N B Swami vs The Primary Co-Operative … on 24 July, 2009

_{§1i:2jgi ati<ii':iQ::a1 maimfiai b€fOI'€ the Di$<:ip1i1"13r§;
'-V./._.}5§L;{}'}{}vi'i§}" of 'wmit:h {ha dfilifiqfififit {"3}31§}0}*'i')€ has
;10Ai§;::3i¥1;edge:. Hewsvrstzs, when the Encguiry (kfficar
_ " 'gées Vfljixttiégr arzd records his finciérigs, as Stated

–.__ab%}*a.?’;3.,__ wiiiisii may or ma}; HOE E36 based 011 {ha

‘ $vi(.?;;ei1::jf.<":'01} record 31' Contraxjfy' ta ma wme GI' in
ig:s'}.,0:'a:*1c€ af it, such fimiixzgs are an additional

. Ifgaféériai. HEKIIGWH to the éxziplayae but am takers
" * ._i1"§té c0':'15ideraiiG1": by the C§i,s<:ip1inaIj; aumofity
fwhiie 31*rivi2'3g at iis €®I}€E{1$i®fis Bat}: rm:

iiicriatas of EEK: }’€£:’:.SQ3’i1ab§€: :2pp0:*1:u:1i:*~.:” as Weii as

ms: §3I§flC’.iE}§€S <3?' zxatsaifal izzatiae, tixfirfifsrfi,
f€{§'&1§}'fi that béffirs the cikitipliziarzr" aui:h@ri1:3='

95:3 1994 :E1C}(§?i V

{EOEEIEES is its awn r;€::"1ciusi11S, {.1112 cieiiizqilazli:
azzinims-“$6 shcxuiail have an p;3or’t”unitv {:3 rczm-‘ ta
ms: §z1<:;uim»»* 0fi"i::&r's fi31diI"3§S. The ::iis{:iI;3}§r:;ia:rv

authsritxz' is thfin rsfiiuired to <::s::1'1Sici§;1"..:"i:.%_1%;:– _
€3Vi{1éiI'1C€, ihe: report of the €§i1QfiiE'V of'iiC€:r«.:z3:'1d "

I'€§3I"f§S€i}'l'{atiGI'l cf the €:n1pim:1i1;”‘::v{)uIé14 have
made a difiérencg to €E1€,__i_’é:;e:::,;it_._j11 the ca:sai:;’t:ha§ it
should set asi:i£:~~.__ thé o’1″::i.:::110iv5;{1g V2′:;.””t>{FJ,:f:: .. 9§:>1?oced:;1’e§ the:
C:0urt:sfTribnnais se_t:~; ” ;isiz:i:.-:”~.i’:h_:i:- arder of
pu11i_sh111er_1i;,_ 1;i”:3″”;’;$’I'<;a§§~i%1*' igbkat shouki be
gramtefi ;:1*s'iir;s,L, £iire{":t F€i}iSEé'tt;t§115iE:1.tV"0f' the eznpiayee
with 1i§w3€":::t_§?I._v.I:_t} fifxtig E;u$.hG{if}/fffflallangfililfifit :00
proceéaci -:j_\$;-'.it13 €:.?:é5f~s;j1';:q~::i;*3;*,' by ylaaizxg {ha
€:113.p.£.<wé'<::_ i:1'3:::}_e1" -»sf:;fus';:2:es11*;~::1o:;f;: 3311:? Continuing tbs:
§r;:gq1.1iI'3?" iifQ,r31 the -fifage 0ff:1r3'1isi"s.i23g him. witlrg {ha
r'ep01*~£;.' V '{7jLii:3S€i£).I1. whathm" the sn1p10j/we
'i5.?O1;Z3{§ }}fi '::::_1%.i-fit-Ed"—f:(i"'{ha backwages anti <)€'h€2'*
bfiilfiffiifi f1=".rm1._tha:: Qziaté of his dis1':<1iss:-ii :0 'i:h£~: dais
:;sr_f'» his réizzisfatenient if 11}t:imata}}=' ardemd $.Ir:<:»u3c:i

*E¢;mgg§:i:;;b1y 'Ef'}:;:..§.::f't' to 336 ziczcidéti by the autiaeritjg

A V {?:;r:"':¢@:*i1.*=j;{1 ac{:9r<:ii1";.g to iaw, zaftsar fha cuixniriazion
=53?"vvifiiai'gzfccaedings 3:333; depending on the final
::;i.:%;{jG1:1§:.§.T'vfiif' the emgxizyyee succeecig in the frash
"i3'1qui1*"f:'j_ fi1*:d is. directad to be reizistaiedg the
""4-aui;_§1G:%if};* shank} be at liberty is decicie a.Cear{'iing

its 13?; how it WEE Ema: {ha parioé from the date of

. iiigiziifisai iiii the rémstatament 3116 ta what
_ 'E::er:'€f§_ts, if any anti the sextant of "ma benafits, 11%:
23:31 {)6 eiztitied. Ths rei:1stat$'mez1£ made a3 a

§'€S1..};i'€. sf iihé saitiiig 3.:-sifie ef ifha iziquiry' fer
faihiffi E10 f1i1I'I23:3§'1 tits report. ghauki be trsatsd as
$3. rsinsiatézzaeifi {ii}? 233:3 purpasa of .?2{3i::"§_§ng the

W

ix)
L3′;

§’:r'<:sE': }:.1}.£§Ei§.E°'f£ f"r0::: {E26 :~a1:'ag&: :3? i'm"z':ai:~s§1i::1g Sim
m}?;<s:_'ii :3:i":{':i not, mimi, v§§1":<:}:'e:: i%s_.1<:i"1 fr<;:sE:1 i12q1.1ir§; "is;
Eieiizi, 'E"E:a¥: Wiii zaiséfi bérz me (:0;'1"*t:(:t §3{}§3'§f.i(}i"1 in

33

Mm»-” .

E9. ‘i”E1<: i»::':az*°1?.%_::d Siragk: Jzzrzigsi iéiiagi u'{.h{:i

ab{3V<: ;'1a1'3"zm:{i pm<:€:e:i:A1raE irz*t:gjg.:ia3*%ti¢::;si" = -.2§;:';.:+iiV"-.%1§::;g9ji:ii'z:=%$'-

{:@i11I1'1i«i':ir:<i 1):; €}'1i(": <'iis<_:ipi%:"1a1*y A1'_;14{hc;1"ii'ff_§-' ::;:;;{.£".<éé'::;'i,;§{i*§; "<.:%&t'i<:é:1' "

whiie (I{}'{1e:"§.1.ECi'iZ'3g £131": 3'§;i1'i-*.{¥:1.'i.:§£"_V'__.'f,:" 931;. <.:1′”1t::?§v’19§i§;.;:>h_.;t{:~:”i:§ ii:
}€eg:.:la{,io:1»f§S ix”: pr0;3f31* §)€f$’}é%:3A{Z:§f§”?§_v’ ezrfii ” :19 {::»;zm1:E:3<3
i'.E'13f’} –..?n§2 ‘has %iEf”i'{}i’}{i'{}L3S§f€
rszccmiézai his iimiizjggs :::”§:’:$<~: §z':'zpug:'1i3(i <':I'dé::"
ti: 13.2: i;§:Vé':' Vc;f{ic::"-:; {_§§S_:;a_:;j! E”::$_as’ ;é.I’3fy* :*€<:§ué:st' §:;=@f'<3:*é: $163 €}i};.{.§'£..EiI'fy'

: z3__§”1<::_1z:1t::'1'{:s_., 23:; <;§%":<«;"::'

°a~':&2i{:i9<:3'3:{':é?""§:§ '""g;.:§a{r:ée{E am :'€:<:m'*{§ to §;}.':<:"w Eéiat. }'}<2§i'1;*E0:"1«:=;r <}fi%3§*€:<i

"E-1} .4:i:<2i;;:2é':z'r:§3' ::"::§7<€;a;':§': 1¥£§.;;{:$s;€:3 Of} his Siiiéi am} §}r<:w:;%.1__:<i:5:{i

<::i:m:;i§1': z;£i:3E:. aiiwssizi ‘{3}; {mi

Efiié. 11:3′ -f”<;i§'3{:§r". F'u§"?{3E';:»:::"'_, me: E€a:'mE:€i §E*§iz'z if? sézzci if wi§%T2:1%;

” . c::yr:’s§:i:::%§:’§_g $3253 §’::::g;{}:”‘€’.za2’z€_. Ei§~§§}fi{3§’.S 3″},3}”Z”&§i{i{§ z§,E;:;}:;<3, %'aa§_~;

' " 12:.-'2={;§':§§§:' :’::::2 fig: ma’-“~: :::<;_:1<:i3..2si@::: 52:'. §f}£§£'é% '? %;%;2z2%.. E',§";;£§ ::§'_1:_a:*g;§:$

\\w/

ieveikizi against. the a;:»p<=:3i}.am am grave in :1at:,:;::5T',_%,i:v01vi:T1g
f'iz'1;-mijiai ::1isapp1"0pI'ia.E;i0I1 and {£163 penalty _i¢?9§'§:€é:1 "the

c§i:3<:ipEi_:1a1j$: £iI.1fi1.{}I°if,}? kg in ar'(i331Ce 2-¥=’iI;§:.. Ea1a7.T S§.i1€,iiaI1f: with :’€f€I’€:I1(:e {,0 {E18 :=gro1_-mg:ivS ‘-:;£’*;;,}£t’::i T ?.é=*r:”:f;f I

;)a:.i:.ie:;r: Eflinii aise zmt a1;’3piy”i’:1g, hi.S’..§E.i”i:1d f:c;».i:}11%:” :§ér’p::c’m},,–.:V ihé ‘E3:2qu°1’ry
Ofiicer ta finci mm: as fig.) wh€§}:1s:*_:f”£316–»g:hargesv.§.evi-éileil against

the a;;3pe§ia1’1t was p:”0Ver:i ,\%«?ifi’13vi.f(?f(;§E’f§’RCC–,, to the positive: and

iifgéfi €’:.?id€:”};${3 :31} _;’€:<:€::'{£ : '§§E"1{i'_i3:1€if€'f{if€', ii-<;'é: am: Sf tbs

{:::3r::-:i::'1év1'®<'§ :?iex§?'~i'}i"3$;:. ._i'f1x:1f;""$1:{-;' ieazzieii Singlfi Judge is erred

iii E"10§<ii;':g " §%€11aE€.}? Eéivied by the': {fiSC§,p}iE1aI'jf

– V. A aut:§:a§’2::*i:.§k’ is 27;; ;i<:<:<3_f€L?J:<:§: with iaw,

2{_'V}. za.pp1'€<:iaf,i<}r1 Gf matgéiriai on §'€£20.i'd §*.?'§'f}1

f<~:fc51'-mzfiiais' i;_;*<j;*._iii?'}%€g'e,1iatii::3:1«.§8 mid thf: iaia-* Iaizi d{)*a2'n bjgz the

'V R}3€§{ .§i:':':;:§*fi in its fifiéjisiargs ciieii SL:.pra_, ma €E"iqI..ii,i'§

Lfz:<§3.".:{%3:;Ci§<:§ bjs; the §§.sci;31i:'1a?y A1,at§'10r§§.}a is :»*it§a€.s:z:§ in E3215.

' '§%'é;§.:'E;§::r:1' we fiimi 'shaé, E§'1e:'e is .z::;§i,Ir3mg an ré{:{}:*:i iii} $32012: ihai.

'4 $126 §§'}{}jEi}'"f;" I*@§}:::r"E;. $3 §':::*:':i8i'z&:{'% 3%,'; 33:6 apggeliam; E'}{3E"'€3i1'3 bfiifififfi

pa$si:'1g thf: §mp1,1g1"1€:d <3;:::i€~:r <3? <:I:1pu}s;01″:g;’ 1*e:i1’é::§1i€:1t. 1’33;

issuing $€(:C%11{i siievs cause 11t.i<:€:, wfaich is ma;{:r1'a$§Q1f"y 3 in

Eaw, a3 hezici 'Z33' the Coilstimtion Bench §)€Ci.SiQfi
bur': in Ieianamng Directar, ?-.163, ?$. —

refe:rred supra and t}1eref0re, the i;:np;;1grieci..{;r:iér ‘pfé;s,s{‘::ef1 by

the Eeamed Single Jutige <31j.; 1’etifé’21§$::;: GE’ épfisllmit .fI’OII1

his senrice is nonest ejée :3£’,ia2§;=,a7:1d consequently, the
same is iiabia to be set aside. A_s_..;_¥t:A_’}3.a§f€ alreaéy heid on
point No. (ii) ths:'”£§:'(iz%f:1″hf]gozizggifisarily mtiring the

appeiiaizt is :1<§i,V':'p;f:*:’1g {ha

3’f.p;)§:iiaIit.fA f$’*a}s<) bad in law for :1{m««<:0::1p3ia1":<:6 sf {ha

§nafida7z<-$5,? p:f{}:::€3<h1re gm the part sf the Emquirj; Qfiicex' in

1.101: =::ai}i=:=:g_VL':i':;30I1 the €'5}}fi@}Of§feEi€ ta armwer each arm of the

-«._ <:ha:*g€S_$'3f:<i §:.E'}E?'I'€:f@I'§.':9 'aha Grziez' pamed $32 this B§sx§;;2§;§’

“S5: E3: Hindustan Petraieum C’erpi:.._ £;$jc:é,,_ ” 12%.,’
Darius Shapur Cfhenai} this Coz;,r€””ra:*f%§é!”ri?z§:;” £0
ifihalaz-I Eaizadwaysji Q_ i.1td;;,’ V “‘z”;L{
G, ?”?zim;g21a?1a$a?nE9andam’-_ E1€;%;z::E.: {EFQEZLE if

‘£4. $254121’; :3 §u:i’§§<:–;?.a§ :"<':"a:§c::*s;4.é 0:1
<:e:r1:a:i3'"; :»:im.a?;ii)S(‘:i’V€;fC3: %:’3a::(,;%-;;’.2?5-:3, para$ :34-35}

“.({%4,… .g__ it is z’}O’%e2§ ‘a;€:i.i–.$et.’t%t:<i'V t:i';at 3 quassi»
jLi{.i'§€:i2s_} a§:;j21"£fz11,1St',_ "p0::–«3" zmtt) i.t$6:Ef a
{3(}f'1";{i"C3'{ {§};};fi1§§'§Ii{)EZE_ –.$}{§*~_aiié ":25: §3.'z'I'iV€ at 3. x::0I';r'c:<":'£:
fi:1dizT1g'%.)'fT'facf§. ' A "é:if1':)1*iEgf'qLi;€a$,ti<)I3 ;;2€}:st=:(:1 ktacis :0
Vwrgfigg ai:'s}~.=;;z «*ei"–._ "£33 ? ?}'i'$vv'$£';kS€, _t'1__n*t}1e:'1n{}r€, ':;?1<3

1.;11is{ii§’%:i:’fi(:;*:«inI1′:mitt.<:<:i E33; iihs §.1'1r:imst:1'ia1
'F'_1'i f::..1}'1:3.£_ k22§i"a.S ":?3;._§i"'f;1§l"}.'"§_fiI1?C7 i:"z:3:::fl2z;* as; ii'. {iii} 110$:
apgqiy .f,E':::-. pis*iAi:;s;'i§:r–i1_{:" Sf res ipsa Eoquitur" v:h§.<:I*1
z&*a$L":.t€§£:%;a1';i:: f%?}r'1i'I1e pu2'p<)Ss:~: of this <;:::.1s<: ami,

_ ' 'tfiizus, fa:;:<:{:§ $10 {flake imta <:r1$i(i&:*z3.f:.is::;§;3_ 2:: mlaiivzailt.

§;:3§;{:§., not ‘g6,;:;*::;<"a_3':<: f%:;r {Ee€€.€:m1i:;,i13g Q16: §8S3;'Ef:,

I'}53_;;1_§f:i3f_, {fiat that: passangers ::;f the 331,15 'E25.?i3i'i':3

_ :";=2g2:';€iE:§f:§;rfi_i}* rficguired to be €XaI3}.i1"}.€{§. '1'%}e

. fi'§5£'_é,3_$E§7ié§} 'i':'iE3'sii:ai fmfthsir failed ta agsply thti

ci2f ii”: ;’e£a.ti0:”: iii} 3

{E-%:Ami:’:’Sii<:. €'ii"i{}_?.,1if"_'§=', whicfx E8 'fjrapoiigieraizae £3'?

";.3:'t;;%)g1E;i1§i:}:" Hflfii apspiificé i;§"ifi gtamiarzi Sf igmaf

.__ ;<°{é<§u§_§*éE<i €272»? £3; cri._:11i'£1a1 €:r§.a£ 3% case ft}? gizeziiztiai
i"'€¥§€W '€$£§;%l$, ifzus, <":i€:;§;*i}s Izzagiéré €'IE.i'?.

;3%;i:. _E<Z:*r<};*s ai' _f'a<:t: 03:; 3335: Ex: 22:. S£_§.§'3j{f{Z?~
£':'i&}'§;'i',€ii" Qf j¥._":€'§;§€.'i§i§ zfiviéwy §€€:f<::':::'1:ts: ii": E}'}'§$

3
%»§és::%.:2$€m1 §’?e€::’}§z3::»:n r;’:oz”;:s£: Lid», ‘:5. §}:m§::s Sézzépm” €:_7%::’:§2:»;z’ sfi2f}€.}if;: ‘I’ :52″

\§\\M/

{:<)m1ect.i{m ma}; raise be: Iflafifi 113 an iz1%':.e1*esti11g
article by Pam} P.(';'raig,. Q.(l1ti1€<1 'Judiciai
Review; Appeai arwé Facsmai Error' pubii$11ed in
'2{}{}4'¥ Pufiaiic Law; 53,788."

:2 I. 51:; pm” 1.11’€;, whiiflz is Eaimiing autharity
uzidssr !m:.i<:Ie I41 :11" _} of C311 this
grmmd iiseif i.E1€__o:'d<2rAA01?:f:QnL;fi:V:;§,'s<'$f§;%' §;ééi7i§%:rz:€I1i. is Bahia to

be q11s{;4;–}1e£_1,' V

S2;26 'ififgfééi . §'i§:«;:s._r€7_ :fc1 '..'L's;3:"€§e1' for retizxstatemezié: 0f the

~ , "&g);:;_€~;'§ia:f3i:' fa:-_i_:i'i'.§1j;§i.v backwagm; for 1131:: re:.a$ia:i<m ef r€gu£ati.o:1s 311$

.:'1jir:3s= a1'1§i"%,Ejséf1:iesiSi_o13s 0%" Suprexne ($01.11*: and made the

'.vag);}ai§a.1§%;,A Zaigai his famfly mambers ta fiufibr as he Cauld mat

{§b:=:V a5'fb§;€ fies givfi €{iH€3§E}Tj{}1'1§ iiveiiizood arid basic flfifiiiéi :0 his

.___'""'<:%?i'5§E<E:'61': ii}? a §3€1"i{§(i sf '? jaéars, 'W iich rmzgi h3'i%'€': aeziverga

~ 35 szzgxa IEGES E E

\\¢\/

31

‘E’l’2{:z’e:%2;m, ‘fiéfififi feet} ?:}’2a;t. $1: is .3 fit. case fan’ dijz*::3.<:i3:»i.1':'g (hi:

:':=:s;j}<:m.if3’i:§,-{“‘

filéipifi}-781’ ‘i3aI1_i< is pay {$16 back: W_8AgfifS43S §5éf;"'t1i'iv€3 (.i'5é_:§,si:’f ”

{ha S1,1pre2’z:t1@ Ceufi: in Reap
wherein it. was held that 1_’}’:.>f;iu:E’§%l’IS%,3f%§.E1.(fif31fl.:L£}:_££5}::-~II¥{3€31″I’¥7’§”}}’%}}
fuii back Wages is j;:siif1€;1_…;»?if3E*§§1′;;_._»L}1&.his:ifilisfiiissad fmm
service E¥i’£.I1()E_}.E1 “;3*1’°(}«:)€1: z%.:i:q.§’;:E:”§; .4 “‘é§t ‘1’~€::;t1irefi under the
801151110: 85 E;)is;:_ip.i§i1€ };~3i’:’;1’E§-$1.’: V V’ .

:_.E?’::’;3:’*.§r}I’*§g_:)_ii1g_ r3’a7£i€;a:21’V1;~;,”‘fhe appea}: filed by the

éi’f.p}T3€fl£IF;”{E'{ §_ié’:3I%;;:v¢§§. t@. 3iEe:¥§§<::3¢ Eiaazzca, we paw the
f23i10wi:1§'Qr5c§;€::":' " L'
TQRDER

{.1}? "§7§1€é wriz fiiipézai is. aiiawfié. Thg-tr §;;;'3.':{;1'a.1§E'3.€::;i 5311,3231'

I 'fi&$S€(§ by $13 Eearrissci Single sjucigfi in

W.?';<;NO,,.'_" ':T:%E35$9j2{}{}3 is 867$', aside" 'file wrii: peiitisn is

: '3iEo'§fy*€§§';'–* : 'E"i'1€: Grdfir daitfid 2%. }£3.2{}£}2 bearing

. K§A§iag$fianug’iég=21″*%.22g fie. €f:{L3€_Zf/ Sissfhizj C%1z§b3I”giJ Efiazziiafiej §£i1’z3b3raf :3}

réiigfiiéfl 519:2 3

352
(}2–()3 passed by the Respendem No. 3. produced-33 & F
respeetiveiy to the Writ petition are quashed;f’Iff£e:::res§ei1defi§s are

directed to reinstate the appeilanif, i11t_(3 Asjefqiee.’ with ibaclé zmges

with interest at 6% per benefits
within four weeks fiom the I order. However,
liberty is gven to the te redo the inquiry de-

novo striefly in of Service Ruies
Reglflation-5§§ are so advised.

Heroor is fixed at Rs.2,5U{)/-

payable     Lqal Services Committee, Circtxit
\V 36391555 G"Jba';g3 ° "   

Sd/-en
Judge

Sd/-»
Judge