High Court Karnataka High Court

Shafee S/O Khuddus Sharief vs Divl Controller Ksrtc on 17 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Shafee S/O Khuddus Sharief vs Divl Controller Ksrtc on 17 July, 2009
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda


3

mg mg; mam €Z{}E§§~?’§’ {>9 E~eZ.&E%%$ATAK§a, B?g§§{§;’§:;{}i§§’E§ 1%
SAYEB was <23: mg; :*;m% 2:55? $9'$;:;;§,*%2{§i:}«<3V__'*7~
BEZFQREZ 1 A' . '

-ma aazmm MR5 JUS’E’§€f:-}135’=§;’3RE§?%’E§{?sSE§’.:€§{2,$é~?VI§;§

Misc. 0:131; 169.. 2753{~’;%«Qo9 z:§’fif*a:§1s::3:* 12%;’; 0? 2005

SETWEEH

SH£xF’EE
Saga: 0??’ E{§~!%§Bi’§€JS si=;A:2_:’1£:F 1′ ”
AGES

séG.2,9–,%13Rs~V%cR:.§§53 _
SAB},}§§.¥€iYFL§é;%D Tfiflfifii-La –

p§«::,:,Aa:’?

{Bey 3&3: iéi. $§€E.§§*:E’€A§”‘Jfi; S:_. Ami)

‘ §:’s?3$’§{>é\:»,5gL;CQENTRQLLER, E{3R”}’C

._§~::3%mi;:1z”:;éI$¢’z.,$*v;{>:=s?

tax’

zcma. –

EE’\§’I’%;’~.’»§£”~%%L £!’§S{ERAN{3E E7″UE”4§

‘ .. }§{SR’§’€”;’;, Sfifilfifi Bzéavaw,

y:;’H,23aUE:_,§: RQAE,
2 $§£>AN-‘i’H:NAGAR,

‘ggA;azGA:,0RE:-2?.

RESPONBEETS

{E}; SR}: :3 A K Gfiwfifij §:;>1s:;

@.

Ex}

‘§E{S MFJX FILEEZ3 §}[SV}?3{LE.} C15?’ M? A{..”fT fi:{3:A,§E’€S’?’ T§’§E
JEEEGMENT Affif} AWARE E3?~;T’E{§ 3/12112399555 §’ASSE};} MVC
§’%i’};636j8 SN TEEE §3’§LE OF “§’EiE2 £3§L.Cf”si§§,.- J{§B{“$fEf;.{_S’§f)_} fig
MAST, MAE%%B”‘x’§§_§ ?AR'”§’LY ;%LLO’W§?§G “i”‘¥iE Chéiiivi PE2’T’i’fE{}.§€-_§3′{}f€

C€}Ee€Pf£1I\%S;¥E'”£GE% & $g§;}<:s-:<3 ::2:?éHA:s:(:§e:;;g2'§::;2:*§f. ..___f _.__<:;:5.Ie'

{3{3MPE?~§$»A'E'§GE€.

“¥’E~HS MFA camms 02% Fifi?! §sE?:§%S§§$S&IGE§~§.V;E%§’j§E’S”§”§§f&’f:, ‘i’§»{V§iVV’

{1(}U§%””§’ Mfxififi -ma: FGLLGWENG: _
GREEK ‘

This agpeai, was érispossé 152.15};fif§”t::1i;é:11::§:t:’gVL’

file campsnsatiog awalfiefi the ?fi颒i.h.¢:° ;R:3s.3G,€}GQ[ –
under diffarent heads Eat if: £’»E§i}.:.S’ %€;§€f’:VE;1:§:1€said juégmem. the

€1′?3§3I1C{i{3. axnmgzzli v:}f’–€:{2m;3£:11$:2aJ:i:3n”is’, mafzfisfirséd as R3;i2;5,,§§&Ci/’-

éizsteaé off R:s3[€j:;i”,f_{)Q;”n%,V .44F£»%:_’11»::~:;=:, — “Q16 {réaémant has mafia an
a§§;§:i{éatim::; Af€}r”§::o:”tt=:§%i»:f§:1b{s§&_Tfi71§:” game; §2{.’.Ctf§§Ej§Bg {ha masmzg

f§’E&§€{§ £23. figs: éi£’i§3.:_§a’c”i§.’~ supgmrt sf me agjgxiicaéiign ami

?t§f’:’!.iS§.E’ig éghzs §u ::,:e5’a¢;§§ ag;éé;;;:;%:g0a@;«.

sa/-f:___
Judge