Muniyallappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 2 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court

Author: H N Das

1

W.P.3 I $87-7f}6:'()9

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BANGALORE 

DATED THIS THE 02"" DAY OF NOVEMBER 20%» j  _T 

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE H.N.rgAﬁ3A:v:Oa4:.ANAaAA:S--  1%

WRET PETITEON NOs:31537–765’/2.0d9,(‘LB–BA;/M – = E’

BETWEEN:

MUNIYALLAPPA
S/O RAMAIAH
AGE: 49 YEARS.

JAYAMMA E

D/O VENKA.TAF{A’M/WAPPAEAV ”

AGE:51;rEABS~;..–‘:–_V_ ‘ »

Rumimz’ .

W/O GANESH _ *
AGE:4’9AYE.AVRS._ A

RAJENDRA = E

as/’O ;;;_I.NGEGOW’E3’A”‘ ”
~ . AGE: 55 YEARS.

._
A 8/0 GUN.DA’PPA
“AG E.;_”58-YEARS.

A ELsHEiv.ANNA
‘ :3zO VEERABADRAPPA
* –_AraE: 52 YEARS.

NAGARAJU
S/O CHANNAPPA
AGE: 49 YEARS.

OLV”

116

BHAGYALAKSHMAMMA
D/O LENGAMMMA
AGE: 55 YEARS.

MUNIYAPPA
S/O MUNESWAMAPPA
AGE: 56 YEARS.

HANUMATHAIAH
S/O NARASIMHAIAH
AGE: 55 YEARS.

LEELA
W/O THANARAAM
AGE: 47 YEARS.

AVCHJKKARAJU H A
3/0 VEERABADBEGOWDA
AGE:49 r

B.BVASAAvVA*R5AJU.,€€. Y
s/oi..vEERAT’HA’iAH,.SS A ~
AGE:’49’YEARS.’ ~

B.s.KRISHNAMLJ–RTHY;~

giro SIJBRAMA_Nl,
._ .. ….. .. y

Y ‘j’:<RisHAN;AMLJRTHv
_ "~"S./O"'P.UTTL.l:NGAlAH
. AGE; 72.~:{EARs.

B :r<AE..AhY
W/O.BALARAJ

'' '*-AGE: 48 YEARS.

RRAMADEV:

9/O M NAGABHUSHANA

AGE: 47 YEARS.

K’; \f\,f’»

\,,./

W,P’3 1587-766/(}9

RENUKAMEVEA
S/O NANJAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

SHiVAN.JA!AH
S/O NANJAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

S PALANIYAPPA
S/O SUBBAIAH
AGE: 60 YEARS.

KAVERAMMA
D/O VENKATAPPA
AGE: 54 YEARS.

K SURESH ‘S R’

8/0 LATE KRISHNAMURTHY A V’

AGE: 40 YEARS.-._
JAYAMMA’ ‘ S

W/CSVKRVISRHNVAPEAR
AGE; 49 YEARS’;–…L”A ‘

v sARo.J.AsxaMA % S
D/Q EERAPPAV _

A_;3E:nso YEARS’. :

. .,bUé'<.éA$tA«sKAR PATAK

.s,'0"AN'A..NAT.HA.PATAK
"~'A(3E';v 64-,,YE.AF{S.

“PuTTArL§~YAMMA

WIO A._AD|MUR’FHY

‘ .. _AeEv:.–ao YEARS.

*-PDSHPA
w/o LATE KWSHNAPPA
‘ AGE: 35 YEARS.

¢\_.r””\»x,

W.P.3 I 587J(>(n/()9

MUNIYAMMA
W/O MUNISWAMAPPA,
AGE: 55 YEARS.

VENKATESHA
S/O THIMMAIAH
AGE: 49 YEARS.

M CHANNAPPA
S/O MAYAPPA
AGE: 63 YEARS.

CHOUDAIAH

S/O CHOUDAIAH

AGE: 48 YEARS.

