High Court Karnataka High Court

New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Sangawwa on 11 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Sangawwa on 11 August, 2009
Author: H.N.Nagamohan Das


– – B§%;1’J€%M4vQRE$’S’é%’%27 BY yrs MAN;%GER_

S§§’§v;’VS§§;S§iK&LA 2,. 333$, ADV.)

I

{N THE HIGH COURT 01? KARNATAK;%;”%%<kL%

CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHAR¥E';3E:B ff

DATED THIS THE 11"' DAY"()F A'»'l,?(u};I«¢'§g§§fV':VVi':,«,.}2V§IVvi}'A;'§'e'
BFF01i§:.. '<._%'

THE HOWBLE MR. J1:sTI<::i§: 3.3:. :;\A(;g§:v1 0e;iz%gAN ms

zv1.§.;:s.% 3%). I'_§S3§3f2I3£¥§' % (M. V)%

BETWEEN:

was :ND:2;%1ass:%%:RANcE C0. :.:m.,
BRAECH QFFi£E?’KAiK£G*%R BHAVAN,
ivm RQAQ. Sz%N*{}L.i”BY” ‘

REGIQNAL amca, (Mr? S{}1LE)IN(fr
AEWEXE, P: KALINGA RAG R€)A;S,

. . K APFELLfi{%R?T

L mg .’ J%

x E’ z Sangawwa,

Aged 3}; gears,
W253 Basavaprabizu Bfiumarfi

Kizmari Nagawwa,

Ageé E1 years?

350 Bagavaprahim Bhumar,

;’jL;.,W-w

Raspondezntsfi {G S arej £21if;{§”;:s 2

Kmnaré Raj-as§2.:’ee.T
Agad 8 yearsg,
§).:_'{3 Basavaprabhu Shaman

Kama: Parushuram,
Ageé “5′ years: T.

SE31) Basavaprabhfi Bhi13’I_’i311′:z

Kmnar A.div$ppa,
Aged .37 years, ‘

Sfo Basavaprdbhti ‘SE:u§’_:3;afim’i&:1%:+3 _ V

6.

AGARQST

Sinij’.:¥é*,_:1da:?;§iva;”«..«’_’ .
“‘–.AgeéV51’:¢%&-afia. ‘

§’f_:”‘{ 3 §,,aE{§~i_af;3–pa 5B’i%.1:§§’i&3’r?

V }3.;E;%21:’a.r,:’e:2 S§*<i;d[_é§?p:ir, V"
' ;3é;:i1a};§,}a:;,d§Ta!1:§s:—-. —-

A . %~«s::;a%%% R1ii;:mi§ai,
" s'$g€_<i' years,
. ~1?'é;'{f;..- 2% ij a§pa Evieiri,
z fife Wanissswaéi, Sangiij

– Row at .Siddapur,

Eamakhazzdé Tg.

(By 82% Rajasiwizar B3%§§g(?§ fa? RE}

, ._ . §%.§iSF{}§\§$§i’§’«3″i”$

THEE g’§’x?i:}E.z§xE,; ESE FEMEB UESSC. E?’3{§) (3%? ?vf.¥} AC’?

YHEZ EEEGMENT ANQ AWARD E}A’§§i§}

§3’§3;,E§€}’? PASSEE) Eh? Fifi). 33..52{§{§5: ii)?-?’J Tifii §7§§,£f;

2.:/’

K.

aim doing .E§a:%”:a.§% ‘i.%?'{}I'”k. {En ‘ihfi itzaség :3? fizés éviéégraca an

recarfi the Trééiznaé haé ‘iaizgega monthiy incame fl’f”§§1.FQ’~€i_€{§t1j& S~3=fi

at Rs. §3GC}0z”-. Even after the death {sf

agricniturai §ar;fi remains W-‘%”{§z ».__tE’:e._-~Trjéisgiéagéééfité.’ f–.._Ez§»::;_€i3e ‘

c§r€:1z:*:1s’£anc€S, emiciugicsn x;”:’i’T3tI%’1=:%__T2’ib1’z:’:3;E $11131′ )j{§}:f§:,:{§3£€?3E§€é was

earning 3 mm 0? Rs. S,8{}G.f»= p;€fii’;z§:»:3vt§} ap§e3I.3_A§{%_f2e cm higher
Side. “313 Sfidfi afjizsiica wii’§L._bf’=3 %.néf incame offiaceaseé

ifi taken at R3,. 1:§éa’é»é’ireni, the respaiadmzts

wig Vhead L033 ztrf f}®}}€E1§éiEE€-3′ E2:
pizzas AséfR3 -~ ” ‘ «

‘V %§2’z”2§fis*”i§%;_§:%V§e.a:;3:;: {£333 £3? iiwe ané z%.’%'{ect§:::§2 the ‘?§*i%a:§3a§

. niégaa? zfzfiifjsgf afiééaféed R5, 5,{?{)8:’=-. “$38 maieriai an reearé d§S€§{}S&S

. * fit-5;’: §§¢2:é»é’;f,:aVA’?:=§}§i;ah§zzz éied Eaavéng Baizénd Eéés sizesthsr, xraféfe afié

fats: iéiéziééiran’ Téxsrefagefi §a§”:>$3f€§a21 imam’ iha Emmi Lgwa

‘ _ ézizfi Ai§$s’§§§::: is is Em éiacmasafi §y 3;m”2€§*ze.:* R3,2{},€}%{%f~. E23 Eéie

?€SE,§§’5£, {he f’8’E3§’3€}£}€§%¥E€$ am afifiéfiééé Eh” 2.-{‘;~x~§*:”:§m:sa’i;ée;}:”: aéf

RS2 €3,33,@§§£’=».

x’:3’\7:/’\f-

bf

‘ V’ . &%.§§e.;i;”s:.en”2-c;z”§%;’

:3
4′ §*:’::’ {fie raaszmg gtaiezi aiaavey 31:1: §9§E:::vw%:2g €;:’&é:::
Qrder

The appeafl is para}; aE§£;:wedA

Thai: érupugzkeé Eiiiéafii daieté §f§.{}2.2{}Q7′.. i.:é3

33;’2€}{}é passeci by 9:’? Cévéi Euaigéf ‘ 7 ‘

MA{“fT«~V, iamakizagadé is; m<;rdifEe:d'3:e&::cing :'§1t';:A£:;::ri3pg;.g%;ati{;::L

K"; Rs' 5,333a::1a§ ii}?

sd/2
JLEJDGE

V’ E