EN T1313 EIEGIE CGURT OF I<Z.?§§{}€Fa"}"n'* Is.' A A'? IKAEEGALOEEE, \¥.§'.}éG.é2§3 G}? 28%
&.14fr:31--§45»£'2 C3}? 208*? & N560 317 2:38?
1
15% THE H36}-I COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALOj5?ifi
DATED Tl-11$ THE 29% DAY 01%' MAY, ..
sesame L
me a-;o:~a*aL£ am. JUSTECE '%ae.:<.§§A7;L%@'%" 'T "
WRI? FETITIOEI 39.6358 cg,'%145eaxi-%3;«¢scé§~%fk J7
or 2009 & 14560 cm 2_009"i..QM~RES~ 3,
ggwgggx; '"" V' 'V'
-2 PARPSKALA PQWER Pvrue -
NQ.$3% ?1.ooR:N,sAvEm:;A2 s*s:::EEj."%'., V
SESHADREPURAM,BANGA'LG¥?»:E~2Q,fx .
&Es'3.B'{i'€S 92953709: -- V g 1
A,v.s,mAgu.
2 %<:E§L"£"R${$§¥flF§~vff.}¥E'?§f;;%? AL:§':§a..m;:':c:u .
NEE'§"s'GRt<iNG ;*=~x+*"r:..m§ ;
r~:o.4moL.LAe'z.c:;2La:~:'«a-. ..
-.3?NAG.¢.RJ£%NGR§;€3.RE=-.?5;..
RERBY as "E3%'REC'fQR; _
:q:=r.:é,EE9A; _ " '
:a:a1s,:::=:_ea:=:,4 _ . >
.*~%.$.§'efE§~é$3aR STREET:
sé3f%%Aa;%2?uR;a:¢1', ..
BA.:§G:.aL{:_gRE--.2s, .....
* 3%: {F8 DZARECTCER
» gay. aAaz.,:%
4 " %<:;:.m:::~;:::::'.s.,<3§=_::':+.*:'E i5.JFO?v€AT§ON
:~am:.IcRK:r~zr.;jw':" Lm,
m;--.s,_: ,oo.LL,aR.'.VccLo5e'a
. J.P.:~¢AeaR,8ANeALeRE-?8;
. ' REP'.B'%' was azagcxoas
::n;.TaEEp;:~:<
E'?§TEONE§RS
" gsfgér: :V';sw':sH zu waaAw¢4z & BASAVARAJ, ;\S's.'QCA"E"ES}
if-é 'i'1~i!:' EEGH {.3{3U}{'§'C}1*'i{Ai~l?%A'l}§.KA kl' BAN€32\i.{_}i{E 'éé.P.Z'\.E0.éE§3 U3" 2&8
3: i45<'£E«H54§ (3? EGG? & I-'$5600? 206'?
1}»? THE EH31} CTQURT OF E{AR1'~§A'§'AKA AT Bfi3'*§G}'xL'C}Rl7; ¥'v'.}'.'z'sEc».éa2S3 O37 2398
3;. iséfief»-}«?u35é'a'.r3 OF 23%? 3:. 345-69 SF 23%?
4
1:
AND :
'3 STATE Q?" KARNAYQKA
REF"E3'z" {TS CHEF SESREYRRYS
VEDHANA SOUDHPM
BANGALGRE.
2 THE PRE%'~e'$EPAL 3E'{.'2F2E"fARY ._
TG GGVERNEENT; ;
GEPARVMENT -$3'? ENERGY?
2N3 FLO{3fi,\"%¥ . _
THESE war: §~é":':..":f::»;-;f?;=.A A:R'E'.:::&L::;3.'.%':::;séR":«;{m"ec:.Es as AME}
22? as THE cc>:~e;sT:';r;:.r:":;xz'--.<:;.*=L 'zwma .VPa.:w2:s:s3 To mam": 'ma
GGVERNMENE-R2--v 32;: i§,r:;;a:s1:2;§R'-3f;4E._»s2_15PREsem=a.r::-2s 5:4: "ma
PETWGNERS 9'-.-1 €3,.>:~s.2ow--v:9E=.ANN£x.£,E:. we as RE€3PECT£VEL'{ ma
E%'»i%~3A%'»£CE%e1s'2P~3T <:f.::r'-.'2*e<2;r;_= iM'3Tfi.L£EB«. ,r:APA:::":"v 0? "ma mite: Hvaa.
scaazvas, --------
*2';-gag wear? P£2fm§fjQ:sxé'a§5'rv::r<:"a 0:4 ma PRELSMSNARY Hsaaama
QN 'S sszgup, 'ms SAY,' "{Hi§, x.:.»<:,:1.::f-2*: Mae mg FQLLQWWG:
these gatfiicng have saught far a
éirabiiégn, v_r-i%:"é;:;:§§*1g fiwe Gavemment ---- secarid respondent
gcjngidszé the raprmentations cf the petitianers dated
Azguigust 20GB vide Armexures E, E? to E3 respactively
Ifé TH}-I HEQH (,I{3Ui{‘E’ {JF KA.R.NATAKA XE’ B.=3:?s§{ii%LQ£€}:’L W.P.N€3.é2S3 DP’ 2633
<3? 145é31~E45«$2 (H3 2509 & 14560 DF ?(}{}9
ER TEIEE HIGH CO§_?§~iT OF E<ZAR2'5ATA1€.A AT }3A2'u'{1ALGRi2 W.P.}€o.f§2S3 CH? 2333
& L154}-34542 SF 2009 5?. 1~'£5e{${}C}F 2939
3
for enhancement of the ingtaiieci capacity 0f the mini
Hyde! schemes.
2. I have heard ieamed cwrxsei appea’fifi§V”:.fof”vv.,
petitioners anci iearneé Gavemrnent Pieader H
far r%pczndents_
3. The cmiy grievarmeg of V4;3e;Ei%ianer§..”.%_
patitiens is that, in pursuance by
ihe State Governme:’§_,._”‘:«– pe–Ié§iti§?:;f1″‘e§f$g i*:a_ve ‘fiiéd the
appiication for estabiishméijt Mini Hydei
Prejects. Th_e appiicatian and
the rasqgivgandeiiifiv’iafterflifirisidéring fheir request has
iaeued app§'{:;:§fiaat:éV’s_s2¥r:§;ti::::fré’ order an 3″ November ZGG1.
fifze fih*:e…..::sf’ex1ensit3r1 ta ctbmpiete the said
‘w;a ss:v'”g§{a’fi.ted by granting another six monthg fiy
their ,_:6rder.’i§i§ts§d 23*” Nawember 2005. When things
TT”‘~.-4..__%s%7oed fiaqé, petitimxers herein have suhmified their
T:fépi*%j é:ntation cum appiicaticsrz in the smund respcndeni:
‘ j:-Seeiking enhancement af ta insiaéied capacity cf the
IN ‘E’i~1E HXQH {.?{JL£R.’i’ £3}? §<.AR,NA"£"AKA ASE' BANELSALGRE '}si'.PkNQ.i')3r:E§3 £3}? 2993
:2: Ifi5é1v=§452$2 GF 25%? 3: M5653 GE? 28013
as "$3213 mm: COURT 0;? KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE '§%'.P,?%0.62§3 9;? 2838
& 14541-14552 G? 259; & 345.50 3:? 2939
rf
'?
f%§.’)6C?fi’é& pmjecis ad’ the peffticmers, in the iighfi 9f the
same terms and ctrmditions of aiiaiment, keepirrg in.g{ia§c.%%
the heavy investmerxt rnacie by flame peti*ti:f*;3§:%§.’A ~
rmparzdents have neither c;onsid.v3s*e-ci4Anc’;§’ fékfiffi “a;:_’;y
CiéI.”;§$it3fi an the representstiens “”s;1.{t*;:§;*ii9t’te<:i"
Therefore, the petitioners %ier§¥e}c2» feff 'Vita
prfient these petitions' ~sgeek§i"i§ 'épgfifogriaié "reiiéfs 32-;
stated supra. ' 2 ' % '
4. 1′-‘after’ ca’r*.sa¢f§J5 bégfufia¥ fif”§ié ifi$i§§i’iéi avaiiabie er:
$33, ‘It five’ in fact submitted
datailed1″‘:epfes:=§fii£§€i:$n$4V_%’arifiiatég’ ‘Annexure E, E1 to E3
respectively “af%§ August 2fiO6 to the second
..geeiU<'Efig;" ***** enhaficerrient 9f the instafled
of their raspecihie mini hydei pmjects
dué ihvestment maée by them Gfi {ha same
azrsdt' canéiiians. The said representations cf the
T.ps«:§itier:érs am naither mrmidered hf)?' taken any decision
_ "'r<eépéng the reprwefitatio 5; {bf the petitioners in
IN 'I'!-{E Hiflifi f.3{.}U1{'£'iLJ1**' RA?-3'.?'aéA'1'ABLA AT BANGALORE W,PANa.é353 L}? 2388
& 1»1541~E4§42 OF 23$'? 3:. E4560 OF 20$?
‘ :31’.
IN’ TEE EIEGH COSRT GP KAR}€A’FA}<1A AT BA';€<1ALOR£7\'-V.Pu}39,62§3 {BF 21338
8.: iiifiéi-145$? 017 280? & leifréi} C}? 2%?
3
abeyance and not taking any decéaion wiihinjfiae
seasanabie time is net justifzabie. Therefereyxé.(i§§i_:3iI=f__ ‘
expressing any opinion can merifs of the c3$:;véf;:VV.§t”é§%ouié”
sufféca for this Cesar? to issue: appfgpriafaf?c*:§4ireéticm”i::’i:j~’t’if{e;v_
aampeient authczrify.
5. fiaving regard fa the 0%’
the 633%, the writ ;§e*ii;1§¥0ns;.’;3e:tificners are
dispczsaci cf wéih_:”a__’dir;eéf§:.::%:§:: ifispcaricient to
ccnsider thfi by pefiiicmers
herein “t€2″””E3’€:*e$pmtiveIy 3%} dated
13*” Aug:£;;i-st the same; in accardance
with iavgg asV’°e;:pt:-;::¥i::i’¢::v.:jir-;_i:3I”:e:’§ passibée, at any rate, within
~t.hre;§””rr:’bhths fram the éz-ate of receépi cf
‘€;:%;;:3§4_i’.éi*’if mi: airway cansiderefi and dispczged
Sd/–
Judge
ah: ‘mag Hiiihi {;’.¢Z3E,%R’i’ my K.fi.fiNA’§’A1«L% AT BANLEA, L€)£§:%::m’éJ.?,N;;駧3 was 26%;
3:, 145%: 44542 «:3? 2699 & 14569 OF 2309