S CHANDRA.MQUL_i N

8/0 S VARA3_DAFf,AJVU.
AGE: 49 ‘;-“Er’\”RS;=.»~7:*_V A

SUBE?.AMAE\E~3_A”‘ .
S/O:,KUPPA8\V’VAf\/}3{ 3
AGE?:,52′-YEARS-f:’-~.’L”A. ”

SAM PAI\’AC_§iAF32AE\}iA_Sa\r’\VIﬂxE\A’\'(»AA 4′ A
8/0 LATE ‘mAA4A-YAPPA
AQE: 58 YEARS.’ V

A wYEx%”A!\/iA;S\;’\1VA:At*.{EY
S’/’O. “P.~AMA’i-AH’-

._ “A_C:E’:’48..YEwA’R’S.

M. M F_<i'AN.nl:"' 3

W10 KAVERAPPA

Y ;AGE:=55 YEARS.

.. 3′ –KA5R|YAPPA
S/O KABBALEGOWDA
7 AGE: 68 YEARS.

§j\X’&=\

W. 931 587-76(1!{)’)

MUNIKRISHNA
S/O CHANGALARAYAPPA
AGE: 58 YEARS.

T VENKATARAMANAPPA
S/O THSMMARAYAPPA
AGE: 63 YEARS.

MCHINNAPPA
S/O MUNISWAMAPPA
AGE: 73 YEARS.

PRASANNAKUMAR
S/O NARAYANA,
AGE: 58 YEARS.

MUNISWAMY .

s/o DODDA;'</AE*\;t§,L\TA:P PA

AGE:70 yEx.=.R%_s*;;_;;_ ~ '

DoDpAVMIv.57— ,_ _
W/CrVSAMPA}'\'G|

AGE':.A59'-YEARI55-»,_

GTHIMVMAIAH A
S/,0.GUJA'1'/\}j{
Age; 60 YEARS.'

A V.1E'AKé}§§y€Ai\«%MA
w;*o'i=9AP.ANNA

_ "-."3_\_C~'aE":"5?~.,YEAR'S.

M BALAI’-.|GA A
8/0 ML}N!YAN

A’ vGAGE’:.4’9 YEARS,

” -JAYAMMA
w/0 RAMANNA
f AGE: 53 YEARS.

3*-‘\»~*
£’,\’

W.P,3 E 587~76€>!(J’f~}

H NARASIMHAIAH
S/O NARASAIAH
AGE: 70 YEARS.

DANALAKSHME

we (3. KRISHNA

AGE: 49 YEARS.

N.NAF?ASlMHAlA!-I
S/O DODDANARASAPPA
AGE: 57 YEARS.

B R SRIDHARAMURTHY .
S/O RAMACHANDRA M
AGE: 50 YEARS. A ‘
BASAVARAJ,U–_

S/O GANGA__DH,§;H .
AGE: 48 YEARS:A–<:–_V '

S/O; LAT R' SAs{3DAARED'DY_ A
AGE:,6Ct Y'E.AR'S;;-..AA%"A '

DEVEGOWD./* " A
S/0.,MARtSwA.M,aeowD-A

A§3E: 52 YEARS: V

' » .(§.AN't3:A RAAJLJ
= S'/0 GHINNAVENKATARAYAPPA

._ "-.AGE':v43,YEAvRS.

V. LAKSHRIAMMA
w/0 SPALANIYAPPAN

A’ SAGE’:–61 YEARS.

‘ ” -».!\1i.AHABALESHWARABHAT
S/O GANAPAMSHAT
A’ AGE: 49 YEARS.

<;"}*'"V"'

VV.?.3 i 587-766/(")9

B M KRESHNAMURTHY
S/O S R MUNEYAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

VARADAMMA
W/O K M RANGAPPA
AGE: 50 YEARS.

NANDA GOPALA
S/O K APPNAHNAIDU
AGE: 55 YEARS.

T SHARADAMMA

w/o M D E\/EUDDURAN€i..!V’§§’SW’L:AM;f_Y’ ”

AGE: 82 YEARS.

“rARAvINDAf
S/O CHINNATHAMVBE.
AGE: 52f{‘EA_RVS;.»–‘:–___ ‘

D/cYMuN|vSNA¢KA:A.pPA A
Acagpse YEARS}-..AS%’ ‘
G JAYA’RAMAN” S . _
S/VO_VG|DD’AGURA’PP’A ”

A;SE:u54 YEARS; V

. ML: IYEHAYAM MA

Svv,/So”+§ ‘RAMACHANDRAPPA
6£}X’E.AF{S.

