Karnataka High Court
Oriental Insurance Co.Ltd vs Shashikala W/O Late B.C.Rudraiah on 25 February, 2010
IN TI-'IE HIGH COURT (3? KARNATAKA AT I3}-\.NC}x'\1,Q_RI3Z
I)2a1 e*1'11a:1f3x Egg) 3:()'-: f;Lav.
B E PC) R I32
'l'I-I_E) HC)N'BI,E MR.JUS'l'I(i: isMy.JAcj;,Ase»N:A'%1'}{;2§NA _: "
EV1.F.A.No.8998/5200??"{WCfJ= T
BE.€'I'\?\/Ii EN :
C)RH+2N"I'/\L INSURANC', 3:: Q... 1113.. " « . V , 9
TOMA BU 51.1) 5 N <3 . C .;Ro_m;~ f1iL_J'M:::i:3." _
LEO sn01>1':>1Nc -:\x1:*>;.T'1-«:>4.I--3«Y 13$ .;_)1=~::>1J"w_ MA?Jf;C}1*ZI£W
vsmfr '::.V%T11";T>i-:-£9, refs: :3 ._ ,
(By Sm' M.A:"RA1/m,
3 T. _z:'~«._(;£i-31'?)..3Q..Y1::ARs.
' 1.3 .R :C.,'_I~E::,/-\Y13x.
13/ C}"LA"'I'i'€ 13 C RUI'.)RA§AI I.
~ VA{"'xI?II..) 25 YEARS.
1% R S}--11V/\R;?\Ji_J.
S/O I,A'I'[C H C I'2LJI)RA.IAI'"'i.
AGEZIJ 23 YEARS.
ALI, R/A I':3A£\§ { )1} iAI.LI;
;\'I'I"I'U R I"£OBI.I .
C'}[§Ef:3BI T;'?\1.[EK. '§'L'!§\/JKUR I}IS'I'RI(7'I'.
/\I'i'I-51,1.-[\§\J'I"
4. '1' M RA..J MAJOR.
3/(,3 Mz'\E.AI..)i£S3 1- 1mII>:>z\.
1>1R11=:":"R. 1.. ":'1'2/xi-\%sfs1'>(1>R*:'.
"R; M Ki} R.
{By 51-: I-"A"l'BI. 1,) KARE eowm. AI),\~?_. :«''N :';V£+:;\e'fi'*&; .
'm1s Mm 1«'n.1«-:1) U/S :3o(1}'*£;>1i§ w"§'c:.1 ;Mjii*':?. gxr.;f;A'%1fy~.a€*1*~i.
THE AWARD I..)ATE33I') -s..g'js.()2§':;';«:)()s3V TvJ'f;/5\.":f»Aj:-:I3:Vi":)VV IN
WCA/CR/57'/2004 ON Tl--If4fxf*'iE,}-C (5? *,§.A1souR
0I'~"I'~'1c1«:R AND cm./1MISs'1'oi§'i.:1§"-VL. _ 2 rc)I§ ' "~w<jI-<KM1_«;N
CZOMI-4'I£NSA'I'iOi\i. "I'Ui\/§}<{J%_1 g{.,' ; uI"'3ig '1.Tb1""2I--1>i5AI.. Q.?§r»/£1NC§""'ON 1«i'(.)R C)R.I.')l£RE:3 'I'E---HS
DAY: <::Q:ji5{":A?L4.:E:r£a:¢1;'rw\{':i:1:§1«;'1:) Tl--I 12: I-'(')LL()WlI\E(}:
4 fiEDGMENf
«' E,/A"'N}'1«t?I?1 11'1c*"ffiéI1'l.{.e1' was (%a1}c('1. 1ca.u'1'T1e(i (7(,):T.11T1s(f} for
::,1 p-p£3%'H£u_1i:_:..Submitietc} that the a1I1m.ml. 11915; 2-1131?:-1(Tiy
t:.Qe:"1 .£i~s~_gi'c.a$i1€1c1 by \-va_v of c"}'1ec;u.c-: 21:16 it was known
AA Qn}y'"e:1'fi'.t:~1" 1.11:3. app1i<*.ai.i<'m xva;-ass filemi secrki1"1g
'--.. '_pr¢~.:*:nissi:n to c1cp0siI'. the a.1nm.1111. 'E'1":m'cf01'c, Ihc
T deposi1'.' alreaciy m fie? be 1*a1t'ific'*d.
.' I
2. I1": x-'i«:.\.x«' of 1l"1c> e11')(.)\.-mt s1.1bmission.
pc1'1nission to cicrposil docs not 2--wise as the dc-_-*.-;;_)()si{
has 21I1'ea.dy bccn made.
{-3. Sri. Panel I"). I{e11'C;___>;()w(i2k {EEKCS._I1012i~(,'(' i"('>:',: V'
respc)nclen1s 1 to 3.
4. Ht-:2=11'ci both S;i(_i::;s;. A..$*-1.1% és$LT.1,ts".V.i1A":m}l\r€.(i
only 1*¢:ga1rdi21g the 112119 CH1'.._ix1'11.ere.:s'{*.()1;(1(¥1'cC2;: by {ha-'2
(3(m11Tnissi011er. in '\..:j_i.é;w (if 'l.§§_1"?\vf' "§fc'1.i('i doum by the
Apex Court' in iI1_e_ 'c:--2:1:;svc?_ :_(')'i' 'CQ)1*i#::1r1fa! I£"l.'%Lil'2-1£']('("
C()n3___}Je:1:_:3.r VI.;'i~"1.:1i.t_@-id»\fls "F'/1(.;!'1t1. Nasir 1'L'p()l'1'.L'(_'1 in 2009
AIR §)£i_V"cI1l'Jlt'*. will be an" 7'4.»'2'3?rE:> from
f:,.i?1§lg_> Vciaie <)I; (__?'}V.21.m1 applia.1i'1cI' {iii the paylncnt
'--Ais-.}'11Q1(i:f5%"*ai';=V12%. A(*(%()r(}i11gIy. the i1'11c*1'c¥*s;l p()E'ii()II of
1.
136.. (fifgi C1′ is modified.
5. T110 appeal is clisp()sc(i of 2:c'<.'():'(Tii1'1;giy_
z'~\m(.)Lmt in <:i<.'}3}if-1' be» i1'zu1si"c=?1*11~.("l to iho
~1-
WC.C2mrr1issinner and the 1f>a1Ea_z’1(*(“- be 1’&:’«.fi1.IT4i:€1.i”4i’3355′ ..
Ihc app@11z;11’1i. I:’zssL1n;u1<'rc Ccm1pa–my.
Dvz":