Nanjappa vs Doddaiah on 31 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court

Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda

2?: mg §~éZ§%-§ mugs: Q?' 2a;s;j:éJ    

7 §.EG%§§.A%; agaasza A§?E§a%;§'~§§w$3$'é;2§'$§
_c,;w    
ggsuagg S§C§f%:fB~~.$§?_E;%Lé*é§_.$3§;'2@§2

$E'¥"if\!EETﬁ§:

gs": ikiarzjappa,     . U 
mad about 64€ye;~2§'rs;""'"'«.._ >   
S/a $:i. Gorsagja,     «-
ﬂies? §<er2k<~a:'é'T"£-i§§'éri1Qe;"fl:  
Gaﬁdasi E~§.;ob§i_,.    v '
ﬁwa$E§<ere Taiakg ' _ V
Hassan §§st:*£:;?z. . ' _  '

  ﬁasaééaﬁi gamma"? §§'§ §c3%.%:

{By 524,; 31;, _§$'!.,a*+§'%.V Sfgaﬁziééar  é;d%z,;}

1;" =.§%é..;- §;<:;§i§;é.;&a§éV;J--V:%--?~'
§:§$5§*a§@u€Lj--§§= yaasﬁg
S;*':*::--..4;§§'é§_.E~5§§.E'§%%<E<aéa%': §§3%%'§§§'E%"§§;

"   ' 2,} ' ~.;%§*§, %2;§é;§g ﬁmmag
 ' gﬁégvtaégﬁsai #2 years;
 " f§%%',5;;€_fE3§"§$ §$§§:a§¢3,

  _;é§§%;e rsameﬂ %"é§§§fE§e§"E§§ E 333$ 2 35%
 "ﬁ:g§:*§ag§£a:r§s€s, r/at Kaaéezé viiéggef
*~.§€§5a:':éas: é-éehéi, ﬁrasékera T§§%.3§§, §'§§§TS8?'§ Qésiréai.

 Reggeaﬁaﬁﬁg §:2 Rﬁé ?§§$$3ég'2§§;?;



ﬁne Eraiah, 563:; Q? Semi Eraéaim, was me a*$;§*:e§f*":?:.;€

Earsd measuring 3, a-tra 3§ gizrstag Ea 

Kenkere Véiiage, $3:/mas; %~§§§§E, ﬁeragékere  K

exemted a ﬁeed ef gettégmani §:§'"?.'§;§.:§%.?';§  

gefiiéng the saéé §m§e§"%:3r and aifféer  §r;a¥';:.';éAr§:%.e£gV 

faxseagr 3? size §m€.€~§§§2§amma é%;;5§"'~€;f?:§%<i:<aws:;::a... V§9?§:%V'§%'é'%¥§f%é
and we Era Chikkaiah; S§f'i ;§§ Sgrm' §§fa*3c V%%-§L§;<§:a§a:%é'."-$za:'§ Em
Séeikkasah 3:36 ma wifg fS':%:%;'E§3a%5f:§'%§a}  §¥s§§&£

sway %&av§r2§ §b:&?s'E:I;jd ;;§§§é:*r:~,;  ":":'s§«%éV'1e:* éaasgﬁtﬁr

ééum.Ra::§§amr:9éa;f. F§f7h;étté;r _3ﬁpvéééétée:2 cf 2% saga; %% ég

rsescassary  ':':st%ce; '*:fé;*sw:§'*§és':aa%$g§ca§ trae 6;' Eéée saéﬁ

partiaﬁ, which §§ as fwews: 

"  .... ﬁgéﬂﬂggw
E

 2239:: $553223 ~~  Emixh

 .  .°%':ss::::%"§:faié§: E1§*3{f§:§§§.i;a§§§;
{Sakai}  Ea:-,::é"; iﬁesé}

{,";Eai§<é<3.:"2_m :f"te:r;ag5;;;a Em €f§:§.§+:§;;aé:§§§
 Eiéiméaia {ﬁggé} ggﬁgg
:'f§}$a{%'}
E E E
E E E
ﬁéngamﬁéa  ﬁmzszisagamma
i 3935'; éfﬁgazﬁé
s 

3 ' ' E iémsgazxzgm

{ E 3 ::§}ef'§:«2 :3 €7.33. §§i2§§€§'i§§

£;.a£<_E<amma: 'fkngamma E<%:a;r:=s:::a





Smtﬁééngamma, wife 3? C§"'$§§€§(§?'%%"§a @ Hittaiaﬁ, far 

am an behaéé' 9? we saéd §3;$ 55%-33;3:*::£:j: js::?:§w§.§§ifA'f;Z§xf*§§é:25§;'4 (£§§§ﬂ"%§é

to ﬁe   :}§' -- §5!d:dfa%a%: {Egg éefertéarsi

in bath %;%;:Ae~; Js'a.§§%s)  §a§e ﬂew éataﬁ
2?5:i,1§¥.:?ﬁ1{E§$é;;'$§2XE'.~.'."E%é%sV?i; s$:°2 3? §§wé§:3§amva§a Em
I-ﬁﬁh§.§<;Ai§a'%--;§%~;!i.,§g2§%'aj§.a1'¥;1_3;'}. ' é;;f:'é---.f<"%r

§erpet:.:a% énjunctéers against the df_e??3€f§:;§a~~:3»€s. 

3. Accsrééng ts the 1% ;}i3'V'e:;.i1':"e'e§9*ié_a.;?fé'*%;,9.';3?t»f_' '.fe$p<:22%é@:'§%§

Ningamma, was :aE<i_:}§;-- cake 1ef..'m%r:.e7Ef* '.§<~u§%_}_,VV§'%aa§amma am

she had c:;.«;':*s.:@:=5.:{ie'::¥ 't?*§'i;-::.;,*:«ro"«;:Ve:<'§*;'§?§'"fa*s:'§:s;* sf Eraégh, 2&3'? 9?
Gewdanné':}asz§ra E?é2fj'vi:Z%:1¥£%:vie%;7aé§%*;,L__' gases" iéze gaée éeeé éaieﬁ

SBJQ56 {Exf}§s§;V}..ag§é__%5%:§' :2.;é;L?s*ﬁe is {sat in xziﬁaiéasz ﬁf my

v4.~;mfavisv%»a;-Ezsv55%aw;'*~-_g%££e:"é§s"3§ is ézim, iéseye ég ms»-

 'a:€§s:;§'ipt§am:_ 1&5-:§«?e _jS3r.§\3$. in §}{,32, iéze saie éeeﬁ éaieﬁ

 V 2'?.,'.2--.iLi;.§17:3}',' é:;¢e'¢:é3§ed by Eraéah sag: 5% §aa%:ﬁa§2:3§?':a::ara

 Vgjfra €%3:4§'i<i§af'% a; %i,," V£z*: favew sf éiém, §?'§$ié§§"% ma ﬁwaéaféeg

.VV:V'-éérgaégseé 25$ samag Aasﬁgﬁéﬁg :5 Wm; the §"£%§S*§§$£§'%§?§§§%

 '.§;%g_aév.é4é€T£§f§e§ Er: the m§.stai§§:°'2 at Exﬁé. 3% gag 'féieé
 T 431 \a°~..':1~£i?'@
 ggﬁgai 19$?-98 agamst Sm%.Ra§:§§mma §:: ﬁg iiezsfi $5'

_ '=_ '€%':& Agségtant Qgmmigsééréar, §L§"':§§§$%"%§§§"%§ iaa gmgiatéais
 (Q c,.».»-w..d*....1 vhpﬂe c-#6' i
//,_

A.x--.\~:'.=*a-«am

""-*'5"7'3*?-"""*---~

}"~SXf**a» }-kuﬁigiz. z9rmrv<.,"3*_



entry affsgcteﬁ in f§'sfQi.é§' sf Rangamma ﬂy 

3,«':§9s~99 éateéé 2s.:,3.§9;?, yééhichjégais ai1sc'a%;%~i.{%;iA%k;A?:;%:;?'%'?'%'%%:  

Asaistant Commissianer $5": 3.12g2aaé3_.  . 3 A

4. Eeth we suéfs were   V$a's--";}f%:'z's::é'.: 
was mssrﬁed; wﬁergén PE{%..f$.i«.<'t"é Vafé':s§A  :3 §
aemseci and Exam :9 :3. 'a5§*:_5é fé':Eé 3;T3§1:'§§%§§:f§%e§'_V_%?:a:"%<:seé am
a aemmem juégmvaﬁf $33  52% 523%. 'fﬁé
maﬁa mama €53?   is mat, me pmgseriy
wéaécéz was:.~--~--c%?%$"§;§F2'e$*§:.;i:.:2£'%:*-- %%é'e' "'$&%%§eme:':€: §$e§ ﬁataﬁ
?.5§:§6$:V{1v§x;?'i:Z'f§;'%.é§%{$-$1sﬁééﬁ:§§V.$%:~::,é§§nfamma, fgr §2erse%f

aﬁd 33 §:;a§§V5'ia.sjf§M :2? %n§%é<;.;"ﬁ.és%2§3mma, 5:: favaar 3% Efaéaéa

 gm.3;;%i%%:%gm i§.'%{e"~'sa_§;e:.«s%eed éatgﬁ 5.92355 {gxmgg

éés_%2§e§f:?'--»xex§fa=;'3v_i:.0i:.. é§*sa§£a§*:gad 323$ wcame ﬁrsai ané %a§:%§e

 S:24§1't;--"§f§i.;:;i§Ié%%é§V¥§r%'%::«., Eéiﬁgamma 3:253 Rsggamma, ﬁaé ma

 Vgaéaabééé' %g:*§1.: a~'=,:;'é§s5§ 2% aﬁszvey {E29 wit §§"§§&?'E§{ Er; faaéazg? gf

 f§§as§.:;§:§§1§'°§§":ée;" me saée éaaég 532% 22'§efa,:§§§ 352$

 ;'.1'%.;'.i2; 3..§§'5:"? {Exam am 92}, Wﬁéie arziyéag a: 2% gaéé

T *c§;%§%§¢éé2s§asrs, it wag aésa ézeéﬁ tﬁaa S§'§:%..?;a§:§a:?2ma ?"§§%.:-"§§'3§

 get cééaéieragaé {ha 53% iraﬁsagiéaﬁ w§%:%*2§z2 3 %*'§§?"§ §?'§§"?'3 éﬁza



gate sf she attainiﬁg majaréty, we 322%: ﬁg aisar éa%;':f§3%%'§--~ .:ij*;.f:a;_V': 

garésﬁ cf §§§1;"%%iia'{EG§'?.

S. ﬁxgaénét the éecreea gasgeé Esség  *;.§_;7e '%"2"§§E.,%%i;£%:§:"é'

the gaéé sasits, the p§a§sz::f§ f§':'s:a; R3§.,:2a2?£z;%:g:}@?';:§V""i"agak
E.A.23;'2§%32, wbéch hasgérzgx begzs"i§€L_£--§%a§L. %$§é§%:¢.r,V§were
ﬁismiﬁseﬁ by iiwe f§:*s%  a3f§3f;:€%'§3%$' :' asrrzman
ﬁadgmént am ga;3§i*§te "éxT;f¥%'.8,2.$%2, $3!

reteréiﬂg tizag"cég*:_§;i§-rfgrét-:_j;*§§}éi§f:g   §mt,Ra::gamma

(defen$iaz3%;**§'%i'é.é §L§é' §;I$v;.88,?.2'§V5Gi¥};'--~%2.aa§ :29 vaﬁé tétée $3": i:%*:e
preseriy  1a: s  __§*;hEch she azecuteé ?§"'§§

registered sa:V§e.4_'§ae§ .%:4éAA§§a'l:%;é.-{sf as? me géaiﬁiéff, amga Em?"

_;f%g%2t, gtijfzéé am %?é§&_?Té$% ﬁg téte 53%: grweriy ms airéaﬁg

'be;e1::V.s§::%_§é:. f:":-:%a%@.;;r cf Eraéaié, gar: §? ﬁawéaﬁmaﬁavaga gm

C§:L'§"E«::5<3i'§_a:%§ié  §3;}""%%:?:§ $5": $353, ma? 33%-é iééa §§?"{:§$§'€'g' ?§

 %.':_§'%$ §ei%aam%a{§:::<:"'%:;: $,$.§?;':s§§% {Em $2 & $3}, sieeéggzasif

 f" éasg:_.%if§:f%§.%;§§"§%2%§'§§§;, iéwga sgamé §§§§§§$ ésaagﬁ aeeié

 .

é, A 3% Ravésiimaééar, ieargeaﬁ aeasmgé fa? ééwa

huaiggeiiarzi Eféﬁiéié €§§§t&?’é§;

3%)

:2 giaiasf wééazé a yysémg”

Adméiteéiy, Pééggamrgza was mi %%§e§~«~=::.a£_%;:s’:f§§5.j’

gasgrééarz 5? the §”?’%§§%@§’ :1′-?;a§2§a:+§**:%’§*aa%,._.§.i_”§;g§%–;.fs%:_% 3

mszéﬁ arziy ﬁe 3 ﬁexfaizazhig§;%:§*§i;a’§*%__3?§:£ _i$~,.g.,

aha Ac’: s*ega,s§3f:§§ iéféa a£ :é’€;;3’$V. af Eﬁ?’%é,.§fé’a’§:.s?é}§ ”

§%§§f§i§§’°E sass $3?’ :’$5§§é;2:?é:fs§:*2’g %?2é’A”‘5.%a1a§V§2″g§$f
m§§:$:”§ §§’§§&;”::’;«%*.__E$ ‘V

§a£t%§§’: :2 ﬁaéf.-.2- %§§€ ‘\:§V§az§. 3§§¥ _’§.;msa:g:* as a
‘égiiééﬁiéi

§e?%?z*2i_~.:’$%;é%%”§§, t”%°;i§_C%:&u..:.§:;¢i: “am V ﬁr; $33? §:2=a;§§§§%§

:%:a.:; é*ss;’§..__§a%a§2*;§%Epé§%.___:3%*2.a§§ ﬁe aggééﬁiaé E? 3%

‘?”:7.’%_§§;§{.”3§”$’ iE§%’3§’§”¥§~2§é{‘§._§?§%E§’%S§ Er: ém gm: fgmééy is

‘ V 3:? t§§é’-»?§§i:§§§$ éf azééuii memwr sf %%%§ §%§”f’§§§}”‘w

5:33 azz

T’ ~..V:§v::;V{§éaé§’§eE§ mares: Ea iéze Eﬁiﬁi fsmiiy gag Zi’>£§””i%§§

__’§§”:’§ §*?’1$§”§3§&§”‘ﬁ$§E”$ éa wééé’: ﬂag aﬁéazéi: %”‘?’%§§?’E§§§” sf

»:§ée faméég, 33$ gasasﬁéagz gﬁaéé 325$ %§§§%§’E§$§ far

33% §?E’§?3§§” 93%??? ?”%$§$€§ is %Eef:’ H

§s”@§ar’:3z §%§§¥?§§§”§§ ta hasj-T§f5¥%%*:*e%.”,’ Véizé’.

Saw S§..§§”‘¥§%:’EE’§§ memhe? é%*;*%§é:ég:_

ﬁance, me iégfrztf ééiie-.§§’~::j§» éniiéswgi..§f%év§§”%§%”‘*%;%:é

mérwr, cmséé gm}: §%a§:V&’*§:§e;§a%%”~-»;eséasé*ge§ Em

seif gtyéed g§’zéa; :”é§’a2s2.:’I’» SmL§%,?2%%§é’§;§?¥:m&, £3

ad§'{:§tfi€{é§%*;,a%%;é%:’2-iaiéars $1? §;a§§§%s’*ﬁ:”:’1a’$ :”§§%%?; as ﬁéégzgamma

z -ﬁg a§«§§§é:§a xméﬁj, whéaﬁ ﬁg aéaa s:§§§§ﬁ&§ ﬁg: ﬁg

raiéﬁ if}? éaw ﬁaﬂiaréai Es: §§’§§ saga’; §%i,
?v%A§%~%§$§%%’*5§A {§§ﬁ:$} 8′? §MRS,,, 33$.

&?é§A%s«V__a$’s2_§é:’ £s:::«.

the sa§e of ma §rcV§eé§§§;, wéfémggt–..§§§:é’§’–§f§é%”§%’2§
the bar cerata§ne;§ ur3:éé’s*–..5$_;@c €’§-~33: 13$?’-.t%*=é 5392:,

whim sgecéficaﬁé _T_*.:%a’£*s, –gi..§a2*é%ar; ‘ac:

éeaé k.«5;Ei.%§ 2.21:9 g”;-_Eé*0;§’e’§”;fy .;§f’~?:’§%e :’%:§’:rs:t,§::

$§:<:f'éE"s*.;£~j,rg__. tf{gEe»'.§c;t ééaé we amﬁéaaiéaa ta '§§°§§

f;=;;::¥t15_ §'§v._ié7:-é<éa—3é;.«"é%s%':Ec%: ézag éaéa '%ﬁ§?$§'é§§'§

};3§§:%"§§.é" azié éaévisase Séegaéigz §§C§§&é $3? 725%

% *T"£eé2;r%;_s %'.%§§é§%é';

VL “§:’éa§ am 2% figs: §%§§&§§§%$ C@%.i:”‘i$

v_.§;~§é$§ V.§r§ve§y a§**:eé ii? §°§Q§ﬁ§E’$§ Eﬁéig the

” v.V__{:-yéregéstéreé mésggatii éaieﬁ §.§.:§§§ E3 mg: as

aérséésaébié géece $2; ezééﬁeséaa. ‘fﬁe £a:.z:’%§ §5eE§%%s
aasgéﬁ ta haw féﬁﬁgﬁiﬁﬁﬁ ééﬁ 8;’§?~:§$ e{£}<§§}
i,§?'§§§?' whéah Rafégamma segaraéseigz %£§i.£§%"é§

fa? gamma a? iaaﬁ %§*2 S'g.%é§«Z§§,f3 am 3%

/T.

aafgaeﬁaééara sf ?”E”%é5i%’T§§§§% @525}? ﬁg: 3:39

i;’§?;”:m§s5§cner 3&2? éiﬁa giasgréy wag ‘§;:§ﬁ%'{éf§*éé 3

is? favsw’ 9? we §§&§::€Véi’§;”l:::2a,2§’:«”§’

e}r:€%n§i§§£%’:eé ha: 233% ﬁe:é:§:»é’;.V_A.pre§$.;ff%:*g%.”

paiasipatti s:3§§=;t ‘éﬁ Vhz;%.§.’§3e’v–%,§eé§2*3%§z::w%é;§ %§u §a

marked tantaiizsgéy &$*”3s€ _§$V%%”§.%;_E: §%: §”€s7éi7:;.’§ée§

iﬁe maize? ai izhé %é__;*2’§§ aa §’i%§§§ 5:’:

me ca$&; :¢f,,_ a§:é’:§§ $:§3;La%§’*%§§;;3f;:;;f:%V§égégsgmg $5.

5″;”g?a;=%w,a;:i$:’§’§ :$%a§%é§:?;»;£;2 {gag gas:

vS_€: ::..§é} :’I;,;’: A’

IX} :’:’3§.s§’é agaéﬁgfz am ﬁﬁﬁéﬁﬁfi

c§’a5′:c§:r::é,::§V’ éziry, as sﬁaiﬁ $2′: $38 ‘£8$€

¢§%A.3Aa5A’%’§;%:éVV::s§ 3593?? €ﬁ€*»’§M§SS.°£G?s§E”‘t%i’$1:f£

the gaia made in faveur ef .E.ra;§a%°2 _–a%%”§;:§:,,iV§~§6§.V u

is mt swssaé to §aw am?-1′ %ze;*::s§,. a¥T§.’:2a§:§’§z’:§}é§’

germésséars $2′ the Sfnéi’ ;s§%*aI=§:

grogeriy, wag ;gnnacas%§:a§’;*§_._ ” 2 vv
ii} were is 0:33;: é”‘~:;i;sa::£Vgs;é’§§%:’%–$’§% :éf._:he gsmmrzgr
Er; merz?;§a:§ér£§ ‘Lin {ﬁe saée
ﬁeeéé executed hy
_ __E;fa1i:a.§f2 ‘- :__ though the
:?_ beaﬁﬁféaéii’a’z.=;;?~;~:.§§2}..__i§*cé same and the ééeretéty
baiéag me weaarty avaééaﬁe
far Vxén é§y.u!%Es.256;’4 fer bemg ezmveyaé
r§f:’%’§.descr§pt%an has men rezztiﬁeé 5::

{E25} facta §f3§ céyaumsiaﬁcas at? %he sage, éi is;
z “”éect§@:§ 3.2 9? téze Act wﬁéch is ag§%§cabé&,,. whisk
ﬁgeraies as’: itg em”: and the pravisiisras

aerstaineé in Sectiasrza 3 am 13 $2′ the gist, ﬁé

mat gut any fetters an Sectéar; 12 oitize Aai,

IV)

‘£8

The undivided éniafest in 3 fcégzt f»3:’3f%::§’é’§% -V._
property can be soéd by téza far;*s£iy__A–*:% e¥éff?15.§{é~:fT’
and that, Sectien 12 s;a§5es_th§3″”a’%%é%’§3§§’e%§_’sV

maﬁa by ‘aha member sfv’-al 3?r’.:§;’%::A.’é%.? §é’:°§_ié§:e,:j:”cr:Véiéé-e ‘*?1.J_’

Kartha as the case m5Va1’$=~.V§;e, _ V ‘

Tha first ﬁ~.p_pe§¥ate__;’_L ‘i;¥;§%é”‘~r%’$§bé:€,§\;’e.

En szievgnf the.~V’cs;Q.;f9é.}§§¥ée;*ai:Eeg’s am c9’r2$eq:.§e::t§yf the semné

z Qégﬁeaé is net maé:3ta§§*:a:h%e.

” -22%;}

{1}

Stmgzg reiéance was géaceé 9:: %:he decégiaeég, in
fine aase sf;

Qﬁsféﬁﬁll RAG ANS ARQTHER 35$;

Ci~%AN¥é&PP.?-‘a 8: GTHERS {mi {:3 K2,:

33?);

{2} KAMALAMMA VS. RAMABHASRA Gi§?”§”ﬁ.

(ILR 1988 KAR 20);

{3} SRE NARQYAN EAL ANQ QTE~§ER§ ‘:53.

SRIQHAR smaa Am emeas ma :7;-2g5_

SC 23%) and

(4) SANNAMMA AN? DTHERS VS.

