High Court Karnataka High Court

Raghukumar S/O … vs Abu Fernandis, S/O Late Joseph … on 14 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Raghukumar S/O … vs Abu Fernandis, S/O Late Joseph … on 14 December, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda


1
3% Tm mm-1 mum’ 0? K£R§£%:’2*§sI§2%. gr 3mG2+.1;mE

mmfi ma ‘mm 14%: my $5′ mc.EzamER, 2;a:5;’:§Aj% ~ K

BE» FQRE

*1′:-m HQEELE 2»m,.3:;r§’m<;§ B.$REY£5 §I?%2*fiSE~ é:§§f?g'1};§g":V"

1sa.irm. 2%$,3§?3; :'2%w§{:v:*é.»';

BE'§'%¥JEEi§    V

SR1R5€':iEiUKfiM£R  
:2;;'m,sR:     Is:-M35

mm mm? 24 $3333

Rf£iT,§$.1Q,6EFfi8R§:§t?S, %
wgzms mm
vajayamsaa k % %

QAEGALQRE ‘ %V

gay 33: RMs£§{i§E$I§Ré”§’.§$§%£§;;%§V,)

3.’ §*9:§”e:§A§§Is

* ,3; ;§QS7E–PH FERNAHEES

Esflifijfi mags
R{§sfI’i.’C»§-§ES§F’£?s1i” CGLQRY”

_ 3.1? 33%.)’ .

Kfifiifififi

% ‘ A’ §i£§.$%.§E*»*=–‘ 573%:

-*§*§§e’:”:a”;éi’:3aE*;aLL Eéwamcg ca LTD.’

“”SR§ mmzwzm smma camax

– § * E’€;;¥’S~S’§’§aNEi Ram, 93.: 3:2
. j§iAS:E&§ – .333 231

RE F. E93′ B1″‘s:’}$IQ§.$;L Beifiififixfififi
EESPf3F§§E§’ifTS

($1.

. .. _F;«*§%”§i:”:ri%2fi ta a_a%; ¥$7 mi 33%.» Fm Q? :1: _£~.§’QL;J§EZZ33E”< _
Am mmax MA€.":'E', BA§G&i.«DRE2,~~ $¢aH«:3;TkA?a;2*:%;¥%
£LL.«QWmG 'rm cum mxrmmz ma; CQZ§»:fi3EE§$?Afi'EQ§"v§.§§§}: 5

sgsma asgymazmrsw Q? ammsgsafim, %

mg 39935.1. same §§jL*m§%%Am».§;:$$::::§kk3*:-2:3 k %

my; aim ezizamr mzwmma '1*1+mFj4m;;:,g:;'w1z§§4%:'~% ;
Jfifi'"i'i__v'§! mm

flaw" apfii Ea by thaVV_V_c}'§_,:'m' af

:.*smpan§atir§-zfji
2, z–;am."*:§_ ':hé' .§§}:rpea:_ :2 m gdmitt. ed mg with him

"£:£}_§;z:.a&i :5 far tha $, ii fig

$§f;'";§§_&fi"iE ' .

@1323′ zrégfar

aakaa ::3§ mawniwmeg the

2-1 1:23 in aha elaém gaiitisztzzi bafare

4; 93% Erieffacms am cam

%..

3
Q1} Qélliiéfifi, whw 1:11:13 ¢ € was fiawifi igmhe

Tata Sum rwhwafisn B¥9xKfi–»§.1–362’2

Ham} 903:, E€§i«-$8, Eivifiaaé, K

—L Iva-.:.§<:5;~3.3~am6 '

:"2%}$sz1t mmmr arid dashafi ihz: 9§.fi;TA

mug im sum'a$::2efi mgwfig Eieé 3
befemz am M£'x€'§', Bangagsm :15!'
Ea'-4,%§£@f ~, The sf
Es.,1.§§i},§%<};'~ €i3_%§:p_..§fs;,; AA

$5 rgardixg cxcmzrrenes af
aacfientg an? the insurer 9? 11%
sfifgndiw', ._if29eE*2.£t}e § gain: fiat mifiizs far my

._ mmgamafisn awarcisfi hy tha
'§r1"i*;'mn§:' fig. gum azzé raa3e33:zab& at ziaefi it ma far

– – < iv ' ~ _ ' ~»erz%2am3..'s§_§i%t?"

tizg learfi gamma:

§Ei1:s§ arzéi mmmigg thé jndgmnt anfi awazxi af am

i am af the View tizat the mmpsrzaafiam awaréeé by

%

4
E:§1¢ Eibmai is riiziijiifii azyé magsxxzsahka, ii: @ rm this Eawezfisda

m3dEwme§fl%£.mqufi%émbe &§..

‘E’. “§”%w ghfint has sustaixmd ‘tha ..

E. ‘§”§.”sare £3 mndernmxs

jaizzt with im:ab§1i:y sf crane; :#as&ia*:;§::ar

jmlni. , ._ V;

2. ‘fimere is bang swelling the diafizygi iavgnii ‘
stftiw raéius. _ fg

3. Rfitriazafi n%msm:1:cnt«..%§–. 3&5: *95s?*;=iat
a} Eomifiexiarr; rwn’.f£§zi:’£=:.=?;-La:3;iE’;.sjt’ V3351;
b} kimar Aflw5m3:.§.33$_il1e-last ‘};8* ” ”
Q} §J&.£3fi;al’§?:§V%$.ti£ii:fl f_,mfffi1’1$; ma 3.’€3**’?’
:1} §¢§°miéiéf;a.l ifiézatiea far Vi;'{“}5*
e} ‘fi*a::tL1m
gs;-:<.~:j:? £35333 fcharzgea :3?
vmwflwmfiwm ""

‘fine i_§§_*§’ii3fim am.!§;§Vt@V ” E’ by the ciaimant are evident Exam

and 3’§.3.§>§}Z”‘t% %;y ma} wfianw

gf wkzca were ed as Fwsml mmi

‘.; % rs§&m»3%£*9a1;%j’;’ the fimztgr has atataii in his avfienea

aufiwaé aémaaagr :35 35% zg §im% mzfi 22%

é;;%§:§3:a%”i?aaci1é.}a

T “sf; Qensisiarfiiig mg mama ef kgurifiag Rs.3a,a@g-

by the Tzéhurzal mwmés ‘win and 3fi§ 9 is» just

955

5
ami grrrrpw anfi ‘fif}{:I”¢ is rm scape fear azzémmmazzi. unéef

fiaadg

9; magma: Ems pmaum m.urfiia§._?:.’ ” .,:f§3i3’_§ &

Rs:2é,45G-i’~– and am Tribumz .%gjj%

F;a§35_.,fiGfif~ tswarclas ‘infiiaai :érm iei:a :2m§

saw 32$ fag: aflé prayer i§~ _ 3%-<;ge:: fer'
' _ 'V
1%. Em azaimgnz in as,

gésgafia ':9 fi=f"§s;4§5&Z¥f~ per mnth
smiah £3 e1éi:2é:2:£.V &e;}31'§;}':_j .i";I1~:9:;:""a:;ia;7Tz;ezr§.? m at Ex.?}€3.

j 'T'fmr~e:¥:'c:'=e§ his inmama at Rs$35Uflf~

a sum as? Es.15;5€fii~– izaswmfis

'§;¢s£5§'}a§;i up garégfi' whigh £3 gust and prrsxgsar

ikmfi Ear an §:;ana%&2:1t urfiar €E$ heaéx

'..j §i;=-_§$®séd$rix§ {$113 natarfi gf §§:§§.;;rTms, diwitéiity

énswr anfi. an armunt at' fiiammfart mzrfi

' £112: elammt Ems ia uzfiargs 2321 3:213 fumm fife:

u §$4i3;§?{§§f- awardafi by 'Eliza '§'*rih2.12m}; tswazfia flaw £3?

awfirzitigsf $3 an aha Iawar skis, hat a': §"..§'}$ Sam timc it $3 'is: be

fir

6
nmiiczaé. that $1: aiafiwnt am; afiésr austajxg £rg§un7eg3f”has

asntinuaéz his amgakyment anfi them 5.3 :_:%f

am§3c:§sm$:t:§.Q Sfiifi; 9:133 Tribunal has aw’a1*éas:3i…:€_;§’3:.,§éE1€:}.;jf:§§3f!;?f ‘A

tawwds ‘Essa mf fixture irmnm’

an-hanaammzt af eampezmtisesn urafigr a£1§:_ §h::a:§; ,

mmwzxaatiazz awarziad Lillfiifif” the ‘$33 &

13. :; 3.3M Sf

§:~§:__% »A