High Court Karnataka High Court

S Gopal S/O Late Swamy Kannan vs N K Jayaprakash S/O N N Kanne … on 6 November, 2008

Karnataka High Court
S Gopal S/O Late Swamy Kannan vs N K Jayaprakash S/O N N Kanne … on 6 November, 2008
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda


IN “§’EiE HEGH €Q’;{3i_3R’i’ (BF ix”‘Ai%I’é£&’1’§fi{A, E3A§€(§E§éLQRE

§)A’E’E’:”;_’i)) ‘3’}a£IS W13; 6% {BAY :3? E*sI«:>*+.r€1*:3;3:’;»:”:.1f_«’;;?;_{}{¥S:

BEWDRE

‘I’1r§3 E-££f3§~E*E.%LEI; me. .»;u:3*:’:<;:§*;;%% }3g::a:.:i:§::§:;:§§*g;s;s§:§:k. "

E*vE.F.A, ?*€=::_ .g§£}6i§"f} E" 200%?

BETWEEN’: A %

3 GOPAL 35:3 L;;f§E«-Swgusy x§Ar;z_x;;:._rs:”«.A

EEE§’€D%,I. NOW as 3? YE:_§{§7€E ‘ %

raga {‘€€§}=5i§1h%’§’E-E €::a:<;;:::;s ' '
héUNESE;G;%R;”

z4:<';s:;%a='u,2*s2.. L§J;fQi,FF , . _
fiEgi5&.?.'${f:§.$§-'E4J(.fig§£T:€-E;V:.E'€fi5{:'$6%:{_ I ' * '*–.–;–.~:a??g':JLAh*T

_ {:93}; 39.2. "S 'gaiziéégjisiygigfixéraa, A;3v.;

_~ LA 3-: ;i;~z:5 i;3€jfl}Ni3»§;E€
_ v.’:£E3′:§£5-*3; ma5g<:R
_ "–v.R;'.,£;M':*§r: *. E s:a1N Egan
i’:§§}§{§<i:%Q§jGGDi,
.- §'3$E'fE.£.%AL{3RE :2§

.. :2 $5 £3R;'aI'«ECH§*eiA§€A{3E§.

{Z%§{EE§%T{1L

§§”€$UEi§3;E’°iCE {If} ,¥J§”[;’a

?’~€{_3I2iE, 3AE’:’JAE%§:”a£\%$g%§;£ CfI}§~JiP’L’£:}i
BGSUE. Efiéfiéfé §%?f}:’§}f}§

§a§_}U{§€”_’l%E”}E,

§3z%NC%£’3;L%§5T§:?;”§5§ $39:

‘E{E3P{)%=§D§€;}%”§$

{B}? Si”‘i.§iS§*§{}§”~: N ?AT§Ii 33?}? R2}

Sm)

?s:1I=’;”a FELES U_;’S« 1′?3{i} C}? §¢E’s2′ ACT. £=.{}.A§§’$$’§ THE <Ji}D£377.¥iE¢iTE?€T
ANEZE §'a'-éJ'z%F€':I'; E}AM'1'Ei} '£i§{3'¢T20Qr3 Ff'-.8833 {$3 $24" {I Nf;}.;3{}? 31*-I
Téiif. Z"-'ELE ff)?' EX RDIIJ§TE{3!€AL JUDGK CTC')UR'T £3? S2§!hfiLL.C}k?}3T.E-33.,

Es;iEEv€BEF-'I. E~«'§1'sCT»'?', BAi'=E€3A'§,<'T)R':C;, P.£9:R'?L':' ALLC3'$JiIiGj""i"E{?3x'~CL:%;.f§vE'~.
PET§TiC§N F(j3§<3 C'.{L%?=iEP§E'\I$RTI€}N :'~&i'€D $EEIE§£N{} EIi§{s3$&C%–.EE¢€A§EEi:"%f" "

C{}M?E»NS,{3;T{{}N5

Thig Evifiifi, comiilg 9):: far a€§i11i$§i_0:§: thiS"d21y,' 'tibia

Caurt madg the fzyll-zawing :

.,;g;’::%::s:%+i§:;:~:’§*~«%.% ” V

“§’h.i::”:~ a;3?g}é::§é;£.L.is the”‘¥;1a.iH§ai”:t-fer aiihaxécemfzzgt of
:::®mpe3;113a¥§iz:>n_;”‘V é ‘ _ V

$”::af.§:,i:E:fi£i Esadiijg in} Elfififi in a
Elliiiiéi” :*;(::a'<:1'a{*Ci€i§§%';:g§,»T.:;§f;€T»;:gi;:;:-fiicizaaci thri. MAST, Baragafuara,
Sfifikiilg rj{:::_*§r;'1;»;i:1Ti§'é,a'i5ia:s.:1, Aj-Tiie 'E'r§3i:ru::ai awarffieéi Eaira a
313:1: 3:}? Rs,?3,'i},i}i§f- §%'§.'i"i 5.25% i:1'i€3:¢;%st., Agfievad by fix:

a_a;3pr%;2ia;1t=é '""'z15a$ greffirraii this appaai fer

7 ':33ii;i1a;':::<":;:5':::€}:e;a<;fi" e::f Ciéfiififiiifiaiifiilu

*2, A§j 'i';§':€fi*'@ 11:3: iiif.-'2§_ZIzE.1i%i §"'f'i:g§f{iiE1g i:'1_}1;::*i€;§ :~3::S€:a§:1€:{'i

'A ::h§’ Emati :a<::(":is.:i€_m: azzci {ES

§::§g;"}€:'2»§é is §;<r'&f%:r:'€:e:£ fiitfzsr E3}; i:ht:- {}wz1a:" i§'1SEj§I'fiE"' sf %:i3¢:%

— s:§fft:’§1¥:i§.§:g vésiiicia {?E1a§3::”::1g:i:’:g {ha féziriéézg <3?' 3&1? "§':'ibi;:=':2:i

V' "§’i ifzsi: if-f.:~31:i~i: ‘§§’:é3§ ‘£15: a§:3¥}€:’§;i3::3E §”§?_n1§:”»?’.§3.§§’3fi1fj.’i §’:”:~i”:.::’fi=’ 3:”: i}””::?r

5&5

La.)

W59, ii-

acczcieni arising 91.1: (if t%:t:1:~ C%f.{I11{)’i,{)3.” c}=”<:1-rgt Eéfifififig }."«u::., «

%

K;~'a.8§:3. EFf3§Gi39 an Eioimr reati jf

ihe t3i'13:\_,2" iss-:;ua mat, §£:i11a;§1"3_s f01*"-A1313" {'Ii}1"s$_§i–'§'i."§t"?§1'eE;§§iZi€j'I1

whfithaz' the co:':':p€;::sa'I:i0:1 633:1 T:*'%}3'L1:3a} is

321$? zmii }3E'Qs§}€i"1" <31' ii: '(:,_afi§-3 fi7:_~1" eszxfiagzijvézzifizzii,

3. This a;;:;1e:§§?3:$1i §;£16f§§i}G:¥:i§1g i.§:1}’1:ri=as,:

Frat:-:{.::’§§._’ ‘ mi’ xigizi tibia and
€?:3;3i’A1§V$si:§fl”{%§§ff~:h1:” ;:2;i*3§€i,”*i\”i;fi C-.?:«i€;} 313.3 r_7spi§:€:<:%. ihai
§;'2}t_1:"§; ';'\E:§;.'1 :'::'a.€:.3r:?:, Appeiiamt 's::€€..a*{.&<:E

in <:€3§::*s;€}1*g:3;i;?;V%:*._ é*:iai"::'1€:r in E{Z':E'€'i'ii1g 1r£Q$§;:§i3':.

éfjigéiiéiéi-€:1M':1§g i§i%""'s3§¥:1::, Rs»;2)53€}§

gizfii :i<_::r.[I’é3i:ii’v::»*:§<:E an}; z§:€<,ii€:ai isiiis g:,:p;:x~{:~:""'€i:1g his C€}Z'1'§f,€23'§§{}§1

fifzail Em Tim:-3 S§:€;:f:'i:. RS:2;§,;€3€.fiEi}j =~ i.m*»;a:'{Es t:'<:::§;im%":1':t

. — §f"§€f§ :,_a:'"is§: 2;1':s:3:':%;: a§'1s:i (TQ'§'i'~'J{':fx§8,¥;':{3ii?: aizsiii i..i':e:'%:::?<3§":::,

E33, E.€j§§€i}{}€1}/ ~ a "é%f€§f;',::::=:’ <}3'i:§{::* 3:: ii} Ciifiifi'

:'%'i£f;L–':

44,!

“i”?:11*t: the: §:2pc3:T:3af¥.:€>m 23%’ _SE15.»”§”f§~;5T§€}i3§’;£—:’ ~

z~_23;;ai’ci€:d ‘{3}; {ha ‘i’:”:?%3:111:_«1E Es; __,fiiE7§§’f§a’%l1{f?3€’§ ” éat?5′;’is,,€_§:”%::’%’j:ff V

1″.’ ‘.

E€S.2$,€3€j’2{};’~– ¥i?’fi’fi”i §L;:;§4.*:-::”v::S3i’ at €}5.’?i:1; *E:1’3. :%’:{:_§E5::’:11;$§:’
<:m§:;3:.=:1":;:sa€,§€::'r1 f1'<;:::1 the :;%:£i:,_€i"~.g;:§' ijéviliigiéfifgv 'VET-i€;%i-*'E..§:':'–£i'V

;:aajgr}.?:s 6:12;,

:33 '§'h€ 3'c?;:3p{:2"1é;1rii:i2E, = ;if11;31,:§::'aA:i1:f-siaf, 13332:: cQg:§pe:”:$:;éif’ié:’:~ g2.;::’a:::::j;i. ‘w=§_§§:i1i um §1′:a::1’i”h$

f:r'{;:m .§I§’i§f.’v{1§n§§ii§%:’€}’fVi’; “.sf’:§;’;’;sf;A€f:.€’ a; :3? §T:i”}.€i zawani,

ix-ma

;%{:<::§1?<:.§i:':g';%f%'; ?:€"§:§ié;;:«<:;§1é is aEi€:2W€:{i, J1,3JiT3;g":"11€iI}i' 3::"§e:§

9:; =*3.if€'§, ;3;§s$:'i:€i I£33:'. .i.':':{E'.'§7*1*'i%3':":::;V::::§,E is Ixiséciiéféeiii; "Etc: i;.§'2€: €::;<;i:::;1'€

Sd/-3&1
Fudge