High Court Karnataka High Court

National Insurance Co Ltd., vs Sri N Prabhu Shetty on 23 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co Ltd., vs Sri N Prabhu Shetty on 23 January, 2009
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
w.,...,. .. .\....,..........M ruur! n.uuxI..u_r KAKNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNAIAKA men cwaror KARNATAKA I-HGH come

it'! me HIGH COURT or KARNATAkA;'.«..§_ 4-   
cmcurr BENCH AT GULBAR(3.A j V if  V

DATED mxs 'ms 23"' oAv <$f= ;A:su}xRv,   ;

me HOWBLE MR.  5. r:1§¢?c:r§i:,*;'E"!2I 

BETWEEN}

 

Natior1a£Insurarxoe£;o.v..Ltd.;: '   
Near Minwidhanai Scmifza.   4'  " 
BEigundiComp;_k9.'x"'      '
Gutbarga Taiuk anéci Distflct _  é_  
By its Division  $ A   

 V.   APPELLANT

"  '  Advocate)
M9 % .A  

 3:1 :41, Prabhu siaéw %%%%% 

- S/é'%«Sha?r:appa
 about '3.7""years

 ___O'z:c_:  Fractitioraer and Agriouitzre

e2/<5 Tawrr Ha rmabad
Disigfict: £!%da{_ '

 _ _y Sri Sat%tt $;h V
"   V '3.fQLsha'nircrappa fialwmi
"Agec'i-abaut 32 years

 .,A.grimi1:u:7e

%   Rxto Hamkhea we
<   _»V"{aiuk: Humnabad
" District: fiidar

 RESPOAQENTS
(by Sri Baku H. Metgma, Advocate for R1
Sr! Matmb C. Nagaraie, Advocate for R2)



COU

. ......... u. mmu-an-nun nnur-I I...uUIt1«§.Jl* ICARNATAKA HiGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNNIAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HiG!'!

This MFA is filed u/5 173(1) of MV Act a.ga::.sr::i?e'an¢

award dt.7.2.2008 passed by the CJ. (S:f_.'l.'_1':3,..)'.._i.3s}(f§ i':~r.4.,cr,.,,

fiasavakalyara, in M.V.C. No.43/2006.

the following:

This appeal is directed afiaistst fix-en  and award
dated, 7*" February, Zoofltfiassatl t;;ée:a¢;..ceus: Judgersr. Dn.) and
Additional M.A.C.T.,VBasavaVl;§'ly§§'v'ifi   of 2006.

Z; The brief qf .,$rfg=2.  5"' February, 2006,
the respom§VerIt,a Vrxigs  Hero Honda motorcycle.
Another l,tero__ l-l6iév:;la«.,_ri'zot6rt€$r::l_e-- came from behind in a rash and

negligent rriegrraaer ara.c§ "lift  respondent's motorcycle. As a

‘result r;f–vtl3is’u}’-.ic*.r:.i¢jer’:t the? first resvortdent sustained multiple

Virij~l.rriés tsf*q’1rieVrr_us natiirc. The Tribunal awarded camaensatien of

:’f8°io interest thereon, the breakup of which is as

follofisar it Amgm ig Rgggs

‘Loss offirture income ~ 2,2S,000.0fi

v ” ..,Pa.ér;..§nd éufiferi-rig – 30,868.99
:1′:-menities — 30,000.00

_ Less’ of expactation of life – 25,090.09
Meal-icai expensm – 1,37,29a0.OO

. V .. ” Travelling expenses, attendant charges

V and other sundry expensw — 15,930.00

«~u–c-vuuoupumn-uuupupvn–.—-p

This MFA coming on for admissiim ‘j

i …V….. VI!’ nnmvnlnnn ruurl uuux} pr mmmnm nae:-1 COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA H56!»-I COURT or KARNATAKA ltllnélllwtqioui

Tribunal in excess of the award amount be ordereétlltéf

to the appellant. I am not inclined ton»1Va>_ke the

the appeiiant to file the necessary memo:–elf’. Tceticnletienélibeffésfeé the”. ‘:

Tribunal and if the amounts depesited ére’found.’vtel..be,;in of
the appeilanfs liability, its return ltaube byvvfthe appellant
before the Tribunal only. ‘ VA A L

Inn