“fx!EAYA§<f§A!:SHNAREDDY

S/O MUNISWAMIREDDY

* _ ; LAGEL71 YEARS.

* –..R:A\VEl<Ul\/IARA

S/O KFHSHNAPPA

E AGE: 47 YEARS.

<7L

P3 l537–7{3()/O')

EV’EUNiYELLAPPA
S/O YELLAPPA
AGE: 43 YEARS.

THIMMAKKA
W/O BASAVAIAH
AGE: 65 YEARS. I

N E BASAVARAJ U

S/O ESHWARAPPA
AGE: 53 YEARS.

THE MARENAHALLI ,vA.sATRa’H’EE:\:A’RA

SANGHA MARENAHALLI, S
BANASHANKARI POST .
JAYANAGAR 5TH BLOCK. ‘

BANGALORE. –_4 BY; ITS RR E..:SA|’E)’E.P_\ET’ ” ~ A
SR|AVCH3_KKARAJU”. A

AGE: 49f{‘EA_BS*..v~–‘:-___ ‘

MNA.RAs’i”m4.R’AiA,H– ” E
S/O.MUNHi’.fENK’ATA.PPAV

AGE; 88 YEAF€S'{‘-~._R ‘

YRAMVNAHVV A _
S10 YALLAPPA.,

A535: 60 YEAF*€…3, :

. SLEEEALAKSHM:

– .vwoH.RNARENERANATR

, _ ‘=’A(3E: 6$.,YE.}f\F{‘S.

M ME’ENA”KSHE

D/C3 GMKARAPPA

. VELAGE’:–55 YEARS.

–..s.L}GANDHAMMA

D/0 BARAMAP PA

A AGE: 68 YEARS.

W.§’.3 I S87’~7′()6/()9

Vfsé

NANJAMMA
D/O HONNAiAH @ THAMMAIAH
AGE: 46 YEARS.

NAGARATHNA
W/O NAGABHUSHANA
AGE: 67 YEARS.

PRABHAVATHI
D/O NARASAPPA
AGE: 49 YEARS.

R RAMESH 4
s/0 R RANGASWAMY—_ M
AGE: 52 YEARS. A ‘
SHANTHAMMAA
D/oHuTcHAPF;AV .
AGE: 52 ::Y’EARVS”.Y-v-~’:–_V

M KlJ–B–EF3A”;.VAh’
S/O:,KR|SH?d.A.PPA<V
AGE»; 49 YE.AF<s.'.;–. A

KAMAL'A5Aa_ A _ . g
W/Q PANDUF2ANGA'*.

AQE: 49 YEARS: V

*.ARA¥HLEa_

– w,’Q’E2_A3A\1AAAJu

A L *i.’Aca E’: <1'f..,,YEAvR'S.

Gom{‘R’A!\2;MA

D/Q MDASAPPA

Y VEAGE’:Y-E38 YEARS.

* NIRMALA
vv/0 PRASHANTH BABU
A’ AGE: 48 YEARS.

C7’\\/z’x/L

W.P.3 I 587-766/()9

-94 8

LAKSHMAMMA
W/O NARASIEVH-IAIAH
AGE: 57 YEARS.

V LAKSHMJ
W/O H SHIVARUDRA
AGE: 55 YEARS.

SHARADAMMA
D/O MUNIYAPPA
AGE: 68 YEARS.

M CHANNAMMA
D/O MUN!’/APPA
AGE: 55 YEARS.

K S TULASIDEVI

w/0 KALIYAMURTHY A

AGE: 60 YEABSA.’

N.LATHA,:_. 5lf_”,..’;’. ‘

D/O :kALGtYAv:§.é»uRT”}%JVY, M A

AGE::.47~.’v’EARsffj-._’

SUCHITFLA – V P
8/0. S HAREVSHAV _ I
Age: 47 YEA!’-§S_._ V

A .,:}J”:x:AEa.§é\irz)§~”r:x1A
9/Q PPAPAR EDDY

A _ A’QE:”48″Y_EA’B8′.

