an ‘I’HE HIGH comm’ 012*
cmcurr BENCH AT c+UL3A.v¢:..<.L§ V %
§,'};'§"€§_€:.EjT) 'mils "my: :2 1. S'? {.355 :;::2;? g§;:jt:}%:%:%:§'1*, ':.a*<);i::é 7
¥E3F?§.E?£j_)Eé£}%} 'g ' A % %
'.:*1-15: iw§_;*a:’*-§;1.,.§;s: :~.:1};:J: 9353M ‘M<:24fiAN _f€Is3{Z*{)Y
WE'. m<_:=.:;:;":2<39f<:1%§ w;2.7CegaV%%'(A'%w.2yI-*;<E:B)
%i3;e:J1'w£_%::A§%§; '
SEf5%.%%35§NA¥3;ExS}7a}??'P.!a,7.
E:’§;'{f3 SAN;(;A:i%P;ié,_ »
§z{§~EI§’.) 25′ YEARS, % A_
sZ}{“:€T:._. .’E?.[.:.Qi;?§{ ‘ r;ri<:&:__.':, :<3:;;'::"s_:z~é
R/<3,AN1%:H£s’I’;…jgem'(:;H’1_I:€;;-» ‘ _ __ ..E?’E’E’£’1’Ir§AE<2£;s;i Adv. ;
= .1,” ‘”*:’i»~1E’fi:j’ S{__f§?E}Ri’?€’f§§3NE}iN(} EENGENPZER (V)
A &._:x:1._<_:.:§«z«:::V,ss::,<:;:+:s<7:M, E€AI€3’H_UR’,
” :1″ -m’§:’}s.::MS*’§5;’%E:X_§«:<:U'm;:£a: I%"Z§\i'(}IN}%§}.§E5 (EL)
«:_T::-fiz, M.~3:J}'::: 'i';ams_1M,
E.,.EN{‘;-A’SV{_§G{,§R, 5135:’. _RA1<T:m.:R.
— A.¢ia.;%fmi§ .;E§éE¥?-“E’%Z§l%;i¥N’i’E?:Nif__}ii’NC}» ENC}INf§EI’~% {I€3Lf%:{.ifL}
:3 :’§’a;._M (§.i’:§I<'3{.,'iE;E:, ('}E2${.'::i.)M5
..?v§£4§'§'€§}2§k.E5%_A.{)9 . §€£%1'S§P('}N i"}E%:?~$'E'S
~ »v—'§'VE%}f :%;.§22:; R $ §m*::__,, z'%.<izs.¥}
3§'n5r';«%-§z'35r
-‘m1s WRIT P}3″1’1′}’i()N IS FILE-DE) E}N{)E§R. f&RT1A{L:{;E”S _ 2255. 4_
3:. :22? 01?’ THE C€)NS’FiTLI’E’I()N OI?” gmxyjzg i5?.RAYI’i”J'{_3 F’r~:.sr3e”g1;:..;::r\1’i’»:X”~ g§L:A2:é’r=;.F1*%{zs:
IE§A{TiiE~i EEELLINQ 31 ‘}’}fE’}_i?E?I{‘Fi’Ti’I(}f€E%¥?. _
THIS WEST PETITION (::::;Es>:%§r«I{3 E}?-I._1i'<§¥é'.:Pré;:§L:évIINARY
f~{fi§%RiE'~iG "I'P£iS DA "mg: "v«;:c:um* 'm2;:,,1vE12ED THE
m:_,Lw§Nc;; —
0f a flour anti
Sawmilii 52:2; in an inspectioxi
<:Cs;.'2ciL_:§V<:t£'3;€'%:TA"§ I it was aliczgeii that the
met.er seais and (:01I1111it:ts:e;i
%,}'_1eff€; of e1;2<:rg§:_ ;é%;fi.:21*' d1'é3i¥if1g 2: ';)a;{1(:I1ar1ama this m<~:t;z3r
" wsié; :'*€:*ifI:=:}€rc%g} :«3.r1(i S€'iZ€i'd and 3 <:e:)1'I1pIai_m. in Cri11'1<:
f.['v:;;:;é:s 1Q<'£ged b{iff}I'f3 the ifiigasugtvzi" poiictj
s§z31"§:§<312,_"' -.'*i'%;:: p€2:{iI:i0z'1er whe1'1 visited Witt: a final
VV"a:ss£25ss:7E1%:z'1£, cf Rs.94,}_?'2/- as back bifliug chargéss,
':;v.:"::§::'é" f.'3€3{,'.i§.{}i'} E2fi Gf U162 f,*Z'E<::<:f;:".i<:ii;j;f Act, 2003, {far sherf.
