo._ 0.3» mwmﬁ

moon was $5 momma may 35 wﬁﬁvwmm muauciommwm 23

..HO.w HUWQQCO wummmﬂ uvambg Jkw Muss uvvuc wuﬂuwﬁ

95 3:? ﬁemaﬁcv Fawn mumvwmommeu emu Hmcw wﬁnﬁumoﬁ

9&5. m EE 93 “cassava at “mood: m :0

a .mu.:mB.:o9.mm.~ me: gobs wmmtxes
ﬁmﬁﬁmw 3: B23 xmzoﬁnmnw St 8% wmmnzsoo
3:82 EH 8 .§Bo .w,.£.~o 3.5.8 :m..,E.§,

meow

. , ..?.~m co mgmuko Lextzuakobmuus mg: 3.5

meow ~29?’ Ram mgokma .8 ma .$…._5.n.nma

‘M as EEEE 3 seem ﬂcmumommﬁ .3: 5.3

.ﬁu$..,uumk ﬁnn. xmtotﬁmk .95 .:.mDLK. Hummuﬁsoaﬁw
._:mm£ £o.E.S m_…9.s,….x.m:§x E S Bmtmkw:
. ﬁzuﬁﬁov .w.5

.m,§mB.:o&wm.~ me: ma ﬁmﬁmm:

gnu. ﬁg» mm: was 30: wmﬁﬁmg

. maﬁa u§kk._%$.= aEmm 9: Eat mmntoﬁzu
V.m£%k mo. . L mama :_o.=§ ﬁzmsuoou

3% 3?? gang «E mm m 85 muamss

H mﬁ kc gouomhﬁ mﬁmazuﬁ
m§s_§m _..w.£.~ mﬁﬁwﬁno mwzmﬁﬁooﬁ

Q5 ..Mo. Bmsn… mtg ..£um3.. an . Muzmwtemmmg
are on zunwo nun u.» ..muumuuuﬁ..nh,_nu…uu_mu£U mutoﬂtnnw
mi» 8 .£m.S,&.to.H ,__.muaw..b.3.o«mEw muﬁmﬁsuot
3: E32 8 ﬂzmmﬁoamﬁ _._._m£ 8.. _wm:mm..m.. ww
:o.Som.£o Etwwtw :6 “wm._u,:.§.aJ:._.1b..mu .m.§ E. H

ﬁoﬁmm mac” Ukuam ..o…m m4,..L:m:_S.uomu
ms” 583…. 8 ﬁmwamﬁm . mﬂwtomwﬁw.
.6: SS an sanaowmwﬂea mad w:o~_&_3_..mmuw.%ema§.

m.o.$mEB 2

ea… woman; Eon? mnﬁoﬁﬁm Bmmommm «mam 2.3 30.32 3%?
mhoﬁonﬁvnm v5 .3 mvﬂuwﬂom 2.3 wﬁﬁﬁv cam wwﬂoﬁﬁw
Bwmommw may .3 moﬂmﬁmﬁwxo Ema «wagon how E.§vo._
80% wucuﬁﬁoow auﬂm mm wivwmwoow .550 wax wwaﬂoauw
mo wxoon 95 w8.a..§£ E vomuwﬁm 95% mucovaommup
2% 3:» mm.EuE….5ow 2.3 mo momnuava 05 8 Gamma on
ado doﬂnwvoxo on Someaonw was noﬁﬁvm mu? van muws macaw
penoﬂﬁvm mum» on… .3 muvvswopa mvvn 9%: :03? 396.8
man .2 mm mv>u wunmmnno moon mam dm>o.:..Em.. seam Jam.”

an Jmﬂ… Houovhm HO mvmommmmﬁunoﬁ BO Mﬂ.H®C®mU…HOwO®.HwQ

mo…%.,..wmo%mH5EoO .330 one we E>o.:Em .§.a vs» nuts mums
..m3.,n.wooxu woﬁvm m .8.w pvomao mﬂcﬁﬁomaﬁ Q3 .3

_ @0530.” on 8 mwaoﬁﬁoov uvmuo .8 muaﬂoocm
. 0.5 mvﬁmdv mmwommuvmw Raﬁ use we

_ …$.M aow.$.w…ﬁe..«w_…wowa%_..m% 8 omﬁoa Bu éaﬁouam

ivkem aﬁoﬁmpwmew … wcmmﬂommma
one mo _…©ommﬁ…..aoﬁ.m.c..,..«»_ou Hmnwusﬁm cam. .3
. .. . . . Ammommmu

Ema muuvmwm. unﬁt .3 Goﬁd.n.%.¥wv_.uow…mvuwm o_…_.dmpoo.E.

mm? uoﬁwuu one £04. an” .3 znonuww. 30.30am

mcéﬁﬁg ¢ —

ﬂown: mm mwmwm
QUE? ..8 E H: nmmoﬁwﬁoum

>,,§:§m v5 .3 mﬁumoa mo Hana woﬂxnnnﬁm 02¢ mm x .3.

.mumvmm5o©

_ 8 mucovnommvu 2,: mo 536 an… 3 an «Em 30¢ mo

.. ___ mcnnwmuvu .5,” BE 3 .530 on m” 895 mu
. Mo ﬁoﬁva 05 buﬂm .£….aoDTUvwn5m

. wvwmma wcﬂunmoama pom uuwao

ye: maﬁa Eu .5 E5 was @8309 mm ﬂ

Eaaatv%%,%:aa%3 .mS5.ﬁv..wpo.ﬁ .5 wcuuﬁsoamm HO.”
homﬁﬁ .Hv~..mu.Tam_ .m…_.v..M was w§_§$§xuM%,Hom hogs am mama
vac mad §.%.ﬁaa8 ugh. ._M.m..&.v.ﬂLouE…..3 LU:oMmmwﬁSQU

ecu mo E>o.R5.m 05 ~33. . .. .. __ﬂ_u3.wm

vaoaun moﬂmouma wad Bﬂo__.u.umm.. .3.

vcmﬁ on Edonm HOBO wﬁvﬂnoamn

uoaﬁmo voﬁmpmﬁ umhm 05 E mxoon wmnouum \§_aanuo«v%%§

mo.v.mmcmB w H

05 .8 mowwﬁvm. 23 so wvuwﬁ mm eonmuua :80 $6.8 Ev
mﬁmmwa oaomvn wmzouuu D5 5 mzaom an Edonm mimﬁouwu
HO.” wmommua 2.3 $5 ﬁoﬁmmﬁmnzm Rm .3 ﬁommdm 5 .mm,

ﬁvzwmﬂv an 3 mm Bomvawmw Ema BS 5
uvﬂzﬁavm pom mam vﬁadaﬁﬁwsm Hon mg Hum .630 nusm ..m2u.mo
auuﬂ .3 wvwnvuxo wﬁvdﬁoaaﬂ mo wowmea 05 dumoﬁwmﬁuﬁov
M5 mo §,o..&%. .8?» nuts «Em wﬁwﬂmoamm now .520
Gm mg 9.55 3.5 wﬁﬁﬁwnm 03¢. vnomvaoﬁ 9% 33.3m on:
3 wosﬂumva woﬂva out we ﬁoﬂmwavw :50… E on uomﬁmo

..m…w.m@ Qovﬂﬂ mo ﬂmnm H350 an.» mﬁxu mo unvﬁwmvwﬁ

. ,.m.,..m.amm…o5 53,. uoﬁmmomnou 5 on Emonm moﬂmﬂuwxv
qwmu uomoﬁﬂvm D5 mom Emﬁﬁoo wwﬁmmoﬁ

.8 mommgnsm 05 cm? m… : .3.

Mom mwﬂoﬂﬂom «.5 .5 mwmwﬁww
_. _.B._.. mwmmawdoow. o5 m§.5»w.M won
mam .mm.£_. ﬁoﬁvm m mm wmom
mm. .8.” moom. o.m..u_ m wﬁﬁnmuvu

mom Emu yaw Hm was aoﬁmouwu we voﬁom

mo mowmmvuxm H0.” @390 mmwa….ov.._.n.nowmmwdm8om_…, ME”. Cebu

oo.vm.mE3 m _

.®.HO.Qu on go Us ﬂonmooxe aw mm .m.mmm. mwoﬁm mg :3:
.559 on… .vm..3ou Eauoﬁ 23 E .r8o monommmmﬁauoc .530
05 mo ~m>o,HEm .25 mﬁﬂnwuno H505?» mwmv mwuﬁm vacuum
on wommmo ﬁonavpvm emu 3.5 35.5% tam wﬁvaﬁomén go.”
maommom wﬁwuoova H505″? _.u%§oa§ on uoaﬁmo mumﬁooom.
no mxoon .8 muauﬁﬁooc scam $5 3% “M was omﬁoaa
05 E caﬁom on S 53.3 mm pvkom ecu mo HEM: .530 9%

nsaoa, any wﬁwmwuaoxv mom mean on… 3 uoumnmm wanes 90¢ ecu

no Mm… noﬂovm no Fa. ﬁoﬂoomﬁzm muvﬁﬁ gvkom um? dm

dvwmummm Q5 umﬁmwmm How» 05

.mm.w..a.5_ auvmmu Goﬁom and mo uxewaoo 95 E muuﬁomuzw EH.

. . $03.3 muﬁmoouw Mo mxoon «Em mwduﬁduov we

new mac mw :o§>o.5 Rmouﬁumum warm .mm

. .a£.§_.§> was 3E§3
3 amﬁwgomﬁ .3 3:8. 2.:

mgemﬁwu mo :&:§.,..

own so «ECG m.,_wom….ow . mm wvmwwoa

on 8 wviomusa 98 €Em%%Hv%§% m5 mwnmnoﬁva

muﬁﬁouow .3 mxooa mm £03.». mmﬁuaﬁvoﬁ _

oo.$mwn§ mm

5.8.3 vacuum ﬂowmoumﬁ o>o.&,.m.m… 8 hxsom emu .mwUEo5_§
aonwﬁ mg mo «m>o,KEm mﬁﬁmﬁno .8 Fﬁﬂwvwmm wag 5:? cam
mnommma oﬁﬁﬂmmﬁm km wnomvn nowwmuaxo wumamvm vim mwmw

S935 MO HOHUO MVHU 69:.” was upsamum OE mama? .mwm.

.m®:oMmm_,ﬁ§oQ
any we mm>o.REm uoﬂm 03 5:5 ﬂaw uwoauﬁa ummoomm
3:… new E8 P85 3% .25.” w you am. $30 98. mowmaouxv
£3. nuuﬁm wﬂ uavaﬁoow mo aoﬂmowon paw ﬂan .350 is

saowmgomm maouzuwum 05 3 wﬁwomuﬁ mm age mam uoﬂ’H mumoﬁﬁoow 93 >,mB.m
magma 3 um». _..vum:m..u…n .Hu>_§.m msﬁﬁenudw

2.: ﬁuaowwva 3» you ~wm~wno.o%..m.u..an.mvm ,_.nm_S.nM ._ﬂm.Am ﬁm

.3 vvﬁﬂmnzm mm “ammo uﬁvmﬁm… wmu..HM..wuow.ﬁ Am.

(C;

033

moéwmwma

M/S. Subha And Prabha Builders Pvt … vs Income Tax Officer on 24 April, 2009

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

M/S. Subha And Prabha Builders Pvt … vs Income Tax Officer on 24 April, 2009

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel