High Court Karnataka High Court

Satish vs State Of Karnataka on 3 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Satish vs State Of Karnataka on 3 December, 2009
Author: H.Billappa


‘I’HI:I- I’lI(.3§””l (‘T.(){}I-3’1′ (“H5 i{:’\RN;’\’l’.f\Kr’\

(“II-{(“‘{_..!l’l’ E%l1I;\?(…’l–{ :’\’l’ E31 I:=\l-‘{\=’\4’.~’\I:.)

nATHn11ns1wn:3M>nAv<n=wHtuwMfinL§xxfiIT«fa7

BEFORE «M-

‘r111c El£)%?l$IMLC A41<JJz;s;11<'1§'1;_r§fr;L;xrfi*E\'~. , " ' TfiTA

map.NoxH74H/20oQ1gwmfim§3. }x'"

Between:

Sz.’11isI’: S/0 law (_’3z112z1 ;:)z;:11″;!S2.’1 AVE:-513111f_\§’LTi:{1’c’.V’
.»’\.g’:-‘: 5(>’_\.»’L’21.1’.~.-;. (.)<.-(*2 I:'»1v1.sV;–iVr:.a.~}§:sV'– ¢ _ –
IR/211 z'\1'n!.)ik2;-1na;g.;V11f; I\'"c§:_.s11§.*.'a1.f.)1.1<1.'
Hubli 2:3. I'V')"1'f,12kl5fi}£,1:(I'1*Di91:l-'iV('1..__ .

(.’:t)1′:>e-:1 I S./L)’ Ii’1″i..<A9"( ':'i\:::1_j1V'1z'11._l izsgi' E<'Zi*:-r..1.i.1j1m Ru;itI;’ff-)¢&s;.;1i”(..j1%ass ‘

HumLINmnuuflfi$rMgfn’ .HJHfiTNONERS

(133: Sri. i*’.\”. E-“;i1V’iLI’-«.6; ‘H1Il’:.-j1\-;i~,,I;’.’i.?2»iIil. .«-“\(I\-we]

And:

‘ _’AI”1’1c-‘.._S’1 2.3%-.Lr.: of? K2-11’1 1′;-i’1″2′;1’i{V2_t
_ RtD1′:-“:%§”1’}.1(‘–£1 ‘?»>_V\_-‘ 111:.” Su<':1'(-r1'2.11"_\.-*
L_¥..)L-1p;1'r–i 1v§"::,§1'1»vf' k_~:;f: 2-1122]» Es'; E-{<.:'_L:"i.s'i. 1';-11 ion

I3'; :1 i"'mTa1 1<i'1"p2′-i 0 I£(_)m1z.1.1.’)1.)2-21 ¥–~loi;1;;’1

{S451 §7’f’£ii’.'”.-‘;, (i”,}(‘<.*: z\;,{1"i(~11Ii1.11'v
_ R.,z';11 fifizté" §\§2-.:;:;11'. [711I<e1l ;"'\1'L=*;1

~. ]-v{,1V;h§"i~_\ §')l1a;1I"u-"zul i)i.'=s11":'("I

Z,/,..

wit11111 1.1’1<..* <"Ic::'l'i1'1it11111 of "i1'15t1"u1'11c11I". S2110 e'1;__2;1'<=-;at::111__c='11I' is
111ccc.~.ss3a11'1'ly 2.111 11'1S11'1111'1c111 ;111(i it is 1"i1'125-1111112-1}')}(' wiE.}'1 .4C:i1.1:.tij,r_ '£111(.l
§.)("£1€111\-".

.1 1.. T110 ncxi q:1CsEjc’)1’1 \\-‘E1c.*.il’1″Lr1*-.1&1’1.c”–‘_4’i’1ji£1’IT’C_1i’1iu1″1€:1.i 11.1, t%.€’1;.'(“.1″..f1;T'(‘*_V

K’

(.io<:1.:111c11t' {'0 11110 [i)ist1'1'c.t Rc;1gisl.1':-1..1j1:11' c'(.)1i':.jc*1'1oT1f1'_. (1I";(1"{1"'1y E.111.("1 V

pc.1'11e1l1_v'? W }'11'1c=-1 i1 is t1'11('§.-" :.111(i1=11'1'.§§<*'{1.f1;11i"1-313 of t'.1V'1't1 'Ka1'11a{.aka
Stzunp A1311. G-.*.\»'c1'y pc1's<.)1'1 ]1.21\*i-T1'1g;g IL");-1' i';1w.._i..3:.9. jC(':)1j1Sc–'1"1l. 01' paflics
a11I.ho1'11y to 1"c¢c':c%i\-1:"12?7i'e:'1c1'1.=<,1e*.1.2:-1rrEc.i 1__3_'Ljv1f"ssc)1'1 11'1–<"ha1*g€ 0121

p1.1bl1c o1'I'i<ct1=-115:. '211"1'—- ()I;i'i«€jjc:1' 'adi? fl) ;.:ji1″1i1’111 xx.-111′] (l11I”_\/. is p1’ud1.1(‘c(1

or (fumes in f.h,(.’?’ ;:)c*19i’.(_11’1”.:_1£11-.1_cF’c1 of his £111-‘1ct.i()11s. she1.1E.. if it.
2iLp’})_t’€111’S_”€10 Vi_”1 1I1’1u I’i’1’«1T”+%.:_.1_<.%l'11 1'11s'11'1.11'1'1c1'1I' is 1111:' (.i1.1Ey ste11'1'1pL.%cl.

i1'111p<511.11 (}–1.t1'1z:j s"f11111&'=2-m(E ..s'c1"1(1 ii. 1.0 1111.' If)c1:)L1t'y Con'11'11iss1(.)11e.r

~..___1j.<) (.Im'(=1'11"'1'1'11C t:i"1'é-*j_ r;f:1.1'E_v 211'1(1i };)L'I'}E'11I_V. B111. in. the })rc'sC111{ (xase.

4K *.U'}.("._(i(){"1.I1']'1~f_T1i§. he-15-:. t)('01'1 tc.11<'k;'.1'e?(l in ox-'ic'ki:11(.=.L:. "F1110 1(:2.11'1'1c('i

"~.: ('{.}1.i1.iS£")1 £01' 1.1"1(‘*1.11m:.11E’. was

‘f”1=1–r.’>V1:. I’1*?111.i:;.r1’c.?c’.f in v\’i(lc.?1″1(.’c;.=. 1-%1.1Ij1}1.1’112.1i1.”1.<s. in the