High Court Karnataka High Court

New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Sri S Kantaraj on 13 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court
New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Sri S Kantaraj on 13 November, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan


E

$33 THFT; H§{§:H CGEIQT GET’ ¥{A§2N2§T§§§{A ix’? Rf§N{‘}A¥,{‘}E?§’31

Ezatadz ‘é”his tbs: iifiih éafy af Nmzzimbcz’ 299$?

BE§ORE

THE §~§€:2:mL§..t 1%.: J$*1*:c;::2:: $’;:jAr3A§*é§€Af3′>§;i;€-§;f’–‘ A.

M.§’.§:.E’J3a8§126!QQ£3’7 cm; M:.’§*;;a4.§4o’tg;3é§§%2 S;. V’:

8€%2′}j2(3Ci’?, ?:.’%’.i’~T’.r”.;”F:’-“S5″?’,r’;’?;£’T:¢.’§»’?,A ‘

§;:.F.A.::~gb.37:2z2:3:3?. Evi¢§+’.i%-.f?;’:13:s8f2if}£3:’:*,. 2 ”

M.F.A.Crob.3?3i2ao?;’332:?.;” .f=Z2{)£3?,.. izgazfigga 7′-::i~aa¢2! %Q€§’:§?;”
:ar:.§=.zs,.G;ub.3?7′;*Q«Go?–,_ 13? :3,
13723 ag 23?24;’A2:2}:3?L {M’mJ

EN’ M,?jx.Na,s5,’:25§ *.2I.:a?:.:

8?3T£¥E3§§:Tfi; —

‘F-.-If

“?s€Lfi’j§;i?(,}AD} “.E’sA.?%1_{};’&LfJ1’~”$E4.

?~.i’:%i.-1%; VV.i§§i£f>i;é. ;izS:¥§%: ca, ::m=:
REF: 3?: D§’fiE§${}i=~§&i..i¥’IA§EAGER,
3:~.s:–;%.rg«:Ar,Amj_H’M: CHAMBERS;

! . , &PF’§$LL.:’%?~E’§’

@,s-g,a ,,§;a;v:4é*%i2.;§;_;:<A$§~:, m":::::}

V L' _a2§:i':'

AA 5:;§§'"s KAr$m§A,5:: ?2s§fi£.Ef}&

E-31:} :3-'.é%.":'}:§?Fé'3;,

VV '§'§i'I),24§§ i:"§'§'§~i ftsigiiifl 4TH f_iR£fz§3§"3'5

IE'~3{3{§S"§"§3é'§&E,.«- fifififi,
RA:.}§:J§}7*¥$G&§3, BAEIGALGRE.

SRE E~§Hi§Pfi-._’§”‘H’¥, Magatéfi;

Siiji 53fi’s.§’€€L%iI}Ti&§~§,
Mzsvggfi ‘2?~§i”) {RSS3} S {T x’v’€Z§”¥”‘F’ Rama

“9 ;

4 .-9
@–2

*-;a::*: §£1’3L’i1’iE'{§ ‘i?~J§.§.§: Ehr: a;:::,;r~:§.E.£a’§1t §f1’53t};¥_’8£1{.’%fi £Z’.~t3m::>:9a:1f»;

‘i::€a::*l_1″;g: E’€3;§{J1§~€_?’;%-4:341 g._.,i;;3.g tgwax’-tig .E2«€2ag~;a,:§§._

33291 523 bath the yrislrzicézss £9,111: fact: is f.3r;’s_ jézisi’ :.

3._:3€§de3:1§, :;2<:C:.:;:':'€::i can-t~:-é.:":g iflimifis ta §.h€"§33.f–;§':?:€§:9;,..,£9$

£33: iéafi bus, mi u'fi::t_;:1aE gmghii :'31Qi;;–igivfilif A'

éfififfi biamrz 51:": £316: d.rit;€~:r*€_3f_ the " *§s,_é:;i:ada:;;:*"§%§;;"1,_Ha§::i

flflfiffi 25933 aésa I1-f3g§ig€5'E§1C§ 9:1 Sifzst» §:=–a:a'€; éf' tiiérél ::§:'i%é':3:" :3?
{:15 bus as "flit: §~zE€'§:as:§¢%;:-zi ?g*'a'\,1::,'._::E_:'é§;_-ss';*3;:*' "haS";:§§*§:203fid if} his

avizisézcsi 313:" %_}3.:;3 §;::s'V-e:§:'§%;:%;* '-<5::3,_s' 't:j%;§:";;g ' :43 §_1':S£;°:1.'§i 9;

:«l'§."%:*fi?'Ef§_£"1§E, 2§?3:*;;3.%:3;; _§: : ':;:::?é; Q?' the a&1;§<:§.s:-.§:<r:: 3.1%

3 V' r:*§;§;§:,i'i:a»§-, <:*:«,:;u§{1 _§9:<3'%::"'é:§3.2r€ f¢;s:.:::z:i, fsjait 323:3: zxzéiéz she

L_e:ii':fi?é:. *

$32′; {ha é:’%:Spr:3:3:.”§;zé:::%:. ‘§:::3u:*2an::::,t éiflszzzzpgaizy fair zfséze $12.3?

