High Court Karnataka High Court

National Insurance Company … vs Puttaswamy on 24 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Company … vs Puttaswamy on 24 July, 2008
Author: K.L.Manjunath & B.V.Nagarathna


1

mm wag amen cauaw Q? KA3§A$AKA.am aA§a3$§RE”

DAEEB $313 mug 2a” may aw auL¥, 20a§Vju j_L

ERESEET_W»
was uQN*3LE MR. JusmxcE4x;;q3m§yJafi&T§f, %T
.§m§

mam HmN’BLm mas. Jusfixfifi $,v;*x$$ARA$xmA

3ETWEER?

fiatxanal ;nsu£&nné_C¢w7Ltdf;fu_J
3.0,; Mugfiapga Qmmiax, . _V
Vivakananda*Rfi§é}bT@mkfix}_’_
Ey ita Magagfig. x >faA” g .. A§§ELLAWT

{By.fifi#é&a§é*$r@;Q,Mmhe3h}
Aflfli

1″ ?uttaawamyV3/9 flhewdaiah,

v*MajGr, fiQ.§?1fl£&aruthi
«'”Ni§éyé¢&Kamak$hipalyaF
wuQhann1gap9a Layout,
‘V;-fi@3§$1fi¥%{:

2g_N.VfPuttalakahmaiah aim
Vfiafia Vfiaxamnaf major,
SriQ.Raja1ak§hmi Ebtara,
_ Mufialapane, Kaxatagere,

AV”Emmkux fli3t§ RESEfiEfiENTS

{Amvmmate 5×1.K,$,Rmm&sh ffir R-1}
{Adwmgata Sr1¢$¢K.Sh;va§rakamh fax R–2§

,2

‘1f;t1.;t.5 m§FwA<n zm £.:i.,1.ed amalgam Safi§”3,..ij:.—..___’2″‘. ;?G”e;¥2

passed in we :~zo.3411/2333 an thé f:1e~._c;£:a§<.r';z "A«:1?;&s3.'.'» 4_
Jkxdge, MACE, Bangalcra City, part1§,*…V.§§i;c:–*-gag vibe

m.§..mT,,m petiti-an fax $m1mn$at;i,.9'i1.»..
T}f%,:i.$ Espp-aaja ix mmmfig :"' Qf1 :'f3br" 'f§";§;Ig%..L
fihrhs «fiay-, h%JUNA'I'E§ J', éelivérejd the £f,®3,la$'wing'.: '

J n g §§§;E m"w,
Thmugh. the maf%;*i'.gex' K fQV:§f" kinxdaxmg by

Qonaent; mi partiaa a§;5pea.;Z£; my ism: fgnai

Imaax.j..nt3? ,

3% A. the 3..n.5uram'm amnyany
cha;L;Léx:t~g,i:_;g"V him.» cf czazrtgmasatgimn awarmefi by

the z~m.¢éx14;vv;sa:a.-.+_;@a.,2;o:+.::{xé,- in we 343.3.,x2cu::m dates;

"'R-:3: x fiiied claim petmgtimn mlammng

'c:;1<niv:t@Ve3t;$z.=*neit;'¢f;.Vr;it¢ __ ma. aamaunt emf mm injmxias s'amt;a,i,:;a@

H Km-ad, 't:xaf£.:m arsmzgtiant; ammzuxrxreezi. an

28 .I'3,E'.i'Z.+¢IG""V'at abmmt ii-EG ;a…m,. whila he was xzifiimg

@1123 ségfimt-my he:m:;i,m.g N¢.KA G2 '93:'-8%é9 an aatzaxmznt cat?

"~fi:J1':za.."'2z:a¥:ah and nragiigant; cfixxvinnq at the oppcmmita ham

.. _;:iea,x~;mg N&,.§£A ea A»-MM. in the ammaant Em:

suatainacfi fixamtzuxe e.<::»;f math ting wanes; mi" right Smczwax

iv

4
inamme at Rfiwfigfififm gex mmnth, awardad. a wgag ofi

Rs.%fQ5,flQ0!« under the heafi future im§§Wa£fa§%n$mg

tmtaiiy Ra.$,62,1éQf~ $5 awardad. as_fim§m§%m$afiimna”

under mfzemnt madam misfit ju§§:g&£_t. ‘1 ‘

eaiiwfi an gnmstman my the ingurémme gamfiany §fiVtfia

gxamna that tha mmmpenmatxgfiuawax&gfi>u%§§$ fiha heaé

futuxa Amsa cf inamma 15 sh higher fi;dé;'”

3; Amcexdxng tn Mx¢m&hew@,:tfi®fifi@$ has mamittefi

an axrmx inf¢fi%$;fiéK1mg’tfie ificnm@ Qf the mlammnt

at Ra;5$Qfif%~ §éx– manna aufi further mmmitted an
axxmx K ;n” h§§$imgTV_%h§t thaxe ms iunctgmmai
fim5ab113§yj Qfx’5$%;W1fiheme£@xe he mainly Qfifitehfifi

that; ¢mmpen$at;Qn Vawaxfimd unfiex the head future

:;¢3$ Q§ ;n@mm& hag ta ha xedngefi and tha intexemt

“awa£§éfl a§ $§*ham ta be redacaa he 6% y,am,

&

V§x u ?fiw2v§@mtQx HM has haan examinafi befmze the

:Rtribgg§@ ta gnaw the di$ab;;;ty Qf the appeilamt,

.] ha i$ thm damtar attaahea ta gyms, his avgdanee $5

u”h¢t seraausly ahailengad by aha a@yeLlant«$n$uxamme

qmmany. In mthar wards, evid&nce $£ wwg ga um»

g/

&

laaa af ,:i.n.$£:~nm fur a pex’§,.mé. 9:5 23

Amzmaflizmg tea the: trxbunai, mkaimnt. wag

flux: 23 fiaysm gut; tltm t;x§mbuna§.»._ d;i.e:§ z’:;?{;§?fi’V:.’g’3¢$§I1::3_igV:134L&–¥’

“c.h.a.t: even afitax mgahaxge }*:2e:’.f<rm£z.'e:{ '»$;flw}°lTa.,5 a':73;..'

3z:'a$':: and «gamma not 1»mr3c." '"-,1'h&xfs£afm;x:ie, _aw"§;;z::;i_:i.;n"g rm'-V

mmw-am$at.;o11 unfiex: the "-3V..::.–:*..§ cf ‘ §a.3.r.:.i.n,g
3.111% pariogi 13 an ,l€3fi}§;*’n.:.£”‘ $i.*’§&;,;_ : “i!2j’.”i;hf::2§a.l has awmreiiaa
mnly R$*3:5:,823/–A-f’ bageé hillfi”
But :19 -2tt:m::1@s¢’;éxi’;:,”f;=j’-:.F;’2’L..::I7::1-_& a;ii?$:;i:”fi:j«a’«,y””:’;—-.V.’f°’t;3:;de1r the head
I1QX:§IS,3m’i%3’33I*»%$}t;: § V afitanziant’ 5 zthaxgea
dt1;.x3;x:eg’ t1ié’ Jlmgf’~,§ia»a§§fi;’£*Léi,Z;i.zat;i»1mexz.$at$1.m»:1 awarded mnqfieé’ the-2

‘ ham$.. £12i;11s;:ie.’,1.’c:.$_$ rzsf imacaxm .:.i…:5 ma higher 3:Lde,. tcétag

c*,#d;1rg.°éé”2 ::g,,3aiL*r:u3?.’V&;s2I’:__ p;és;§aa.b3m-9 ta trim eiainmnt i4′: mwammd. by the i;x;;:<::u.na.,3M Hmwavexg. we

mmt: intexast awamclvazfi by 33.11% txguh-1:azm,1. at 9% :3

W.

7
an highax 3;d&w Amaarfixnglyf the $am&m;$ $éd@m@d

§rmm.§% ta §% yuan»

5v Qmiy” with thga mmfi&fi¢at$Q§5; th$S*.apy§é@__ia’

fiispmaed mi,

‘V H mzmma