High Court Karnataka High Court

Rachayya Shidramayya Dandin vs State Of Karnataka By Mulgund Ps … on 15 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Rachayya Shidramayya Dandin vs State Of Karnataka By Mulgund Ps … on 15 July, 2008
Author: A.S.Pachhapure


w-«J

Efi ‘T%i%’;I; Eé§{3~§% SQEERE’ S? §<;%RNz%T?:s.§{.§~:.

{T/EECUE’? 8EZ§’€€’:§*~§ A’? SEEAEQWAQ

SATEQ ‘§’%%iS “E’§%§?; :3??? EEAY SF 135;? giééézs’ ‘ “‘

BEZFGRE

“ma %§G§’€’%%”,-{<3 :v;;a.g,z:,:$?§{:-3 .;3.3§§é3g£;;.3-:';:§;z;?;:"2:%§;– .. 'V [ 1:'

{3RE§x:EEE'~EAL ;%§3?EAL§'§'_C2,?§'2A{f;i{}§3 " "

BE:’§’$€E:EZ§~£: ‘ ”

Sirzzé §%a{:.h3.y}Fa S§1i{3i§”3§;5§::§f§?«’3.

Age: 4′? years; E’€{e:): Shi.1′{$i–,* f }_
“Sq: Margzzmai, Bésfiz Qadag, ‘- _ 1 f_,_2.’§;3§>e§E;az:€

(83? Sri £k1§1az2§%?a$§§?:ka§?__ E-“,.?a.?§.§E, ‘5§i:V’:’§3?},§§}B

Staifl {sf
By Mu.lgu17:£§S. Rep. by’ _
Sfiaic jPf!._,;.E3%»i<: §¥'m_sa~:£;%%,z'ier,'~.

High.j§;”:01I1*t ‘E:311i1t_i’i_¥1g, Bangaigmg Eéaspatigient

V. {By Sm :4; G kg::k}’;§néi, gag?)

._ agpfialé is filasfi 2;m{i€;: 3′?%§§} Czéiéf;

against ti1§:~:§i,;v.igmenTt. datézgi 3i.3.2{§fi.:’§ passeci ii}? Sessions
Judga, fiaaiag in $p3..S_=:f: 5%; 3′? {M2,} CC .§’§§.i§f1.l3€}{}§

‘ C(§§”£’£IiC¥L~’iI1g:_ 31$ appe1i:¢i;1E–éicffen.<:*€i ;j:uuI1.isha'§3ie:
V urge: S6::*'£ia2f; 39'? GE' EEC 3,116; S€f§§_§Z€fiCi;fig him 3:9 :.::2{%$:'gQ RE.
:’ 3″-§«iea.r3 and as pay fine of §E;<;.i2,Gi}fi;' –~ arm} E13,, is fa_2:"§fé:;a::'{
" _ :: §::i5?:g& 83,' {gr {me month, fay éhs €%f§E'§§.£"fi jg'2'i§ffi}i$§}§:E§§§9f: %..:z*:.2:"§.{.*.:'
' 8€g{:?iO?;1 3%? af§.P,€j3.

This <:;a"im.i:3a}; appeai czrmkag 9:: far E1:"::a3:*iz1g ihaés iiaggz,

V' the ceurt tzieiivered '€116: ifeiiowixlg:

2’»)

x..§UBC”§’%’1§?’%§T
The é:§p&E%a:1é: E333 zchaiéfizéfgfié ‘zzés «:a;’3:;?§§j:f£i:s§i” – éi%z§:;..
$€fi”EfiI3.{“fs’3 far $15 aflenae ‘%.3.m§.€r Sfitiiazz 3%}? §§”a€E«._§:3. ifigé

héid 135; S{‘3SSi€33’iS 69%;? 2%; Qaéiag,

2. Sans u§:m€€:e5$$a:’§’ :§:§€_ §§;'<§s€:<:'a:":§;j;%:;V'_ %s€3:'i;%.§:'s

zznfoiiisii émkzg ihe trfzai is a3 131152.52;

?W.1»Seva})§:a §~%a’:}V’:32′;;235;i::§;§:i v §:’ii;13fgff»}f§’}.”s*;%§f;E*;’v’€i*:? i$ ihe

regidafié, 9%” Shi:t}§:V§.§§ag§:’é;§€%:z£f%:{: ‘i3:;:§ §’sz333Ets 0%’ Mzzigazxd

Police SJ€3§1’§:€3~f’i.’ V§,’§£A%i§.”;<;'}§ .;3._1,';§é.,_1€2?§;?'?f«"vi:2 'aha avafimg 22% :;zbc:":,sfl;

KEG, c=@::};3§éé'i§;:s;§§§;<T§Bf€:fi§§"¢7;};§32z'§%am1ma}§§3:a §}m'ga§3§§a£:av3:a*
{PW.1§ vsaé 35$ vééiage 535$ gifts? aiigiztizig aé

Sh'i;1;::2{inaz;as V'§}'z'r_;:{:£:6{%%31g is Eiég viiiags 'E25; *e5;'a1i<:' 2%; E218

.:°€§s:va§_'€ '§.é:;::.t§,"–..':1; i$ afiagfié; 323? 3:6 ziccugaiii frag} "ifiiaéz

'Si§§.'%":"V1§<_:-'?E,}'€3i'~&i~§$;;';5-;&EJ1}%:Zi{§. {ha :1€§ Saw €335

‘€:s;*–“f€}?’_i’}S€{§”‘§§?§1G was §:L@}{§i;§1>g we sgsiaéifiii 352:3 E12333 wzzfi :<;:%;:1:;.5;z:{§

3:18' -Aéampiaiizarai in fi£*§};1j; Eafigamgs azzé aggaaziieié 2&3

* -~£–ri:+£1§1a§:3.23.::1f: xvii}: 'abs gickié: an $26 ahsaiamézs. 8:; 1336 ':im&.,

{Z¥§7,2-Ev§ai§~a::ag{;'u€§a ézzésezvsmaai amé :£iC{'3%l$5{3{§ 3:13} 3:: §5:_;;=:v€:

~L

..;,,

13%"? firzfi §'s§a€:§: 1:}: éhreaififiérgg 132$: {,'G2?§}§&_§}EE€;i"§€ =%.;$

waiiiai fmisiz him $3052. 2%; 'ih€i"'fi€="if§€i" ihafi

was hraaghi. is his éwéisfi 333% i;::–;' in Was" '–2éé}:';:§:%.{'v€:*2″zm_z:~3’é %%Zaé:;pé€3i {£21 éiéaiiag.

PWE Efimfieafi Cagzséafie ‘*§,.t:§€:%:a:°ge@ ‘.235 ?«.<§;:§gz§33.€§ "V19a7§i,

S%a§i<";.z2_ rscziiveé €316 _§}3;a:2:g;€ Sééiééei "9;?s<:u§: figs:
iz1C.ifie§2'?{. 3:15? the V'TE'_$_ €'§f};g. £1 §§;$?;E"§.€':"€
Qavcmmfifit HfZ}§%f§%§.'£.%§.1 ii'-*{3E}:i E0 232::

§'3OS§§f5£{:T§    X'%3CG}f*{,§€;"{§ "€336
{:a'.3mpE3NvVi2<:t~::§A{T%':;i'§*:v::$'§'€;»':*1$3.}.    hi3 $ig;:,:.am.:2=.2

ret’um:$:% fie ‘h’:Vé ‘§*«i§,’s.h%;§§é: efifi ?i’€’:§§S?,{fI’&’€§ €338 aampéaégzi
€21 C2’i:m: ?:§§}?’_ E§{*:%’_.’~:”.i24:f£E§;ces urzzcifia” Sififiiifili 325,-; 3&5″,

5Q%=?3§5 §,x?.v{§3 azlii gem {ha €s:;2z.;;g}Eaé2::'{ zéxiaéizfi’; E311 ;.{3

E’;E.g§.g~-€§<ii3§{b§fi: «?.8 is} $335 §*é£:%gis%:'a€fi. §*§€ :*:a"§;*"::$§%:{'§ ;§i"1z§"i§':a%:"

'mvégfigéfién '{:2;""%"'~E?.8, Wiw sseuwzzi EEK: ziéifigéézzg "sZe.?}:%§.E£3$€§~¥§

m;_:§""'ai.:«-'£1:-__?:':.'é':g?£§:':{: Sgsei aim Efzfiiai 'aha :::p{}*i maE.';a2:ar»€:{§3i?{;%%; 9%.

h "%i2_z'€:c91};"-iisfi. {E35 Sifiifimfifiifi sf *Ji?§'{}i3;€fSS€S 311$ §'i.'1€'§'f:3f'§£§'
" , '?2z§}é".73:+:-4} ta 3-<:}::'ih€8 @531 ihfi 'r:§<::«i§y 05 {E238 §§;a3f'a:'e& were aeézszi
V. ..i_:3:§é:€§' the K§.3}'1é%Zfii'~§X.?.3.- fie i~}fiCi_Ei'€{§. "{§?é.ii° atasis $:=::*?;:;i§.<::a3:&w

V Exéflg <33' Ejfiigii 353$ §3*§::::° %'W.},§. atzszméizzzfaeé {Egg i::%.?£§;%.§.g:;s:*;c::§2

oil

Am

azizéé 353.2% 332%: iasiizaéiii §3§:;:G{§ -E'}§§:i,]'.I§'§§'fi{§ e;?§a::2€E:-2:.€§ 3%} $335: 531%; _§é':3 iiféé}.

§}X2sm:é:_:£~::* zfsgzszi <33 'igii z~u3§'::i§;?: af théf a.<?s;rz23€{1 3;}

vs:}§;u:2%:a§:s.r .:gi;:–';§::m:::':€:t 'E'.2%2m;:;§f:: Efizéi =f~%€L'£'3.}:SE3€3i Em; §7*'a::{§:7::n::f 23.35}

ssimséézag %é:,E%m:t:%${:s, "{%':a:* si<':§<'}:;.i:m’2. :’E’:€:_2*z€4;;;,V§:i:**; -;:}.:.’é’

<':<2m§:€<i'ié:’: £3? éféizzi :§,:;§¥;<;*.§

agaénssz. %z:E7;,e Zi££'CE3;S§f{§.. iiga:::'::* <:L:<.;E:.§?a:sé%.. .:"ép§};%.'E $5235

z*a<:e:§%;i:& a3i::a:§ :31 '$4-'2«2::~'~: ;:a§{;s<%=';:§:€{£ §;J"*=:i:'?i5i':';fi.:"§3f';é"(«'.,:€}"z«E3."'§,.

E§z.::'i:;g fiiifi Vzzéai, §Zi.»,%:=V _§:~:'@$:%-*:c.§;L:;'{1*%':é§;::. €§»:é;:r{;?§§1»::{E ?%%€'§.§ Ea;

1 E and in E§:1€?_:§* €:"':g§':?:»%§'i 6I;'§.(.;*:a£f' g5?§'iV.ma}§§k£{i' E'-;~',"x:§i%h;'.*és R1 :9 9 322:?

§*«*!.Gs.}_ {Q {Q}: $téT§a:;2;§f::§1_£ ;:'=Lé1:""'tE1ég 33012335} was :r§:cG:*{i{::§

uizgiei' f$2:{:£i::.%fs; §"i{Z;.._z»":§é. -.323 '§::~:}@eE{ "ibfi {3;{:i§<3;2;:i-2 0% %:§§*: gs’:

Kaa3″E:3 Siaifimiizzé :35 PEEJ. E.

A {En .ap§:é:cia€§.<3z;z <35 Q15 maisriaé an §"€{?i3§.'§, $13:-:3

¢<;':::.2f2':_ 11f{)V§:'.§§3;:Z€§§.'VV.'i:'i1$€ §ip§f3§'&k'.£§ far iézfi €}§§i'§§,{T§5 [:23'2::i$§" $€{?§"é

3%?-3:15}; sé::;1f:§:23_<:€{§ gm}; {:3 a:.§::'.%€z'g::: :'°ég<e:}:*:::2'%:.:;=s

" Vi':i:3:§3E'f§§§Gf§E':E§§1§ £31" p€§'i${§ sf ihzaf: jg'€£;i§"'$ aiiaii £1: page-=' 5372:: 3?

_ E{*s§2;.-{3f3G;'~x Psggzéiivaai 2:3' gm cgzzvéctégzg zmgii; S{':1'.'i5€€§'§<2€5, €326

agziéfliiaiéi has 2a;§;;:m3aC.%:::{§ {his éimm': 51:5: appsaég

i haw Ezéiarii €236: §.£3r:;=;e{i {3<m;"::saé:E 1523:' fzhée ;:&§;"s§ss:§3z::1?£

51$ £16 §é:ai*::e:'i:§ {}{}v&§21m§:§;é PE:=:::1r:i::r<

4; '?%:€ §3<32';<1E§; §:?:3.23é:. zrzzégi-:3 E32" 1333;" s:<}§:$V'%s:§:'-r3":s§%§':§"%:3:[:'333%'; M

'3é§:".§f:£'§r:€::'° '$15: §:;égzz:fi:2.E }z;::1:'§:.A,:;:;.z'z%§:2.2:' :'%z:§é:*aié%:é:2g =?'I"£f
apgeiiarit for "ma €:){f€'.X3(.'{:'. ':.:.na:'E:er ;'§:é<?E::.*2«;;::;.~ ,;%si,"3'?"
and E136 3fi'i::%€::€i: E:'3§i§£.:’€§.a:2*’.-3

§. E: :33 3:93 {f§}E}iE’E3§.i{}E; {:§”*§;§E:€ .V–C<;aa,:,.2:5§:§ E32" 2;?/2%

é:§';:::::2: '* 5: "2129

'»%?;%'£.€1t:§;V;:?;{":S ~_'é;£: §§::'§.:.§;:%:::s r€i~ €;5:3L%:._%.?€2?$iée:m: {:35 $325: §:zj;::%:*{i zmé flzzai: 'zézss
séckifi: 1%-*I%3z?<%?;'; £3 Séiiffi is; ;i::;2<;§g+ £35631 35352:} E11: 32:: 5-':s,<:~:2a;a:;§"§. E333; '::;§*€=:, he saégzgzéég $33? :%:;:: iézfzii ésvitifizsfi 0?

§:éa3:;;,2;é«.;b€ a<:€:i=:;3"{§:§ £932" {3{}Ef§'i§€3ai"i'§§ ifflfi a§§§}€:§i§::§;'2é. E:

3&3-£5'; E233 «§n:=;:a2;:=:T

};§i§.:}:1 Eééai '%;5'§:§z:3 is 538 is'z'%:,:':.z:§_*;<3:': 'Egg; iféiéiififi

aiazéséfta; sfségzi -*:..§:;,%;%:z'+: fig; ,:;:<:: '§§.£3§f;%-"ii %:%fi;22§;'3§%sE';;§{§ 75%;; ii
.. V 2

{E325-r<:'§%3:'s, E15 s:,;{i::§§;.§%,3 $3735-: :_ff(3§;3.%i'§: 'i?_§z'}:{2a 21:6:

37*'

' agagzafiazzi 'fer ihéz ::;f'fsz2.C& éiifiiifli" S5:§;s:::°, ‘>4

5, “$13 éaaazmzii €r:>vam,me:;K§ Piaaéer szuigmits ihai ‘aha:
iris} C9113? has §i3aS€f§’§. E313 C€>.’2.1Vi(:fi€3z} on fhfi gensral p:*;r1<éi§:si&
ihaéi ihfi iaguraé; {$953 13%': impiirsaée 9:5: én119c$v:n*'%J "3;'2e:%
fizerefem, ha aubmifis 'shat that appsfiafii 'hag

gmmids E0 warrwi izziszfszazzcs.

?1 £5 cauid ‘as seen {ram 152%}: _§aé%{‘iz.é’;:<ré: '1::{3" -.V%:x:{'V3E,}g;€_'

pregscufiafi, §71"W',§ 11$ ilaa §0€:fi.::}.; w§:é3*5§€€§€€::i a€”s:K%%§E:%:é€, ?%%’.§}
staias in his evéiiezma ézhaé f%;§m “%§:§:,;f%:”%« Eiafi §a$’:a;’.::@{% 3
.Eac€ra$€§ éxifiuxy mézasuriizig $’%é’€f.?C’ {Em Estzffi

E§;§.:*pch511{i.rium .. a:3.;§i’_-m32§;2aa§§g:a:§;.’1 ragééifg V~ %:;éa§¥,’ miéfiézze, éiziaisiégzz

fJ{):§S <;ma:it;;§-3 %;3e'a:f25&:._§'§¥,$3l:§£ 132$ ahéemcsfi, '§'E:::re was
'gfiséiimg éggafi i:<:'ag%::_$E7.'zh,é"%af£§a;:é{% xvem 936311 €1":'éE?;, 'E'}<':s izgjarezé

was 332:': {Q Hubii far §"a;:r:§:er '§§'€af;m.€X35§. E%§:

" 2 was" éiimfiiiefii Qfi 1% §..:%.,..1§9'? fa: ifm purpese 9? imamflfizaé azzii

1§§?. "§'h€ fiaacmr Eiaififi $33? '$33 izzjuzéfig

:§3fi§f§:':5,L7:€3§V1i;'fE;E" ._,i_:;f:§::£'}:2mib}'.?£ 96 am Sémgfie. Exfiibii PC? :13 333%:

{f:€3:"t'3£:'.i€a§;§; *:s;:'~s;;lea hf; a:.;aa.{:a fiagpamz ai Ema}; vshééh zaveais

Wtha da%e _%é~£ afimisséen and aim éaafis af éégafizargek S3 Easkgiagg

E'

;;\::.é:1';1£~:_«s§;}?.{ii$:3a::€ {3§ 'Q15 Eémtiar 313:3 aha :§;GcLsms:.:is §}1"€}€§'iE,{'_ig&

'19. E: is $552.}. es%ia'§iis§f;::s:§ ;;:'%;:c:%.§§.<r: $5 23221: .§§':%:'j

slazjureii gage: 3' £5233 {mi .'22:3§E;3:-iii 233;; .§::z7;:*3<:s:::;':5:« 331$: ~.T *

5'

mg': Eeave 23 pagan whiz has ffifififij}-' ;::aa:.,2.seé }';é:r:$';*=;§'}': ' G;;_ V

this general §}i"}:"Ei{7§}3§€, {E26 i':S;'§{§€fiC€ éfif" €E:;;}é "§;i3L}1.:i'{t:?;"*::_§"a:3£§;:.-§';§.%{'é:;_i

highs: fwaiéng than that 9:" 31:5; 'e3§ht;: 'iv'-§.tfif$S€%\\\,§§:*§§g=f$vh if a L

{ha €'¥'if5:€§1C€ af PW. E i00}{€:_iM§§::'{£Q flifi ~ <3? EEK:
naturé sf éfigazréfis 312fi"¢f%:.§_..V:?;3?A '~§¢:§%i~f_2f0m {ha evééafies
of P"~.¥,§ 311% the i3';§":.:1y 'fie eviderzcé is
izisaifi-atiexzt {Q5 ii';;§%£& if ;_i3ss?.«Vi'i%11 9f ‘:53 v«.7ea§}<;;::a iiiseéf fig

V iEi$H§§€i€fii {Ci séigearci E315: ézvizieizce Rafi 'Q3? SE35 §3:*0s€{:u'?i<.fi?;,

.23 'E"h5 aviiisazsge Caé" ?'%'¢'.1 i$ su§'.i*i533.'2;. '£42 §3z'*s::%.;'$ iiw
aasaaéi §;;§; $316 acirzgsaé vgéiéz $333 §.é£::.§<:i€ am} {."€i'iiS}:E1§f,'S§:'.E;'{§fi§3?if':

iZTij'£31'§:' 'is; E3'E?x-«*1 E, Ea {E26 zfifigaracfi €35 a:2.j;;r" §.t1%$:1§.§:3§1

€i€:a'aE1§ i am 9:? $38 apizzéagz flag? aim: ;_:::"<:~ 3:;$.%.az,§$ §'}§:V$€A:f_."'€§¥:;:2§:Z; Z?'';a;??–T-?*'_& ''

Egg?-Eff, am :19': ;§?;§3."act,€:§, $9 9' §.'i':::;:s.

:§€E’%*”€i;%’€: ;%::.z}’aL-=:i§:3 SEE;.§§€f:i”:’:§§L E3}; E :a;;£:§:§__ zzziififgjif
am sf $313 s;}p§7:mi<;2*:: {ism {E15 3*;-:"§ %i%.:£
aifazxca §,':=.fi{§fiT§" S:é<':'i:%.::}:: <;=é5§::"'é', émia

gremzéiisraiiaa {E16 fact %':§:.:§%; 't;;'i:agé':rt"&é :§~"é:s.3 * ~§§h1.':'z'~'f;$;.§/l:%'§m§§.Mjy'? zwszs: $216

£§{§§{}fi°;€§§ Cams Egg} 31$ {§€§§a{:Ef£;:§i9:;%:"f?£;&?; a3L§.:3:é: wag 21:}. izziézzgiémz

':0 93733:? ?:§*:£=.j?j};€a€%;1{ "E_"%;::: i::§2sff{s'z:ff€3*%= :QE'£.')8'f 9%' $116 %z§€'f,°i"z'$éCa.%}: ta cazése éhf:

iisaiéig i :"§.§§'¥;<2{: §: §_%:§:f2if {figs aria? €:3:;.:’€; in 553:»;

§&gé;~*§;b_._§g §3:’e§e:9.”E=§–::;’:cs, 3:215; ::,*{33::§’3′.::%’§;i:::;§;; ssziéaz’ S<%:: iii)?”

E ‘$3 331$ fizéi {iv.;E<i€§{:<;% ifs s:z,a§_'££<:31{:§3.§ ta: Eiaéé €23.33 ihéé

é:p§€1§a.:2:'_€%;ij_ gzéiéiifg' ai' ihs effmfmz "é,:fl{§€E"' Smriizzz: 324» E. "sift.

" E2; E1"; fiat: Ci£'C'%,E£§$'Z&§'§C€'$, E §i:}S§7§?"€§7' 33% gméai f;_'3?}.§"§}::.-='

2§%2é"*«;;2§°§":::"ms:§§i;a: haiiéizzg iémsr, aha: {.'%E"§¥.; EEEQQ fir}:-' $35: ¢;"}§€§fa{iff

z;a::{§§:' S€:::%:is3z: iii}? LP. is éfsésgaé ;-321$ :é"2;:*:%:a'::* %;§{§ £333

£

sagpafiazzéz gii§:§€}«’ 0%” 2.21%: §%”§€::W.:”.::g ozdfirg

Thtz apgeal is aflowefi ;iii-..__§a:*:i.f c<m'€?§c:§.i:;;f;; 9?? %:':1::=. , L

apgzefiani z-mi aha semienca for _{:§?;E%:Vz2;<:<=; i2.;;==;df€:; Sérzirtaiaza 3%?'
£9.54 is s€t–a$:£:§€, H5 «. ac::p;"§§?:'i:<:j?{17*< :}1€ c%:z:»23"g§ Esvefifié

agaifist him far {Ina saéé Qfjfé'::e.;:i*..v

The a§3;)&§£ai5;i_*.'_is" g'=;;fi';;¢fi :3? £336 Qfiefica zmdezz Sfsatziaa
324 E ""3;;§'Id 51.; gig ._i$ Via:-:'z§:?::°Qé. is 'i,1flé€i"g{} :°%gc:r::;=:.I.s
%}31pzi$e£§;::a§:::€ '<:';a*:: 37881' zméa Ea gag; {ms 0%"

R&2,Q§{},3 ~=, i:1V:i€fs:u§€ ia;.« zjizzgiérgfgs Siififiéfi im§:"i3<:.~§3m€13%: fax' a

perieéi 5;' six mca.:§;5s'.

‘V ‘ _ ._;:m:z’:f’: is séérézcied E9 S€C'{,EZ’€ {E16 §;§:€s€E2<':€ ef €336

V"-i:c:%;'3§?fi -?::3}é"–?:,1§;a;§._V;é:r.g39 the ssfitence.

sal-

Iudqe

‘E53?’