aw: !w5′<ni-"\I6¥mVAfl WW-
mw%fu'avfmmmmW mawm mmwm WE" mmmmmimm fiéififi %.1€%.%W" 0% mmmmm %~%§€$§"*§ gamma" Q? %fi.§%£%%d%fE"£%%ifi@ HEQM flfl
12; Tim mm: GDIJRTOF KA1?t!iA119;§{I§HBAI'XZ3!*.}.+f')1f€I§'}:'A~.::: . A
mm: was Tim 2776 my or aommg % ; A T T 7
BE]?-'OREV %
THE I~1aN'BLE m2.JUs'rzcE
Bmwm:~z:-
2 %
ram I*&AR;§EC1{)Wm»A§’}£E’32 YEERS
ma: Ta§I.c3fi_B&”:ER0PEss1GH%kL
R[C%=£;GA14fi*§.{I.I.¢¢:£,}E.¢
HA.flGAR&V&IJ.£1″:’j’-~
2 sax A M
S]fiw?AAH AGED 27 YEARS
EIC’fiC3?€Li°i.VH.LfiGE
% H£u’*IG;’!1§AV!§l’£J. APm.LAN’rs
% my GGULAY, mu;
arc’ KARNATAKA
£¥.’f~_.MHi3’IRP$LICE
RURALCIRCLE
HE ~§ BY
Vsfmm PUBLIC: mosacnrma
21-HGHCGIIRT HU1LmG
msmzm -31. %
3.?iflO3 flfiifl V)W’.§.WR\mV}§ ifl £85303 Mfllfi V3€V.§..VNHV)l £0 .i,llflOD HSIH wwivmw :40 Jmmxrm imm Wwiwmmm ..ma nmmw 2.2
“d’)iV,.£.VN&’W% :40
we mwwnzwammmnwm animal-um wwwwma we-:9 wwmnammumawm zamwww w.M.,.#’wm:.=::%% Lk’%:’
BY THE Amncaws ma THE ApPELzmJfrIs Aaarrm
-am ..mDGEm:m* :xr.1a.1.2ea5 msszn av t-m’..;.’..=t.;”i:s:. 335 .mnA3o7 or we
mm 2.3., Ti) FAY’§~’.E”£-E” RI.
Fm om YEAR,' a % ~ k % ms ON Fm
rmmma ‘zm.-3* a nmwamn ’11-m
FOI..LOWIG.’:'” _ k
L’ eight the and
aa;§§z3%:3.¢1.2eo5 in s.c. no. 3311993 passed
_ Court – I at C .
‘ mm§}m’r:a.z1t hefcre the Saaaisns Court In tm
@’**”‘
Qaugflilfi ‘§#%K%flE%-IAWWVMYM ..£Hf”t ‘lggnmmwmuun kv..en_mu sum nmnnsnn.-u In
Kwmrum “Cw-‘”OnfF’V>¢V$¥>:’%tf Wvvl we-wwmmwavmmx
if” mmamammfim WEWW %.,.w§..»m WW mmafimgmnmamm imimvw mmmwnm My flwlmsmwwrfiwmwammw >e
my; man in tin am of P.W.2 and ?.w.3 _
zmmaaim mm: than accused about
tile same cams tn be I’3£§i8tered in
sheet in ::.c. No. 11211993
unm swim 325, 397 gm Tm
Scasiens Ceurt to be
cam»: rm no 1=.w.1s and got
mmfieé ExI%\’;:\i.V tn §;.1#5,1*°§Akka§s;i %1i.z.c>.1 to 2.1.0.10. The
a V; i ….. $8. D.W’1 ta ax
V.’§§c;:D.3. The Sressiznza Judge fraxnaci
:r–1§%%%tfa3km-,,%%gy% for m mm’ mm and
raamhxe dnmbt that an 11.03.1993 at 7.15
a.m.,i11AgahviIl&ge<:fA1durtah.1kof
<7q*\./\y
E WXWAVNXVX £0 iflffiflfi 5-mm Wwzvmxvm -M") warm "mm wsmfawmanum Jn manna Mama wxawmrmmwm am mrarfia mfiém uuwwrmuwv an mum": M
C dhtrict, in I
1 mtmtzim at the
rzzaaaaed gm.
j. same dma, this
% they, with an
the death of P’.We. 2 and
rmwam wwwma wr” mmmmnwmm mmww am-mum £3?” %fiKNa%”¥fia%fi &”§%?éE””3 QKQKMW QM’ %fi§”€§””‘«§fla”§”$%sKfi& §”%§$§’§ $3521?
._ A
% __ ;l”ar mtlm?
warren awmmmmmmm 17%; W1
V ‘V The Semmm Judge on appereciathn of the
1:1mta’2a1′ an rmord . tim accuaad finrthe
afiypzzmkhahletznderswfionfié am30’?E’Cs.nd
‘\-J
E
E
§
E
6’:
3
2:
Q
Q
§
5
‘7$
§
5
§
§
§
E
4%
E
n
O
1:
3
$
“E
§
W
§
§
§
E
¢%
3
:3
Q
@
§
$
“5?
§
W
5
§
§
dO1&f§m§ 5-éméfii m%’%’w:.e..{¢:;,é;:s;1A5?’:2;as?*;.»+”‘Q am mmrm M
nwawgax *s, Wm mmrormareunimtrww/«v:
3%” M%K$T§ §m%a§K$.§§’§¥ W13?” Rflfliflfififififlfi Tfi””¥%M§’ls'”{t MWWWE. W3 §%:£*:”‘1i¥£’%.>&V6f«I””§’-as-*”‘Ie\&\M!!”%#a mm
t11ra-:2 years and 12:: pay a fine of ‘V
defauk M aufiar rigorous
‘ by this judmezrxt of ” “tlfie
6, are the mm’ ‘ who
of tag assault by the
the ew:ier1′ as an P.W.2 and
evidence of P.W.1 when is the son and
.P.,W:§’*~wh::3: imam at’ the. bus. Fmna the w:den.oe”
‘ H V’é*.:a;P’:W..-ti» it is seen that on therelevant dfle, an
A the aecusod n-amad in the bus keeping
kj M.!i3r.9 and M.{D.1G in may bag and attackzad
‘4 xP.W.2 and P.W.3 when they was gaming inside tm bus
whmzfimmmwassmppcdinfinmaftmflmme.
} ’12
3 Vxviyflfiwfl flfl ififlflfi H9354 W”§§WiVNHW3i J3 lflflflfi M9?” mawwmma 230 iflflfifi Z»-Wfli-E WEIWQVNHVEQ -nit’) mmm Hfiiiiufi Wwivmmw && iflfiflfl
Wu» ‘mvarvmv/wwa \’inWfl
m«z.:2:v”‘es’fim,<iiiV"frn.9r'"':w,2 and ?.w.3 the wound
<34;-:a'fifi£:ate3 — the Sasinm
Judga-.2, assessing the
concluded that on
11.a3.1§9s mek mm and 1′-.w.s. min
‘sf ‘5 supported by evidence
juattaable gmund to iuterfiere
A. . wcrund ca:-fificabe Ex..P’.5 relating ta P.W.2
that wound No. 1 Q yievoua in nature and
VT waumia are simple in rzatura. Wound Ha. I in
3 xE:r::.P.5 5%} am that it is a lasmtaed wouid 011$’ the ngh1′
shouldmr with cut musck: and home men through tbs
§_j,a-
Wvxmaw $0 Jfiflflfl Hflllé V)E%%.VN&W)I #0 1.3303 flfiflfi wmwama $6 .m7am H95}-I VXV.iVNXW)§ M} imam an-mm W”%WE’WML%ieW%aE .M”3 mnnw ma
JV mmmxwwwmm. WEWW wmtwtmm W’? wmflmm2Mm.m”-nfiwm-mgwwmm wr mmatmmirmmm trwww vwwwswu wr wxmmmmammm wawm wwwma wu” :sv»..mmwmw.mmm mlwm www
waund. Exfififi 1’3 anatller wound catificate
?,W,.3 anfltiw samnsp-acifiw that wauld £«’I’i:i’. ‘~1>« V
in nafimre and other wounds am 9i’.”I4’1eyA’ “-‘m’..’__t I J, V’ A T
wemzd 3%», 4 dmcribed as
mmamng 3 cm. x m cm. 31 ga mg pgm
E:x.P.5 and vmavxzrzdifioi: in mztuzre.
3. the But of Im-rm
dmxgaa’ ted “‘ :1; the am reads as under.
H ‘V _de~a»@4e££Ju=2d’sts:”*grie*aou.a”-
X T Fix-£9 smawumon
V Swond1y – Pmmanemt prisatbn of the
&[&s;g,:m: firearm eya.
1h%fl3v~ mha&ndt&
Fuu.rthly~Priva&nofanym;e:1:nbex-of
jsirzt,
/4\,./\/
L HQEH WKWRVMXWQ -W”! Bflfififl §-£e9l~”§§M wuwawmmwm mfifl gunmen um”; wuwwwmauwm mm awmmfl ngsgmzrs
Wu7?”§l-“bm?E’l«lP’9A.IVm’N:mok”%2 fit” Ei\ElNP’mi”Q.. IKE
Fifth}? ” ‘ or 99″”
jnitm
the head arfiace. ..
Eizhthly - aw)' lifie :21' 'd*.:1'ing the space bodily pain' fir fc'§aw" !.
impaum ‘ es” the powm of any mm a,
Sixthly — peunanett 91’ T.
9. Avtnaah She-my Vs.
swig ET I set: (:1-me’ 315 haki that
menticrns in the wound
the aamsfailsinone of
mpema under Section 320 Im. The
gfzmrms as dam-ibed. in Ex.P.5 and
N WWWWH Wm mfixyajfefimmamm xrwww wwwiu WE” wmmmmemmm flifiwm mmwm WW mfimwmmm M§%;M*% fififiéfifif W5′ %fig$7$f.§’\§£%C”£”fl@Kfi, Hfififi fiwfi,
dc mt fafl under any can of the cabagé
spec§t=d under Sectian 3% IPC. Thmvfare the: nature of
‘mmsvmwa M mam ms»; mmvnaw m Lzmm mm vxvwmw so imam was-5 wmmmma m’.p.f*n}m mm wwimvmw m mam M
«aw » w wma 71W x we aw as :?:”\Vt, 2:wM;;
a¥3H°’\\nfi?~.”§!?( wwwmx ww” mmfifggaffmmfimmm mwwwm a…-wwm W?” mmmmflfimwa mum mzum if?” géemwmamw. Mifififi m;;2w&”5″ WW Nfisfiwfifwfiwfi gmggjflw CW3.
I0 ߤ
summed’ by 1=.w.z and 933.3 wifi A’
Swflon 324 of IPC caufim hurt by
am thesam wiil mt fall SectI0 ” V’
Saaaiana. -Juclgwx, witheut
griesmus hurts 1.111531′ 32:’:%:§f of
E:n:.P.5 and Ex.P.§;1′:v ‘gang the
amused fart Section 326
avaiiame mmamnwn be held that tha mm
¢;a;useat Am i%.xé.2 and 953.3 do caanstitutza
géfirfifmbk un«.-1m- Section 324 ms and not
iarequired to 12¢ mediflad.
