High Court Karnataka High Court

Poornesh @ Poorna vs State Of Karnataka on 23 September, 2011

Karnataka High Court
Poornesh @ Poorna vs State Of Karnataka on 23 September, 2011
Author: H.Billappa


‘ ” v g§3:L*’t;r::s:%{.%’ — §:.f_}”f:.f”i”fié:’iE’

TE iii E—-{‘£{}§:§ C{‘}'{§£{‘i’ {FF Kj’xE1{5’§;§”l”z’§%§x’%,, E’3z’%.E\E{.’:z5’ai,€,§vE’¥Z.}?7Z
E..};’:’§’E~ZIT) ‘§”§4–{ES Ti-:EE.:: 2:33″ §”},s7~§'{ (iii? ;§3EiE?’.E”§*Z3’»’E BEEEQ :20 E E.
E’T3§:£E'{_}Ri%Z
THE HOEPBLE MR.JUS’I’}§CE §:.3ILL’§F?¢’i: V .

{?§{iMIP€£a.E- PEZ’I’E’l.’E{Z*§’€ ?\§’~:}.S_v{}Ei?A T253 : .;1 1
BETWEEBE: V
E3’1″:’1.:3i”:’1.a.,
S ,5 2:; L2: R:e;}tf:n’2 i I’: 2′: :’22-z.y;3:.:22¢;,.i
faggieé zabmzi 28 };a%:a~1§°:%.

E?,,f£1.N(f}.18§ 22"" €Ii?me:ss,
3.1;; 21:'1z-i§:>;:}::: §;2.23;:>:.éE ,

R--"'2?L;'3.j;22.:":2.1g;'::':1 2?"? Sia§__§<%';' V 1  _ 
E-3*'~'1i'3:'-i€'i§€3~'<""#":  é       ME-3e§;.E€..i<}:2{;%;°

{E3}? 3;; R ESE. Da%~33I<;':{' Ag.-:9'; v._ 3'

ANB: V """ "

Sims;-,*. sf Ei;'.::':§a1':;2i%:é:5 V &  .

E152:yz1t'1a;;";:.1";'1 f""i'{'{E§{".f&?' Si';-:é..i€§i?1  __

$3; éiss E->:2%3fic=. E-‘mE=-r:;::c:.;§.:<:s:"s._ " mEiEz;%$;}<:;<::{§@§'32;

53:;-3,3 ss;;~;'«:;:;;%<-2.AéA ' _ :§’2 :’E§€:{i ::;:’:{§:’*:z” i§z:%<ii,4§3E§ eZ§3*:1'E–3*.{.L 33:; E326
£55'-'a:§*a.–":'§z:'»-:;zE..:::_E'1:” ‘:E’;§%..§§ar’€.,ji §:.*>1’*m:’ §’§’E”2’ij;’§§.’l§§ 2i..E’3;-1%.. ‘=i=E::§s=”-,2 §*”1§.£j}:’1’?;3§€? {T<}':.':z*E: 2222:}: @536
g'– r<;%i'.§i§{}:"y3.:° {:=;'§. e:=z:3'§:i<:2:§:a:;1§':.a:;"y éaaaafi 3:"; €.§":a3
.:;r'3_a f£§3z'.?*J':},f34;§ ,..–"E 2 mi" '%§ij;:jg;12':a_;_;::22ya E-KS" Ef:%a2'zg;f2£Za}:*:=:,

"::%:?a;mt. {sf 2::-§"I."é??f,%'s'E.~

£?:}:" ?*.§j1:::? <.}§'§7<;":i;<'§§3§.,._§2f:.2,/s;°3E%§§ 4&2 EE-'3€f,

' « V " ._{Ti{':.:_: 3' "§:':;'2{'iiE" E"

J

<.7i:*i:::'?:'1:Z:2;';§ §'3{i*E"§Ei{'}§"§ <é{_}§'z':E:':§j 522:': E22' a.'::."{?;t;t%z'::':~; §.E".:'§s»a {Ea}-fl. '§'E::_43
§':::% §?;.}§§ ;3:’1&2:% .E’:a..<:; £216-%d t'.E':.i$ p€iii'E'.i{}I.'i 1§I1{§.€;T'.f ::»:e:i=<':i.E<m @238

5)? {i§’x”«’E.1?{i.”i.; §3§”B.};’§’E’}g:§f €522′ g.§:’2’i:”:§’ GE”3:13£.::f§e’:”‘
§i”EE”:{f}{‘f{,”5’£’1E wf ihiz’ gf}§”£E*:12£:r;%s’»; z3:i3;:%§.I{<%<i z32g2£i:1$i him .;<:2":.. ‘§’I’;@ §}§*3″{‘.§{I%{:}IiE€§}£’ »E’1é§_ii’:~?-; f”-:’§_I1″2V«.; as.

:’e$;;)€r{:%.;’~:%:>EtE fzz..z11.iEj;. ‘§fE’§s;>. p{éi.§.’£:i<}:=§<::':f__ £55; 2:" ':':lj'?§.'V{.:<".i§':E'";'V{fHifif' 2;2_..i'1<;ii:-'=; »

r<::ae:i§;' its} a%:si<.§:3 by 52%.} <f<m{iii;;Ls2s€::{i,

‘E’h:%2*’cE'<::°:; 'éizeg: peié§;i:f:m3:' §1;:=%éT' §}.E"';9.;?;.}–="€jf3,}£T"§ »é'é§3f 'g;952::::j;E. ‘§_” 2:z.:1§:%:”jg;

‘miy V

:3. E€_i’ z2:§E<Egc:.éE«.%"}";.::;i'?«-(gm. 2Ei.%C}'?,2G3 L at 2.:.b{i;ut "£8.45
§}..§fz';" W§":@_:': '%'.h&?"<::*s1;3Ea1§:’1A2:§”:€’~~–é§m§ E133 sséziff w:=::§°{=: §};:§€:42″{.’§§i::}g, ‘éthe

,:E.%f::im;>§;:§;%j§5»::’1;’%:;.%_ giéaicia»-‘é;%{§” ~~~~ -zgi r”.:*:”:;’1′::1.’¥}.’Z:E’i.5,_ §*:;§y<«;;c: f<}:"1'm2:i 52 ;;*:°up at §€P€f1′- 2%!-=<;2.::E',_ ::u:%x'E: iii}

"~="f£:¥§E's1££;'§§? §3;,-::."2:.?:§:'-:%E' «-:.;*<é2?:.§£§ E".2{?é;i.E' s$2'_.2:-s.:":'1;esésI5':§}2:§:su {',§E"(,'.§{Ti. ";?'E3.<:t§; 'W€Ef.ET'€£?

:vE'Z<f__}§€',%§.§"}§f§ {:%:_::2:3_:§3 {I§£§.,éif'{.;§§’L:+;’ :;:.d gzmzi. E:’:<'}§*': §§'E{? a«*2.2§a.:;;3'E.3Eé3:;e.

:_*i<;:';'*:g':}E_;-*2%_:"":;f:':':*é" s:;s;%:{.:E_ g_:§;–::”2;{T:.%22;’:sé; :’1§”i{§ w<32':i. is} %i_§:_<.% f$§}i.}§…

E5'<.}u:" p:§’s3<':~§?::=.-:; '§Fs..?{?§"{? <%2::':.i§g;.h'i(. 3-2132:? i'.3*I"i»f.':'. :?${'T£1§}€fi'.{i, '§.'E'3.<~: 2x?::?;.-§p:'}:'1s;
w§;::*<? :'%§€?Eif;éEd.. A <,?2:5;.3=fEE I 201 1 uf “V-“‘ik’§21y2:;.::a.g2:12*z;::. §3<i}Eice.
$%'.2§'§".iz”3 Emsiie %;>{%e:é:'”; :’:?g;fi:%t:€::’c<'i %*<.}2" ':..}'::;i= £:.;.£"§?:%:'::;?:%s5 p:::'1is%'1z=iE}.§ _:f:»%’:::i::%:’

s:~s&%<::U:’:é:% £3?-ESE ;}md 4632 {if ZPC,

4. Tiiia? §€;,21″1′:@{i {,T3{}?;,.E 1::-saji zficyr the §}§,’.§:§§§’.§'{:’}Vj¥.’E§%§”7~.§’i{>.é£.i'{fE”E€:i€?C£~.V’ ‘

E13321? H16 _;_:3i=-%i::¥§’.i.<3§'1m' E i';'11*;<?:{:eni ; ” L.

:’~;”3%’s.;:.’:3mi’€.§z%{.i £”h2:zE:’ ihéé pe£:i.€’i{::ne:* i::§ .2é’=$£:a.x._§§r;?:’1:.”mfE371 ‘ §.iTi€§ ilaiif.-is

§’;”c3:1: 2;: r:*’3§:i’i:§:*:@;’ ram bis

g§a.:’:§€3<:£ am.é..i{é§pai:<)'zfy bail. _

3 ;;ag{21;;in_.S5£..: i~Ef:M.§$,4 Eéévéé' _jE:3z::.:':2s;3{ti £}<3v<:::*_nm€.:'1ET. Pieader
59-;u%}:":'1:?€:*£:<;?”é; and
§1.~:’.%__s __j§ffv.§”§*?,”:’VE__ zzC:<:i.:'::a::2.a:i§\…i:': C:1i"'€<3,'.2539,!2{%§ E ;2:z*;-‘1.

?{}i£–s::ét :§:s:§’,&1?7’1§.{i9E.f;>Aé.s!’€f;i'{§V!§f.§’}=ZT§T’€3§fiE”€?., EEEEE ;:€:%?é’.i%..i<};3€2* <;:2;:.:"m::v%: big: §;;§§"2-':3':i".{;%€§

V A.___2;:§1.§' 2'.a:%§§.§;«2 E 5; E};.:.§'.f.~;I_ _ A

'§,VE':".=;;5.::% <:;;2.:;"::?§%.,fl§}; .:”:z;%.<T§ §"§";:=;% .<e;:,.x;%';m§_s:;esssi<mss izézzeéfi

–,§:3sj/;. ‘§::§’:.§:* ‘§::;:%:;’::::={‘§ a’%2.z:2s~.;€:’E €52’ ézim ‘§i}éjE§”§§€%fi%4

“F1 ‘f’E’*:. pezzém £’§’32:i’ z::.2″i5e;&:s; ékirur my ;’ z’.;”‘zs;? g3c»7€i{.£:)z’z.:%r var’: Ex-F §;raI”z£.e?::Z £1.322f”Ec:r§g3(z§.€>r°§; E3sfz:’Ei-5′

8. It :'<*r:.1.é=:vz-mi ii} 1'}<32"€i*.. '§':hs:'-? 2-12h:%§gz?:tic.):1S é1£'€.*VE.§'}».E§E:".§'§.'v'£?

am E:.:':{:';w:'1 §}e.z"§=;:’::»:+; f<'mm%e:i :1 g§z*<}z.1g3 ax

_§'~:r;%:;: _

§éE3;'j£{"}L1'§Il§ E.'1.€:?X§ Ea I"é1ih*JEE£.§£' pzumziiei 'm:.»":::i.., E'£€i.?£.*J"' §€22::§';'.z<':;.E:::i:ziika '<:VE§_V'€:§<;%' =

p£a;1:':i:'1;§; in <':§i’:: zmd i:E1’i~::§i:’:§j’ §:i}é:§.2:;’?s§.3j}?’

v;:%:e3.p:_::’:s. £433.22′ :31′ E1§”i€:”?E’§1 x=ve’:*r2§ ‘i’:-:5§%’v«r;:.s.g;€:fi.pe{i

‘vi?&:a;3:’1s5 E’221vé:é be{~:n seizzéézi. T310 §3_{;_E E..i1E’V}f.z:};i:71_;:::” is _.éa;’€:L:{§%37m. 0%’ Yfi

32:352. a.va§Ea’:[:E:::? 32:32″ §£T1.x»’:%:::iTig§zj:€”.ér’w§1’A 7’T§,fi’§1i}g:*:f:>;i”€:’;–§.f:~”, *;E–:;<;*: pei:ii;§.{3::2€2:* Cam

E36: ;;j:"z':z1.%.c2::’2$.

€93. f3sh£?{j3:€}4§'{fi3″3f§’§1€’i_. ‘§Z;f:’*;.:1i§’§2;2E E3§2″§§E;ie}:’a. zisas 21iE(i>w€.<% 22m{E
i;.}1e §'}E'fii§'{Z§{L}1"E{EE" §g;:";;§.:';_€.<€:§_ 2,-1s;~;';'*;€_£c:':ip:ai:3;"'§,–' Exaii s~,suE'3_§€<:"i. H3» éiaéz

£f:§§_Ef%j:.:jf;? ::§._<:;:': ; Q ' ' " ~~~~~ ~ ' V
_ :Z';?'§T $'E'3:% "-;:ézr<%:':%:; §':§'3.<=3: p<::£.it§’E§ ::§’322.EE §,?si’: :*{::.§<3;-"::=:;a%a'§ zr:.i§ <33": E";§;+':;
<é.x<;%§:* 5:-mm 0% ?2§,{}{;%{}/ — Wit}: 01:63

§~;:.2:'<%§".}; :§%.::z §E3::;=: E§E§é:%$:.:§:': ii} E,.?:é.?. 522;;-1%é4§::v;£E;:<§E.§::2::": :32" é'.E':;€: HI}.

§:§E§fi6 "

{ii}

{iii}

{iv}

‘E’h::::’ p{%€..§”{“i.<:r§'1é:.§' safzaii 23;);3:'-%:;:;* E:)::%fk'}r(: {.319 "{6} w.ié',E:i:'1
<.:z":«:=: 13,-T'f§?fE§ fraizm. 1%.<;£§.a.}; and s::;}';.a__E.E <':0–p€rr;1:'<é w'f.E'.E2 flit-=;
EC} Em" iz':'*s,-»'c%*:1a:;§.i;:{::::£.1321. 4:522 a:a.<'E W216i': E"€:'.{§E..I§}"_€Zf§:§ f:*

Ez’1v:::+:f: iggzzzit Em”: .,

“§i’h:”;% p2’1ez” smaii nzzinii. ‘z.2:1mp;’:s:2′:;;; V’

‘i’E’2:% g::e?~§’i.€’:E<3m?:" s::'E'222:_§_§ zzm. §;'1g:E:Ié'£;g<:« .i;*1'..:m;g: §f$§'§}»::';s;iE::~723;:f::;:§.

sa=;§'1z?:E§ 2:E;§.+:%'n.ci the P{}3if3{%: 3/3i,£1§_§§}}"i:. §'Ei{T{E1§i'"£ §.§ {£2155

2;: .S:.2:'}{§22;3.:',, %3a=%€:wa2£:r; <'§~;{}{}_p§;"1".:,'aiisi

if ;»:_z1.}-* <t<mdi%.i<i;':':. is; xr£<}E–;:::::’:<i€%:':§':«S'£.22.€<=?

{"2232 :11_<}v::r ii}? c:a:":€::.{:?§:;_'£;'_.i::2::' ;':{"é–I%:<;=AA§§%;§.i§.

F:.1:';'1iE~.ah {}§}&2rz::.'i.v<: Pa:»:*%:Vi:§§1% ;.:”<i{e1=,

{iii}.