S Panduranga vs Karnataka State Financial … on 6 June, 2008

IN THE 3:33 ccuam GF KARHAEAKA AT héN&&L¢§E" 

-1-

DA'$'E'.D THIS THE 6?' D3;Y"'GF'J°fTNE_.,.':2i§Q8:  

pm»:s21r€'fr.V  ' 3
ram HQN'BLE MR. Jfl$$iQE L RgRAgAmA*$wAMf

warm Pmmxrxam NQ,f276;3eo?'1K$E¢f

BEEWEESN :

3.

-.-..w.w.....-e...

s PADfiRAN@A _ -A;
32% Law£aR,sH;N:vg$A_"!},V =
NQ.§,{HA3flMfiJfifi1REBD¥AROAD;"

HAL&$fiRf*RA3GA&QREV'7

FETX TEGNER

'_$r;_s,§ §aAm1§'3"@'aIRI$H, Amv,. )

Kakfiamaxa}sTAmE*§IwANcxAL CGRFGRAEION

'*gAvINa-xrs BRANCH QF?1CE AT HQ.2T16,

1 F;0oR,"saz;HARsHA aoan, MYSORE

. Rgyfn, By xms ASST. GEKERAL MARAGER

 134.5  VA

*.§g3"¢fiA$RMAN & MANAGING nxagcmoa

KAR$A$AKA.smATE E:NANc:AL coaponawzom
m9,1; mH1mMA1AK ROAD,

H" .EaN&&LaRE~55a ea;

:65?

wflm nmfiumy aommxssxoflma

aamaaaaaa HREAN mxsm.,

BANALORE

... RESPORDENTS
Sr; N KUMAR FOR R1 5 R2 )
33: N HANUMANTHARREA, xcey FOR R-3}



-2,

rams WLP. FILED PRAIING we acnafia raga :33
ACTIQN 0? THE RESFONBENTS 1 AKD 2, mg» xxvcKE'a
PRQVESIQNS OF sgcmxom 32(g) 0F;"iHE] KA£HAw3KK.'°
swarm FINANCIAL. coapanamxbns. Ac2,_*u1g51» As i

ILLEGAL, ARE CQNSEQUENTLY,

mars wnzm §mwxTIoM'coMIfla'cN FOR ?REfiIE3N$Rf>

HEARING xx B GROUP wnxs gay, was gogR§"M§bm THE
FQLLOWING; ~ ".u* »_'J~ 2

g3§§§[  .

The petition§£u fi%§:5b¢%r§$éd a loan bf
as.25,0o,0QnXf;_ :§:€$a §$§a;§§n#r dafaultad in
payment d§fl}§#§; ?£fi%aadifi§s,have been initiated
u/S.31§1}}a$f aad $%§ 32-¢§ the Kaxnataka State
winafig1a1v §a§§§x§ti§n; get, 1951 againgt the
suxetg'h§;d§r'¢fi §fi§}§i1e af the First Additional

fiisfirxst Jfidgé} Eaore in Misc.Case N@.5f29G1.

A ':fi"tfi§:x%apwhile, the first raapundent issmed a

i.qéfi@%Wd&u$&:*m&tiae ufS,&2{g) of the Aat aa pex

Annexure§CA dated 2sw3~2eo7. as per the fiaid

V».n0tiéa 'the patitianex was due in a 3mm of

" R3€i,5?,§1,453[~ an& ha was askeé to ahaw cauae

V"w ": %it%in la éaym as ta why tha rewards shculfl nmt

be meat km Deputy Cmmmi$$ieners Qff1¢e fax taking

steps ta raacver thw amwunt due a3 arreara wf

i



land revenue. Eha petitioner in this §atitiqn_i§. *

ahallanging the ahaw causeIgoti¢§'&a£eau2Eg3g29§7

isfiued uf$.32(q) of the gut §s'u1travi;é§.f§x thé;

reasmn that there i$ g§1xead§x@fi 5p§p¢eading5
pand1ng' againat .§het sfifi§£§w fl§ider 'fiXS13l{1)(aa}
and hence the preséhfi §fé§éed@fi§§ @/S.32{g} wmuld
amount to pafi§;lelJ§%é§ee§i§§$4 :' 

:2.   '  xézsn behalf at" the
resp§#éé$t?m,g#§§¢%é%§aa iwghat the prmmeedinga
ufS.i1{§}{éa§  $nfi"~§&§ [proceedings u/S.32{g} re

not a p§£a;iel;  pé§cea&ings, but thay are

*Ww; fififiapenflamq '*w?r¢geedings. The pxoceadings

';fifS53;fl§£§a} ia against. the suxety' haldmr and

"tfié« fiffiséédings u/$.32{g} is against the

principal harrower.

3. fine yatitianar is neither in a yosition

hm shew any legal praviaicn mar any deaiaion ta

sub$tantiate his contentian.

"\



...¢-;.,

4. It ia breught. to my natiae tha$Xl£&i$

caurt an zawawenav had fitayad _§h¢;; gé;é.

amnfirnmtiam tikl tha next  

wharmaftex an zmamaoev tn@figh "t§e_f ¢:ur;#e.'»raTr:::3,* Wstay,

the xceapanaent-~c:rat.icirxA  <*$Jc:s;;d  E'1f'amr<-év taken
azzaticrn purauant ta:  ,afi3.1f1'z1e f:v;t;z3";*e:V'~n{::'§  Kewaver, it is-3
summittea. by_ the i:éarfiga;«§mgns%§;.@pat mm finch

action ha$.--V}:'xe==.,~ariV_V_tg.aka:';__&$9 f.;ax°ff.v .

Q .¢ha w¢nfie§t:§n.of the patitianer is that

parallml Lj:r;°2<rm5%~:::::=a«$T.9}€AfV2:4J!;';'a.;'§:';,.'i.0lA'.lv'"Li;-$E---«'V3.l3.4'.§.'g"a.l. As long as the law

 'Z3¥§£il!tit?$§ '1ii3«%9f.;1.a.t-iwén of independent proceedinga, it

i«:<g 'n0t   for the petitioner to claim fihat

«V 'lT.T&e\ 1*§}a.i:V"§§l.l'é3. frarmceedings are illegal.

   Hence I pass the fallowing axder;

The wxit petition is disrnisaed. 'me

gxetitianer is pemrdtted ta file objeatians if any

to the ahew matxse notice at nexurewc within mm



W5-

mnth Exam the: date sf raacseipt emf this e;:'*r:;c3.er.

The respondents are 9e:r:'zm'.t:ted. to take appfégiiiégte

axtztian in aczcordanca with law, o2:1l3t–A4 :a,.ftya::*- ” “<':a Ii&::» "

math frown tha date of reae:i.p;_t~~0£

Mr, H iiamxmantharaya ;ifezérn–7e¢:1"'

pemnitted rm fiiwe his Csffl;fippeafi;#@§'e2–v…w:i§thin'. '

four weeks .