High Court Karnataka High Court

Sharabanu W/O Basheer Saheb vs Praveen Ballal S/O Sheela Ballal on 30 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sharabanu W/O Basheer Saheb vs Praveen Ballal S/O Sheela Ballal on 30 July, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil And H.Billappa
awnwm-2 4

"%!er.'K'%:w?"'|s¢efl"¥'1'«>¥ was awmwmwmamltnwxm ::"uw%"'*a' mwwem WW wmammmmm Mgfififi fiflfififivg

11: Tim may COURT or mmawnn arr mmasoax
axma was me 33" am or sum: 2909

93532:;-r _ 

1'35 mx'3:.a I-:a.aus'rIcz; s.JKs?A'r1z; %
"W         

1'!-IE woman: xn.aus'r:cs H. 51*L:;§é9a  . . " "

n.r..=..nre.;a46,;z:s_6_c. gm;  V
asrwxm:  J %

sharabanu, fife anshaa: $a£flh,  ;g " '.
Agod about 41 ytars, _;' «a'* H
ale 5 cents colony,_ ,w,_x.'. , "
Kavarady Village, Knngpura T&1uk;4=, «
dupi District. f 'g._ V: a "  ,_'mEppe1lant
(By 331 Maheafi K1§§fifi§hs§f§gnfidfiodgtei
m9..:fl* """   ..   

1. Fravaan Baikal, fiajar,
S/Oxfihaela finlldl,
RJa:"a.BnVfi9ter§;'Habri,

gizarxaz Tgxuk, 9.1:. Dist.

" _2: Thé éziental Insurance Co.Ltd.,

~.Varvzs;dna1 attics,

,. vifihnufsgakash auilding,
=¢II'r1o¢r, court Read,

._ dupi¢'Rnprasontad by its
' Bivisianal Hanagar.

s;Rmaah, Hajar,
_ "33/a scngoden,

'--*R/a 85.2354, II cross,
arc Lsyaut, Eangalara.

.-
F
.-g

4. Th: Hatianal Insurance c¢.Ltd.,

Divisional attics, Shankcr Building,

xasque Road, udupi, By its Kanagar.

...Rnapondants

(By 3:1 A.Raviahanka:, Anvvcate fa: R.2,
sri B.C.saathaxana Rae, Advecata for R.4)



" '*"'""""W'"""»" W" flwwflfiwmwmflwm vswvwm vwwwaxm wk &m'*ama%wma:Mmm mmwm wwmamis wt" mmmawmgmggm grwqmm wwmmg

This appeal is filed under section 17i3?{3.) 0:
mar. that against the judgment and awaj:}&-jfdétad

11.a.2ces passed in we No.7a3/2904 
or the Civil Judge £8r.Dn.) _..._,_u jn.-2;'--{;:mnaber,V 
Add1.nAC'P, mnaapum, pa.rt1§"fll;c;:wi;;g_ *~{-,;-:3-.g31§;"£.a1  A'

petition for cmensati-on ind 1'_i._'sTe¢e'lci1ng_"' §':;a11a"::i"_c;s.1jix§:t.:jat
of comtbanaation. '    V  " 

This appnl ¢aning___ £>n  .-{gr érdfis :this day,
ILK. 93311., 3., daxivarad tVhi:..._£¢ :"l--.1oving'é 'A

..     

2. ‘°:”hi’s- at the judgment

and a§’.grd4’_ ‘ sgzeos passed in
uVC.xc.703/25354.. c} n._ file of thfi luau:-Md civil.

contending that, the

w’Usv=ae

by the Claims Tribunal in

agpallant is entitled fur

_¢nha:§:am¢t§t’vi”n than light at than judgmant at the

– :4<"~w'wvnw.mw0'~»an»r'w»1hw'"m man

' " ,t:_:m.11**.:;

Kurd the loarnad counsal appearing for

‘ iV:i’£é appellant and the lnrnad counsel nppaazing

” ‘£61? thfi rispondants.

k\sti$”t1r<4"¥(?f Wm-w~mu uw» ww~uw«w.wu.awm«wr"aL new-rawmwa mwwwmts 'MW' s'¥a.;.?'°'4.¥:"sE'?F§'x9"*'e1£:!#"%§«V§'<*mi% &%'"'£¥%3W"'?fi "*m'5».p$'3§».#tI"'§§§'

4. Both the counsel rairly submitted.» thatz

the instant nppaai is squaraly covegéaf’-.§5r:.V’vvtha

judgmant at the Apex court in the ‘§eai*

India Assurance Cowanry £;t:d~.._, A “‘a:’§&’ ;

Others reported in zoos AIfi’1.é3C.i§’ 6V13’§~.=

5. Tharatora, V is” thaf}
following the ;i2′:::*.1V_g’moI.-‘:’£’:'”” §:h§ a3’p¢x”‘VV:Court as
rmferred to ‘% *;ha = award passed
by the Claim: modified and

learned Counsel for
bo*qfi’._t§5,a fpa.:fi:’i §_na_’T’i:§’p4iacad on record.

” Accc..V~rd.i:n’q 3.y, ‘the instant appeal stands’

that judgment of the Apex court
or New India Assurance cowazzy Ltd.
and Others ruportad in 2006 AIR sew
6139.v’:__Aho1ding that, appellant is entitled for a
at ns.1,so,oeo/– inatead of Rs.1,53,£IG£3/~.

‘I. Aacordingly, the judgment and award is
miried. The appellant is entitled to: 3 mm at
Rs.1,B9,00fii–~ instant: at aa.1,53,008l- with

V W. m.,mxmm.u.w~m auww wwwna mm” mmhawmkmawm mawsm mqwwrw WW mfifiwflififlfl as-emw ‘LJUWNH W? mfimmrflm Wgfirgfi CQURY

4

intarest at 6! from the date at potiticrn till. the

data of realisation.

Further, it is needless to ::ta.i’l:¢:…._i4t;_&?V11z::f.i;,§’VA~Vivvtne

liability is find against respandenttfizv

per the ordax: passad by the:-‘C1aim§”..”r::i’$g;§zggi;.'{L

Respandants 2 amt q__ a2é”._§ixacr.Vai: déspfisft;

thair mspectivo sha£§s..? ‘1i.ab1ify night

nuke frat: today- A’

The claims 5_. 51 ” to disburse

the anzoutytii t§i§1?i_k:aV V ataly.

draw up tna award.

accoétdi-ng1y .V’~ if-» .’

“a, !,.AEt8;_N1

…H.::”<z.H 22 mmmamwamxm. wvuvvmemn