/, gs

AH’OME3_ALAMMA
D/O..LAATE MUTHIAH

AA AQE:55′ YEARS.

‘V52. RASTHURI
go/o BALAPPA
__5AGE: 55 YEARS.

W.P.3 E 587-766/U0

T00

101

102

103

105

MAHADEVAMMA
W/OMAHADEVNAH
AGE: 55 YEARS.

VEERABHADREGOWDA
S/O MALLESADDEGOUDA
AGE: 68 YEARS.

RENUKA
D/O SHIVARUDRA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

GOWRAMMA
D/O KARIYAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

HOMBALAIAH
3/0 C KARIYAPPA . V A
AGE: 48 YEARS ‘

VAJRAMMI5-E

w/OE VlEGvl\lF<'r*\Af*E7.AR%A,VVJ'U
AGE; 55; \r'EA'RS:;-. *

CHIKKAMMA . V
w/0 NAF¥ﬁ'.SlMA|AH'*_

,A¢.E;AA72 YE}f\R_S.

. _»VARA’£;§:AiAFEA–._

SJQGANGA AF%AS|A%AH

:2; .5«wEARs.

“‘MUN’I’Y”A:MMAL

,<oF2AMu S

Y _AGE.:–50 YEARS.

* –P{RiSHNA v

S/O VEERAPPA
AGE: 60 YEARS.

V’v’.P.3 1587-766/(39

107

108

109

115

VIJAYALAKSHMI
D/O KRISHNAPPA
AGE: 65 YEARS.

RAMESHA
S/O KRISHNAMURTHY,

AGE: 49 YEARS.

MELAPPA
S/O DASAPPA
AGE: 67 YEARS.

G H RAESHWARi
D/O NARAYANAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS. A V’

EVE MUN|VENKATAPPA__ ‘A
S/O YELLAPPA’ _’ ‘
AGE: 51 YE_AR$,.- ‘V .

Pu”rTALiéSHj_Q’rA’AA’A)i;A»

W/C5VKRV!SRH!A$iVAPF.5::A;’
AGE; 4″; YEARS’;-..

KUMARY-V _E.»_;
0/0′ N NARASAPPA
A£ﬁ3E:SA48 YEARS’. V

. w%>i:.I_iAs\AA)jA«…V
Tv»’.ro’£:H,Ar«e.pRYAEEA

49.,Y’E.ARs.

‘;J.AYAN’:§é:’~”H R

8/0 RAMACHANDRAPPA

_ _AGE:…48 YEARS.

E:-SATHYANARAYANA SHETTY
S/O R GOVINDAPPA SHETTY
‘ AGE: 72 YEARS.

c7*%*\/A

\rV.E’.3 l587~766/{)9

117

118

119

120

121

122

123

17.1214′

125

1 3 W.P.3 lS87~76(Y/()9

VENKATAMMA
W/O BHEEMAIAH
AGE: 50 YEARS.

RAJU
s/o LATE NARASAPPA
AGE: 35 YEARS.

H R KRESHNAPPA ‘
s/o MADDURAPPA : ‘
AGE: 49 YEARS.

KRISHNAPPA,
s/0 MADDURAPRA, w
AGED : 49 YEARS.

KA?\/|ALAMMA.a ‘
w/0 CH|KKBi¥.NG1APF!A 1 ~ 5
AGE:53 Y.E.ARe;_f .1 2 _ 1;,

M KR:sH:~a..ARPR_

S/O,1\AU1E1\E’|S’J1LAM151i§P.ﬂ1:’=~.:’_’ %
AGE; 53 YEARS; A ‘-

RAME§i”,, 11.1,}
s/Q t_ATE*SHIVARUD.RA1AH

A_f3E:*39 YEAR3 V

v_§RAéHAVATH|

– Tvuuo-t,AT,Evgm/ARUDRAYAH
3~a,_YE.AR’s.

N PL.3’SH~§’«}X

wxo E. G GANGARAJU

.1 _AGEv:..–5o YEARS.

*.sR0BHA

D/O LATE RAJAGOPALA

1 AGE: 42 YEARS.

137

138

139

140

141

142

143

“1.44~

LAKSHMAMMA

SINCE DECEASED BY HER
i_R3 RAJESHWARE

AGE: 37 YEARS,

LAKSHMAMMA,
W/O KR§SHNAPPA
AGE : 50 YEARS.