I13 &1das unsign-
(:}\\/_.«~–*’\/
= WVLVNfiW £0 1.3003 HQM V%W.%VN%W)l 50 A3303 MQJH VfiV.£VNHV}i #6 A3303 M95}-3 V)W’3.VN§V§l :10 lfiflfifi HQEH V)W.W’NEW)l :40 mg/my i-I
L§’*2x..34″‘¥5:l!’$slir”fi£!””€’afi£$”‘*3:E!’?¢«z¥’~’?; Wfi&Vm’a’??W’3 wwwmm WW5 1EVxs?”R«fii”e.$?W«é”‘”{b€§é’?”‘i%K’%#”% K”fi.fi’&W§.”7fi “¢*»m”§:d’¥ufi
JV !f’%.a$'”$W.iW&’U:E£”‘%%’% %”‘§WEi¥i”¥ ‘kéfiflhfifififi V5?!” §”0.fi°’$V’£\§’fi:6″‘%.N(§”§l$’és.§Wt. li'”Rtt»’?kaW¥§”¥ V¥:m:WnWVhct5W5.§ WW W\«f”%%’1W’W;?”%.$s?”HVwfiW; §§E2W%’§.’$ ‘%«%r5!’53so«#§’%§ WM?
11 m..fi.3.l§.o’.Ha’5
‘I5.IbaGnsfit1d:emzo_fierweunder
Smnflan .307 we ofme afiienoe ‘
be,p:v*%t:’
M an intasrflan of or
relating
For the pnrpm o_f’_S&J ‘ rt.
mmriai is the ¢::’r-the ‘
no: the mnsemenoe 0}’
tfiépwzwse 0}’ $336 T313
fisrifs in £m’ng
an ammmt of The
miwmfion or must be
such as is In
the a.!_;:senz:eӢ:gff knowledge which is
the ::’e5é:easazy* 307; there
can be .m::., c:-_,,3’I;:fna~2, ‘v_f mfianpt flu mwtier’.
Infant Bf mind cannot be
mg as a: fact it
Tar Enferredfiom other
Mcfiom” Sonia gnaw refiwwxt ‘ ‘
csfthe weapan uwd, the
the nature
% me w in which
wok piw Can the evidence on
V f:fzep%tim has bamabie In
that the villagers have susxmnad
by firing and itw-as an
apgéxwrvaaudfiznerwafflwinjwedrzemfiy
tfmisacaanspieieladccfeuidenoeafintention
ta mam such injw-imfar which the amused
M513″ WHWIWKIKHW JQK fl3l£”9fi”\*’§ maxim wmawlmmwmmnw a.mu.’ k:V1.’}s;m.1Iw.an.. m’une.ga”;n L:q1«1:§2a. mm themwith sickle.
_ to straw that the ammed
of PW-2 & PW-3 gfing into the bus
Furthsmr, there is no ev1dence’ on
V the aocuaad pa-eparod thexrmubau in
suammm by PW-2 and 333-3 am that of that
add%mt§s, t1*1eevid%ofPW-1 tn PW-4-d.iscbaas
thatafcm’th¢ix1cidm,,flmaecu.sedrar1awm.*fi’omthe
xxx/”‘”
Vflvlvmflvil £3 l_Wflf’I_'”) 3-QHHM wwmswmmwm Jfl Mann-w m.zMa.,sa umwawmrvufiu an M.-r=.9.’««m %mHL..:m>n Imammyw 93!
*3″
£3
:9
E
E2
3:
“‘»z>’?’ W7?’ 91% 15
WE mwmfifiwmnmmm wmwn zmwwm WK” mwmwmamfim Wfiww mama U?” %fiK?<¥fiiW&fi& flfififl flflifim" Q?' Kfikgéiwéfli
i4 £2tL..&.2J.§£.Q§
spat. an the cthm fund, the eviderace of pw-5 d'ncIafs.g_a_fu :" ::.
that, am: amuaad went away from the spot _::
fiddw to mrm, there is no enridexnecxn é ' %
aeczusad mm: to the spot m advance 2
bzicycie and they run away in
incidm; mm it is mmtrmt
the mm :2». the to
prewznt the W-3 and
30 aka m catch on
mm wnablfihw fiiie no m1en1:i<x1' on
true ta PW-2 & PW-3. The
in cenvlctjng the
under S5930'? m: in
the asmnmn to c.-mm death of ma & Pw-3.
_ no msmrialk placed onmcord m
A' prepared thnnzmclwa in advance
M, & PW-«B. The taamnlity of the
wmvmw M mam 1-mm wmvmmw go mam was-1 mvxvmvx 40 .z.uno:: Ham vwmmw am ggnogmwg %%WwWm m mam Mi
an wmrnnmwwemrmxzw mum-as mwwmm wt: mamsmavw-anwwaw-a aammsvma mwvwamu Wt mJWe.xwtcvw»Hs»'*Mxw*9s §'s:§\3=;M2s wwrwww Wm' mmmmmmammaw new" MMMME *io.,M*'" mmmgwmammm mgwm mww
15 W..A.33.§.€Q§
ofabsezzxzzmf ixztmxtizsn afacctmesitn nnmier PW-2 & '
3.
:2, ‘rm maid” em: had taimzpzaee am 3.0
back. €311 the date at’
‘ 93-} cf 25 y-wars
boy 91’ 29 years and ‘ 1}-Iévizag
azzd m talmn into
mmdsmtjmn while A for than oflbxxoe
by
the __to bus on hgher side. I am of
am! ‘ of this
ai’ be met by aentmofi the
5} of di already undmow
V ‘f§:~w_f3vfKF”‘ of Ra.1.’3,000[- max and ‘m dcfault to
1: to umwsampm ‘ ‘ an-
aiae 1*i1-3:.V,.5;:i’€=i3zmor1tb byanchoftha accused. Gutofthe
fine smwnt, mmcpmmatzkan 91′ Ra.14~,000}’- to each of the
<:2"'\2"'\'
fig lxflflfl QQXEM WWWQWMSEWE Jfi EMMMW umltfi wwwiwmfimwu !cm."n'm':'A'!"\na.I-on sw.am..£Ln .4. u….,……. H
Mfifiw cm
Wwfl
§
fig
Q
E"
%
3
Q
Q
E
:%
§
§
§
2
E
E-
9
F–
&
m
as
Q
2
§
3
§
§
5
E
is
3
§
3
3
3
5
2
§
§
5
i
16 W..A.2lfil52§
mum’ ‘ PW»-2 and mt-3 is awnrdad. ?
atawd abewwe, the follawinga
The mml
Ear the Ipc
x smwsaed Judmt
for the afience
ggaxxsananxe Seo.307 my Sec.34 we in
pea-ind airway xzndmgom as
A under sec.32-4 wt: and in pay a
‘ gm: m.15,o0a1- by each of the accused
ix: dafiult to pay fine tn uzfim szmk
m &ram’mfisk mxmthseach.
Out aafthfi fin: amaunt, a sum of Ra.1-13,000}-
\l,.z/\«\/
vgggyjywfiyfi 59 gang? H9″! vfivjlvfixvx $0 lafiam H9!” Vxyfilvfluvx #0 MIHO3 H9!!! V)EW.l.\1N}fiW% wkfie mnrm mm” wwswawmzsawu .2;-1 Ivmnn an
I. £u..1:…: :5: z!.:e;u:IIa§ 145…: 3323!:
.t2.:.§_.¥a 1,; agémveéfiémfifimfififi inflame waifimfi «.3. §3§23u§,m_..3 wig?
“.T!;g}g?§
17
is awe:-éed as anazxpenaaatzisan tn
vsetzm P-car-2 am)?-3. 1
LRS.x’dh
E33 fimfidmvk .w.%§€mm§.&.§wwu§..%..§ ..m§ 3.3333 fiaifi gfigmgfimgifi .33 u.K§$§.§ a»._m…,§;w §%.£_¥..:¢&$n§,?_3a mg ¢,§.§§w§» awaisnu §a§E:$a§§n pm? §§§%§.2i ma.B:.; uL§3F3_fa9a§?.?; 3.3