High Court Karnataka High Court

National Insurance Co Ltd vs Vivek Since Minor Rep By His on 10 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co Ltd vs Vivek Since Minor Rep By His on 10 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Am ma 

1

m rm mm: scum <3? KARNATAKA AT BANw.LQ:2 E  

mmm ms T1-m mrrfi Q2? I*IQVEBawEF€__:§i§.i£j"V-.   

BEFGREM_

THIE H{.'.¥N'ELE EH2, 3531193 

Mm 39.9477]  {hm    A

  :3;   

ma EQ,§%$?5f fi0;:;,.A§ A  ; ~ 
W735 £535 ?=m?*§?'m

 

3m*wEE:»:%;T  L   j
HA'HC3N§%L 'E$21'SI.? R7é§1;'%*§'i';}E.' E..IM1"I'E D,
nzszzsxmraz, <3F1:*zsm€:x.2; %

z~:m«g maaasa re::%ss.x<3:s3%kRcAI3,
3A§ZG.:Fi§20;R£ -  027.

   -BY rz*s:;:%D%rvIs%zaNAL gawacm,
 2-mam: R21'-=m«?:sm'ma BY Tm
'REVGIfl§;&1,,"G?§;'IfiE, ms.144,

s§mE3mm.%a a§jfi.E*.g    -
_BA.HRE"- see my

   ,3? ms mgxvry mzmemn.

 AFWLLAN'?

  ;(.a*:*{S§é:. H.3.mmARM, .mv.:)

,
4%: B mm, 51% (13038,
mama:-macaw,

Bmmzmxzs --- 560 021.

2. 1'9i.B.RamESH, MAJGR,  *  
FKIT-IER'S sum HGT KHOWI§,;"* 2 T
Hams, sen mm, Sm cgmss, 
C &ET, *    
BAzm~Az,oRE - sw 913.  

3. M] s.'m*m $oHs*LI1";3_'A:¢ic*2§ .s£rsfvIt:?E; 33
Many Rssmsxcygeazfz;       %
5AmA;.aRE~55o   
B'ff'§.'8 :   

k   1 % } ;..1?:ES%NI.")ERTS

(BY SR1. H.S.B,H;  aim. F93 111%}

52.2 E'Q'Ei'C'E m::L2) 'S3'£.I:'{- WITH IMEREST AT
awagg 12* am mm mm 0:: mmmzsr mg,

2  _RE£§i;ISA'IT{.}§§2

"    No.Q4?5g2c:ar'? L133

A   §H.a:1*z=3z~:A.z, mmamca cammv Lamas,

QE'=?}SE§§2%L GFFESE E612;
No.64, 1.AL3fi.GH I%§SSIC)H Fffififl,
BARGALGRE -- 5% 027'.
1

K

 



   r.a,1%§$£tAtm . €:0:m3LTANcY SERVIQESE

% A'  Tgmfkafiéi. h?.S,BH.fiT,ADV.,1~?'Q*R 2.1
%  ___'"§.2;R€3'I'I{:E mm szmzmmmg
T d' ;=2%.3sERx1Em}

BY rm DIVI$I§NAL MANAGER',
I-Exam REPW SEKTEE BY' THE
mamas; 3323123., N6. 144;
smsmmm commx,
z~§§.R$m.   
Baxmmfis - 560 am, 
BY ms mmw MAH.§GER.

(BY SR1. H..S.LRifG-ARAJ,AEV;;"jVV.:._   %
mg:   _  

1.

BI*{£;E§@G}€>_WDA,_..~…_’-.
mmA3mrr44firE jk%<:s,
5,19.

Ha.13*2*0,    %  %

51%: cms:.:,  
Bgammxz    i

4. Is%§BnRAJESEi',w  

FA’I’B’ER-‘S Ham: KNOWN.
2§fiv.2G&;’~V3§”9 3?:-1 GROSS,

_
%%%3T£x§€§.}:a:,QRE 01.8.

L % % §:*rI’c22*:%,RE-smgncy mm,
»..B&EG~$§A3RE – 550 cm.
mt mmaem.

RESKHEIIEHTS

‘ms Lmxa, 13 FREE tmmszrz 3ECTIC)i*I 3:73 {:1
GP’ MV ACET, AGAEIST TEE JUDGMENT 155% AWARE}
m-‘rm: 55. 12.2096 P:-‘sSSED2 m MVC Hc.41{3?/2064 ms:

t

TEE FEE GF XVE ADIBITIQRAL JUDGE, .
Bafiaamars SCCH — 24, A.WARfi§3js.’_.?’%-. % :5
c:m.m.Ns.a:r1oN are Rs§2’7,3%[— mm mm-RE $’1*’%é’%%;x’r’% ,
swag. mam Tram mm GE’ mmigfi

REflLI$£’I’Ii3H.

as was. I~:a.9-vraggm? {Q %

BETWEEN:

KATIGBIAL B*ISURANC:Ei –.{;”i’)B&F’AI;,I’f;’§;I££;*:I}’I’;*EQ
EMSEQRAL DFFIGE» 2:92,
M64, LALBAGH I;vflSSI€}1*¥..;EV€}iiI’;u_
BMGAEGRE-~.56nG’Q27i, :
BYITS mms1¢wAa}1s:n-maGER,. %
rmfism REPRE»$}Ef~¥’IfE:B”B¥”1HE
REGEORAL Qwiaa, Ne;;,1*-}4–, «
sHUBHA1z;§2q:T%¢;om¢émx;j«kL%%
}k&.§.Rflé-§.E),._– % %
BAB€GAL<3IRE.-» 5eskm';s<:«.1,%%%i
BY ITS DE 2siP¢HTA{§i's'gR;;

APELAHT

% {B2 Ii;S.’£4B€G§xEEEJ; Amt, ;

%mz:2; %% J =

I 1,. 7K,§.a¢A2:JULA,

.’ I

M;E%z:: mm}? 39 YEARS:

A WIQ. amxmmwm
k%1g;.137o, 4%: 3 mm,
” –»3.’f’s.’.?*’r§ CRGSS, PRRKASPWAGAE
Bmaawm 560 021.

M.BsRAJESH, MAJQR,
Fm’:-mR’s Hmfl Hm KNGWN,
2-mgm, 3&3 mm, 5%: mass,
cmzvmaaaamr, _
BA.RG&.LGRE – 5m 6218.

‘R

3, M; s.’1:a.’m CCJHSULTANCY SERVICES, j % A
Hrmzs: RE smmrcy mm,
BA.R’G.§LC3RE — 550 m1.
BY rm MARAGER.

(BY am H.Sg3HAfI’, A.Dv., FC}R4_R,l””* _
R2 NGTICE mm SUFFICENZ: %
12.3 SERVES.)

ms M.F.A. IS m»:a:1)%UrmE%aj%3Ec’noN 173 (13
C33′ MV ACET, AGAEIST ;.TLIf;)GMEN._’E”._£+.Rm Awam
DATED 96. 1232995 Fassimgm E¥1~1§§L MAST,
BARGAL£.’}RE.~ 4′ ‘£:~§}€:;H .; 3:44, A Awmmma 8.
£3O£sWEI§’S£§TIO{¥’_,QF””R5_.’3;3,9G’€}j~ m’rEREsT AT
6%P.A. PE’TI’I’IC)N TEL
REALIs&’flQI~ig%i M

Bamragxg:

‘ J. §fiTI{}fiIAa;3;¥ maméfitié, gammy Lmmrg
‘–£3§’:*ES£Qji’€AL:é?tFFICE 1sIc.2,

r;%%::,§«§, ianmacéamsslan mm.
Bayzeamm 62?.

as: m; swxsxanm MAN:’&§E-R,
% _ zmkam REPHSEHTED BY ‘1’!-E
% k *~RE€,}§_O}§.2§L @FF:cE, Na. M4,
% mauarggmmz coumgxg
.f3.«fI’§’f}{R7{}Afi,
fBA2:GALORE – 569 001,

gvrrs mmw MANAGER.

&P%£LAHT
(BY SR3. H.S.LEfG–ARAJ, A3′;/., 3

‘K

L K.KAVITEm, AGED AECEUTSC3 W388,
Wag SR1. Mamuxamg %
M24, 21%’ mm: RQAD A
5% FEET Ram; * *
was szgwma amcx,

GiRIR’§.QAR, ”

mmasoga — 5m 33:,

2* ré.B.R&IE»SE-i,M&}-QR,

1rr:a*r1m2*s mm at rs::~Ic3*3m~,;V% 4
E5205, 333 MAIN. S??? ‘C}?f€”.:S;§, ‘
_
BA§GA:.QR§:_;+5a3 318.: – %

3. M; S..TA’I’3%. S,
NITOI?

BY ES ¥tei:iE’§fi’LGi’£_»R’.~ _ _
V ‘ Rssmnasxm

(BY SR}. ;N_$.31é;m ‘, m.r.%>; 1162 R:
E32 Hefziazgsg ‘E-$1.9 3U§*1:~::*,:m:~z*:*,

3;§k.*§+.5;%%%zs mm URDER 333303 173 (13

m%acfi:ammsT Tm Jzmecasmmr MD AWARD

1:>A’m3″m.:2.2m5 PASSEE m Mvc Ro.€>1’?’0/ 2994 on

FEE, iC3F xv; ADBYFIGHAL mms. MACT,

, .VV’VE§A}I€§.2*.L0RE meta — 14, Awmmme A

mzs11i>’33r~zj:;’3..a:’1’z:sr cs? Rzs.22,QDOf- mm mmnzsr AT

e%I=.;x.FRe1wx Tim mm S? PE’rmQ2\I mL
RE£;,1.;E&fiTIGP¥.

TEESE Ai.:’»’~£LS C{)§%{} GE” FGR I-mAR3€G

ms mm’, m cermr DELIVERED Tim

FGL G:–

‘\

_ rwpendmt figs’? and 3 are the srmw of the
“sa=_I4;’ii:::1c$s Tha petific:-um bcfem rm Tribmzal ham made
fiiazzxx’ far mam’ aumnm mg’ gm’ while t1’ai.reIIing

Time agfik are filed by
cxmumgixzg the judgmsnt k %
pama in awn Haa.4:c$§;2m4§%%k
I910-egzqm and xv:

adammz .}7udge;§_ MAQTQ an the
gnufifi

2. and award, firm
mum cf Ra.2′?,’£§@/-§
Ra4*2?3o::;i%-.A _R5$vf33;;§ 6fi3.V£._5_..§#nd Rs.22maz~ mpectiveiy

per 8.333% finm the data of pefifiozz

VA this mac: the fimt rwpondant is the

absg With their fmiifg mambcrs an Gi,€>5.2§fi4 in ‘TATA

8

mm bmrmg Ro.KA-G4-P{41G§ arid afiw

the $”fl%etiiI’.s’%§ tlue “£’§ibu@ hm

mmpematilmx, Thaa Inauraw V

atabawnt mi’ obijecrtion by ”

rezsporficnt $55.2 and :3 in tn
wag irmzzm with t;:.t;der
fimefom, the irzzmtaea sf Ema for any

cammnsation fi~cm.Vth¢: –

4. the Izmurance
Cfamparxy whys.» has deposed
that the pfiiacjf ” a §..- is only an Act pczlicy

imuz-ad mz-mot be

imzgnm the mm’ 21% sf the vehiclm. It is

t1:<5.ea'~a ¥iiinugh the mumm mmgmxy hm

fiefare tlm Tributml, the sigma has

Tm discussinns in rapes': 0f the

ms 13%;}; made at Para 2§ sf the craler, but rm

A. has been §Vm' an the garmixi. taking 'Ihem Em

admmism by RER1 that zfipendent No.1 is mt tine RC

1
“\

V _ ‘ .c2f§.hza”a~?g:zm}Jant, it £3 awn that a specific greumi
_La ‘.,, “a§m11t the poiicy an Act which
mm the rm: 9%’ mm mm’ mm. The vehicia in

the c3ama’ nt was flammw” is a mm.’ ta *mh$::§e

9

awrm of that afibzxdim (ear, but tha afiaxdizg
stanfis in tm mm nf xfipondezzt fifi-,’.}’5§”.
rzespomlent $133.3. is 3 are jeint:ky'”‘a:3d& V’

Iiabie.

5. The has
aubmittéfi that as it at 2€o,2§ cf the
judmsnt – :%;:Im’sséon mde
by Eva, juat am pmper,

I do not {Em appeal is
crmnsmed. L A kk

=3, the pames’ .

?’.A F:ft:3:.zv, ‘tHe atafaemmt sf abjecfisns Efaed an

arnfipremiumhmmtbaenwkitsthaifiimmmver

\