R RANGASWAMY
S/O MOTAIAH
AGE: 59 YEARS.

BHAGAVAN
S/O TULASIRAM

AGE:50 YEARS. A

KSLAKSHMI % S
D/O NAr–3Ae3″iNVGASAO-._–..___
AGE:41YEA_F{S. ‘E
G F{Ai\AADAS3_,

S/OLM caoPA’LAj”- -. .1 ‘ —
AGE: «55’YEA’RS; . ”

MU_N§SW”/AMY A _

gixo e.HANN’APPA V

-.AGE’:,49.1.\{EARS.’V’ *****

A f sY2:3′:.”3w.:\2z 1- A
“-‘.VWO’vNA.GAHA’JU

.9 ‘A1GE:_48Ai*{EARs.

_ 145

.1AYA*M§£A
WIGMUNISWAMY

1′ ‘M35: 50 YEARS.

SAASAROJINI

W/O M RAYAN
AGE: 70 YEARS.

(/$,kH\V:-=7./RH.

W.P,3 I 5875/’66/()9

147

148

149

150

351

152

153

“1

PREMA
W/O SHIVASHANKARA
AGE: 49 YEARS.

VANAJA R
W/O RAMANUJA
AGE: 53 YEARS.

V MURTHY
S/O VENAKTESHA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

RAMACHANDRA _ ._
S/O HANUMANTHAIAH
AGE: 47 YEARS. ‘

KGsHEKA_RA;:;~y . A
S/O KODAf~.J’D_A’–R E_vDE3Y._
AGE: SGVYEARLS.
NE:ELAMNiAj.. 4 _ .
W/OANAHA.YA’I\IfA¥? PA 1. ‘
AGE: 48’-YEA’R_S; . ”

KAMALAMMSAV _

W/O C-EANGADHARA:

– AG ,,55»\x’EARS.’ ” ***** ~’

‘A f B’ sQWGaF:.é§G-YA
“-‘.V\£/OG’ANGA!AH

V ?AGE:.$’2A:’?{E’/i\RS.

_ I155

GANGAMMA

S W/GNAGARAJU

A “AGE: 49 YEARS.

_ 56;

RGANGAMMA,

W/O KEMPAMH,
AGE : 50 YEARS.

54. ivfxw/’L

W,P.3 I587–?(>ﬁ/()9

157

158

159

160

161

162

163

165

JAYAMMA
W/O LINGARAJU
AGE: 60 YEARS.

GANGADHARA
S/O VASUDEVA
AGE: 51 YEARS.

RAJESHWAR1
W/O SRIDHARPRASAD
AGE: 55 YEARS.

c RAMAKRIsHNAPPA..__
S/C) KADEERAPPA ”
AGE: 50 YEARS.

SBABU 5′ ‘
S/O SYED s3A3;u’sA3’-1 ‘

PRAMEVELA._% ;*<:;._ ~ V

w/0 G A R,A»MAK'RIsH4N«APPA A

AGE; so "vEA'r-13.-»

v SARASWATHL ~
W/O JANARDHANA'NA:'~Du

,,A_:QE;A~ 51 YEARS. V

'13 NA.§§A.#ANAPPA

w1OA–vvEN'A.T"ARAMANAPPA

*?IA<31+;-;

M MAHAA21MED ALE

S/’O MQDIN SAB

_ _AGE:.–50 YEARS.

* –..éAGHuNATHA T

S/’O THIPPANNA
AGE: 48 YEARS’

C><\….'\~/'\»~'

W.P.3 1 537A766!(}9

167'

168

169

170

171

172

173

:75

PUTTATHAYAMMA
S/O NARASEGOWDA
AGE: 50 YEARS.

LAKSHMAMMA
W/O BASAVASAH
AGE: 52 YEARS.

M N KODANDARAMA
S/O LATE N NAGAPPA
AGE: 55 YEARS.

iNDRANE
D/O K H SHARMA

AGE: so YEARS.

DEVARAGU,[3[)A’€AH,i. A
s/o MAHADEV£ai’AH.V ‘
AGE:

D/Cf MARE'{3:QWD.A
AGE; so YEARS]-»..L’ A

BYRAPPA11 _ A _ .
S/Q CHANNAF-}A’.;–‘AF?PA”‘

A;g3.E;*s5 YEARS. V
. :i’3A.A/§A4A
= D;’OM_OTE{3OWDA
*-‘A,GE; 4’;3.,_YAEAF{S.

“RAM1AKQA:”é1H NA

S/Q MAYANNA

V. %AGEA;A47 YEARS.

= .,.S’HAsH:KALA

D/O KRISHNA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

(jg ‘\\/’/K,/’\..

W.P.3 I 587-7(36f(J’)

177

178

179

180

19 w.R3 I ssvrzma/(.39;

SUGANTHI DAVID
W/O DAVID CHALLAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

US!-IA M
D/O MADAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS.

SHEVANNA {-3
S10 BASAVALINGAIAH
AGE: 49 YEARS.

LAKSHIVH
D/O AYYAPPAN
AGE: 37 YEARS.

ALL ARE F3/QSY’-.-No.11? &I_1.>:~3, ‘ ”
MARENAHALLI5V|LL.AGE;;_ _ ._ ” ‘
BANGAL;ORE..SOU’_TH «T_ALU.K,’-~ _
BANGALQRE. ‘ A « ..

PETITIONERS

(By Sri: My VEDACRALAI 3Av4’P=D”H§DANANDA, Advs.,)

AND:

STATED? I§ARIIATAI<A
"'REP.-RESIENTED BY' ITS CHIEF SECRETARY,

A f–.ViDHANAS~O_UDHA, VIDHANA VEEDHI,
'' _RAI\IQALr)REf;~ 560 om.

BA’NGI’\LORE.

D’ _T’I~IE sRI§:7$IAL DEPUTY COMMISSIONER

‘(‘REvi’EAIuE), BANGALORE DISTRICT,

RESPONDEENTS

A.IIsA{sAa=I;R.DEVADASS, AGA)

20 W.P.3 I 587~766ff)9

THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTtC_l;E$

226 & 227 or THE CONSTITUTION OE INDIA

DIRECT THE R2, TO CCNSDIER THEIR CLAINI O_F?…_F,i’V”£4_jt3t«Vft’1″:~;.i.:”I’I..’_FL!ifv’ J

AND INTEREST 1N RESPECT CE sITES;:’SrT:tJAfi”E«D

& 18 CE MARENAHALLI VILLAGE, SANrs’ALoREe,’iSoftJT’H

. BAGALORE IN ACCORDANCE W|T’ti:THEIR REP’RE_’SE”NTATIoN

MADE COLLECTIVELY AT.AN_N-Q1.~~I’N”ACCo’RDANCE”w’ITH LAW,

THESE WRIT RETITIQNS TCCMINS or-I EUR’ PRELIMINARY

HEARING THIS ‘Si./_§:\VY, M_/:.1IDE”i’THE”FOLLOWlN63

on-DER

Sri.Dev’e.dass, AdhditioItailﬁovernznent Advocate is directed to

_ take notice for respondent.

.0: ‘«!.n’t.hese writ petitions, the petitioners’ have prayed for a

wri’t~_irI-._tri*teV”nat»:it_re~1;”‘ot. mandamus directing the 2″” respondent to

V Consider their Ciatrn as per their representation dated 12.05.2009 as

“‘.’.’4’3’£):t’.tE”.dV–.E_’l'{ Annexure — Q to the writ petitions requesting for issue of

.k_hatha provide basic amenities and for other reliefs.

CZ7′”\x’/’v

2 1 W.P.3 I587-766/()9

3. No pregudice witt be caused to the respondejit’

are directed to consider the petitioners’ represe.ntat:i’c.r}V”dated

12.05.2009 as per Annexure «– Q

Accordingiy, the writ petitions are hereby disposed of.
Sri.Devadass, teamed AdditioﬁaéV:Governmen’t’t [.43.-dveeatte is

permitted to tile memo of appei§raﬂnce_.W§tt1i’:1-Ithreeyveeké frorri today.

JUDGE

dh*

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

Muniyallappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 2 November, 2009

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel