EN mg man mum' 0? §<;%RNATAKA AT BA;*é<;f;s;§;.{3-;ééj'}_g_,
Dated: 26th day cf August V
Present";
:--IN'BLE Mr.JUS'I'ICE V'».:GC?PA§;A'
HQNZBLE Di".JUSTICSE"KVf&BHAK'i'HAVATS;§LA
M.F'.A No.4535 c/:&',g;.§g?i;i2ao7(2uié7
1;: MFA N6.4536l2{}0 . V
Between: , '
M] s.U111ted Incifii.Ii;;sii:'za;1;ce"€,§:t>,{;2tc1§",_
I Fioor, Stafion Roa<d,:'_ ' .
g..§0Sp€t_ .... _A
Now rapid; by Divisgionaij. 'O _
A1,
~ {fiwner NQRKA 35 2'?03,
" r.~»;;2"
Tracmr,
R [ 0.Yashwanth:1agar,
Sandmr Taiuk,
Beiiary District.
{By Sri.Mahcsh R.Uppin,Ari;v:Vf{5r'E?1", V' ._
Ownggir ::»f,Tru<:kh§arfing N9,
R} ;of&'as'hWan?hnagar,
V' 'Sa1id11r"Tai1§}s:, ' ' --._
'$611213? %
Bxarzzch
I iIni%:ee:§Zi1;:1iai3s11rance €30. Ltei,
--« "*1? F1v.::0zi,__ i~3§ati<:s33 Road, Hespet,
A Bisfiiet.
RESPGNDE¥'€'§'S
V. (;%3y S ri.AkM.Venkat&sh§ gay. far R2
_§'€ioi;i<::c: E0 E1 ciispansesri With)
- 3&0»
,.,REs;§~Q':sz.:§Er3ni§
These M.F'.As are fiied under Section 3€§j("i:} ""§gf"*jhe
' Wtarktmerxs' Compensation Act against the J3;itigI1;+3f1€;__a13.d
Award éated 30/9/'E006 passes} by the Cor::{111is3;f£}i1é:1f'_"'f0:? 4_
Workmens' Cempensatiorz, DaVa:--::~a._"g<§r€:..V: " in»
WCA/CR/N0.4O/2006.
Th€S€ M.F.As coming on for Ei.ict§§tif1g
the C01111; this day, Dr.Bha}{§hava€§ala, XV-Vd6IiV'er€}d"'~!;?1<_;
foilowirlgz ~
I} 9 egg». .3;
".
:3.
-A These two appealgé' 0116 and the
same order dzfited in Case
i'€0.LGD:WCA:-CE;?';_Nib:;45Q <31' Comnlissioner for
Davarzagere.
2. }§"£E:'3§1C:<:',: argumentfi and we praceed
£0 éispase 0:' appéaiA:':;_ ¥:§§;:*' i;E1is grammar: judgxnent,
A Egearzagd iji1$éI appfiariiiig for the app1ican§:~m0th&r
Si;};;>:£:;,.3}tV$f - cempensatiofi was ciaimeé on the
g°out2d;4:_V deaeaseci son was warking as Loader arid
" :f' "Ui'}}u{;1=3d€I'?,»}i1"1fl€I' Ffifipfiflfififli 3$\é'<3.2---0wI1::§* sf fiat: iipper, an 3
A Rs.5,G08/-' per margth, apart fmm RS520 per fiay as
i";sstai Bu': the Cemmissioner has fixed the earnings of the
L
deceased at lower rate of Rs.3,000/-- per month. He further
submits that 2"' respondent--owner of the tipper filed written
statement stating that the deceased was getting sa1a1*yj’of
Rs.4,000/– per month and therefore, he _
wages of the deceased may be fixed at Rys>74,00Q-,=;»pd¢;:monthit ‘w
and award compensation.
4. On the other hand, _.1earne’d:”counse1.’:for
insurance company submits ‘applicant: not
produced any record to sho’1y”that’_’itheA videceiased vyasuearning
Rs.5,000/– per month apart He further
submits thatythe’ though stated in his
objections that deceasedyvas %{:e’tting wages of Rs.4,000/- per
mouth, h§’\%_ha$. riot ‘subjected himseif for cross–eXamination
and.’-henicet.thestatement of objections filed by the owner
‘it?’regarding”Wages.?fof7’ the deceased cannot be accepted and
_ __ao’_red.jupon. ~~
5. As per Notification No. KAE 43 LMW 2001 dated 5-2-
2003 relating to loading and unloading in a warehousing,
with reference to Sector–I City Corporation areas,’
minimum wage is fixed at Rs.3,163.90. [Basic _
D.A. of Rs.1020–90). There is no disputemahout’.’th’e-jiiactoirv’-oiit
224 applied. Therefore, ends of justice
minimum wage is appiied for .
compensation. it it H’ V
6. There is no merit in «the insurance
company. On the other ._.}:_1a1’3;d,’ deceased
partly succeedvsin sheuisentitied for enhanced
compensation. A’r3;.cC’ordi1?i:g’1jf;’.thasubstantiai questions raised
are answered in uifavvour’ of the mother of the deceased
work’ In “an. ‘- ‘
the appeal in M.F.A.No.4536/2007
by the.__Vins_urance company fails and the same is hereby
1297?
‘ egeeme, i\”/1′.F:LA.No.i–26″?/2007 filed by the mother of the
(awake? as Fe’! end»-‘*d=’~ 1:~f2:–2’–9-9? 3; @;.;=ee&N’~;fQ1;x:m:
partly allowed holding that she is entitled to
“=-rii’opeeeepeeee:ien of Rs.3,54,258/– [$3166.90/2 x 224)
6
as against Rs.3,36,000/~ awarded by the CO}I1″1I!1iSSiOI1€I’~§°i”r win??? Fifi
55″””‘l5’Tg§ 44 A-Ike’?
the interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 117-2005.
and not from 12–7–2005. The amount deposited by*.fheg: V M
insurance company in this appeal be reieaseclfidi favodr of
appliearmmother. The Insurance Co3npan$fV..ie”-direcfedain * dd
deposit the balance amount with the “Co.fnmissi’of_1e1″aVV
interest within a month from toda3}%{‘~.,
V’ =
MP/ck