ANS G?-§ERS (ELK 260? KRR 3641′)”

in supacrt cat’ the can$er:t%<sn.s aéad ' afiz';-"é.c.;» ?.%€g.

findingsjczamciusiens sf the Caurts beiiowi,' j; *

8. Having haard the §earrze7r;?..__:ce1;:i”s;a§ e:’sV l_s%§i§sH V

part and after gerugérsg the re<ca:;é=!ef f She iaiigggégaijs, Véfr: my
minim, the si2%$§a:ztEa§ . _5'qf?2 e3-§§§::_:'s "e:'«._f %"a:e~g, raéseﬁ $3

3§.1,2§O3é'V at §§%1x.'=z% f€§:';':§4 {3f 8»fi'rn§$$–§@§'s; required re-§:'ar:"2%§*s§
ané §*:erace,'ézj: a:<:as';.§s ae.:.Ljsf§'a:..§f§S:i§'C:%en veateé iéﬁﬁﬁ? Seﬁimz

103(5) :96, v%'7a7s,_:V?e:«fé*ar4:ie€"'.is:°: zmgaag. Tim feééﬁwigzg

ﬁfe ;"e'+v§?ifa:*:?§'£3d ':*2.;zbs'£a %é£Eé'i& quesiiena sf §a%.«%§;

. {?,§- ::jja%§;;é§;:e:§ age saie déeﬁ gazeaas 53.2955 {$252,}

" .s§céCufe§ Sm: ﬁfﬁgammag fer fserggf am' aésa as

V £§'<.~*;{ "~-Vﬁéégaaéa §#:.2.arr'a'§a;: 35:: mks}? $5 §'??§f?ﬁf

: n §<é;;%;*;'§'<:a:'§§a!§?;?3a, 33 V655 as fﬁffiﬁ, fa éiéw exéexé sf

V. rfgéi §i?§ frgiferesf af mfmz' Ki.§a'?'$,§§§?§3§?'l?fﬁ§, es?

acfccszsizf 92' She $3!' ﬁnder Seezian £3 gf €'??8 é~§§;m?;3
5-ffnarffy sad §fssasm'ia:33:":§§ get, $55? g

{ii} Wﬁethér, the éefenﬁanfsﬂreaganﬁeﬁég
acquired wider 328 safe §’£.?$a’S, Exs,§2 asiéa’ §.’.:?1,,~.:.ég§§’;2§_’- ”

rigézt, {Safe am’ iszteresf, was $5; :’es;9e$i”-. _:?&f, §f§?¥e-3″ S

groperéy cf ruins: K:2m.Rangam;:3;a.? ‘

9. Leameﬁ Cazmsei an §::i:%: %:?:ef’«.s%§es, mésé:fjs;:’%*zz2’a§£–4 ‘

at Eength, witb yeference ‘£3 t%’2’éL’L.V_%**e–2’:°ar#s?3fé:_§_”‘;*~2a%’§3s§§:’:i:§Va§
§i.E€$t§§E’§8 sf iaw.

1%. %<ee§%:*2g is _v§ew""re:§1:'§'* ;:;:»',_i'%"éle, iaéé am riazaé
E8§§t€?'%'€§&£"iS, t¥'1;8:~ﬁ€'3j%"§ﬁ:§§é€'£§§'+'}_f%'~§§"§&§– ms §f§'§éa:arm%na'€%sn,
reéafces taﬁief '£c:??€;i:é;f£-e{§*:c;ei""::Af""S§z*¥:.féiagammag m saéé iﬁe

r§§%'2%, tithe aé€é_4_§§:5té%'e.s:é.'§§' §§:§2é0r Raszgammat $5: 'ﬁsa gasii

_..~§;js§a:f§.§*, ms 3:{I§§%."£:§"'v§VfSr;___§"§§.'3E' gzsarﬁarg. if 233% Q%3eSi'§%{§ :3

z=ts.;fjss~.;2:$;%%sa:\e_cé¥.. affirmative am %t is ﬁeéﬁ iizai,

§r?§:',;§§é'E;%.:;a;%s§29%:'f§.. 'SEQ €§m§e§:&§:£e E»; aﬁeﬁaié we $%*:§:"§

9%? mE:3é":* §:R3;;§'{a"m§"€:a; as 32%;" gasaréiaag iﬁagzf mg "?%a% $§i§§"'?;

§é,:;éA't§§a;.A¥§%§§€ gégmaééaizg Qmssi, 'waya ﬁgézi agsé ﬁagsatéfiaég, Ea

~-%ér3§'5£~%;é»§§' %§%§: $29 %:§'a{§3aci%%§'*: E3? gaie ig éiaéégtg $3: §§f:z%:.,

'éévégamfﬁ-3 aszﬁ we gemayzs £§§§¥""€"§§§"":§ ?§?f:3E.%§§": émzsy,

§éSi.%§'§§EE§ £31 éégméagai 8% 32% Si3§§iS. ﬁg we gihar ézagigl, if éi

-:.”

.i§ mm tézatg Smt, ééiagamma ééaé gm £em§&i&:::$ ..§§._V_

aéienate téwe rigézt af miaer Raﬁgamms in 232% saslﬁ

then, tése gaie iraasattéaag we vam a;%3w*—%.%f2;§?;;§.:3V”~..}a};r°s_§

caasaqisesitéy, we immigrseé j§i§§:i?3″‘°E§§’§:§$;; .:v§u?’€§.: _§’a”‘%:’$”\§t§.§;, .: :,E

gassed $2; the Csasris beéaw, aregééafgie Eﬁﬁe 3

1:” Y9 be 3 3::éstayétsag”v«%§f§:~;’%$tE§§2″*§%’ §§é%S,. %s

amtemgiataai asnéér S,i%?L.”‘§.§§3C,§-‘_;:§*:$.{g;;.v,:~:%A§§zf:Eéaai aségea Er:
3 case ag ﬁeiween Ajthe §aA§ff:%.§’$_;«,§§”9é.}c>::§§§’°’?:§%;%.:¥i a’§’: émmct £9?

effeat éf $;:astia§*:__”§§§’;%Ta=;§.¥s; %:%}£: §$’fr:§.§§1ieV.%35″§§’:~§:§°’sa E3 éaiwﬁezz
am gaftéé:-.:;_. ‘ A wﬁéaf: Eséaééaniaéiy é?’

c§i§§t&:*a%§%;; %Vi’£:fsg§:2§ $3 i.:$’a:?§_%.??;’§ $2″: Em fmaé aaséagmg, wééé

gfgaéi baa.3-.,§§b:;:%an§ié’§”–+:’:=;:.2_§$€’§$%’% af éaw, if ::?*:a §§§%§$?Z§@?’% $5 Ema;

Vhgs ;}§§%E’s ..§s;e%::’§efé’*b*g & §${§S»§G?% §% 32% %=§$§2′?s%§ S::§§:*e?;¥%%

§§as§5%: §.s%’ a1f’§§§§”§;f?el:.::€, it €§§’%§”;§§’: ﬁg gsaéé ﬁéaig tése saga

§é”§”s:’§§¥&§ 3; ﬁsgfbééaniéai §::e§fs:%§:% Q? § éﬁ @333, aha gage 2-%;§’§§

ivaé-.;s:;..j$§’:$5§§e%§’a§ 33 géyiag §’§$§ 3% 3 §é§§§%§§’§%%§§ §i.§&§’i§§?§

:3? §§a5’%§;; fséséga, ééaaiésaé §i%%§§§§§”§ e? 33% wag ééaégaé ea§’E%§%:

“%¢%:§¢%:%.%%ea;er,. if 32% %r§a§,:*’§”§§*$i a§§e§%a’z& Cami? Eéave mi: mséiaeﬁ

Efaa %”$§%’%§§§’§i §§3’§i§i%?”§? §;”w§§§§;*;§ ﬁg-gﬁaaﬁée is éézg maiégz

§.§

3:” the §§§’§§§f’§§ §§£%S%$E”§ as? iééa %~£=3:%’§§§ Sasﬁreme

ﬁzis Cﬁiéfi 9:’ mégirgiarpreteﬁ 9;” mésawééaé the ﬁ€;:%:%;%a5é:*:””;é.£§§~e:”§ _

the aarract a§§§%<:at§$;: 6? 33%;, as §ec§a;{;e§§, %é§€}€£§'{§'':§.}'?f&%f'é'::E§Ei'§§ '4

ta a ééffemssi desiséan, ééée aﬁgeaé, rézjseﬁi'a"T?.$:sb'§%a§*;%%L3_§

QL§&S§§OE'¥ sf Eaw; éesmte the %aw'éa.r§%er§:2ﬁi%n§ bé5&5'§'§3.':Si'E'*;f§$§$?:'1§ V

by biﬁééng preceéent. "me 3;z7d§é§%_{e ':*z%§}§'*:ax:%

géxserz raise is the 3f$:"eme_:2?§E*§§:::;§§ ;v:;§b?'$.i'&..;é?£f§a_§ €§i§&St§$%"§$ sf

iaw. '
12, T$'{;–":"::?:§f';éser"'?£§%&; gzgbrgéantéaV§w:;é5es€é§:%s af iaw, 3:3

$1? Em A£§"$§r'e;§§i$ §§'§§VrA§:'cé:.§¢%%?:._§%;'§%_§3 tamer §°e§e%;a:'si ﬁ§*§%;%§§@:*:s
af 3% Ad; 5§é4–:;é;::.::é%${d §§?b':§3'i¢%~*1 §§§5§5E ﬁﬁiiﬁﬁé'

:__?;§:%VVS§V{§–'§.:§;f if%*;e ﬁéai, me amfesgéafz '"'§%..;a:*é§§:':"'

%':% {Z§«$§¢§'f'%_f8§ ig $"'E'Eé§§%; $2 gergan §"'é§"¥§?%§ 3% aara $3'

$:;é:%é*sesn $5 3 mégar %E" 9? M2 gmgarigf $5 a?

'"'§§%t§§"'§ héa garsim am §§"§§&§"§;§f 33$ énﬁaséesg

{%} g géaiasfai gisarééan;

{ii} a gaiardéars agggmiaﬁ $32 tﬁe aafééé £3?

tize rr;§§*;@:”§ fame? ﬁr mgiééér;

A’vgei’% % ag

{iii} 3 guardéas awaéaieé 9;’ éeciareﬁf ms
cassrt; am

(iv) 3 peman amgcwémé tcz 55%: &s

as?’ i,é§’i§&§” am: aﬁactmesﬁ :*€=:§:é’€:§&§2.:§ “:e”A ”

any war: 9? warcérg –

3;’: Gauge {(2}, tﬁe term “‘14%:’:a’§’é;%”‘:::5§ g§%;s–a;V s*a§.Eg2°§””

éeﬁﬁeé ta mews; –.;3?%*:§g sf” .f:%2v?;VV’v§::’a_;”e’f’§;*§za’¥é
ment%$:%eﬁ §:*:_,.55.€. §%”:$is”§:§.r§vf:.%’§s;A..’E%*:aa:e

been made :*e:7§a:%§-§:*:g;_ f5::{a’%.a%a:é*a§_.§é..;:a:*é§a:2s 3% a

§-§§ré’§’§;T. V_r*a_%A:’sVAiz;;” §;’E *~?’_é£I§§f?E 9? m§:’2a;”§ §§§’*s$r: ES

_§’;*:..L;’r:san;isi§§*£%’sf ﬂea mérzafs ﬁrwaﬁy.

« . £:”;c;’§u€§:.=’=;_?z%a§§”;’.,«3, ihéiggwer @? na%u§’a§ §i.§&§”§%§{‘§ ts:

;,f”3§§é?}&i$”‘§tZ?§é §§’§§&?””£¥ g? a ména? fs? ‘se*%’§”§§€§”§

“‘;<}_:*<;-¥?%§§éj;%% izag §ee:': maﬁa iéféﬁﬁf 38 Ea a§s$

:"é§'é§;.=:ir'Vé§ 2% ha Eéiaﬁi if? zféessam

__§;'?$§§b-=S§c%éas=2 {1} ﬁf $5 ammwarg 3 ?E§%'ii?§§

§a.sa%'°§§3§'§ as? 5 ééigsézs méaef, sagﬁgézi 3% ﬁg
$E"$¥E$§$§*'§§ ea? mg $e«:€%§:1,, :5 ésa 3%; aﬁig vgézécgﬁ
are Eéecagsafg gr §"ea§s:§%§§§$ aﬁé wage? §a? iéée

bésieféi 3?" i§"':% mémg g? fag' izézé %'*&§%%$§%§§§"§,

méner aria any aiéanation made thereunder, §e%rs§ against

me statutory previséon, wsuéd 5% veié ab énétée

aiienee, weuié act acquire any ‘we is Ehe §mpert=;?:;”

:5. in the case sf ‘§2&;§.ARE E£;;é;7?¢A«{s’;;p;a;ég;t_égasé?

been new as f0EEows:–«

As the iaw ata nﬁs afterfhe ce%z1§«n_g’ ‘misc: févvféé’ 9?
the Aci asnder nu r:E:f.£.t§§r1star2.:’xé*.s–.a?”-~é_e fa’ti:3..ge;;§§’dEar:
can transfer tha r%::’3–:;s’:tsr”s’A._ p::gs;l$e’:<i;'$gA 'i*;*:_;ere§';i an Eha
gmund of his tzeing ajﬁfe:»§:s'a§f§§~é;'§f:_, .. E? in fiééase