-~i;E:<: '§'i<:t4'}g, §;!i'fif§.if"E'€i{f 23:'; éippf-=:a§ 11z"':{i€::" $;z.:%:; ${~:{:fi.«31} { 1.} of
E§:=%€:£'é2; .2_.:2′? £3? i}%1a:: 5§_:::f:9 :’i{3§;{}s§§i,€:<§ .2 j3?fi {sf 'i'.§"i€': a;§'22_:,r:%;$
3
3,}
<3q12ivz::}€::I'1f'. its RS3 1,3911/' m as 1"§1.{.(22)
<3?' Sé:<:3;i::s1'1 1/27 of U516 Act, w_E'1t31'"1c:r: <:k:c:tr'i;:i1};;;*:~:<i. Thgz pc:£.i.tj(_)1'1(31" s€'at€tssmf.}12;i, by "'€:i{§r)fse11';t:I1't,
da1:<–:(i 1.".30(}€* thé: f'11"sf;. I'cSp€:%;’,jt§or1er that t.1′:aug}1 _F£’s,3TI,3′?}() /’+_ <1§§(%S.i~:;'A%.~e'::2;s V _'}.43§'&' ~.
£3f:.1"1e:: back biliilig <:ha_rge 1.72,./. by 'V
:?:<%ct.§01'1 }p27(2}. '{,}{1.(': 1:0 coilsicier
313.1%: appttai i:':'1~ ‘:’1HV,V by the KaI*11atak’aT
E2i€:ct1fi§;i§3§ that bemg 9. Civil
111i%<:, 3§f<§t:vjIhs;3V Ey the con1pet<~:nt crirninai
‘a1g1″1 ieéatmzieci cmixlsai, statirlg ‘£113.11 the
;g’3c:.t,_}Tf.iT:;;-3;§,%§.*.VVizzigfi..3303: (:£s11’m1§'(:t.<:c1 any theft of energy ami he
.%'1£;:.:§Vr:':ai,:j1f§3;§.3':<:(§ the hiils ':1§){{) (i£–1t€? 21116 'E'h€I'f': is rzirastic
'%za:'_iat..i{§:":.s;; in $116: %.';i.E1s zmd nu-=:t,<:-3;" r€:a:.:gI’1i. <'§m;'}_}")i1T;g Qf pi."'("}{'fi{§{f(.fii"Ig_,T, TE":a_E. :'1<}i,i(:<':
"i.%£2§:-;'é"::s;;3<:;: 26.12:-iii {£3 ¥:';jg %;:§'1:'-2* fi1"'E§"€. :'::$p:%tii’§{C:I1v§’
_:’é..
céated 1?.1.2{){)’–§} Ammxurér ‘G’ simixag that.
B€1i”1g8}€}i”(‘?, by iéztitzr datr:d 2′?}.8.i2{}(}7 had
1;:’:’:(ic3r ‘:E§<-::1 15<'¥(f3){6) the Spééiial.«::0i,1rt,,ié'~1*§:qi:iz?'té(i'v.i'.of
{iet,e1'mi;;1e:t the civil 1iabi1_it.§; agai':§St_;i" (:01'i:;:u1V11e;* fi"f'1'(§ t}1€
appéiilate zmt:}'1ori't§; has I"}€}___pVVf}Wfii17_»'[{} d.{'?:fi1'V¥Vif.hi5 the cases:
of thefii. sf e1'1e1g,.2 af1d% '£}?1é:.ye:£?o3*t: "'2{I;;;)€::i1ate autharity was
d€:pri.vc::d cf i:é3;"ing;"f}"ils::'::';3p€;a}.__ ..
2.2: V aI10thf3'1' Ietter dated 'H' callirig, upon the
§>et.i{5;{>1_1é’;1iM t(}/– as {:0mpcm.rzd.i11g fee: and
t¥;1c:’v§1a.C}§ E;i,’§1;ir1g3 of Rs.94~,172/-. Hence this writ
‘j__”T hr: E2’ie<:tr.ic'it.fy-* Act, 2008 cr1$. The fH’Si. is 1111der Sectiorx 1.26: if the AC1:
” _ §if§,€1’ i:”1vfi:st§g23.t§011, cm §}f1$p{‘:(:ti£;}I1, if the ass:’::ss§.i’1g cafikter
<:§:’1<»::–; to 'éhéi :":<3I?:<:111:~'si'{1 that, the conzmmezi’ is iriduigirag
in E,l1’1€:’£.1.4if;§1¢Z}I*§$i§€§. use: in? <:E§i<:!:'iVi$i(>r13i1y
£}3.$E~’;{f’SS £11: mg: magi: :33′ E133 _}:2.’i§E.;mE::1f___iiiQ
file hi3 c)bj<:(:t.i0n_s and tixeragaftézr _ 1"i1"1a;'r.
asst-":ss1:ner:t.. SE'-3CtiO1"i .112'? of '».:th6_'~!3uT::t. p19£}'£.?idc:9S:"ibt'*:;aI1
appeal to the appézllate' 'e:1.1_v1'£i1-;V)»21'§?.4:}',}" fiiaali *
8SS€SS1I1€I1t slibjec; ' of the: back
bifiirig Chalfgféfié. 'V " u
4. ::”§$a~:}”1ed with the n<31:_ice of
flb'i'};i.i;;i;é <:1"1arge:s of R394, 372/"
p1*efVérre£i’_ ” fiI’Si’. rr:sponder1t: appellate
au:1″1c11″iVi:y-. _Vi11’2d£3zf_ S~f§€)i;§.~¥’;§I.l .127 of the Act by d€:p0~sitTing
the S «’i’fi€}v..§§.E_.}1*l1. Thus it is for the firsf, I’:3spc>1i1d:31’1i
‘ ‘tféry V §i’€:§:i’d§:”~ fins”: appeai an its Eilffffiffi arid pzzms e3rd€:1*a;
‘ r.h’é5:f’t:£)1’T1′.’ L: T._
, v’I’§2e $;6:{:0I’.1d is Part XIV of the Act w.f1.iCI1
A §}1′”>S}f%f’i{§{iS f’£>:’* {}fiE’,’§’l{3f*:S and §::»z:”::”:zaEtiéa$, ¥Vhé3I”€3EE}’3{‘i€’:i” Se<::'£.i:’z
§..;2;f§ siizaia 2rs:*%?.};’1 ?,}{i{:3ff. {if <:};<-:<":f§;%."i.:':;it:s;, 'fi?§1fi.E?: figs'-2 ;t;I':§<:fi:5 :~:;§}§:<:%ai <:::}z:r%: is §";:':,:'Vi<':&:;: in Sa=:::i,i{m
xx
§ §
7 . “K
4?
“$3..
If:§f%. S€«:::{:i»:m 3332 ;rrvi<'i<:s far {mm 3<:.3:.2:'1i’f:%1i’.r.<i(:s.
Thifi s€{:E:§<_:=r: 31:31:23 thai: zwtwithst_a;}<i'i::ggV A_T231':j/:13:iz'1g
<:<:r1'1i;ai.z"16:d in 1.1%: {?<";«de of {3I"i:11;'ii1al }31'c:v<:'e:{i1'§}'i'i:,_: E 3 inf
},9?4}, the Ap;::I*@pI*iati: j.(}<)vef':.1ni–c::1t: . §§)ifi<rér*
£'i1.lf.E'}Of'iS€3€i lay it'. in this hézljéif n1:§5;..'é1(:c€2pt: ,f1'o1'n azzy
c:0"ns11n1er or pe:r*so3'1i ix.~ri Whe is reasonabiy
s11sp€::::t.{3d :<:)f7–::I§27:&ri1A1gA '0Effe1'1<:€ cf theft: 0f
€:i£;'CE1'?2CifTj~?4H13;é}1'"1%S'}'£;<3;l;f1€§-.1':;f§;{i{i€:§:. Act, a sum sf rI1on(::y'
2353; '._'t".Ii1IéV:c::f'{'t:":I:c::es as sptzczifiézd in
1:115: 5:-zctioxx (3) ssfates that the
a<:{:c;pta;T':é'£:-: 5}? .t;tf;.£”£_’_é’k”;{:_a in ;»3cc:{>’I’*<i'2i:"1c<3 ui='i'£;h sub~:;<~:ct4io.r1 (1) by the
_ "fapf;§'<:§o§:-§{i2:fiéj;.T_{§~;3vc:r1'1mem_. or an Qfficfif' eH1pw<«3r€-:(Tl in this
':3:.:_1"i:3[ifVs.I:1a3;.EEx: ezleemtrzti "tic; a:11<:'u3'::i: to an a::q1,1i{,'{aE wi'£;h,in
'atiiizi :':1{:fim§z'1g sf S€C§.i{§E'3 30%} Of the {."3{:a<'i<%: of (73ri11'1i1":afii
.§.';f{.§{}t'z:c§:j'1re, }€3'?§:3 {2 of .2974).
5}’ .3: 33 3.3: iii{‘3;{jE’1}Z_f:.E§§3I’i(‘3€:3 s.«=s.:§fi_: me: pr’:;>vi:’~;i{>;’2 fax”
::;:a::«:”:”:§;;z_>’a§:§:§é_§’:g {gf {}ff:,::1g_;%{~::§, %i’1;;3§’. ‘E}”:<: fir*&;f, §'i'1Sp{}i"I€'§€fiI'fi,
5
.5
H
“‘i;—-…W»w~
iss:§1,_1<:<fi mt: (:<;~:1'3m111r3i<:a.?:i01"} ::.iz3.£i1’1:::1” to C0mp1md thé
;,3ajs;%.ng I-€s.40,00{)/~ in za{lc1i'{‘i£31*’z’*-H)’ t;I1<:; "-E§ii1xi:i1g '
charges of ¥"€s.94-,1"?i2/-. "t;<)=
C0I11p<3m'1diug chargczs iSv&1{f,,:'\:.ff1C3 G}3Ti€)}'1
a<:<:1.1$<ed of t;i'1::ft of »(3¢.}€§€3?3."i(:§f5;VViI£_é.'1t vi«éw-0f"tVE.f1e n1a1;t<~:r
ii, is ape}: frgr: {£16 offer' and make
I'3aIv'fi1€31'11=i' campounci fee, and
agairlst hijm. Tflemfore
it <:a§i:1($t 1)e £116 _petitioner has suffemci a
grfi-:va11¢£§"-. by _'S:1%1<é:=_ <:£L)VI11z11ur1i<:ati<)n dated 8.7.2(}{}9
«Ha
"7 «. *'_231{h':}i1gl'1 tbs: relief in the": writ ;s(–:'t'if:.i<m is to
{1{ias.h.V :,5.:'11:i::x1;i"<: 'Ii' .:'1»:)t.i<:e »:ia?.é2<.i_ 8.7 ,:2€'}{)§} i1'1f0m'1:£r1g i;ht:<
";:2<;%.Efit;i<)i':_€:.:' :».:bm.,:ij the e::<3mp0'uI1£img fez: é';'i£"1d _fc3r* 22 Wxfi of
A'=§2::'§§:':€is33T:1:..z$ {i§;'<:<.:i',i:"':g, 1':;:s;_§3<31':si{:1"1t.. E10 E'£éfé_.n'1<'i i?};:<': {'§€E§}{}$i.{', 0f
"}é3:~?;,.3 }_,3<I?€},/~ %;'.%':ws;:1t;¥’;:%.§ *:..i;’::;.§: for CO}fIIpli3I}€,’€.
. &*f;_<;:.;
:;:.%1argp€:a1
I,h»:: f’i2*ssi; f”€S}}{}I’1d€iI}f, a;:1s;i :{;’:1’a1*€:.'{f«s=:i:i’€.ir::::1eI’ I:;3: 11123:
C:€e{ii1’1gs.
Thus 1316: e1’1dz>rs<=,H1e:;f1i: 1__g.2€}{Z:$}'»"2§:1:1exu;'e 'E2' and
EEK»: :*ep}§; 'G' of 1.116 first
;'r::s.;30.r1£i::%Iii"V;_'Eis{§{31i§.fi§".{§ ,l.:$5. fhff: appeai of Kim
§:s€:'i:.if_i()1*ie;:?t {§§'s£;i9é§fé~:s qi_1:2i$}1e<'1 zmd. is accardingly
(}ilaSh€:d.._
4;' " W1*§€;V__ f.)éti'{i3I1 is ()1'(}€I'f;'d accordingly. Twa
53?;
éwfifgf, fig
.
gm’?