R.Umesh vs The State Of Karnataka on 21 April, 2009

IN THE HIGH COURT OF' KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 2137 DAY OF APRIL 2009

BEFORE

THE HOBPBLE MR. JUSTICE 3. mam' NA;z;=.i;E1é'_';    

WRIT PETITION Nos.903i:300€9',T .. 3
381/2009, 92352009, 87612009 min
gm To gm; :3{)Us; g§3;<i::S3  V

BETWEEN:

IN WP. Ne.903l20G9

Sri. R. Umttsh      .  .
S1/o.Sri, H. Ramaialfi  V      
Aged about.':';9 ycar~.s"'  %      %
Working as Pecan' 2 j_  * _  A_

Gflict: of £111:  l:3;iI_.tf_(:ia:'.§? '  '

M/s. Karnanaka St:m~:_;;'?ofi,st¥11CE.i.o-n --
Corpnrafion, 1I3r.'.f4:aj1:i1}ti;arVi3bh§éxs;e£i2 ' '

Bangalore --~ 560 010 '  " 4'

IN__W.P. Ng_;j'$'s%1/200$» V 

S5, :3; Pagghéfigggiiah
S] 0;: Basavcgcwda   " "
Aged abczfizt .4'?  

1 " AA Wcxrking. as: Woi'k* §;;:s:.5pects3:*
 Tiffivre of the (}€=Eh.erQ1 Manager
/ :3. Ka;::i11a"f.aka, State Construction
" " ~¢'3:'<fi»';135<5'ratioz1, Dr; Rajkumar Bhavan
: =BangaiQz'év-: 560 610



113 WP. No. 9123/2009

Sari. B.H. Rangappa

S,' 0. Amavasayya

Aged abaut 45 mars

Wo1'kiug as Dzivcz' M  V
On mm basis at the  
Gfiice of the Secretary 1:0 Govemment

Public Works Department

Vikasa Soudha

Bangalore - 560 001

IN WP. No. 8'36/2009

Sn'. H.M. Kalaiah   '

S/0, Sn'. Late H. Madai-_:fi1V__  "  _   :
Aged about 53 Yearfi  4     'V   
Workiliig as Work I1ClS1~'%ec€'€'_'¥5'-'. ' "    ' '

DEC: of the Gtnnlial I's:I4é1:<__1ag€r»   A'
M/5:. Kamataka S§f;=.~'i::; ('2tiar§s1j;"1;:::_f[i<;z't

Corparation, $iiiii\ic:g;aj'

IN map. Nos. 966 9'?o;'2@Q,§f = % V

311'. H.B. Har:amagoucL:»:.,V' V
S/o,.-Ba%%ago1;_<_:Ia ff. Hoflna.-1?.-n'avar
Aged .a§t5o11t' '49 _x}*€§2=:.rs' '~ A A_

Woz'1iiug  P603;/1VaI.<§1mnan

(Jffioc hf thg: R'é;s.ifi::rii: Fingintécr

 3. Karuatjaka Siziie Construction
 vCbo1'poraIio:1;44_Dazzaz1a,g;e1*e  Pctr.1'n..WP.966/12009



 2 Ab Corporaijdn', Daviéjgyigere

Sri. Sharanappa Revanasidclappa Chiniwar
S] 0. Rcvanasicidappa B. Chiimiwar

Aged about 52 years
Wcrldng as f.}river
Offirte of the Resident. Flnginettr

M] 3. Karnataka State Construction

Corpoxaticsn, Davanagcre

Sri. M. Chandrashekar

S / 0. Mallanna Irani

Agcd about 4'?' years V
Working as Mixer Operator
011103 01' {he Resident Engint:t~:x'

M] S. Iiamzataka State iixwn:-:tI':1Ar;"£--ior}" V

Corporation, Dava11;3g:t;7_e'1'.

Sn". Ashe}; Sfinkalf: VV  
S] 9. Samba L3QI1d1baA.nka1e
Arg€:;d_ab01;t'i4?._Lyca1*s H "
W'gc_:rki1:;g as £'é'c;13/_\rt%_;tc1:Lma11

C¥fl'i«::;:' :.?.["£'uc~: Rxgsizitz-11 t' Eng:i11t:c~:1*

M] 5:. "K3?f1-91T}}'3T3"-$;T3fi'3 . (--"3onstr11cfion

i   2009

 Pe11*.i11.W'§'.969/ 2999

 .Petr.in.WI?.. 4. A  "



Sri. Rudrappa L. Guddannavar

S/0. Sri. Laxmaan Yallappa Gudciatmavar
Aged about 4'? years

Working as Swticpctr

(")f'ficc of the Residrmt Engineer

M] 3. Karnataka State Constxuctinn

Corporatirm, Davanagere    

(By Sri. GR. Prakash, Adv.)
AN D :

1. The State 01" Kamataka

Rep. by its Chief Secretary

Vidhafia Soudha "

tiangaloret -- 569 ()0 1

The Secretarytcz P:1_b1icj: V . _ .  
Works Bepmémcist V .    'V  " 
Also the      
M] 3. Ka111ata1~::a 3taté C i1$t:1ic'£iofi;

 " . _  V 
f}c:ve:r,¢:11Izcnf 'e{fEa1i1ai'ak4§_ _ --
ViI«::asa. Scvudha' = » "   ~
Bangalore ~'~   " 

{A3

3. The  Vie Vfiiélaliceliiepartment
 Goyfimmcnt of Pianaataka
' '  _ Beuflgalgzre ~+~ A566 

4.   '§'h§:"E2~se:€Erfiftz24f},*.T_if<§ .i11igati<)n Dcpartment
" G<';n.af_¢mm¢n:  fiarnataka
M :3; Btlildings, Bangaiam - 560 £101

  The  to WRIZIQ Deparmemnt

, --- _ ' Govemment of Kamataka
 Anajzda Rat: Ci,r:CI¢:'.



Bangalore -- 560 009

6. The Chief Engineer
Public. Works Department    .
(Jommtmications and Bufléiingsy A  
51.12. Circle   '
Fiangzalnre -- 560 001  _

7. The Secretary to the I)epai11nent"  " 
of Personnel and Adminjstraflvc Reforms 
Government o{'1s1a_1'aa_=iaka  _4 V  H "
Vidhana Soudha « _   _  "

Bangalore -- 560 0'31  'V '

3- The ?I'iT1'€2i§91 5='€CI?<'3Tfi1'Y"~    j
Depa:it1né--_.'ir1:; of Dis?.i11ve_s.ttn.V nt 
State.  f3}n__.té:'r;§:fisr:=s
Rt:fmf1i1:-;1{QDPER) ~ ' M 
 E.-ah'"'£'riWer " "
 Ba11gai:;;r£.:_4a360_ . j

9. mé Mammg 
Mjs, Ka;:nata_ka'Sfatc Construction
' 'V _(,10rpu:~€_1ti'on, Dr. Rajkttmar Road

 :__LRajajmaigar ..... 
 Bangggalom - 550010  RF:SP<'rNr:F:N'I's

   sfi;.Q%.s$.si;idhar s. Karmadi, HCGP, for R~1 to 3
* A Sri. I3.' Ra-mash 85 M. B. Kan:-;-wi, Advs. fin" R-9)

......

‘”‘I.’hes£: Writ Petitions are filed under Arficlc 226 of the

L.’ . <i;'if;~:*;:.stit11tio11 of India, praying ta direct the respondents to
absorb the services of the petitioners in pubiic works
dcpartmcntfwatcr mmtmcctsfirrigation departmetms as per

the decision anived at the meeting of public sector

comnaittce held on 31.01.2001 under the: ief '2 H

Horfblc Chief Minister o1'Ka1*nata1c;a and etc.

These Writ Pefitions coming on £9; prder-:s"tI':3i$: the '4

Court made the fcxiiowiugz

Learned Counsel for {he HsV-xion
of this Court to withdmw~""fi1¢ alritiéei' p¢:titio1§f§siiV1ce the

petitioners have aiready seeking
re£i1*ement—-z1–s "REe–ti17e1ji1e11t Scheme.

2. ‘i’}3.¢ iearncd Counsel for the

petifioners is The above writ petitions are

” ”dism1é§;:d_as w31ihcir’é\i¢?3:£;’AVNo costs’

Sd/-M
Judge