High Court Karnataka High Court

P Vishwanath Shetty vs K Balachandra Shetty on 3 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
P Vishwanath Shetty vs K Balachandra Shetty on 3 March, 2009
Author: K.Sreedhar Rao S.N.Satyanarayana
 

3 E%§3'§. ;x2'.::.;:; 2 3 5   '

{E4 THE, Hzcm eVA:*r:é«:1 ' 

:>A*:'§:§ 'mas '?E~§%: 3&9 £T}A"\;' ::i>A:;?1;%%=":e"::%:«§ 2£3{§€§'  

?RESENT A
'§'HE: aQN?BL£«: ;aA:%.5a;s*rv:<::§f§ :'i§.»s3%§i;«:§::§;é§&§§'V_:E%}és§§§"" 
  5m____ , j _ fl ._ 5
"'i"}~§}':E; §~i£}E'€'BLE3 zséR.£:1{és*§:<§§;:.,----mT£»':_ E3 ':<;::;:s;~i §i'?j'§'Tf'_:'
?s!:_AJOR;'f?; O1 =<:;«$:~, 3 ;»=;~..;v:A:r\;.
:1 §$?;~».m:, R:»%':"2,?.%11*£::::v<,"*f'~E:A:*»'z'$:iv.;

  1" V T_ " ' ::x;§§>0::m3
 §.,fi;.LB?.{':H
T3;%.E'\?{}:%LfiRE

 :2'  "-.;~.z: R §'~Iz%RES§~E SHE'???

' °'S{S RAGHi}§~7%A§»f§ SHETTY
MAJOR, Rffl "}'06f4§ VISHK%fAVAf€i
21$ Féiiififi, KERR
MUMB,s%3

3 JA.HNAV§ SHE'???
Wjifi RAG¥~§UE€§;§'fi S¥i§§T'i'Y
Evi§§J{3R, Rf?) '?{}E;§~'-'E, 'sfESH§5£.§£V&I"§E
2}; R{'}A§}, }{HE,ZF€
MLEMEAE

Ig.

 '
s
E



 

CH

}§

aw}

2 ism §szg.a:1:s;:a;€;~»'

RAGHUQAM SHETFY

Sjil} SHEEENAPPA §S§~£E§'E"E"';'
Ms"%.JGR,, R,/O '?Q6f4, ¥'§SE¥\Es.?2%'¢'A?€I
2} ROKKB, 

ML3'MB5§.E

SUBEESE SHE'???

Sjf} {ER 2% 3&3'???

MAJGK Rm RAMEESH' mvas   
E FLGOK .3 9 R059  
ANDHERIWES1'

MUMBA:

VENKAPPA S?£E'§"'§"Y 

3/0 céfianmiaa $1.91???   _ 
MAJGR, Rgé} Avsayqmz , ;;:3:>, $V  .__ _ 
Sm S'E:C"§'iC}N, fiMB%iR?$-A'E'f§§-. ;   

A*:'**::; L--.:-1%}-~£.E;';"£""i'"f{.. _  ., ' -
3,; <3. Viifé §~{fi5TEa?j_'E3T'_13;' «..;<3gE;":"'f;'i.'=;?
E*«iFs.}'€?fR,*R,?Ci' A¥3?;P%'§'}'i_'§ } 43:5;

313:: s§::<:*":'_i:::2'~:v,',--.A:«;;.;B:~3:~:;"::«:A'm

V. Z .: . }'}%THE%$E D§.}i"Sv:J----:-wry

3_;':::§ "€_Ei!E*Ei{A'E'fiP?'a 353;'???

T " 'MEi:.}{3Q'; ;R'j--€.i3 AVAN'£"'§~§'i , 2-$333
 SA: .S.E§{f§i»{§'N, &EviBE§R1'§A'§'E-§

 3»: .§é&i§§A§§YANA SEE'???

:3:.;:;:»:_ ifif§"'E3 ii P 3&2???
Rf»;-'} sagws {:mpau%s:}

LAL8§{}§i
..»'§%AE§{}RLGR%3

F: BKLAPPA SH E???

8/Q Kfififéafifi 38'???

we 3 vmmpgg; {EAREEEEN
mmzgass,

'%%NG§.i,C2RE

:-::_ mivmazixzss SirEE'§"E'Y
Sjéflz KQRAGA 35%'?
Rm S 'i?'£"§E§¢i?L¥:"_i (§33;RE3E:'.?~E'

$/,



 

13..

35

11+

E%§="A  E35 

C.e§>

KS 13%! 85%.: L
Mfifié GALORE',

M §'~§.%RAYA?'%A SHETTE'

SI/{,3 K N£~'«:N-J2%?PA S§~I'E'}T'§"§

MAJCIR, Eff) Rfi} $E~§E';"£"E"Y"S {7Z{}Mi3€)i§§"¥'§3
E,-ALBAGH

?v'§AN€f3":AL{}R E

K SARFGJENE SEE'???

33,38 NE N2"sRAYflNA SHEET?

MAJSFL age R/G SHE-""£""E'T';"fS {:is:y§§*{§:,%:s::j"  - . «. "  A T

L%'?&LB7§§Gv}9i
E'vE,&N GALGR E;

K S%éASEi£E;AiA s;§~:s:2*§Y  -.  " 

W} {is 8 NaRAYANA--..S}-zE§--f:'3i. . f ~  
magszyfi, age R/Cr SH§§"f'?§.';"§;* §':O%s§!,Tv§?£)V;_}"?€i"}
LALBAGH    g V  

Ea§ki§'§{}P;L»€V3V§9§w"§"%;..  u

Ji%:E::%:::§éLg1;";~§§i<i:«;;§§""_; '

_3.,:*{; 1.39513; E?' E:»i.E;{"§{}E§Z'"
.. «.{:1§;EA;;§OR R}'£1'¥. ;':§§~£E'E"FY €E()?v£i3'(§iE?uf§i}
 A  ilffigfifga  ..... 
 _V §Ji?:E'€§3,3§;i;:"}E€?:i

' .__ViJ$i};'_:€_g :§§'E'é:§E
 WI?) ;3?r1E:'%£'fi§~$LAL %~§E€}§E':-
 §g»::?:1;:::V:<' ago S¥~iE'i"F"'£' cc;§§p<:::::-z{}

L{'5iLs;F3;'~';GEi5 ?v§z§?€if§ALC3§€§§

"~«.SE{§%fANfi;§*E{)& 8i~+1?i:'E"'1'Y
aw M ?€AR.fis'fAi\é1f: SBEESTTY

'M?xJfi'R RIG SHE??? QOMPOEFEQB

EALB&@?i
MR5: GALQRE

4/



 

4 E€§3'£'--: ;:€%§;§:

'18 SUJA1'?IA Si§E?TTY
WI?) 8. SHiV§;§'-¥P'J'~§i':'éA S}iE'_F'F'E' _- " -
EVEAJQR R/Q SHE-'"i"§'Y C3()?\J1PGEJi"§E}"--. « 
Li3sLB§¥GH, §\£1A;'~§GfiLC'RE§ ' 

;§ 5%: : '%'S%~iE'I'T"'E'   -~
:3_;=:3 LATE: $H£3E§'€AP?§. :<«g:&,,E*§?ffs*¥
Y\£é§«_§OR, :32, 2:  A£3v<_i'{:A'§"*§:S..~"§%;::::~2;R 19 }

3?}-{E8 RE?z'_?:  P'§LE=§} :;;_,§;; -g5'  (:93 9.;j@€s-é'v:::s;99 PASSEQ ix
0.3.3323

. 43£%9g<¢-;.i;:. :3?-v.:?,2§'E;['j—-VE1._§':3::3:…V..{;:'i'"*§ (31%; JEBEJGEE,
BANGALQREZ,"V.DEC-REE}NC} "*§:*:~;2=: ; £01? MONEY –

=”m’a.i3§:;§.”<;:§:':»r§i:%2<:"5:35: $353K HEARENG THEE my,
SREEB3e%R R£&Q 3;, ;i:y§s;L:§;<te:;2E:n: mg F-<32,-:ma;::*e<:;-;

_ fig: ta G M E :3 1*

'A :°éS'§:_si fiiefilffzrst piainfifim sntfiraéi imc: & writtsrz

Aé:g;:;rs:ii;r:i&:vr§£"–«<,i$«éfLi.iii}-62*E8'? wiifizz {he appeiianq' a%.§fa§.E\§s.}

\?§{"}n:€1"":,”npa.;13,-‘ was said

fiiace vaiué: of Rs.2G,G€gfiG€s§~« unziar Eixqfil.

_§§_s§.T’;G,{}€},€}GC*f~ wag paifi iewazfis $115 gart. sf éizé

étaizsifimration. Thé ‘baiazzitéfi <35 §€s.1§,€¥{},0Q{3;'« was agrztezi 10

be yayabie wifilin six months. E11 E1§(§',§ it was 333$

stipuiamé {$181 if 123131166 0?' Rs. }€2i,{}€},{}®{)j – £5 '§1iI}°{ paésiii an :32'

«—-%/

5 ;1':§ra rm:-:=; :3 :i.;:-%91s

befimz 3(}«{}Z%- i§$§, Eixfi %i’§3f{;}€}}8;{}i sshaii g§a.§g i§’z_%s:2?§:’:i:–i ‘ V-

p..;::. \>a:=°.::.f. 31~9’?~1§8§ ‘aiii tém aéaifi <3?" ::a§;z:1'€:::t:.," M '

'i'he Téékih re3pe:1<'§€::tj{i:fi:,.,fiafiii"was '£3%:§i"_; E§"ié1::z1g§ :ég.;_vA '

Bi:r€:’ ifi” the éiempaily as «:321 1:;”:1ij::9:”xia€t=:. {>”f_:i”it;:%
C{)I1S€I},fi.E1g wiizzess am}; 1m<§€::*
';ZXss.i?,§ mid $2, Tiizz: {pa ?"d_33£l€33_i§'};E¥
Eififlcfi, the Sui'; an }»?~'32. '§"3::e
first mfg N03 1:9 as have
2131 sig:::'€7€E"t;:%'}sB;a(ia an a;;2;;1i<:2'§3i.§ 35% iheiz’ pa:=;:e:’::’ {sf

” v _a;fic:_:”*:i:3j»;;_ T116 a.fi::n;_d; ;:;1s;:I:E. is aéiowaé zmcé aafikcésé. aziéfi. srsrimr

%=:;§’::i;e; t1%,a§~C%.’.:;.{f:;___éa%fi{i 9 :««§8~:9§s.

‘ ifimt a;:p€i§,a” E}? flied Writiazé Siaifimfifii

j <:<;£;t§é:§ai§:::gti?;.at {E13 suit is %3a.;:'I*€§ "E33; @135: "Sig 5:13: §}§8§}1§i§

.:§fiz§n.<3% §iav€ gmwer {Ff aiiemey sf §1'5:f& E'€@.2 fig 3:8 as an "$33

Q:-igiéwéaf '%:i§=:9P.} myii i?':2, Tha $1138: £3 fi:}SEi€.%,1E7E{§ wfitixmut $316

u '";s§ig,na*:a2res :3? Piifa, ?~iG,,'2 is £36 fizmrsfsm the mstéiufiozg af

{he gait is a fiifiifiifii ii". iii': furihfir stated fizai, {Em f';:3*$"£. fgziaimiff
S{1§}§§}i'fiSE£€fi the mai:£1'ia'i facm rfigagséizig the éaafi §':::;a.§:{*.ia§

::§1a§:w: af '£3.13 c<::m'p3::3}; azxci by m.iS:%§;re$@::'§.%;t:g {E13 fasia, '£234:

r" {E

5: E~€E¥'f2 §'*%¥3<f; 2:3 6' ~,

Shams are 382:}. {I311 this ciata cf §_§x'?.§ $316: 3;§:§gi:

izzcuzreti imge }(::ss§ tins: $§iE8I’€tS 2.x:m’€ ihéii’é’2=ré;t1′–.§%?€:;2″€’.E§’ fa»J:~e

value Hazica, pray {Err dismissaipf zi1::§«$::£i–§,T:A. I

4. T316 d:€fiwN<:s:i2 at" §§%f%:'m%2:1€
zienfgijag the aiiagaiian fisafe: h€ .§.S" gs:<§_;:'é5t}:A.t0 ;':§ie'v%:.?e;.:;$ac£ien
amd §m~1y€d fmsiiismissal '5s13_1§%;.V ' V &

S. '§'§:e:l tbs £3333 azzfi

{i{}<3§£3}1c'311?;€3.E'}f.'€i'€§"§€if2§%;£'f§ '::';;:§;§1i3z…iE1§:' <§:;.nie11ti1: Gf ‘aha gkziaifif

311:3 ciecfffiééi suii ‘iéivééazr {sf ‘abs §_3ia.:i:2.ii§1 “§”h&:

§’§”S’i’. @i€f€x::;:iéi;:’_:{ 1:3 ‘iii’ «’;’:~)§;”;’:¥*g§’?{~;:f-3:’ n ” V,

5.” _ ‘Ja§-xrazmri, ieaznétzi S31 C»i”_’iE.2i1S€§

VS”:”:;’g3§f§i4§”é:’%:§§i:%?f figs: f<::§.E:3Wing €j'i§"CE§i§}S§&I3.€€S to asgsvli {E352

Aj%1c1§:§:§;€in§.'é§3jL{i fie:-";1:;f.7m:§ cf ihfi"; ma} <::ur’§:~

3} A’Iz’7§}€ §:IEa;§fi_:’:’..~:::§iia}i§; is get signsii E3}? p§t€s.E”€a.2 is .38. 336
V awssmiéfitié; 2211 8:6 giaixat gives mat suggeai. tiizai {Em ;3§’:;€.?=ée.E
A’ ‘T:;3_:%:1:§%1::3:’u£s::::§ ‘:9 §z*os€:cu'{£: tbs Sufi an %}€:ii122Ef <3? piffs.
'§'E=:§i?; £3 18. {in '$316? :f:«'*::Emr hanfi, figs giafiii. Suggesis Ehai,
it is a casa 53?? _"§0i21r:1€r Q5 piaizfiéffs and go-mam of caugss {jg
action. Each (3126 sf Q35 gaiailziiifs assert that 816 Sui': 32$
ixisiitsiifié in "€i"i€.iI' ézziiivéiiuai C8;'§}&€i€§' jeézfiifg 'ass:-étfig Qtiam"
piaitiiiifg.

(E3) ‘?”i?:€: ‘dfiléiiilfiiilfifii. to 23:43: cmma iiiéti fig fifffiifiifiii :§$§€1’§’§’:’%.:;:§
fiffif igééaizfiéff as 818 g3{::%:€r 3%” aiiarzzt}? Kr: “Sim }3i’E.E§. $33.2 is

‘§$ after iigyfifi fig-*zéz«3§s {sf tétafi izzsééuziéssia sf 23:16 gzaéi. ‘§°’i’;§é

3? E€E–‘?’2’% §’*§{},§ 23;’ E-¥7’=_E:2€}

§ifl1fifi€§.3m.’?,§E’£” iéffacieci is afifiz’ iiiii s::i:°’§; of {he _§§i::%€;9;{5;s:_§’§3:;_.

Eéattgzcasz, therit is gm vsiiid §Ei1E§'{i’§”i,§?;i(}1i 5}? ‘£316 %:s§»%f§2§fi’:a’,.T’

§’€{>,i’£i 33:7: 38. –

{if} ‘?E’1€~: agrfiémerii at Ex,P.;»Z €£isc1a:;s€é;:»__ that $16 _-amw:>m1’.i, 3:’$

iii} ‘:36 §f:a§;”a’i3i€ 91:1 01′ be’f<3r€ iE§1»§3'»=S'§ i§::e$'u.i_E ES fé§€:'€i=<3.z:':' M

"§"«»§2 which is bfijgcsfid thé ;3€1i0§"«c;f i§.gniE9_ti:;{.V_’ ‘¥’lf§@ Q apggfifiaxai ‘$€Cau$€
of i”fli$;tfi_}:}1″6’8§:12i§v:§;§3(3I£ p?{f=.rcE1asfid éifttae ShéZ’:}’fi3. in

thaiiz. virsuz f:’:itE’.”é2{}§Ti7EiTi8.(tT;.’ii’£ZEs.’;.’i£i§’ Exfii E is voisi

‘?C u”$j’I”§. Bhaéi, <:0u:mei ft}? :*:«5.%§i.3.

§”ZL’@z”§}'”5€¢_§§;;§§:a:’:’.$e:€es Page 583% raiéimg Qf ‘ihfi Bamfiagr

_ §v§igE:§. “–i;”i{3:»;é:I9t Affé 1313’s §3G;i’?’¥.£3{‘.i’l{Z??;§}’Ei §§2(,x«mfa £§{::’€:.;r £13255
$63. 232, ané the é€c£sin 5:?’ the: ?ai:::a ifigés Qsgmrfg
‘£113.: ésgharé Effs ?§§§£§T£{HT£??’§€§§ §{a,s£m aired {‘2§§’é§?’S fififi? {$82

= .2 $35.3 Painzz 3.243 :13 Eariizg hame, éihié jg3<;ir;'£ mat {he 8§Sfi3S.t_C€
V of signaizzrfiss 9%' sama C3? the giainfifia in {hit piaim weazifi 132:3:

§:'.:.ssa}3'.a:i:;~:E$ ihs gfiaimé. ami (10:33 ms}: r€;;1da:' 313%: had $21 E379.-*.

8 E%FA N£:3..5;= E35 1__§€¥'}

§3'u:ii'ii~:::* ii is heirzi that the making Signatures be:iatfi3i1§:' ' V.

plaént wouid 11:3? make the suit bayrfid by ' V

8. {‘}11 the facts it is s”:17’-{‘.a:1fiV;7:é”t’€::E._ {ha-:1, fi_£:V?’3’i

plaimjff E136. fsiaci {ha pi1t0§s;’er ?0f ”

pitfs’Pé0.”.2 :6 18 at. 25-{>3~1982″‘–ai<:–ngwi£h;–.::;e..§:aii;§}"'::§s:;
the technicai Gbjection by the £i¢r:§'iE:5:1éé:tVfisA,'§111 afifiiicafiiorx was

fiieé for amendment crfa cmzrt after
hearing bet}: ihgffi « Psccotfiingly
the amancimeixfiis ylainiifl" as pcawer
of atE.0I*:1a:y'*'ff«’a:%r%…0£9igi:1a1 power of attorney
is 3113:) it arguefi that {ha {echmlca}.

defvtzcis in u’i,_hé p1a 1i_1€:4V’:§:r%:. §g1’o;::€3″1f§T cureé by the necassarg

amesfiméxgt. Thlér-2f<:re,&Vé£ caxinat be argued that $16 Sufi is

§:§s:;;»u;i;e—;i_ 311:3 bagrimi by time,

dccisien of 'rim :1':-Quzicii the facts

V — éiséicgg fin: suit is Whfifl %;11Siit1§t:2& '£123? 'ihrefi pizaimifié

jainfiy ft)": I"€C(}V&I."y {ff moncyu {Ema mama Mamzn B33 was

_' i3§s7'Ivia:1ag&r for iZ1r€:=: brsthars W119 $19.6; éent 193:: is {he

-~d’é,fen:;iani. ‘the suit was instituted on bahaii’ Qf thme

brothfirs ifireciiiara} {I36 piaini. was verified 311$} Signeszi ‘bf;

Mahini Mamiia E”).-as; the gatition was fiisci by Meézifii §§§G§l”t1E1

3335; {Q amend ‘£11: <:ause title: is impiéad him as –:s3~;;i:ai:;§;i:"£

C?

i} E33335; E’§=::2.€i> E3 ,5 ‘:’7~’r’%_<_,%9

"§'£3i": §:ria§ ::%m:zr"£ aiismigazté. $26 Sui? cm fizz": gmumi :;:;2:' §;éE«:3%:.$%,§%;_.

Efiahxgzz ifias wig} sig§:<é<;': ems} vfiiiiiiéié ms; §}§€_¥¥;;£:§~i'ii§_§SV iii:-iiii ._:é1<}

§§i}{§i€31'i§,:i; am}; 3316 a§}§}§ii3'cE"{i{')§i. €13 cszgzfizf E7
Saki faciis ‘This: P§’.’§515}’ C£}1§§E€?fi sx§:{§. T;§%:;.;A§:;t%§{‘?.;’+::z:1§.§§{:§”:’§ »a1″&

zlaméd 3% ¢{>~§:3.;T:)§::§i;f§$.;”””i’E;,:%” ‘z:a}1.1jLe:$ 0:5 .£é:€;>E:i;.::r:§ Ex-iazzgri axscfi
Eiéfzefifiz’ iviaiiusi E; ‘

‘N-=Ii :15: bifircfi S’is.*zi::§_§; ..<3_1_;f{f; 39:' :%%.{i fzgejg, G3'
fiitjhez" of 'i}.1;=im'.{§;~ afis:§:;n3f_};)i: t}:":»_ r::;;::1r:§;–£afE.;~: the Sngzits, fin? siifi £5:
23535; cmmr1{‘};s::€§ fiiat §’e;e’EEai::ti§°§; 0:,
at any r&2;.¥..<:; t}'.z;1.f.'%{2h;%'§.ta::i_'§'2:is:§§3{1:::1__§:3ugf§'3'*a 1101:. 3:0» his §_¥"€if:Tii€i{§ as :3:
<%s~p1a§;;:E:iff §f'G3i3f§'§§Tii?V':V Efiaiéax’

2%? 1, has; 3:::a_颒€:i1é’ feiiééwizig sbafiwaiiiailsr

$23′; –»”§f”h6.§i”‘?i{s:;f§i’s*;V§:ip$ 0%” {E13 Privjg; élfiaauzzséi ::::’bs§:z:w:§; :2′: E13: $3?

.s;i’ég,:’3é§f}VV’§§.?{i1;; V’ €513′: Efixers wag rm mie thaéi a gmrgegz 1’§.£ij?§1£”:{3: 33

»’}pi;*”<.'in9'z§§'§'_'v_i:(; giaifii. wag 239%: :9 Est iifiaiéié as ea _;}Ea'%;:%;.i'§§
zzrilzigs h§.sig3.1'9&:i§. am? %'€f:E°'ifi€{§, 336:5 géizairst {}r<§a.:' E3 Ruifi 14;.
'%%J31}:i','E'.§. ':€q2i;§:*'€:$ figai &s.?::3;"};' piaigfi sfizauiié 'ms 'S'§g5Ti€_".{§ 233$:

W.,;;}}'2§i11'i:if:'?€ .éi:'1c§ big yieazier, if 3:1}; has, iii': visw ezsf %E:s{«: §3:'£v§»="

{§§:::u_;1ci3{?{iss::3?:.»;iern Ea 'E33 1:1"£:::';}1f°a§eé $0 ag Es; mazzzzz $3113': a '§:%§§'£§§I.i'i.
aiamiizi E36 sigmtfi Es}; ab: Eeagi £3115 $35 &iS=f} Eiiéazl

;*'%.,&;E:ari 'sf, Efizahammaéfi giasm, 323% 1535: ms and ELEE 34

;:;:::;7 gm: 3233': 2%} 336?} {$8}.

23%} SEE rzigards Ihé wsiéifitatiazz <35 ihfi gziaézzi ix: f;Ei:€: fizsizmi
Cfififi it srsag 2,n:=,:"§fi&£§ $3" {f"S§:usE1e§: as agant cf the :'?g§<2§ Li;{I:;i'{§:(3;
{;)§3;'.§3iif§' iwiex 1}. it was ms': vsfified by ;'§§ai;%;1':':if§ Nei. {}:'::i::~::* €35
fink: 15:3 caf the, {iiszfi 1"r0€r<=,(i11.re €Z3i.)<§_e X"af§£}%,11:Z"€$ i'§1a§.iTt::% §.'}i8.§.i:i
sEm':fi:'i Ea verifiaé by $19, §:iai:§::if§' or @336 :33" fiifi §}§z§i::Eif§'::'; G£.'§,1%fg"
Sfimfi ::;i}":€:r gyergmz gisrgwfid ':0 fine $§§8f.'i':3ffi§'fiGI.}. 0f 32:': {j';+:s2_:1*% is
'be': 22<:qu2:i::t.::::% v;2é£:Ez '€325 §a€:':'i.£§ £2? ms: (2352:: {}':'<im: 8} R111: 13,

ii A RE'<""A E'*~J«:}.s*EL:1Z3;'

pazfiaa. fize péaixzt is Ehfsrefsre £101; isfirifisd by 3:1? Qf the
p1a3711'£iffS 3;" by a pamon acquaizztrtszi with the facris of {he
sausax I Woliié iiiifi ":0 imprcas ugjan C<:s11:"Es E'EiiC€;"i'.:'§5{ig'
pifiagiingg and afiivsrs authésiized is rtjcreivzé piaafiings jihe
ilecéassity anci impartanca Gf seeirzg fiheir req'z3ir€me:':'~;$ 'Raf

0113163: 63 Rifles 14 and 1 and cf Quiet T', Rifle §j;u,_'z':1:*€* _
p'rop€r}§,: compiied with. The defect; <31" the absf;~:~:–:2§:~:* A' _
prepay vcirijiicatiaii Csf the: piaint is hawever ezme (.'§'.fi:1i{(.3§§€':%2§:_:¥§;;::3'T€".'.7 ~
and 5:3 a mere irmglzlarity. Tim fiefenéiani d:£d{V__n<'i;+t; €2':)je{:t Ea?
it. in ER 18 A3 395, casa ciecifiad _h.3;. :_}_3z"c:e_'ju§;gé:§, itxiéas
heki that GI" a mare quastion (pf détfzéct caf v'€i;"§f1€:aE7tL:vI::_.Vit 71$ i1'cirt
necessary far an appeélate (3011:? to pa}? a;;éij;~a€i€:11;{i<::fi iii" f::.'–§;x:€'33f_'

any stays '£0 rectify a defect in the \:erif:§«:ai.i;):1 of g_~;;1a:n~:;. * '

2"?) If €ii€f€"){:'–t$" §.xj:g. to = =i§f1t;~ Sfigiaatigfe vefification {if
pre3sntatit::n_m-f "§h5fg31aiI;t4 '(731'l'€i_C13liff€:§A:'" on a flay subsaqzlani to
the date: 91" i°i3i11g_»-fi2»e.31';it, 'a';1i§:LAsii:a:t¢;o£"*v,§I.asti:ution ef the piaint
is mot c11 a ;1ge"<:?. t:;;«1fE1e '%1ihSi¢q'ugnt date, 84 BL-R 628 {AIR
1932 Begum 3'::*:;a;ii.1:,R'::j54 Caz-38a:""§ai1 19:27 Ca} 37%; im :34
All 57; .' and ILR 46 A3} 637: AIR"

1Q25 A11 139}. . \’v*’h&::I:.é;p1a§:i:,§.s…m—sig11ed er re~vm”ified it may
or may :1c;t:v..a1mm11:”€ f::s”:33,1161:£imes:1i :33″ {ha piairxi, iivfin
when a p1ai.t:it…z;$” amsmiefis-“th.s amezxdmsxzt, I’€1=;»’:”i.i€S hawk E19
{E13 mate” Sf {i1e”~:§L1itVexc:3pt in some casafig :::.g,, when ‘trhs

..am&f1_§:m§:n1 gdés iiezszgyarties or gampertieg, Sec 34 Born LR

6225:’ (A112 @932 Sam 36?}, Mohini Kumar ‘xi’. Nia

I%’k)ha:nm_a{i~,”‘~;At§}?_ 3344 {la} 4, Nallakumara V. Pappayi

fimmal; ~,¢x§’z.?. ’19f§:»::f~?~~zv1a.c1 219, Weidon. V max, {$337} :9 (333
3994 Jazijarsfihan iéiz-sshfire La} V. Sib Pmsad. Ram, $341512 43

‘ Ca1§-5: (,§.;::?z,:,i’91? ca: 341;,”

3:1-,_.’§’he rafis laid down in the aiaove éecigians Sq:’uare§°§»*

« ‘£9 the facis on hand. in the i3:1$€:a:’1t case, gfiifs. Féix E

.f£§ %.28 had fiied the suit, the. piaiizt was sifiggd 311:3 Vfififififi by

pitfi N0. Li. X?’ the time ef fiimg ixfthe suit {Em ph€3f.O capiag G?

231:: §}{)i%?”€I’S of attoznejg cf PiiifswN0§2 to 3,8 avers fiied iépssm

Eha abgesfiaan “$33; tize othar side, formai {iefsct was Iwticezii, 321

Q{/_

:3 Km Na{af33;_:_§€s§

12¢ The terms of EI;X.P.i2 tines not say

amourxt is is bit payabie an :31′ befsre 3 L-G3~

a rider ti;1a’t if tha amount is not paid, «§’1’§iaréés–t.__.Vs’§1g§§”b’§

payabie at 1§’2/o 13.3. w.e,£ 31,>7._198g;–$315

canzxat. be construed to mean }L.3.1*§;_8€éA 2′ t3 éfitey
date for p33,-rmreixat 0f t’i1€::sa§3j;eu_1’1f. ” 0tgi«1éVf”i1i§:::d, €336
Ex.P.2 expiicitlfg Sfipuléitfi; item {ha
éatfl of EX.P.2 am 01′ befrsrfi 6-

?’»~198§. ‘Fhé” .}.§LB}itEi’£iOil Waum be
5?. 1989;’ iri;§t§i*£€1t;§7i£””a11′;{)4–Q?~ W32 Within the
pmtioti ‘.

33. S question ef fiauzij $15 fimt.

….,A_v(ief¢:{1i;ian;t’ a;f’t£r §t:;1::j__i_;_a:;e cf ghares vifie E’.-X.P.§ {ii 22–Q8»

Managing Dimctor of {he CC:fl1}_C_3E3.11jy’ anti

xveafkad “:i11V’«.’f1.{ha§£j;;.V€}apacit}* fear afimost t;E1ree ymrs iii} Ex,E3.2.

‘V ‘£’he’.44?djQ§:§*;1;;%:c2§;ti;.:}:1 was flied before BEFR when the appeifiani

K V’ V’ flags .. :}m Ma11a<gi11g fihectnrk The appefiant acknmvieégad the

.' to pay the amaunt 1111:1122" E;x.P.2, which is aimest

"'tiém{é years after EX.V?|<}.r 13:1 between 111$ gaid perriod ihf:

appeliarxt had full kxzowltdge of {ha affairs 0f the Ccmpany

and csnsatiousiy axeczxtsci E1x.P.'2.Ti1¢:rfo;:*t:, it 11$ uniemabie 'far

the appeliant ta (tontenfi that ms CQI1f,I'3C§Z i3 vitiamd by fiaué

14 EFF: :\:¢.5::*s;.%:-%~?;§§

14. in View caf the masons and c:iisc’:3.ssi(§ii’s ..;x1a%:i%%:_.__ ‘

above We iimi that the judgment and €1€(31’€tZ’.}T}a’}.S;a$tf{:i.V

Hie}. juége is prgper. Hsncte, appeai ii;-is} €§i$:i_fl§i§S§1§é..: 4′

& 3’31&$ge

WZNS H