::§?cumsta:3;:es;§_V §efeé:§éa;:t_:'V.«:5 ~::ia§:;*%_§V§%i§ "%%:§*:':sa§;' is ﬁe a

da Zfiaczg §$g;VIaé'é,'3vaf'-.~*§,i_:fa7s<s a§§é:*saEeé the pregertéias $3? t%2e
mine?';;§§a%:::%§f.V_é%'§E§r»§§"%§'€:§'m%§3§ Emits farce sf ﬁe ﬁat;
the _i:*a:2éf<<&.§f{$l area. v;A<:_id"'35:z2d if that ﬁe sa, 2% qiéasiéeﬁ
§»5~iw§:_éthver xz'7§–§d___i§avnsact§ar:s zsszﬁé be raﬁféeé by 5
A_{§%§:"'t§j:"'s A«%'fe?:§'§elfz.';_v%":e attainvs majwéty. The effect at? the
.i2';é§':1#&§;ti#é%£3:'.?bairs§ sméd i$ ﬂzat an ﬁiie gassea £9
.' a_¥iée§%§:é assé tﬁa miawr" amitimzeg ta be the

ésééasisségf é? 33$ grﬁgarﬁv away: a€tar* sash %§"a:2a§es*,

' .. {E§ﬁ§?3$§§S gzsgpﬁéad $3! me}

3%, ' iﬁ iﬁé Cagé ﬁf §A?%§A'¥YA V3. Rﬁﬁﬁﬁeﬁﬁi, {2i,§9°?}

‘Sﬁﬂ 332}, E? has ham haw as f§§§a’w$:- K

__..f;;!Esw$:.~§_

S. A bare raaéirzg sf Sewer: E1 geas is ﬁémw
that it expiécitéy gﬁmviﬁes that aféer Eifsa

aemmamzemémt of téze saw Act 32¢ gefgaa shaVE§ §: e[._V

antitied ts déssesa sf 0:” éeaé with the §re§e5Vri:3$4’_A~é% {‘%’V;~

Hﬁndu miner mereiy as the greafsé sf av:*..Ti*;”é§’A

ﬁeéng the ﬁe facta guarciéass sf E§’§;€;,,??}§%%ﬁ?f; V

1?. %-iewever, Ss’§,A.£§. Shévaﬁaa,: ¥:*é’L:§«sE.._’-.:.’i§%zi§%*;:§’

that, E: E5 332,, which Ems app%§c’é§2§«–<;;: i§ 7;:§': é s:;asa': b:3j '§f%.a§§§§;j;
the same has been rightiy apgsﬁeé Cé§'§ts§_%§eE9§%; aﬁé
by apaiyéng the provisiené 't?zi:~;er1ei:_z:cEV§é:f; "%:V?%'§e.:a5§;f.3aa§ is dezzeéé

a? merit Vang' is iﬁsméssed. E-ﬁance; ii: ig
necessary €§"':=:f33a!E:e V3. ééaférégrzca is $.12, wﬁéch maﬁa as

2 ' Ggzsa=;}§*"ﬁi_a:3 net ta be apyesinted §ar misit§§*"$
' ' .§.:n&§§€§s;ie»¢i'*'E_:ji:erast it; iairat famify pragerty:-

a mémr has $5 unéésziéeﬁ iﬁieresi %§':

§éi:g.:V”‘%’§r%§i%’y amgeﬁy am the ﬁrﬁgeréy $3 amﬁe? iééé

V ” *:”§Ti§EE§§&?”§’3€§?e% sf an aéasét memims” gf ‘E?”§$ famﬁiyf gm

A’ ‘gzsérééaﬁ $é1a%% iss aarpsénteé Fm’ iéze mama? Er: resﬁeééz

K’

éf sud’: é3§%§§’sf§§&§ §%”%§§3–333$T_:a§;éé*§s*:E€§§§.,i’.

it ﬁg nezessary ts netice the a:eci$’§a;=:2:1.’.A%£§[ t%9sE__ <;~z§,;s:.r-:+

%'*~éAQ%~§EGQWDA, wbseraiﬁ, after Vésaﬁkéggg re_;fa's"§:::-:e""..§'aé"'ﬁxé
prcsvisiens cor§ta§::ed in 35.5, 6, 8,—-;'§ f1f' –aé%d'."§.,2 §'f'*=;%3.a..«§c':, it
has been heéd as foiiewsr-« ' A

18, Fmm ti1:e_='_V_p;v*ewx§é§'§<::ss stated

abo:§§§;VT§i avuwed objecf of
saviiig " ' astate being
misapﬁrgyriéfaé§:*.$;g:;i:anderad by any pemars,

by as :f;e!atuienV_Vﬁ?*' a ﬁrftiiy friend daimirag ta §e a
wkgilesarésvhar $f"""the miswr, Secﬁiare 3.1 was

' ; é:r:a;cti;ésﬁ;'< t.:5'o4 prshi-bit any such persm: from

. &.§.;§4:e:i?'a§9i:§a§'~i€;!':i§1:e gmperty 3% aka miner. Essay: E
;z"2&_;$§,.s?§':'g:LA§..§':~'*af:'éias': is fagaéraé is $&&§}~i germéagéazg 9?

_ the 'c{e_{§:*£ ﬁafam aéieﬁatészg any §as°'§ sf tibia egtate 9?
" ?t'%:"a: ﬁner and the ceam is ﬁﬁt is gram: sucﬁ
"I §ia'r7rrsEssi$r: to ma rzaturai guardian axcest in case sf
Eieaaasity es" fa: ars evééent advantage :9 the méﬁmz.
So far as a (ﬁe facto guardian at' 6% faata

manager Ea casxcemaé, the statszta has in nu

ancertain §&i’!’§’§$ gmiﬁﬁited may transfer as?

part of minarws astata by such a §%I’$€’3V§§’$_§:’,V E’¥§ –.

View af the dear statuitary massdate, .–%E§:e§ff€§ A ‘

ﬁttie scape fer doubt thatwany tra:+:–£i_’~aa»:1*” i¥’e_

viaiatiem af the pmhibitiefgt §»s;1j§:t:gr’pq§::§’a:’t¥I%’dVV«.i_}§¥V

Section 11. of the Acct is ab in?tE9 ﬁéid. . A ‘
(E?1*z;;)_L’?;-a_s§se és;3;V2__p§V%e .r;ten$:§é’n*A %jo1f %S::§.;a..e .’%§2«~;;«s..?a:«;:za

that, Smt. Néngamma arié” %n%§%<§r Ware

members of the:.3{2§§f;t:-.Hin.:ﬁugF§:n~;§¢§g;.:'V';;;¢V' iwiingamma

being €h'e,v'VVi{"a'V%t§';a{;5._vhé§fV"Vth:é'»$§'ght '€fi"'5tia§<e desiséam in iéée
irsieresi ef m§m% a?';aV::':'a:;_%'ga:*;§r3<:_:é;'». $:§"1:re§2g reiéanae wag gréaﬁeé

an Em (}¥;&§§$§G¥'ﬁi"§3f;VV %.*%*:.e*.'«t3':=;eV":;ié§f SEE. §%%;3«RA"~:'&?'§ $255.. {$§.£§?'3}

Es»§en'éé%:d:,_~£:ha%:{ in tEé"'i;;'r:asms%§nces 0'? the case, amviaus

§%a:'Vj:':*'*ei;$}:_$é'»:.'T=€"f§"'v«;::;'~;{25": %;%*:§' ;;ea;r?: under 3% far éiszgaséng Q? the

=.:mé§%;'§s.'.§ e3é Er}té%*eislt af minar Rayigamma, $2 §§?& _'§%§§'§§

–« . _f .,§§”€§§§§”€y”ijéié by rééngamma saw Raﬁgamma, was mi

.._:’é§_§,s§V;fe:§a*’;. It hag :9 be stateﬁ that, am Séﬁiﬁiﬁﬁ 3*: ihe saga

S isi§.F:%£RAYA%é EAL @235 been gwtiszgé am EES eﬁect arad

_ a9g§¥ica§§E§ty has baan sgzaiaé irz ihe aase Q? ?%.§%%E$$¥’*£’%A.

Caﬁgégaggntiyf St ig asmeceﬁgary £3 éeai wiﬁs the tﬁﬁieﬁiiﬁﬁ

\>»

3′; »

2′?

a§m’e«-c:.,eE§ed are beaés $2′ as sama string 3%’ zéeaé
be viewed $32 3 sérsgie giimase, s§mu§ta:*%$a:3s§3; “§~–::T

cerajzmctéam wiih each afézer, Each §:’m:§§%@’:’:,

§ar’:%c§3§a§’ Sectésn 8, same: bé vieweﬁ Er; %s¢E«2’$%_:§§7s’*;’~§.’j E€ ‘V’
reaé tcgether the intent ef the E€§§S§&?;Ei.?fé’=.f§?’%’ .§?%§_$

%enef§i_§r”«:>§e§*;:3f 9? a
i~%’%ndu minor, §%he:r*’?i.%_’*:&§2:*£’?ieA£;s::%é’%2.%§éedA§$:?;ez°”‘é5t Es:
jam: famﬁy preaafzigig $§_§§’§;:i £:?eé%1;f_i:A9,€??:;:;3V§a%ea? sgaséer
seamen 8, %2s:§”2_ereu:;;ée«s* _his–.§a§9@é§’*.; ‘§é;’§” dasiies are

§efi1::f%ed,_1Sé£§§§§i._§;.T§_Ca:f%.«*$s_*ass: 3:”: éX£é§§Z§%?% is iééé
mée %%;§%:.- $?%®§.i’§’:§’j_L’~€’;§_’é§2<';é"".i:::;é: gm aézsit mammr a? we

gm: faiémééy. Vm.__:'2'%_v3§'::»'a;§&§*ner:t $2' Em }§%§E*:% faméiy
§:_;{§§:&rty, E%':A-.._:é?%:§c§:: iéze :?:%r:cs:* has am ;§§:d§2.;éé%€§

_ §§';i:éEé$%t,"§&éwardvéééé may be agmégieé: but eréénariiy

' _§§'a.:;$;f%5'§a.:_f:"§ha1Ei be aggaénteé fer 33$'? :.§nﬁ§aéE§eé

".E€'§3£é§"é$§u–V :€3f 1=§¥$ mismz. '§'%*:e aduéi §'§"'%$:'"'¥"'E§%¥' 3% '€?%%

§$~rr;%%v-:§f 'Em "iha managerrzeﬁt Q? the Eaéaé: ﬁéaﬁa Eamiiy

AA gmtpva-§.~:9::'=;' may §e 3 maie er a famaéa, mt aecassaﬁy

_ iiézé Kartai "ﬁe wwar Q? the %-%%§§3 Cam': Gtﬁerwise is

égésaént a §:.:a§'§5%§;':, in S§€i§§'{§§I"E§ gzsstéfyéng, hag Mag:

'T gregeﬁzed. Thég §s tm Ee§%$%a%%*ase saﬁeme ﬁg': zéze

subjeat. ééaéer ﬁeztiers 8 3 natzggraé gagamiaﬁ a? 232%
§§"G§&§'°i'g" cs?' 'She ?"§§§§ﬁiE %"'f3§§'E£E€°, ﬁefﬁra EEQ éégmsaag §§

K',

any émmavaﬁe pfeperty 9f the mégmrj, mast s€%é’%zj

mrrrsissioés of the Csurt. Eat since éémye %:ee§_;:%é”‘;é”{;.T “~v.

namraé gaardiara far am §”§”%§§’%§§””§ zgndévéded %_:f::-erefs’%:v1’§’§:-% A ~

121% Eeint faméiy aragerty, as grmfféééé §§–$e:.:$e§%§.$§:.$

5 am :2 =3? iha ﬁﬁi, Eiée §§*e*si§s§§,ss §;3§&’g’§n%5’§«$§§§;”:.__’:s1§.x%f.%§é’ :J

Cwrt under ﬁeaiéeﬁ 3 fa? §%s§a§é;r_’;g7–.§§’ iﬁé’i§§’%ﬂ.§%.%§ﬁ%:§*.. ”

égzéemsi a? the mimr éza §§’é§*§§§rs% Afaméiy ;;.:*§§;%.£s*%;?;:. 35$
not Fﬁﬂiiiféﬁ. ‘§’%1e_§ia§::: ée 3
éegaé eazity ca9ab%e’:c;;fé§c¥:’§Véé§_ iézs %€$f:V!a ané
sther aﬁm: mem§ers45c’f_T_’:%:éL-fé'{§:%§*gf §=§?éf;*§f:é:§age;*:’se:’:i: Q?
the gsirzt Hiﬁﬁiz_farn:%A§§*”‘§%§g;%é:?Ef§;,_’ ..”¥”‘.’§’::§§?3§’V”‘$ect%e$§ 8 if?
view 3? §5e£~..~§§{§s 5 and :2,

wm:._§ d 2rs;?°2.e§;é a jam: §—§§n§:s famééy
§r$p7a.:f’t4yr.§s’ $§V§:’§«.”,;f’.§’:;”sp_:1:?:-$.%e s?§ 9? $3! $3 Kaéta %§wai%.;§:”a§
an :.z;3§V§’?x;.E_4_$f*e’-::.§ EV§r:§eVr”:’.=~;;sifc.§’f €329 miner if? we aaéd jam:

§i§.;n§*uL..famE§’;*..gééseyéty. ?’ha g:ses%%@:’§ mseﬁ 32 $39

A 5’e:.:§isé*t=:%€e:f&fm’é%é’ée arsgwareé.

_ *;’%s §$-éas§§£:§§;s;-‘§;»g;g~g ‘Em §’rga%:ar§a§ facts ﬁsﬁtaé $i§§%”§,

‘§I_§”E% §§’§*s§:*%;..%3 érzaﬁ aaieé ms §a%23§f sf $38 §3*%%n:3§”§ wars

..nTa$a{%a§-;§:§am*§a§°:3 aréé ﬁg giagerty iﬁai $533 Eééa

“%.:;§’§;§}ect..uA”rr;a:ter sf aiéegzatiaa was Emmi ééiaéas Faméég

:’g3V.ra:§%ért?, whésiﬁ was asmeyéé ﬁg the {gem-{as §a2as”é§a:’ss

‘ “~:’:V;§§ aise iéze Karim 9? 31% Essa? Hénﬁu Famééy. Fmezéaéerss

K n

9? $31 $5′ the At: did mt fa§§ far €ﬁE’§S§§E§”‘3″{E§fE am waéé
carzsidereé and res: fénéing ig fﬁﬁﬁﬁfeé iﬁefeéa.

ratia ef iaw éeciaseé in téae 3a%:%I”‘i§e§:§s%€§§e,_, %€2§s Eeéjj.

agspticatéassé its the mstani gage, sime, °:’:~:::*’:”;:.,T§%§;*2§a5s’:”rf;’:’:*:ai;

mt 322 s:at:;r*a§ gagardian of mE::Ve%*.__§€;angaA%%2ma,.u§:s:,”:$§:é’§’é
ﬁe facts» guardian and t§’¥e§§f§;t;3&r§£’y*”§f:§.’§{#3N'{?_d;, és éisa. wait téae
grcperty sf a Soirzt Hinchg?amiiLy;§* bu.i; I%_v:§s.3 weperty

obtained under a geiiiemegjﬂf’

26. V~E?§”t2~:.a;;§j:§s.é*§;f« {su;>:’a},, the parses:
wha had a c’:t’ei34’_aers was a rsatura gzzarﬁan

am ﬁne }€:9ur§°?;ak%ng -é_nt<f{c§'§%s§ée:°at§en the effect 35.6, 8

3.;?::L_§.f :t§_§g’a éxct,’ %;9E2§§.e___:ivac§ciin§ the aweaé, hag aése mesa

$35 t’:3§E6=%.%§$:’e,4″*%

Tﬁéféféye, a naturai gaaydian, ‘wine éa
e5″t*:*:;’:c>’&ga%e*a”éd. is maﬁage the grspartieg 3? has’ min-er
x ;sens;…c7an never be égﬁrébad as 3 guardéars ﬁg facte.

V._}§€:ajr:ce, 5.3;: $3′ the Act W€ii£§€§ never come was niasi

or: the facts (sf the uresent case.

{iinﬁarééﬁg £3 $3: 5%}

/fl

3§

Hence, the said éecisicn, has as a;3p§%<:at§e%': ta: ?;f's'€§

érzsia nt case.

2:. In the case of KAMAiAM¥%i§m{s_§pra_};'”a’§é’_§:s”z;”§;§}.§ ” 2

guarﬁéan whe haﬁ acted an beéaah’ of’»A:m£r_f’:§;i:’wés_’a’ §a’tié%’e.§_”*i1.T_

guardian, taidrsg which €i¥’CLir!’!Sté_¥%C§ infe-..a’t-tcuréfs’ a;fad..VaV£s§3

cans§der§¥’*s§ $.12 95 the Act, it wa$__4_ﬁ’e§:d 3; fa¥ ‘

?.3 in ‘me case Vc:f. %’a_A§;’1ar%j_a{§é%;e,/jiﬁf’3 jﬁiﬁi Hinﬁis
famiﬁy ccrsséstérzg ef ‘V;’z1 ‘§%’.::3;r bwc§m–%3~a%$;’._’;vi%$~& pewer ef
the Managervisj-530%i cu{t:$3:§ed b§(_~_tif§’e”Vj’%–§’E§’;§u Mérzerity

and:’V”G£:ar§:ij§avn$§’%ib $é5c:’*::f§en :2 3? Ehe ﬁat
s;’3e&’&fic3§§yw wmre a mine? has an
undivéﬁeﬁ-§§3té:*eé;t é:’§ }:§§:§t famiiy grogerty 353$ ‘§?§&
mfagerty ‘§::V. ‘;.é:§§e:” *t?€.é management of we aéaﬁis
xof V”fhe–«”f3m§iy, rm guardan shaéé be

‘ ; ‘ap§c2vi_Vﬁ*teé_ f’:§f_ téwe rzzénsr if’: fesgaect ef such :.2r§é%*¢§deé
._ “$3’§§:é?&§é:;.,V_p§%§v’%’deé that matting Er: {ﬁe Sestémz aézaié be
A:;i4ga:’:fs.acZ:VL’fz§ATaﬁ§ect tém j:3:*%$ﬁéc’§§ef§ a? 3 %~%§§%; zimért ‘m

V a§§f:§§3;?: a §£ear*é%az2 in reggae: 2;? gaéh Entefesi, The

. A’ ‘T:i’&¢:§:%t§’§s csntaénaé is’: time we mﬁrtgaga ﬁeeés, zmaréy
;_ ‘:est’éab£§s%2 that the msrtgaged ﬁrsyerty is 5 ﬁeirsi
famiiy §m$e§€3:. ?:§r’i:§’:e%’*,_ $2 is :39: the saga $5
éafenﬁants 2 and 3 mat tiée mert§age§ gmgerty £3

net 3 iaéni famiiy mspérty, A3 fa?” as céefenéaat W3; is

33;

cancerrsed, ﬁe eases net éisﬁaste thaic he exec;;;%;<-§:é._V_
bath the mefigages as 'me kartha af the 3o§at..§%_$:2 §§.%'.;*

faméiy assisting af h%:*nse%f and EEES twﬁ b:'5='E;.5?f2:5'e:':s:A%<%%¥E§§i.'£'A M
are deferiﬁaﬁts 2 am 3.. "£"hL%s, ;ée§e_;'§ﬁa:2't' W12; f%'faS":%§_'%:.V

executed the twa mertqaczes TEE": §1;:.:fe;_s;"~:t§i4;c;j:'§'._a':e;–.'3VV"_Vs:§;;§

fasts afisarﬁian sf ﬁefendwés 2 a:é'd_ 3 b;§;.i:A§2'e:"%€az=a"'» '

executeﬁ 'them as the §<a-$23» §f %»;2_*3fe' -i{c2'§v§z€"~–,§4§%':é'§:§
famiév censigiérga af %:§mse§fV_a::§é, :ie_f_»ené'a$rai:5 _2 Vgfﬁé 3,
E: is aim 'very aertéiéégt E:-E; §2§2?£,%'¥c:?:__v':?v%i"§af%:_ée§enéan';s 2
am 3 have :35? cfzaééergg-*e ;:ff %%3€:~§§5gi%§é'_'ara:zsac:é§§¢§
er: ihe grﬁgvﬁﬁis €s{e'§é'_–§e§ §1§3é§% eétézag" far

¥ega§ _r;§;ce$$§:ty7V«:_;§; rxfcéff"*:§%€§ béﬁieféﬁiicf 32$ estate'
T % ; {i.§ade:'%§z%§r&§ is :3: me}

§-«Ee:§:.:é,<i:%:e 53%? Tc£v9é,:.£..s:§'€:s%j§,' 'wherein; E: was mt {ﬁe ﬁe

fatte §;.f;a%§'t§iai: %§:§*:"-e» avﬁeé car: ﬁehaéf cf zéte miner, mi;

23%: §é§3$_'f%z$_:'§§:ata§%'a.E_Vgaa§'§ia;°: wim acéieéi, ma': 2%; §§*: féﬁﬁﬁﬁi

a§a%3§2:z%§% giiavréiéy grmeﬁyg hag as agpiigatéam.

E27: Viﬁé cam §f SA§§;§§ﬁ;?¥§§*~:%A {§:s§:"a}; eﬁfa

_?%§~:§:':§AV2:'%é"{§~;a§§a ééaé mggigagéé ﬁeriaéa gmgeriy $3 fﬁigﬁiéé" cf

'V""%..__'??§'a§%9q:§§a and E%%é§"€3?E€%', mg ?%§§§§ ggéﬁ iiréa §ra:§&:*:y $2':

_ %".a;°az:eu:" 9? téie mafigagaa ~ §"'§6§§a§§&. S:2–§s&§:sa§3€§*;§ 5&3?

was ﬁéeé 53; iéer $933, §§:a§%e£:§§;":§ $29 aaée éééd ezziemiaé

by their mather, Tim 55%: was cmiegieﬁ by we é§rfe§%ﬁaV;f§*{sT

Enter aﬁa Cﬁﬁiﬁfiéiﬁg mat, the gaie wag fa" §§§c%':.3.s*_g}§ __?3;;%?e%’

has takem siege. “:’s’%a% €e:;:t_:§a£?s’$e§:§.. %§2eT»..’t,§;é§’§£” V

?’%§&E?’§$i§G§’i am i?E$ decrae é%é’;§V:$:§”~§a;est’§r.?ﬁ:.%{; -I Eﬁﬁ
defaﬁdanta in aggeaég, $*é?’§§3£.§fé %?§§?€x*é”‘:3f§:’;?;ﬁ§’E”EV’§’:§S§;€§, c’%éé%§é%’:g§§%§

‘$€?§§€%’E, geccmﬁ agzpeai waa §?a§s:®z’f’s’éaiV, ;w_§*:’e3§.éf:e:§»;§_’, a féméﬁé

was maﬁa, §§rec:§~va’§~::fse §_é;_;*aer–%>;§§«éE’§é%%’e:. ta £§¥%$§§%E'”

whether, *i;:%2e_$’éE’§’.4%$_a§s;§’A§d~ §§§Iéi§}f2e;3: $29 £aas:”i”$ §a:*m§$s%cs::;

wftetaar $359; §j:*éi§§:%:e;i_.:5§éLé%-§:é-§”:’f;é facéa §iia§’§§§¥’i éﬁiéiéﬁé is

ac: undies. $.11} .. *§é%’séi?3é-?” 555% 3 aaéa ég zméié; wésaiéﬁg”

I- z§7l%3§°j3 Es: {:a§%~%§2= Egfgai naééééétgt Er: iééé egg :3?” Eaw am %%;a;¥°: ii? ii

§§e-..%é e§;:§V,’ saée $3; §§%”E€§%§’?§ % $3: 3% ﬁzé rzgasiizarfg

§%3a:”é fag C8¥,”§£~’;éj5?’§’.’.:§?§, ﬁaftaz zresgégi 3% the ?’%§”‘§’!:§?”i{3 §§”§§%j, ‘gm

= ‘.j’j;-v’«é””f”§s=$t Aggéiééia ﬁaam: having ﬁﬁﬁﬁiﬁefﬁé 2% %”§’§§§’§%§} agééré

‘-.§.§’:T;Ef’E1w§§f;$%E§’§ §?§§ aﬁmaé 332$ aggaééirgg {ﬁe s§:’?’:§,. iﬁa gemgsﬁ

“~-alpgieiai was féiéé, ‘*2-%§§:§:*eé:3; éi wag Enigy a§§& %*:%§$ éééaig t%’:a?a

£53 a riéer érz 3.11 ‘fig gees: §&§”§”‘§’3§§$§§§”‘i at? am ﬁwft §e%:’e

‘X
K”

sa:a::%: aééaﬁaiésa, §-§ms;as?%r, §”‘:$’£§§§§§§ ‘gee éeciséxz $5′: 3%.

r’

§ié,&.R&'{,£a§’2§ 8%.; area awéai wag aééawaﬁ §?’z mg”: %:a§£§:%g ?§”‘§§?,

we 33% 9? §?’%% ﬁragzaﬁy én ragga? sf %”§”%%§’:$s”‘$ giéare £3

éraazaiéé, hat 3% far as aaie by §§”é€ ¥’%”§{.”»i§”E&%” 35 {ﬁe §%aEz%_$s§7? ‘?;§*.._

the exteﬁz 9? ?2e:” sﬁara éfé favaagz’ $5 §efez§_s;%}ééé€é’_’; ~~§-: :

a§§€§§3k’%iS is cancameé, ﬁg ha xe*a§§é,Mm §,.§%%ém2%f:i§~.§~,§:”V%:;”‘*.é$a:’»;V

ﬁféﬁféé ea feéwwg:

Fi.sr’%:%;er, in $9 fa? 53$-..__r§§%:i”‘A§f” ra§<::2'§°s9g:s'3:§§;§: Q? V

zhara of $39 piaéatiffs Ea :%:'é?»,Véf%:ienE a}'§".__2,?"3?53 sﬁgie Er:
Ehé 55%: §§'§$&§'%'g'" is;–~:f:§3:'2£g§';":'%§§_:'étééaxé §r$§'1&s:Ai%%:v:é§ :3:
ma sama ea §e§§s§€'§*:2;gf .%:A§':§=:L :1ﬁ;{;§"§5§3;j;§e"3,»::"za:.s?2% ta ﬁne

ﬁﬁiiiﬁﬁi Q?';2;';1§–7'§_é$§%.az"e::_é'§ﬁ_.§ %:§%2€sy am ezﬁiiéeﬁ E6 ﬁ€§§'%3'%E"§%'
sf $%é3ré._ is .t§%2'£§' §:a4€?é§%:'%., :x§ 2_;3m ﬁr: §§§ss§*: 3:' Eéza

%'?3§@§"{§§§% 7a:2:"2$%;s::%:;.._ " .

fiféég :s_:a%§€§_ §&a§ss§a:;i:__,__d$&s mi ﬁiéﬁﬁﬁfi 133$ saw af 2%

%*.%$§§§€>3¥’E5§;é?é.§fST3yE;§§>¥3§’§ §r:;’§c§§%§,, ii guﬁgaffcg the age af §§”§%

égrji $29 mgg §f %v’§§.§%é§§@%%§’§;&,, §§”%% Egaaig ‘aééﬁfa

:_§%%§§.,: ‘Tim-‘:;e ﬁééﬁge Sawéa was Em §?’§§§§§3§ ewaar §§ tém

ﬁg: §§g;3:.;:a. %~€§ 3&3″ §%§¥§§%§ §’J¥§ éaﬁghtefg %.:§2.g

“”;’%.’ésV;:%V§ t”,Sa§<a§'z*mr"*;a aﬁé §mi,E'%a§amma. 'zﬁsééezs §r?i:$§§<;$e"?%§'£'§§

was 3 mirser, £29: s§ste{ Smtﬁadamma gaumsvtaﬁéy aciémg

as a gasaréian, mid her share 5? the gmperty Eefi

Qewtia, ta Madhegowéa, ‘she ap$e§%a::t, tmdar a :§§§s:5eV§:”é{:%” M

$a’Ee deeé Sated 24.4.1961. ‘”§’he ap§é§A§’és%*:”i««j ‘§$4a;ds§€3ef%§€:_*§$§$’«’

ccnterzdaé ihaﬁ, the saie cs? shaéfe cf A:?”&’.’k__§§>’ét€Ii_*V§'”A.’waévifﬁ”gQ3§é§£§…bVV’V

fasnés for he? marriage am t%*;’a:–f§,,””w–%%::e ?2as.’bVaév:;§§~:
possession 9f the $%”G§%§?Ti;’§’ _a§*§’ci7’A’VL.{cm*Vﬁ:§:}asesA’t’;;t ‘$8 in
possession ef the same. ‘Vﬁaizi—.;’5n§’nc:.:fLT’-$a.i§a§rsma, afteg”

attaming rnajer§%:*,*;Lj-ss»:’;!r:i S}€é'{‘jE-=_ Vm§,g{g§€”¥ ta

Ankegewzﬁa «-_ $”a;gE§tered saée deaé daieﬁ

3:..’?.1%?’. AS§.;s§5:;e:% t§éa:”é’-$;e’e§§,”–é§T<;%§"éas..%ta regardéng sessesgéera

ef the ;;as3ert§§§,v-.§§.n'E§égc wd:.ia: inéiiateé Qmceeéészgg 1mda§"

:'vj._S:a.'i£%S:v"L'fe{A”;”2;*€;.§a:r;’y< :as .,§';?§:' _ }

:."?.i§§?, €329 Saw an whéah s%;§_e§<éé'as.:é:§. regigaééiaééefii "sa§*§«f* 'V

ages is; fazsééjr a? the péaéatéﬁi §:z§1ss:;5e$"?:T
gregarty §'§§ﬁ aéreaéy besr.-«:V:z'~…s;_c:§§_«V'V%':'*':"V_%%:%§§:»§r-gf §'%*§éa §§'%A*;§E§::§%é::§a
{ﬁeferaéani E'é§g3} by re§§s:é%e§_ Eéﬁaigéi
axeaagieé by ﬁe: §:,z?:'€%:$%" mm;

ma: $m:.§a ‘gm;-2 ;§§’§$¥§%”§§f iﬁ me
g§a§:’;t§;ff ﬁaiaé 2@,«%,§.§§:

§§”‘§§’%i§§§§ﬁ ._f:E%§V*2g 3 yaarg as’ aiiaézﬁrag

ma3e§§€y,* §§je§::’é’%saVi;s§”y’ 7′::n§er”é?:& ééaiééﬁ iﬁaii. me gaée wag

I-ﬂ%2§Ii:~ s.;é’§’:§ ; §%3%:”%’::;§§§a§Ee é§”:§3«’, ;&ﬁ§<e§$w§ag ﬁéeé Séﬁﬁﬁﬁ

a§gr;éV§.§_-§'%é':.§§V§:s"";_éM.§'.;$%a;§~5§:;.1a§a%ﬁg: téze saié Searess am ms €33:

"*a§§$wéd__Vi%*sg~~%§{:*§%:$ aggeaé, getzigég ﬁéée iﬁa émgizsggzeﬁ

..f.j'i;j'§;;e%'cr§% a§*:<ﬁ§_. %§&§§ iﬁig §§':§ L§;§., $2' iéze géaérsiiff age a:*:%%%:§&§

A '§§"':wj§:€°._$§f;§r& §§°'é ﬁéé gag: grsggﬁy ané Gfﬁéféé £3?" aartéiéazgz

":é.%§§__§&§%2:ery 3% §$§§SéS$§$§'¥ af their ahara east 9% tiée

"'A»».§;*%eser€y, 'me zavéew getitéan ﬁéed szmseqzsesttiy was

" éismisseﬁ aim the matte? was aarrieé by tha LE3" af Em

éeseased Madhagewda ta the Supreme Caurt,

whéée éi$mi$s§§”§§ the appeaﬁ as éeveié of meréi, E:’s–?:’é”:*§:<a2%}§é':§%";§§% "

5.3.1 cf the Act, ét was heéd as feééswsgr

This sacizian brings

charzga in the iaw reiatéhg-..j:;o d« $vf#ct;€é sgéééigéiaszis
at de facta managers of a§§3 §:x;lga §§i%r§;_§%'$ éjstata
by ersaating in &.:é1:§_ressV"'%&§f:}ﬁ;:§sf"*shat Eéftéf téae
commesmement n¥"'§:§:2ea s':ffé: }p»g:5g'-'::5ea2 has t%¥€:
right Q?' 3i3iZ¥30f'ii§9' i§x'3v..§; ~E¥ 3:3? ﬁe was
guardian eff £%g§:3o'§*5. ';é*i%§:% é:::é:'£i@.%2…:é%2a axgresséan
"ﬁe faiiﬁfi §s§§–;r§i'a'§é.?' §s:.£,:§€§é:'2__ %.r;jz:d§me§'::s, iésege

Es a §% Wfact{3 gigardéaﬁ. Téze
staté2*'t;e" _§'2a:%§§;*a% guarﬁiars G? 3
tesiaménéésy V'£g;;§:é%f:é§»*a;;?:§"_;~s% a guardiaa agﬁainteé 53:
mg' ::r;s;;§"t..V §.z: §2a<é.%$ a'Vpe:;'s?w: was is mi 3 gssazﬁian ag
a»§::f$*r€;.§=s%2er%%§erse§§%:i":'§ iakes éniegeat wen ééérzesaﬁff €§'%$

' 'g9n$:faE§~%é'23:'f:age%*{:e§s': as? the esiiate Q? a mmm' gar: ﬁre
._ §'é'f':;¢«%é"é§;v_§_§°::;§s"é'3t§é3; aéegcréfaeﬁ ag "£2 facm ma;'2a§e:""L
$e;f§:°*je~ éézfgraermesgt 9? tése ﬁat samé ae§':f:;s§e;:
§%"é'¥s'fa}"§A§'£.§§ we? we amaserg sf 3 ﬁe faster} §E§3?'éE&§": er

A A' maagér fa? aiienaémg we aréperty sf ﬁésjhef waré.
was ﬁeﬁd by the Privy immséi E5:

__5%1:sn$amaﬁpersaad Panda?’ case {ﬁuneamaaﬁeésaaﬁ
?ar2éay V. Babesee ﬁuarag Kaenweree, {§.8S4-S?} §

fvﬁﬁz 3% : 3.3 WK 3; {?C}} iéiat 3 ﬁe faatﬁ §§53%”§§&E’§

/.1

had we game aseweg” sf aéiaszatmg izéza sragserty

waré as a :2atura% gaaréian. Sactim: 12 §{%~.’:~i§§dfa:§¥jse{

away with the autharéty 3? any per::=::?.:,i_ :’:¢§

with 9:’ éispasa cf airy p:§é’§¢ r’*s.’§«sr;_ éaffaa

miner on the grauad Bf hisﬁzg. gg

gasarﬁais of suck mina:-**.. Aggy aiii.e§:atEcs%a A5b£§€«-VaVVc3.§
§actc gzsardian wiif b’§é’».:_x%gQve§*’r:é;_&} ‘:b§¥§ thew
pmvisimts is’; Sectiast * “¥2§;;:e: AQSE’. ‘rim
aliersatian, being’ _ statwtmy
$i”£3§’Eibit§6ﬁ, .wa£2id.~–%.v§=v4::§§:__$53 §;;’1:.i5;t§és astﬁ the
aiiersea %.¢afain*a3§gf;# -.’ 51$’: –“a;£:§§§§2*§ ‘j-V§am£.:é tétéa ta ‘ma
ﬁraﬁertwﬂ ‘ ‘

:;’§, saaﬁégeé $3; me}

2%’ ?§€c:a%§f *:ge§¢§é;r:§Eé§ ia the facts a? the sage,

_§E§’s:%}§u.§m§é¥*§?g V§?% ::3a§e$i.’%9§’2 ég {mi 3 gears: faméaz

:”‘g’2-_§’ e{?§e;rt;:§z, E$ ‘a._§m§e:”ty settéed ﬁg: Eraiah ms-er Exﬁm

,_§e:E%€:.i_3{‘ .i:_;*%s ‘fe§’*é£;:sa;r’~T.:;’:2f’ Sm§:.,§%.%¥:3§amma am Era iC§”%§§<K&§§§%

$fecan§7'§§; aééeséaiéan maﬁa %;€":§&%" Exﬁi $3;

W ": .Sz:2§i…?*4,?§§§arﬁ:%1a in fazmasr $3' Eraiaéé, gar; $5

§_:~.§Ta,w2;f'ai's'a§*:f3s:a*~.»'az*a Era Qﬁéxkaéahf %s {set an a§ée§3a%%a:: Q?

'T }ff§'§?»i€';'§*:§$ ﬁktéféﬁi Ev: 3 Mn: ﬁamﬁy gmgarty. Yéwerafageg téaa

\/%

ciacisﬁm Ea the mag sf SR3. %éARA'{A§%3 BALE has 11%

agpéiaatiw.

25, 5,31 insiudes aii Eyﬁes 9? sraperties 9? 3

and no exceﬁtiﬁn is provideé in the Seciéaa. £;’;éijs§’5z3’iz;a5.;§§’~3q },__V’7

Srrstﬂéngamma wha is tha aunt 9? mum: §.E:E’i’§&i§§’E.§}’§Lﬂ is; ” ‘V

{wt 3 gasaméafg 35 éeféraed ur3ée:’:=_VS.é«-{:i’§A.}iv ‘E2?. A%:’§é’e ‘é§;§_; «, .’

‘¥”?:e:’efo2*e, she cage e:”:§y ﬁe .23-Raﬁ fa, ?i2a

gagardéan. Ta 3 traaafer, £3 su£h’V a f<";as3e, :53 As':

sqgsareiy aggiéesw In such % x§.~'§"€i.§£«_%i§C§–€'f£,:.§£?3§'E..§?:i%"i Eaié éawré $3:

the Hashim s–:;'p;~eei§;*:;+-.-%j'%%A:j;¢¢z{ﬁg-%:%=:;&.'$;«§Esos;s.€a.»e§ case, is ésése

f@E§cw%ng e§?e2£i:.;_VV¥3a;uié?ga§3:'._ag§§.§'§es,

«_ Vv '?'§}$§'"éf€3E'.€&}_,____ft§i$§'e £5 ¥§%t§e scaga gm" ﬁauﬁt
%:ansfer Q? the mirmfs interest ha: 3 ﬁa
»-..§£2ﬁiéa ;*§§animanager kaving baem maria in

.' Av;g%'i*4a3:iat §§V§é_aéé¥ ﬁne gxgress ha? ymsvﬁﬁaé asrsﬁar itém
$47e£it?':" ag§§ "$3 gar aa iswa-%§d§ Tim exiﬁaszaaée ﬁi"

.. ,%a§§§*:é;"§i$a 43% §ega§ necessity ia ﬁat §"&§@*afa%¥% ére
V' = caga a€ gawk §§waii§ §raz~§s§a:-2 9; traai§§e§*aa
ﬁt'? such as: aiiarsatiaﬁ dam aeﬁ acﬁazéras any

'T iﬁtamsﬁ iﬁ tﬁa graﬁartv, §s.:c§% an §2wa§§§
traasacgﬁma és ﬁﬁt mqaéraﬁ ta: ﬁe mi asiée ﬁy
f§§§::§ a suit 9? 3?::d§t:ia§ praeeeﬁiﬁg. '§'§"aa mﬁsmg",

as’: aitaéaéng §?*§a§$;*§§§€, gas: :*a§§§§a£f.§”–,%%§f’%:a;=}.€~?.”-

tranaiar Er: 33:? mama? a§ %§§€§ %€§’§’§%§’§ .%.’:éé:$§a%;%:’§§.5%§”as-A *

Em’ it arigeg. ﬁftar §’£§$%§§%§§§ §§§»a§§§”§§%g’;”§§ §ggg”‘é§%eg

tmnsferg égégjﬁer émemgi Sgfg ﬁg ‘;:%:*és:3;$$:§”?s§”§§:s__§’ :T_

§aw§§s% §’¥’$@§’§§%&§’ 3$$%§’%§¥§§ %§E?s%e:;§’%§$§99 *§§%§:e°:>,, *€i$

$$¥”¥§ﬁ tiaat %§ $%§§§§€§$§§§’%§3%”*~$§%ﬁ%.%€-§%’§z§§ ‘§:’%§®._§*§’*:§.§.§£.:«§”
%3a;$ mmzéiatﬁé am %§*a§3$*Es%:?’ §§a§a§’–§§ %§§$§ “ﬁg
gﬁﬁtﬁ §§§aré§a§§§§*s§.a”é§’a~;3j§§§?’.i ” ‘ ‘V

21$: $rs:%g?%é%:°2§s:’§2§*§2a:.-~&z*%f§f §§<é:gs,_§~:9:;: %i:"%é§é<;»<,a§a;: 1%,;

?a:%2a;' :5? §\aﬁ§4$é'3:%:¥z$;:_,§:,?.:VS;V’ Enéésmséaéiyg i§’2%:”§

wag as §’ai”‘t§’§:;i§::. $3″:~§V%i&:4.._ ‘§s?.§g;;e?tg; §$i’%;§e&s’% %;”‘%é§”§”E my

§eiwee;*:_ §é%§:§Lé*;*n§*§:aV §;’%;§-._ §%;~:a%’:’:§amma. %§’£%%;%*2§a§€ §§§”‘{%§;§<§%'%

s§..§%:?e;»_z3:f %_.a:*:§a%*;*:§*=:%:~;"be%r:§ gégaraiaé, éééﬁgamma mg

"i§%'%§$? Exﬁia is': fazfaw sf §;§§%*'3«§-§'a%§§:;

__"%'°%%$ 'sgaée $§ §§é;:%.5g?a:?2%~;:§'5 régééi by Eéiaggmma, $3 '%:%2§

*~-.___a':a;§a$%€*g §s ~§ ﬁe fasia gasafﬁégia %-éaﬁaaf the game %%%I:*:§

_av§_a§§s§§§*':«%';§ exwégg Zﬁag' csfziaéﬁeé £3": §;,:£ aef fsiéé £5?! Exiééﬁ.

€33 §X§§;?%€ sf ﬁééé §§ §§§§§mm3'§ yégézi 5%"? i§"":i§ gas:

'grﬁgagiyg ﬁg $3? 3% %?"%¥§§§§' °?"%2e §%.é;?"£%'%§§§3?" :.::'":§e:é* E23:

asizn, E?"a%a§': {$3533} Ema ﬁg: smagiéeﬁi 3&3; z'%§é:'*\;3:* 'z:2i:%z"§§%:

/1 ,

~ 7.j'§ -2%-?:§am:%s%aV__A?:a§ :'§§%§% 3&6 éféiéfﬁgi saga? eazsé

ﬁg

En the mi: §;"{}§€§"€'y', ta the exﬁené: 5? Ra§*:§§?*s'é§§é&'$
%"§&f'EC€, Em '§f"§¥'§S$£i§§§'E in §e§§e'c%: $5 §ar:§am?::3;*'~a–. ;"§§_§':.§'_ U

Lméer §x.m §&§:*2§ am égwaéézé Eiaasagiém, is mi. ';_§ 1

ée gs: set aside ﬁg; ﬁééng a gait §.&§f%§43?°§":%A?"?'§§%,"'_§§¥'§4'&*§3'§–§fé'§.4§fé'§ __ '

majayééy, sea %'§§§§%&'5:§ ﬁg €s"a?3$§e:" éréaaggég. iiﬁiéj?

atiaérréng magariigs, SE29 has %s¥é'§':$§erra§ sééﬁ

Eniamsi in the 3:29: $r%:;:é§a;f°%*;,¥_<"§é% a:_§§%.§a:§ §"ﬁ$E"':?'§ §§' 33¢

executing the gaéa mad ﬁatadi';3,'§2:3.§§E%~TE:"'{ég¥§':3) 2:: faaaaw

of the pfairgtéff, ti§er§§'_3; aézgegjiiéﬁg §%.§a}7§'§%.%$ §f=§ V§Z§"é§ §m§er:§:,

whécéé E3 22tV_:s§§é¢§_ér;€',_.:9;a $§v§§$';r2; 7zré3§%,_ i:_§'ée mézmr §'%&S zwzgééaiaai

the traﬁsféesg " maééé'-.1'§3§"-.._§%*:€*;"' ﬁg faam §%.;a§"§§a:': –

Smt.?~§§a;:;§mmé;' . §Bg:-ié iéié i%.2?:$ éﬁaza; ésavg rzai amééaé

$1.1' sf? €i'%25e;'-.&€€'._a:3§ §éé'¥'é mi Fsﬁiéﬁﬁé iééa ﬁéﬁéﬁiﬁﬁ éf

c¢%:;;*: %§%…k ¢% gage $2? ?"§;i.,5§§..E E?;A??§,

" M§§?§;':£i_$;*s:$,{:%§§§,:$é*2$§§'*s*:$ %2§§zs$ aéméiieé €"§'%% fag: i§2§i:§

$"'"'@'*

§i"55$$?§7?.;

aéaém ig éééaa 93%? §:2a€§§§:”: ?§%?§§am-ma; 33% iééé

—–.’;:;5%$p}_::-ié§”:*g is §%ﬁ§.3§ fmm wézam ??§é”§* §::§:%:a$%§; §.§ﬁ€§%2″” 2%

“=.._ ¥s}.3§e ﬁéééﬁ aa at $315′ $2 gm $3; §;a:*§§a:’2’*a:?sa”s §’%§%2%: aw

intaregt in the §§'”§§%§”?*§ swig mi §”§§’%-§% wag: g%%§ $3;

ﬁééngamma, if: asiaw’ $3′ me &§{§%’§$§ $3: £§%’*:’€§§:”:&$ ‘V’

{ﬁe £6: am :%%e §?”§?%S§$E”%§ a? 3:25;”:

azguireé gay éaiarest ix 2% $§”%§%%’°”5i.,’§ﬂ

traagaciien 3? ?’°é§§’r§§??”‘z§’%”s§ :.3:’:ée;”‘jE§:.,_V ‘”§§”‘§€ :;;*ré:{>¥:i”?:;i~==;;§:§V§§..3

K .

