S Lingaraju vs Paramashivaiah on 9 June, 2009

    Angadi, Aziv. ;

:32: '1'-Hg: HIGH '%,1}1?"I'€;_';E<' RARNATAKA A'? 

i}A'I'EE} mist THE gm am' 9}? <JL§§%..j'39 .;2;€§§§§)«.A  "  

PRgs§Nff7 ' 
'FH§2 }~£€;}N'BLB: :\4;'<:.- :5,   A
Tm}: H<3N'B.LE3 MyRf4..=.é':;::*s*:?:L<;:;;§ B';$§:EEN£VASE GGWDA
}x;:_.,i§'.A.   §zvI'*~.:'<::;

BETWEEE; 

as Li:figé;iifia§:3L;5. 4' % 
5/9 S;__ {}2§a1es2':::--;2§,~pa,   
Agéd a§:1m1*{, 411$ gfezzgrs __ " 
R,' 0 1'?t33"V--€::'os$,"'.E§'f1:? Nzaigm',
'{i)a§a::ag£:z*e*  V.   

 AFPEL¥;.£\N"E'

I    

1.

Sri Pzafafigasfiivaiah
“A$;€3iS§»3fii. Fcsms’: fjifficfizr,
~ ; Eicider uf Jaep bearing
§€a,MEP-$2558, R/Q Lflkikfiffi Raga,
” N.& 4 Read;

I}a%;a3″:agere4

2.. E»{,£§.LE:i. iviefassr Bfaiifih,
B3.:1galQre.

it! ?’€;é%€ {3§2N’T$

{§r.;%§,: :5:::;:::-.€ A,.i:;1 v_i;a:.;a, gag, ; {gt

This MFA filed u1’1d:E::;’ S€:<:ti:”‘: 173(1) CE. {I16-}ii€E3:.f ‘}’f:;Cf%’
agaiimt {ha judgmcint anti award tlateci }_9_._1″ épapsagci
in Mvc: N9. 3:31/:;[_ ;;’.’9r
aempanfiaiion anii Stifikifig r::1ha1*:Ce:’:1éfit= (‘sf _:;i7<:»1113:§¢:1'§;t3§;iii:311.

This appeai <:r:)111iI1g £01' {£163
C3wi;:gi ”

’12 M

5 is D 36» ;fi.’;E”_;§£_~&
Thia appfiai i3 ‘ijxy-‘%”3″1r:’V€:}aiA1r1:;”s;§.*g”E’TVs£E3€:»,i+:ii’1g firiiaaxicemfint
of ::0mp&:’3t~§a.£i:§ii 1’0??? 131$ injpatjé’ S:1_’.i’$€a37ned. in a. m<::at0r

t::~:hiz:i¢_ apc5x:§nfi:i%_; V

12. E=”{:s:: ‘that? ‘g:ré.1r p»_$v:”:__}”é.>};”‘. s::0mvr:n§_e:1c&, Ti”]:1e fjafiififi am
mféjrrezi ts: as afe raferreii tat; in ihfit ciaim f_§€'{i3Ii€L)1_”1.

Q-§V=T;’i’i§,§20(}3 at 3,08 pm. whfirl 1:hv:-, clainxaxifl: was

“W
.1

pé{§dii%1g’1fi$ bis}.-vie an mad, in fmrtrt. cf EDT Miginearirig

“<;';Q§}<::gé a fieép hearing Ifigifiifafifiil N0. ME? $288 ci:r'fwe13 in

'a f%i–2_$h and nagfigaiii maxniaz' by its {i:*i2z€1" dashati agaitfist

the §fititi§:'1r::.i: 8:1 ac:t::«'u:'3!:i :3? {ha aiiiliifififii 'th.z:': pfitifianer

fell {$313511 fmrm the bicjgcis amci s1,:si'ia:i:1«=:<i @'i€:':1?Q3;1S iiijiifififi.

He was §IfiI"E1E{iia'fE§}é' takezz ta ~:'i'{.':. H<:}spi.fTafi, Eéavangmfis. in

\N/.

:Ci;0{:u.n1€:nta1’j; fivitiétmca on r’€<:oI":;i heiéi t}1a§:~~–§}1%
was 011;. accmint cf the 135.11 anci
jetiizp by 11:5 CII'i"J€*;}' and the
actienahie nagligerzce. '1§1;3e'3¥j€:E:f«1{ti3\\'v.~–.i»;£, ]»jéjt:§X\ ,5?
medical cer"{i,'fi(:a.t.c:: Ex. P 4 '11:h_§: efiéicirfiiffii I113 dactar,
wI"1i£:h discioses t}1a;§i _:t"jf3ei s1is'%ai:'m(1 fractura
cf bath h0z;:es__L:123c,”‘ffz-;2.<:t:i;1reu€%§i'S'h§;i~.¢é:1c:i Lima and. zadius anti
Gthfif };a.é:6:1'a¥.::%£1" §;::g§ii1?§é-:3.4ail {}V'€:§' the b<::::'ij«1 He was

izapaftiézn: fi;I' 88_i;ia}¥'-':3 if};ét€1"I11:i'i:.'s:A:=:2'a"£i}.: in that .%'1es;3:iiaL Evan

:3*f:*2:*£1:1€11I;A'EfiiS' Eeg was s.'E';9:':,€11<:<:i by 2 C1115 and

:ita.,1§'::':::"¥.§:é;;'s;;&'_*;=.;-$*:'=4;'1"<:_ éffiaiifinfici anti there: is 19% :;ii$abiiity {cm the:

Whfiifi Taki:;<g i1"1t€3 rgoilsitzieraiiaiz me eiajm pefition,

U16 :3:iaf;;».~E}1*iai 011 i"'€~fi'f{)]'"d, '(ha 'i'1"i1::1,ma.i has awardfid a sum :31'

V."V'.AA§€§'$.:?;§{}§{3i}£3/~ 'iowarcis gain and stiffaxing, Rs,€22,2=%4/~«

.. jéwarfig 1053 :3'? fizturct aarrzirzg, taking Eha §jE1C{}i1'16 Qf Em:

itiaimarzt at }?.::~:.I?€f)/»~ petty' {ia'_*;, a 51,311} mi' Rs.?,:"Ea{}€}/- was

awardfici iewaréizs £535 ::;sf §:":c{:s3?z:& £:i1_11*i:1g iaid 1.1;') ffififiiéii,

// I
y"

g

Rs.8,G{}0/~« towards medicai éxpenses ~«

¥:owa:’ds icass of future enjoyzizerzt and «.Ti1§,is’

all the ‘.Fri}::una1 has awarded S1;x§1é1 iv<)54i7,§"~."§4:~s}1-,;3"?g:?%§£$»;.?'? V

glabal compansaticrn Wii}3,iI}};fiI'E§Sf;A at 8%p;}i'. dais
Qf fifiiitififi fill ihc date 0:" «. by the
said awarti of the "§'1*i1;'3._'iL}I:9_1é._t_£1;;-gi: 113.3 prefarred this

appcai se€ki11g.;3I1}*ianr;:%3'11:m"1f; _ ' K

5. L&a13j1ed_Cci1i1$é§,”_’ for the t:E-31113311:
assailing iiir1:§*v_.,i::1§::11g'”z£3é=:’§ afward has canienzied that ms
ciaimaaifi was ._fi:éf§ri.:1g “a;%s a cabin b::>§: and saznixlg

I%s.;2,–8Tg{§/ fl1é”éLCfi§i£it::11t is 01” the gag: 200}. and tha

°”{:1aE3:::1ai%fi $9135 a ehance af eafliifzg mom in futuré, the

in an error in taking Raff} ,1 * as

iflC¥3I§1fi.__’}3′{31″4″‘{§&}’. Sinziiafiy the claimant was irxpatisnt far

da3»*S:$;”1v:i he 1213.153′: have heén urififir rest. far % nieizflas,

‘ °¥:.§§éraf3z*€ ha (:0Lf£k7E net rammis ta wmk and tiiarefera fhtffi

“€€§;EII}j}€I1S€ifiGi’i awarciézzi Lmiier 816 heat} ‘E055 emf incazim

céurigzg freaixnem: pariaci is 335% 013 the 30w::’:%:* rsititia.

.Likex.?s:is& $326 3;§?§-“§fi'{i 0%’ E433. §.€},{§{.}(};- iawaréis fut”i::’a

a11′:$:1ii:i<-as is ai:-:0 :I}§§%:3{if.é{€i.Qn is
aWa1’ci<%(i to 'a:*ds f'L'i'{Li1"f'; grieciical expfiiifiés,
anti :3€;:.13'i5hr11<:*11§ Ckaargfis.

&n.}71:a11::c=::11t:1′;i; Qfc<::1z1p:e:":mi",i<}:":.: '. 'T — — V V M V

6, Per c0I:¥:::a 3€:a3'r1§t:i _ {3§;::11é§'c1_' fox' am
:'esp0I1de111: S'i..fiZ)1"I1itf.fi{i 'i'm pL1.§;fit:{i… av;*ar<§ is just
and proper and it €iQ€i;5:figjiefeifgéfi}fag:%£i1:fiif;e:¥1C6n1ent"

7. The t.ha’t ‘ihtt CI23;7::11aI1t

‘5i§::fii~; ;.;3 §e-‘€–ai\\5.§.v.a;:r=;r;_ i:I:e”€i_étr:__ ~::sffi:he. :’:’:CCi€i€i’1′:’.. He was walking
as a ‘Cabin ‘b;<:¥§;~ "§3f1' Eihfiatre anti he, was ci1'awiI1g

E¥Zs,2,-3;f3(T'i/-5 ..§:g.'1:'2.7' at: 1:": the instant case 136

'V " A :*st:iS':E3§3fr;§r_iV%_ g:"ié¥.%§'1;:$"§.V:::_§'L1z"i&3 $1,113: 3.5 ii? frax:1:.u:'€ aparf: from

_ Vggth-€::":V'i,V€::?i*z:3j{.c%{1 waurziis. He was inpatifint fax' 88 days

i:";'si1″Zt”§hS perieci far