‘= :s:ig2§:%:7£i iégat £313 egézfmnca an rfigarai r€ss*€a3$ izhat {ha

§;?§:?-3:’: EEPEES ifiéifliiig dzjmzzz $*a::i§ez11: fmm Etziagazii gézig

iazézards Ba,§3§,a;::::’& 331:? ‘£33: §*».:i=;*:§a{§z3r £5213: w3.=$ zxzmzirzg

¥,£’_1¥’§”-‘a§'{T§’:§ ‘%’e€2:ga::i%_ aaégezé 3;-2:: afiécifgiezai. {3f3€”1.§;.””E’€{§. :33’: §.:?EtEif

‘ 7

§_:3f..’. ‘aisrirs C-f 31$ 2″*::::9.::’i in ‘Va;-“%3.’§€T§’: €131: §3:_:_:~= ?€E.§f:”~§

{?€.Z’5i11i?.E§; £33333: ?¢§aga::§i .§3;’1{§ Eflf}’£’%’3{}EI*;”‘=E’ it Wag 21:33: gei~:§s3′;£3%_zi*~.._

fer aha Met:~3s.:%€3§ ‘>;e’£¥_3″1 e:i1″é*2r§:§” ii: €”‘é,?Efl .€§__:’§§*’€’%:5’

$316 $3.13 §333a:~2:ri;i;1g CE«1§§5_%f3§”;§iE? 121:9 {ape ‘:’€:’::*<?}:*zf§<*3g~. 52:"

1*?"*a 131*

-\
Xnijfi .,

it”

van E1213 E::::,=:a;:’; ::§”sa1’§2,’z:: 5;i’;ez<:%!:§;L.?.'§ 331$: 13:}: 33:5
'§'§"3:2:*~::%f=:ér§; §i.a,i<;i:2g ;:«:3i':: <3? f:af:'€:;':°::__a:i;:§ i:.'n=E~.

" .

§3€:t3fi;i:::::1 :3? IZH3 v:z?:iC§_,S’;’–:é;€4_.. .:”§_:t;g;”§és.3§;§é;i:ejt§: 2′:;§’*:e”~::. it.j:ii7§:’4uzi: 8L§ :’igE::i_§’ Eaéiqté

t%:’:a1i: éhag’ “air?-‘£§i::Z3-Enfif*1%f3i*§:*§,i£if’E’::%::d Q’:¢§§§=”¥:’s.§’: 3_:?cz32::’::t af :.’:»;1i~:»}:

E3

333:3 ::;%3 §;:;i;i.4;{€:;:i” $33.3: 3.’ 253%” are {§*:’Y§’%'{‘T’.Z’ {sf ihif

s

§;.=’§r5::”:i4:=:m;§h:::2:’ a,2″2:§ A:.$E2{f~§”§V§ the Eézzzgéizzg =3? i§::3: §E’?:§T..3Eui’:Z§;§

. 4. _r€:<?g?;3_.§$'a:~:;._L ;§1«::=.__

" §¥':"$}.;"§':";g i:.%::3;3 Emzarzi h::é'{§:

g::»3;;::_g :%':;f:}::§«,

32$: Eiiaififiai 53:": :*€:;'%:§3cz:"§ =;iz., $15 $§<:€%:ch,

a;:;§$;i<5§é as; ?:%":=.':% maigaéiaz' arzé {hf 4Ef'%§i€Z§.f§'E'1{Tf3 sf {€153

E am :3? eiizztfi $;i22:.%.ss; '$513,: ifmfi s:~.::::2_:_%::.

VA 2 §:;;£~3i:i':&§E Er: :;;§2:::E§"e;}Z:";§; that. §;,§£: Q;{3{f§{i%':§"i§. e:::::*r:_::*:'ea*%. £31323"

13$'

{3C€EE."iE1'€. =::::f rash 23:3-ti izfigéégsni ::i:'§V§.::g 2:22': 23:5: 33:?

"E

$33

' §§"£%'fi'. €",§§'§'%s'€§" £2? fig: §§'§€'ié§':i{§GE' 213:2; "§"§'},€ 2:-:'.:*t§.§ir::§:§

Mmiv.

{E

; $3.23′: £22311: i§?.§-22:, Silas ziifi: ?_’%::: “§:f§;f:fe;:;:§%:;:§ if