High Court Karnataka High Court

National Insurance Co Ltd Hubli Do vs Sri Shankarappa Basappa Savadhi on 28 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co Ltd Hubli Do vs Sri Shankarappa Basappa Savadhi on 28 July, 2009
Author: H.N.Nagamohan Das

Hi’ THE Hifisfl ceum’ oz? xggx;%i’AK%’AL-” _ ‘

CIRCEIIT
msrnzz Tms THE 2s?H”-ksxif <31? ;5I'iT,AI :£~",..V
$33 HQPFBLE 3:3,, J:3$T§£f:1E_H«w.:§. zxfgaamfii-mm D53

E'!.§§.;'k," l§:}.'1.2i§3'F*3i?;C*f)fi'~» {Wei
"_.CfiW7% Q@;

i§IFA’i¥£ i5. ‘$.A35’f06’9f2C(36,
13379/395}§;’ 3.297 1;f’335: AND 12074-f2%5

;3;§T”»%EE§§’;

:*as:;m.{3:»:TAL’ .5 :%€ssL§”§::;x:<.{::::.. §ZTi{3§%f£PAE€'%' as §tf§E'F§€',ET3,
§T£:m.:23:;:.,V::a'<;:%5

?§«§'§::é:;;:,::}:§§ gm ;s%§?,,..is»:;4, $i.?.B§?£’fi;F€A§§i {T:£f.}?v3″§*E,,EIiX_,
p”:§’.3€:§’§g{‘\}i§3*E}3 %%%%%

“§E§;?€{§;%§4%i’z.§€Eiw56§ 52$ 3;}

‘ “§’?%’fvE§E”R£§.StE_.?’*§'”iv’13″3§3* E3′ Y§I’f’3 .§;BFvE.{3»E?’FZiTIEZ:E€,

V’E§§¥}E€1′:}.V.”§§;£a?;%§y§VE}§{§i{%s

..A?PELL&.fi3′
{SGMMQXE

{B'{‘*ff$’§’€1.EsB€Z”l§§EE§”T}§;%.R;%§a:’§A Rfifi, 9:32/K}

.5: gm? s§~§;a§§;«:§g%??,% 83§$£§??2’-‘: Sgasgagfig

;%%3E§§} 124 ‘ffifisfifi,
§€I%§$§{.§E2?*%’§’ if}? E{?££’€Z»%iJAi”}%Z§?:L
‘§’§X§.i§§i 52;. I)E;:’?§’§’?€E€CY.£’ i}§~EA§%E%’&i}g

25 SEQ? SE§:’§{§2§?”?fi E%€§:§§4z%§3’§’i:% iifiiffié,-E,
§’V§RJ{,}?%,

;”:%?**-“‘?”A”

J

‘J:

(OWNER OF’ “T51” EJNIT N0.1<;A~25j
*3-45 18-4619) ) _– — .. fr, '- _
";..RESR9_NH'§?.~NT?e

' M1'-'AA N£).12@'?%j-L?,8€.3f:

(BY SRI.RAJA:’r3HEKHAR GU.%’M_ALLI;”AS’J..F’tL’».?? ifi{1 .. :3

SRL MAJ POONACH£a, AQ\2?_P’OR’ R2)’

THIS §%afP’A IS F§.LED L;;s..30(i3-.9? WC”-A£’f§’ ASAINST
THE €)R{)ER- r>AT’;’::_m:31/1′:}z3;€,;2t)’E_P0s_§f_:f T’ieI;E:”‘S;;@;;§4V;E;a ”

1 SR}, :{_;g:~JT;§;a;e..A;;,_
AGES 28 Y’E§AR5§_§~,._
3; 0 :szs1Na:}AP’i°A ‘x3e;-;.,;%:::=a,
F:Es:.z;3E’;z*é”z*’z::s::j§<:H2:vALAQ§:R_:,
';'§A;,;:K <35 :3=:§;sf;'R:e::':" §H§iRW:»'sI}.

" 2, ;<s.%R:E"'$5;,s,.§éGg§PPA NEELAPM KAVALE,

;:»:g;;;Q:*e,,"-V AV ' .

-.*EeE$1:33Vr~ri3.T’£2i:’ KHAVALAGERI,

‘2 *rALU;<; iT$'§S'¥'EI<§lT msmwm,

":';«0W\:4:::z.fm: 'I'«T UNI'? i'~éO.KA-25f
'I'-%6f}…8w46 :9; 3

" ,..aEspomE1wrrs :1:

mass so.12e74/2065

{E}? SRI.S.M.B£&§,WAfi, fi;§’%f.;FCiR 1%};
‘ RZMSERVED)

‘TEES MFA ES FELES if/’S 38$} 8}?’ WQ fiff? AGAENST

TI-*iE QRBER §A’¥’§3B:31/Ci8f2Q{)5 P958385 EN Cg%.S§§
§’%{3,WCA]NF«’278]2Q§4 {}N THE FEE 9? THE? LABOUR

994%”

*2′:

QFFECER ANS COMMfSSE{}§%iE:.B FUR
C{}.MPEI’€SATE€)N, EIAVEEEE, AEFJARNNG <:{}2$m;~:;¢:3;§;i§*:<:%J _:;f

RS.’2,3;’3,182/« W§”FH :rs1′:*E:Es§;:~s;_%1%… _;1:2<;;5 ,_'§?R{[}M ' F.
92/ 11/2004 Am} E§iREJ{'fTENG mzg: &§§3if?§i;{,}'€§$§"3*.._§"{Ei§7i_E3i§§,TE) '

DEPOSIT 'rz~~1E'; SAME:

THESE APPEALS <:o':%s;3%§-<3 Q:\é"';'«"-we .;§_::2;M§~§S§<;;;§ was V

GAY, 'mg C{§§i§R"'!' SE;-;%;§:R{;i§..3_*:4E: m2',~;_.Qw:'rx::;';:§

;;;~ 2}: "N .

Tbs.ag;§e1§§i%13.’:~EI§:s:;i’:3;1c£;«* is bafare this Csuri
calliszg §_1f1 {%’.fJ;:1?i;i”i£::V§;f1 véxrdfir tiaied. .3I.,(38,:2GGf3z in
ms. *:sJ<:gs.;';%é:#*;;2:?j?;%<34§__é_:§:’ ‘f3T}fi’C(§fi1.fi}’§,S§’§f§’fié1’ fag” ¥¢'{3;:*k.m€11*;s* C0m}:)r:z::$atiozr1,
§§a&j€:3″§. _.

‘V x main grisvance {:35 {he aypafiant is that 3;:

Fsgi is Stated filai I’€3pm:2,<§.€12'ts am raaéiiafits sf

ABha1"é&":3_€§; ffkistzrictg bu? {§.&i§§€1"&f€3:y'" they have ffieé {#3133232

gzefiifiiazz bsfére filfi {:(}fl3§}iS§ie:Z}I§1€X" at Eriaarfiré. 'F215 Supremfi

_§§:mm 221:; ,?§£¥€I}R§{§§'~Lr% %3E;{§fiEEE'v§ –¥$~ rgme;a§§%§::z::Ts::”x<so:;. gtizaizxging €:Q:2z§_;z§:n$a€:§§’; E:{}}”‘7iEl€%§,§}-”

rwfig

sf “§}E§j«;'”E}3.£iZfi’ at T12′?/6 pa, Eb this :::’.;<:§~€:1i, ths

passfird $032 'Eh:-:1 {7I':<;3z1missio:1t:r requigfcs m:3€';1fi{E;:{i;?i;3:'2,''''V '

Per the r<=:as»:ms;*S éatexii ai3.os?e,Vf.hT:~%{ féiiiawigzg:

:1} V ThTes¢V_;§ppm§iis éfioxxyad.

dattzrmimlng

:«i.;,_COI3:iE3f:_Ii:§£if££Q_11 aiad fixing liabiiii}-‘ rfimains

V ‘ _ 3:.Ti’I”1§§}K;;’E.§’i:Vi:El1}”:IE3(“:if.”§!.

.3’E;::’é:19~§3z;g11£:é; zisvarii §::s§s;;iE»21* as :3; ffiiaffifl

‘V A’ «.§f§__¢§;:*a;§£ GE” inéeiesi is mmiifissii Specifyixrxg
Eliza? this’: Cs3mp&.n§:–2:£i£:-:1 awardeai £33; £216
iiommissianer caxries inismst at 7 V2 OX3:
pa}, fmm film data 01′ ciaim gstitien 5,1} the:

fiat: sf the azfler 31.G8,2(){}§. ?’uz’fhm;

from the dais of azfisz: iifi {E33 iiata af
paymegzi Q3″ iisspesit, the x::3mp€11$a?:i::

€~}W8I”fi€€i by the Cammiggiangr carrisg

i_I}§Z£§”‘€S§ ai 1:»?/’?e §}.a,.

(ye-~§=*«»..fi.,,

31

iv) The? amotmi in deposit §Z)(:7« iI’31§3f5T%f?’E§.!!’u:I(§’

{he Cammixsiérzer fer *_~.’E?o:”i§:nr:ja:;’s T

CA)i3i3})€”.i’1Sa€’i()I1, Eff’3£i§;7€fIA;.l, f{¢:§i’ *:i§sbu.rsk:fi1r::fi.A._V

xx} Cfirsisred aé*£1:9:féi»é;1g3}?. . ‘

hrp