Ra:2gamma”s régéit beéﬁg wéé 3% iééée’ i:V%;_:f’§£?zeﬁ1§a%?:.’;€
exteﬁt has gagmé an 5? Eﬁﬁ
sasbseqaserst aiéeneeg %.,§,,, v2§é;sjps’§–*:;é§%:§:’s*5t §v_§v;f§:§§EV?.”§§:a:*:§§:’:%§”%:”:a
caatimsed ts 3£:§*’?T§?”‘w~i§§1é””:sa§é §Z§”%?”:$’f§?1
Smt.Raagam:§§ ..g;§s:;§’%’;:%§v iaéeyast E52 2%
prweriy u§{V:Ge§_ 3%4§a:;§§V%§§_._§§.{aha giaisyiéfff is aaﬁicééiéz

ta 5533?; Ethe’;f§§a§ﬁ%$”§§;§V’§:&:* rigézz 3:25 §f:’§&%’§§i 32%

éggvaiéiaf §hé”§§aé:%%§§§, iésa-=; géaégzééff $353 a£§2.:§§’§§%

agaiéé f’$§ii%;té;:3§ af Rayzgammys fight E3 €329 aaééiﬁ

“”‘;:r?$§eri3:..,_ }§~.§$r’_2V?Lf1r:2,§,T ism fmﬁirzgs aséﬁ €$§”:c%:.s$§e:’:$ a? $323

-«. ..: v€:_:’§{_iV.«%:§E’?t$ ?be§5é-:5; ts thé exieﬁt sf ?;3r§gam§§§a’s §'”§§§”%€ in 2%

1*~.V’s:s§:€ §;*e§é’rty being agamsi the §m’zz§§§§%°:S %a $31 9? ﬁne

_;3_;r§§ the ram cf Eaw éeeaéareé 5:: the aaseg a’? ‘§Z%:.,.&§;E

and §*4A§§~%E§®W§A,are £§e<a:"%:i ermrgesas 33:5

§'§3§:'é ta ﬁg mséiﬁeﬁ. k
/

2?. To the extent a?' aéienatien ef Ramgamrﬁa's_4.s§%§§;:%?~.,_

in ma suit property by §'*ze{ ﬁe facts guarééan §*\%%_s:%§.:a}"§"*:é§fé§';§,_j:

the ﬁsuris baﬁaw Ezawe érawsr: wrsag §§%fe:T'ée¢:';vc§:=; $ §*';*:9§':f;

grmzeé fatts $1; ap:§%y%s2g the éaw er%*§§:e:g:.5'33%3:u§'TT..inéiéséi'if-:2?

agpiying $.13. 9? the Ag, 56% -.i:_%fze Vii:-.?au §'t$ V

é'§"?'Q§"!E§3.§$§'y" agmiieé $.32 Q? tﬁe $33?
Nigégamma baireg tha §<a%*'g~.%§;'1a}'* §f".::i':;;es.vL§<:–%.:;»%A 'fa§?:%§y, ézaﬁ tésa

right ts aﬁgnate ?:%*:&:~.§:'a§aaA:fi;3a _ $€2'§%: :%:L§:é"ii;$l:;::–%:'sV"§a§s%§%; %:a°::e

miséifacteé ¥:he;ft?%%sa§é;r<e3$ §§§"a;§€;:s;§3s%zz§;§'%:;.§3é'§"a'§s§"'&:2§ aégg 5:': Eﬁrsa

maﬁa? §f: Va§§§*'e's%Té::_.€%cgs*§"3.éé? mc:3.?ﬁ%; ¥!§§'§Z§"E E'&§€%'"§§"&£§ ia $33
aarmct §:'§%{%$'§~§;': '$5Iéjawé.'~~._ *§~éér:£&, Emesfeyezzaa ié iﬁé

afaresaéﬁ..ex*:e%';t,_ §s-.$&%§:*-§§ fo§; éesgéte '§I§'§& £@'a'}§;'L§§'§"§%"'s§

fiészégags.'§§i.._€;%:e"%~€;a:s:°:§ Vﬁéiﬂw, gérzae, gersersity 23:2 Em? mg'?

%§,e{e:; :§;:;;jé%g:%§s;s:1a:;%s:s%:aé5
28;'"«.E?:€'§'§$;§%§§:é§§§a, ihe mat §:*§§$s'%§a3 ?§§*§*:'2 gaﬁ §§3€§

"' v" ":;.*«§§'?ci&% &f =—-%§:e E333 §"s3%§$t:£'§§'%§ E aaga 22$ sgaéﬁiag in

"'§§£.*§§§'5a;.?;;?§§X3 Q? §<&§2§<§§°'§ %£%%§§§e. §'é§§"%§&?"£"%:"'§"E% Esgé €$§'%%€%"y"§:§

séaéé §r§§3&:':*+,i ﬁiféﬁéf" $33: 5%? §$'§:'%§$§' Q? SW3; %%*§'§% Eaiéé"

5'"

“3§§§ §%””§§ £%§”E’*§§*;?@$ ‘zéae game :§2”:{§$;* téwe gaée ééaﬁa at §:x:.§;?;

éé

‘:’

§6§§3§§§;”E. “ﬁe amér ai gﬁsﬂiﬁ: wag ms: $51 s%§a:E%%A?¥_;i;%*:%;VV”‘m:’~?.

EEEE géaéﬁiéff, the siéenea fmm Raﬁgamma, 3;”: G.$”;.$§S;?2>%2′.;’%i’;é%;;,’?i9 * ‘

05?} the §%”$;%§’%§ that %h& same $3 %§§$§a:§”$€’éé5§?’%;;”;%’;:;*;; ‘

gragaﬁy ézaé akeﬁdy beers 3&6 ﬁg: favzéézr >%;–?ft?2e §::;*~3’§;*s”«:é:\’*%?,

cugﬁi ﬁe ﬁzave ﬁeezt maﬁa 5 gar’;:y’v-§:§”i§z8
1″ resgenéerzi ?§er’e§%”s. %f2’§:i?}§:.,st f?i”‘§é::§:§§§§?’f§’§*;.%.’f’?,53ﬁﬁéfiaﬁg wém
hm mwcésaseé €939 §¥a;3art%% v”;:f:.a %?;§a,, iéw awe?
at §x.§3.1 ﬁas €9;m»é{ Vt’ef;: ta gm
grénséaiaa $5 ::;’._i0:’.V.ée£§a;*at%m°: ca? iiiée
am raat:f’fé”£’$ai?{i-c;§§:/ ﬁE:€’._”V”?%,é;::3:’§ £3? Sighigf éa

ma§:z’%a§::a§*%-3,’ 33′ ::–§§:§.”§§§s’T%;§§§7§—..{,f;g:::§’t $2′: we {gag 5?

SC%§EE.E§.E_& :§§T.§;?V%£§Z5f§§% {–§’;~>}’}”~~%;;*:r§,_§ $5′ €%~é,%;?%é§§;§3;s?§£, gm;

féﬁﬁﬁ aésa §3%%§”é ﬁeéﬁ E’? %;%z% sage af

i”§§§§_m! £$§*a%§%*%;ES§EQ;?*-EEQ gm; :§§§ gag

:2$é} §§zat_,”é%§?’aé:: 3?: §?”ﬁ§f” $3 gggseé is”: 3 iaasiaiéaa

‘z,.,__ ;§§%§:e&&§:=s§’§;ééiééaf E?°: agnggai ﬁg” ragéséeﬁg $329 aaéy §’§§’3″%%a§’§i

_%:: ‘a :§%.;§i~ :.::*2§@§’ grgvégs m 36:35, §./§é§§::9:g_%:s%§%’;:§”‘wfzaﬁ if: iﬁé

pregerty wﬁéah s;§2é f§”:*_e’3:§7 €;%§%ag§é’%%éé§% V’E:§’;%§1§, was ﬁﬁié

ané c§:’aw§§e’:§ -.§§?j;’§’§EQv%’i::fi.?.2’¥2§’%’:f*,;;f’ %é:”‘v§:2*:%§zs§” sf Eraéaéz am: as?
G$w§3:3na3aé3é*a’ Es?’§§fi§§§%%<;Ta§'é%"3_:V'{'§*'s:'*;'3j§. ﬂame 32¢ ganiiazz 3%?

§?s§§rt§* Kéﬁkﬁfé %g*§%%a§e; ¥%'?'§§€§"§

_..~§§§es§;'é:§ ﬁevwaeé agmﬁ 2%? dgagaiag

";*T§%:;':§ia:*;%::;z'§:§;*f§:r._§a=:E;a§ asaveyeﬁ $3: "§°§w§§mrr3 fawazz 3?

V thé';§§a'§V:*'s?i§V%é'; I"'f§f%é§§ §%a§;"si£§f 323$ gm: aaassimﬁ am: s§§%:€: mg

:*z2*:e:'&§§t7 3;: "'§:§:é'§€§%: gysgaariy §§'é§"§i§§§'§ §3§§ %*§¥'%§§§' ?%2$-gamﬁég

§%.:2:ﬁA'?;;:L—iééééaéé éxiéﬁif %§:e §E§"§§§?E§$ §§ ﬁe €e:.s:*'€§ ﬁeégw ara

–r:a§%A:’$;.»§¢i’?é%;s§ am §§a§Ea is he i.§§§’§&§§§ 33%; E9 iéza gaié exigmi,

ﬁrs a§§aa% E5 3 €a§1%:§:*2a§at§§?2 $5 téze saga “§’§%e

3§§€§§8§% ﬁauré, if: *s;’§e¥=; as’ $3, 9…? 3? £§C, may tam Eﬁié

camaéﬁeraiéon tiae events is meaici éhe yeiief. I:*2t t ¥*se. giééééé = M
facts, ciriumstances arm the recard:-J5? ‘?;~he aiese. éné gigé

the ﬁnééngs recorzéeé supra with re:’%;;e:é§:Ee?’TteT[f%E_.§a§é ‘z’%,g:”::”

Smtﬁangamma and the cerre<ﬁ:t2%.e:7£;~s%»cf {ﬁe .?"§?%..;§é§j'§?§§§§ V§¢%§"'i%*%j&

Caurts éeivow with rgferesfma–. '£:§'-»,_tE2e "r§g?:% cf

Smtﬁwpamma, E @993': '}'_:.3$f:" ﬁieééaégary, ta measﬁé

the reéief and ?°:e:°'§c;$,' 3:pa.sf;'éV'€§ée::§f<:5%§z§;:é_s::§:7

E)'

ii)

5 ‘e:§»§:3é%z§_ed I’: :2 gar?

Esé’vvr§§z::§éfEca€§’é§é 3:sé§:?2es*:€ am ﬁeisgga

é:a£eéa ﬁasseé ﬁg tém éaameﬁ iﬁiéi

_t5i§’S§§{&§’&; $3′: G,S.¥*=§es.§?§:’3;§§8 352$

iha Eadgmant azsé ﬁéﬁféﬁ ﬁasseé ms

§§;f_: a’ ééiaérzeﬁ :$:ﬁ§§t§§§’3§§ §%st§’%€i :§ij§§% Haggai: as

.§;Vs~5«’%a§9gs2ﬁjg3Q$;2 ané 2:;2§§2 éateé 2;:,s.2§a2,

3 E-ﬁ.S.?§ﬁ§.é?f1§§$ argé as/2aa§ an the ma 5? {ﬁe

§§’E§§§ §%&??%§

£5232 3uége,?{S:*.§:2g},. Agsikarag

degrees Er: aéart,

éﬁ

?’

22%} (Q.§.?a%$$,§’?;’3§§%} am sazsgggaaé 3;”; iﬁé

Civﬁ hadge {$f’w$§-.§s!\}§ éaraséigare, j<s?*:l'a:§"%—-1:i'_::?;iai';%§f'*.V

éecmeé $3"; the aiamze tarms.

in the fatés azsé c§¥cur::stan€es”‘vef”izixé :’.’Z&1*’f;”§;%:,”§;?”i_:%VE p7’s:§”%%é§
$333: ﬁes?’ 323%? resmectéaze v!:_’::§ :%*:V%Qéi§’§~§9§§;é”:’,.._«

K -L9: $1?’
%<$3s'* Ca» cA. Le
' v- '/_"' t " pg… V
°""«-€'_V"<'~+* :2 __;;_M,? .

ANVG3:

15.09.2609.

omea on ‘ma saws S§?.§}KEE§£é;F_Q:.’:4.,.’ 4′ ‘

RSA 834/2002 C/WRSA

Due to arithmetical errar bo’d-y_of_VV§§*:.:a’ju’t§’g~;*iient ” V

dated 31.03.09 at para 3 of gage 6,:V.i.:;:Ai’ha”‘i.aAst t.jtit–o.neA..§§ine, the
case $0. has been shown an; .;fh’e_Vsame mistake
has reoccurred in the §””_ar~.’~.;t_ lin§:A’d§”;;:;¥§3 47.

Hence, the:_ the ccrrection
skewing the $3-rr.a§ﬁ~Vi£a§é§:_: Na;jag”‘§§Jﬁ:::v9V1;}97-98’, instead of ‘RA
81/9?»-98″. ” %

Sd/-

JUDGE

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

Nanjappa vs Doddaiah on 31 March, 2009

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel