Puttalakshmamma vs The Secretary on 24 April, 2009

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE-

DATED THIS TIIE 24m DAY OF APRIL 2669

BEFGRE

THE HOJWBLE MRJUSTICE S. .43,pUL AZJXEER  "C %

Pf/R_.(TPETITI0NJ\F€l 16618xg_m)ar; %(.S'-?RL.#%%   % * 

Between:

Puttalakshxnanmaa,

\V,fo R. Raxlgmlatiz,

Aged abeut 59 years,

Rfa Rangauatha Pura, -. ='

Nagavaiii Post,   . j  _  v_ «V 
'I'umkm'Tq. & Dist,         Petitioner.

(By Sri M.C ';.  i" "  V

And:

  seam      

 ' A Eept.  Rina} Deve1c~p111e:1t
V  33334 P'«1fi€?¥3§T3fi"3j=
 . S.1':}}z3g;,., Df;z3--°§I11b€dk3I Veed11£,
' }3fiLi1g3i0I'£:. 5  001.

 _ '_  V . Thé ~A§c_0t£ntant Genaerai,

~--  .. {"}fi'1cé 'cf 111$ Aucoutfiani Genera} (A & E),
 V Kétmatakza, Near MS. B¥dg.,
 _ 'Bangalore W 560 001.



3 The Chief Executive Officer,
Taluk F3115-iiayaili,
Mini Vidhana Seudha,

Tmzzkzzr ~ 572 131. .... Rs-":sp011de:1£$. .. V  ~  T ~ 

{By Sri T.P. Srinivas, AG:-X fer R1 & R2
Smt. Veena Jadhav, Adv. for R3')

......»

This Writ Petition is flied under Ar£icl<Vé's__2:2Z€§ 8: 22'?_VA<)"'vL'ie 2  A' '
Constitution, praying to quash the imptégied letterdaiad  

issued by K2, etc.

This Writ Petition comingknj: for.?fé£i;§§jfi#f3r
Group this day, 1111:: Court made the; f0il0l_wi13g:v ' *

 %%%%    A'
The p;=;tjtiétf§er V  appointed by the 3"'
I'£:$p(}fi£§é1I{ 'as   and posted at Nagavaiii
 :l_"_fz;z:rr%1:urv'i'$3§§u£;:;-----£2' Dsitrict, as per the appeintment

er:.iV¢':z¢tc£.:r-.1V'.'s.%Idwt§.'z"§.. 197'}: ::1t is commaed that certain ether similarly

 ».___?}v3C€d  writ petitions befere this Court in

.. _T'T'_fW,4F';?*_§os.1531?:"to 1581351998 seeking reguiarisaiiotz crf their

  Cfliift dispesed of the said writ petitiens on

V'  by diregiing the: EEC}, Tipmr Taluig Tumlazr District to



Ts



consider their case for reguiarisatiorz and absorption in the   _.__ 4 

in which they are working ii'! accordance with law.  ._

Ziila Panrrhafyatli, Tumkur, regularised the S€If:'L'iC€:$ '{)'I'?.!l".Ii'§  X 

as per the order dated 14.1.2000 (Axgnergtsre ;Cf§."--The   3

retired from sezvicae en 30.6.2007   z51ge Vf;of
superannuation. It is contendegfiifgat  _pa3rr1%{--::2"t of
pe:1siona.ry benefits was rggesrted   his order
dated 11.32093   'zmiixea this writ
petition questioning'. 'V-érder and for a
mandamus    To _' Q1'-#".*.r;s2:1ti the pensiaanazy
benefits I0 thevv"ps§tfiit§o'rzer  'Extended to ceriafn other

s¥n1iiar!y s£tu;:ted persEm.<;.A ' " 

  ef the writ petition, the pensienary

 v._:fii;%2'::=fits of time p§ti'iir§iie§' have been settled by taking into acceuat

"s£r:2f*;%'is':eVTren§d :%r<2}<1 by hm' fiorn the date of her regularisation ti}!

.,,, , ,  " « .31? 54:3 :2? hefretirement.



3. Learned Counsel for the petitioner would eenteigd  

2"" reependent ought to liave ineiuded the pei5iod»ii:ife1_::.1"the'1  i _ T 

her appointment as per Annexure 'A' till date <if.:fetiremet:t'"--t'er:tlie  it

purpose of settiement of the pension. It ieViVitri_;it1edVV 
has filed a representation as   
before the 3"' f8Sp0l1dent -- the ---eeeordaiaee
with Rule 224-B of    'Ruies requesting
him to count her    i1ua1ifying service

for pension.

4. 0;; me other .4 iearined HCGP appearing for the
reepeiidetité that the pension ef the petitioner has been

settiett'   the qaalifying service from the date Of

wregularisatien of he} service till the date ef her retirement.

_petit'iet1er is not entitled for any ether pensienazy

iii.'=_hei1efrt$t.VV  



5. It is not in dispute that the petitioner was appointed by the

3"' respenrielit as per the Qfdef dated 6.8.1977 (Ainieuxre 255;') as

Assistant Teacher on temporary basis. The competent authority 

regularised her sertrices as per Atmexure 'C' order dated 14.1.2Q{}0xj   "

and she retired from service on 30.6.2907 cm attaining the 

Superannuation. It is aiso not in dispute ti";-;e'.t  ;;ei1_sién3.rf,r" 

benefits were settied taking into consideration her eeryiees  the '

date of reguiarisatien as per the order at  'Cttiii ithetriatei
of her retirement on attaining esge oi' s}_1.i3ere;uiu'atien. The
question for censideratien isewhetilerr ief'§erv'ieev--rendered

by her fimm  deter   per the order at
Arxnetrure 'A' {mine date  regtiliiriezttien as per Ax1ne2:wre 'C'
erder sheuld Ahave bie'en__vta1=:.e.fl ir:t(3V"'2ieeount for the purpose ef

setfleiiient  
H5.» Evie 'asserted by Ne.FI).06.SR.A.2004 dated

 ' 5.20Q§"    frem 12.5.2906, which is as under:

ix:

\



"Z24-«B Request for taunting of qualifying serVice.~~~.. »  

for pension:  _
tfionvithstanding anything c<mtainedwin._mles' .f2"1 f;".~: 
A, 224-A, 235, 2354:, 235-13, 247, 24%, izé:-s§f25»<i3-.%  4'
A, 2-sits-(AA, 252(1)), 416, 41? em t'e1np1o;zéetV.' ft '
degires to have the benefit of coizxttiiag th§ir'~pt_'é%*io_i:.s  
service «sf additional years as qu-a!:it3ririg..$en!i'cé 'far 
pension, as the case :1ta'3»*_R£'}e_  shall
make 3 request in   
Autherity w£thi:3«.t§§ree  '-daté__§§fjaini:tg

the Goverfttittéttt   years from

the date__;}t'   Lltggaiée may be. No
clainit madétafia»;  «abct%é"spm_:ified time limit, shall

be entertained b§;ffi1~t§V'3t§pQ1§tii%ng autharity.

2. mg agtgjoitttirtg' atithtirity in tam Shall, with
 1'3<;ords'iz1"*supg)zt sf the ciaim, ebtain the
' , 3'§}p!"t3'§? 3Lin  the Gevemment before passing the

 ._ ozgk;-i"'.

 It iS giéar finm the aforesaid Rate that every empioyee

 'désifes _tc'3:"have the benefit of eottnttng hisfher previettg service of

 "addit§énal years as quaiifying service fer pengion, as the case may

3
H
'H

itgfi



he, shall make 3 request in Writitsg to the Appointing  "

witifin three years fium the date ofjoining the Goverttméitt sefitécé

or within three years from the date ef ei'f'er§tH<tf:the..vs£t.id   _ 

Appeinting Authority in turn shalt, with"--.re {:;z1£site  1'é?m§:*ds; it: 

support ofthe clam, obtain the approt¥a1..V§f the Gdveftitzaéntttijeféfitre
passing an appropriate ordmv   '_
8. As stated above, the afc;1fgéai_d  tats effect on

12.5.2066

. The petititégéf’ hag, filed’:ari”a§pl’ic3tit§1é in accordance

with the :tfores;iiéitvt’.;*?.:;§é:’.Vbefitfethe .’ Appointing Authority on

13.4.2869. Iti ether Wcrtis..A1&Ftthiti:”ajyexiod sf three years firom the

date of cgmrzing intta fqrfizse ‘ta-ftltie aforesaid Rule, pefitioner has made

x_a:i “app§’icati’b§1. “T116 3″‘ respondatat has to consider the said

aptfifcatiofi with the aforesaid Rule and pass

V V’ a,ppr0pt’i«ate c;rderS”‘thereon £11 accordance with law.

‘9V.”‘in” the reault, I direct the 3″ raspoladeztt to coxzsider the

:’_4a}p;1-li’:V*atian ef the petitismer at Arttzezszure dated £3.4.2{}09 amt

Q.

KS3

pass appfopriate orders thereon in accordance with iaw..~wi£fii:i__’ ”

period of three mzmths from the date of receipt e:>_f’M g§§p§{ cf 1

Grder. The petitioner is permitted to 2 _

application Annexure aieng xvi£§1_<_a co1§"f,'. <5'f this _9iV*:i£t.1* t§i

competent autharity for his considerat§én.._V'A'

Writ petition is disposed }:§f"a.ccc.¥fdi;1gi§é'~;.__

BMMx2942a<39\,i_a_: