Posted On by &filed under High Court, Karnataka High Court.


Karnataka High Court
Sharanabasappa S/O … vs The State Of Karnataka on 20 March, 2009
Author: S.N.Satyanarayana


IN THE Hzaa COURT 0;? KARNATA_;–;A I

CERCUIT BENCH AT’ GLIL.-BA12Gza.__:’ .

DATED TEES THE 20% Big? 1v:é;’;2C§;’:2.§009VV, :” _ T 1:’

BEI:’_oR§:7. V
THE H<:2N'BLE MR.JUsT:'<;:§~s.N.sA3fifAr:;rgRAvjzAV§zA

WRYI' PETITfli§.}_\$ za:c»w;4*4G::%:%;2;%V§a.(38 {S§i§ESx)
CIW W.

W.P.No..4=O042i2008 gslgggg

BETWEEN: H

3. S}iARANAB.:%§SgiPP3& » ¢ A
Sm GU R’L:3’%:A::x;TA;vsA ;=;rN}EYSf»Ci=1L E3%}E.)’CATi€)N TEACHER
cgcrévr. H.rG:~1ER«.,?R:M;2Ry…_sa*z{0oL, KSRP <:m:=.\:’:’

‘E’AJ’S_IJ}fj?Af’J PU :2 ; »<.:x:;:,g'Ag;:.,g.

2. SH{VAKUfM{3_R 8,1 <3'IzA22;3.:§1§DA¥YA E{A'£'TEPs;EATH
AGE): 44 YEARS, ASS.§S'E'AN'E' TEACHER,
QOW. HIGHER 'PRIMVMY SCHOOL, 2_1?L,A0:x:,
V. ;&_£3§7E3'I': GU LB'§Xi%GA.

'3f"SM'£t.;§'E§:L;§§:vzMA 1:3,/0 KALLAPPA MUGAL-E

v..[;1.C§Ev:-.43' Y EARS, ASSISTANT TEACZHER,
g Gfiw; ;~§'§£:::;:=€R PREMARY SCHOOL, UPLAON
3":-:9' ag-313:'; GULBARGA.
" ' PETITIGNERS

' _ §B¥sR§.S:~zIvAKuMAR MALEPA'§'1L, ADV.)

THE STATE 0;? KARNATAKA

REPRESENTETD CHIEF SECRETAQY
WDHANA SOUDHA,
E%ANGALOR"E–560 GS 3;.

' . T'1~£E'.; STATE {E}? KARNATAKA,

REPQESENTED BY THE
PRENCIPAL SECRETARY,
EQUCATEON DEPARTMENT,
M.S.i3UILDING,
f:3AN(I'zALORE~56G Q01.

, THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,

gzzgpggsgwmn BY THE
PRENSIPAL SECRETARY, _
REJRAL DEVELOPMENT AND"-~._
PANCHAYAT RAJ DEPARTMENT-..V_
Evf.S( BUILDING, – '
BANGALORE 550 00

THE STATE 99' KARN.a;1§_A';$ R’Y- I§{)§;L3.£§TI£} )

M.S.BUiL£)I.1.’\F–G;”””«.__ > _
BANGALQRE: ::¢§o001¢. «-

., THE STATE’V'{:}’F.KARN:%%fAKA, f

REPf{ESENTEi_}.B.¥ ” _
UNDER? SECRETA~E§’i§. ” ”
EDuCA*:’10r«:_DEI%AR’m.;i;2$;:’r,

M.S_. BUiLDI_P~JG,_
BMGALORE’ 559 001′

V THE COMM.1_SS10NER 0;?
‘ ‘F’EJBL_IC VINVSTRUCTIONS,

._NEw..r>Lr;B’Lz{;t.,§;>:1=*FIcEs,

– A NRUPA”?HIjPii=GA ROAD,

§3_ANGA3..Ci;§3E-569 00 1.

¢ THE: AILIDIWCJNAL COMMESSIONEQ OF’
.. vP_E3BLI’%L’; INSTRUCTIONS,

GKZILBARGA DIVISEON,

” GULBARGA,

THE DERECTGR,

PRIMARY ANE) SECEONDARY EDUCATION,
GULBARGA SZSTRICT,
Gi§LBARGA.

9. THE DEPUTY DHQECTOR GE’

PUBLIC ENSTRUCTIONS,
GULBARGA DISTRECT
C§I_1LBARGA§

18/{‘H§: BLOCK EDUCATEON ::>mc:Er~2 {s:;1;f:’H-Tzomz;
GULBARGA EJESTRICT, ‘ »_ 1 ‘
GULBARGA.

£L’T§iE BLOCK EIEBUCATEON OFF’ICE3E€;’,
CHENCHOLI TALUK,
GULBARGA DIS’I’RIC’?’-TL
GULBARGA.

12333 ZILLA PANCHAYAf’?_’
REPRESENTE13 33′
CHIEF EXE}{:”Lfl’E_VE <;=F'F';i{:E'R,"-
GULBARf;3fi.,VQIS'I'E§ICT,« _
<3ULBAE::GA._"–~. '

WRESPONEENTS

{By sri{r~A.K:.g:&§£g;::_,p+.;;1'A:z_j_g008:

BETWEEN:

1 .

SHRIMANTH SHIVALENGAPPA DHABALE
S] C) SHIVALINGAPPA DHAEALE

AGEE) ABOUT 40 YEARS

ASST. TEACHER

NAMMURA LOWER PREMARY Sc:Hr}; ,

BAGDAL ‘§’ANDA{B)

8.’iD&R TALUK AND DISTRICT

NAGAYYA G SWAMY S/O <:;v:;{F:.:aYYA"sfi2«fAr»:y

AGED ABQUT 4: YEARS

ASST. TEACHER _ _A
GQVF. LQWER PRIzs_A1x%«<f3L.V
HUMNABAD '–

319% TALUK AND DISTRICT 1 ‘

?{ANTE’*PF%A BPiALKE§i3HWAi? WADDE
2;; o–.grmL::fE=sHwA’RV wmm;
AGED. A8011’? $2.5 ‘r’§.<3AE?S,–~

ASST. '£E',A<:HE1::' .. '
c;::;W.:4..1,m::: Px”%§IViA’RY SCHOOL

4 ‘ ¥{Er.{ADE3§*L’RA,” BHf=.L§{I TALUK
‘ ::’32__ i:>,’xT;_;> DIS’f’R3.{3fT_v

RA?J[.E$§”iv C BEDAVE S/O C. BNEADAR

– .e:3i:;g1; 2933.21? 41 YEARS
As$7?x__T’E;AcHER

€}OV’£’;– _Efi(§HER PRIMARY SCHOOL.
FgiT”FAvE13AGA, BHAi.Ki TALUK

~BE}f;7AR DISTRICT

DEL}? PANCHAPPA MANDADE
= 53/0 ?ANC§~§APPA MANSABE

AGES ABOUT’ 42 YEARS

ASST’ TEACH ER

GOVT. MODEL PREMARY SCHOOL
MEHAKAR, BHALKE TALUEQ
BIDAR DIS»’TR’iC’I’

-5-

KAMALAKAR NENGAPPA MUTHANGI
S/C’: NINGAPPA MUTHANGI

AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS

ASST’. TEACHER

GOVT. MOSEL PRIMARY SCHOOL

SHARANA NAC3ARA,BASAVAKALYAN ‘i’A;[,i.}’E~{..;. %

BEBAR DISTWCT 3

VENKAT KANTEPPA SHERIKAR

sxo KANTEPPA SHERIKAR *
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS: _

ASST. TEACHER ‘ ‘- V
GOVT. MODEL PRIMARY scH%0c>L
ATTIVAL, BIDAR TALUK
BIDAR DESTRICYF

GANAPATRAO NARAS_iN Gage” Ki} N-Ns:LE ._
S/0 NAR’ASiNC}RAQHK{}–NNALE ~=’
AGED A8013′? 42:YEAREi; _ ‘ ,_
ASST”L’EAf}?HER =: _
GOVT… M0;:§§f,;«,: :>;2;r.r1A;i%§* S€:r£.OOL.
AsHs>KmfAGAR’ ~v$Av;x:;:, A’J.Ié1’A3j}_ TALUK
BIDAR.VD£S’13?§?ICT’_. V ~

sc§r»@%ANA*?;¥r’si§1ér4~K;5;;2A§>PA MALGE
S/O SHANKAEQAPPA ‘”MALGEi

; ‘ AGED ABQUT 44 ‘(EARS
Ass?) TEACHEF: =

C§C}V’F:.MODEL P}?IMfi«.RY SCIFEOOL
SVIKIN’E}AF-?ABAD WAD1, BHALKI TALUK

“$1353? :::1 s;*.”m1::*z’
sHR’::i~.:_;A.i’~zTH RAMAKISHANRAO MORE

S_;”O RAMAKISHANRAO MOE

‘ ..A<2ED ABOUT' 43 YEARS

ASST. TEACHER
GOVT. MOSEL ?RIMARY SCHOQL

1" MEHAKAR BHALK1 TALUKL

n

A BIDAR DESTRICT

KALEDAS IVIOHf§NRAC3 PENE'. S/{Z3 MQHANRAO PENE
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS

ASST. TEACHER

GOV? MODEL PREMARY SCROOL

CHIDAGUPPA, HUMNAEAD TPKLUK

BEDAR DISTRICT

13.

14.

25.

JAGANNfi(I’H§~2AO NAGAPPA MUGAL; sjo NAG?-.PP;3.
MUGALE
AGED ABOUT 43 mags

ASST. TEACHER

GOVT”. HEGHER’ PREMARY SCHOOL

SHEZDOLA, HUMNABAD TALUK

BHSIAR msTR1c:’1* –

SEDRAMAPPA NAGAPPA zv1uc;,é;–.L1 ‘TNAQAPEA :y17t,ii:;;;;§i;:7–i.

AGED ABGUT’ 44 YEARS.

ASST. TEACHER’
GOVT. HEGHER PRIMARY’ “S101-mib(§(3L V
JALASANGI, HUMNABAD ‘I’AL:_Ji:_
BIDAR DISTRIGI’ _
SHIVARAJ BASAYYA sw.I_vr:’. 53/ 0* g;as;aYYa SWAMY
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS 1 _

ASST. TEACHER . 1 ..

99%’. I_,.OW_E’i2 PRIMARY: S<3HO.§:~.Lv _

HALEKHEB ;z'T<:'V'w;3::4*:., E-IBM NAEEAD TALLEK
.BiDA;R"

iVENKfif1;}5£?1f§}§EL%fi’}32;§'{§..E€I~E’}%L}iE S/’0 ?R’ABHATRAO

1E3HALK.E . _ _
AGED ABOUT 4.2 ¥VE;:~._Rs
ASST’;~TE1′:.C3H.ER’«.

5 ‘ $1’-ICSHEVR PF3EMfi;RY SC§-{GO},
}Z3HADSANGAV__L..B HALK1 TFKLUK

E3i’DAV’R..&DISTI2?ICT

J. A.::::MA:2 MAHAWDRAPPA NAVA SIC»: s/<3
. , MA?EA__R1~.§ET}RAPPA NAVAQGI,
' AQE'Lu_=aBoUT 44 YEARS

A538'?-'.. ""I'EACf~IE:R

' §IIGHEf¥Z PREMARY SCHOOL

'I'vE§(:}AMP{§F3, BHALKI TALUK

" .B§£T)AR DISTRICT

BHIMRAC} SHANKARAO WAEJBES
8/G SHANKARAO wmm:

AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS

ASST, TEACHER

GOW’. MODEL PREMARY SCHOOL
GORTA, BASAVAKALYAN ‘z’Aw;<
BIDAR DI8'§'R§C'I'

18%

l\)

M…'

DILEPKUMAR IViONAP¥'A PANCHAL S/'<3 MONAPPA

PANCEHAL

AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS

ASST. TEACHER

GOVT' HIGHER PRiMA'f€'Y SCHOQL

SHARANANAGAR,BASAVAKALYANTALUK '

BIDAR D:s'1*m<::*r ;

MANIKLAL KANNAYYALAL SHA_RMA.- A 3
S/O KANNAYYALAL SHARMA ” 1 ‘
AGED ABOU’1’45 YEARS: _

ASST. *rEAc:HE§e ‘- V
Gown HiGHER PEHMARY s<:}"~§0<:»L
CHANDANALLI, HUMNABAD ':?.:~,LuK
BIDAR DISTRICT * '

RAVENDRA S10 GUNDAPIJA1'

AGED ABQLJT 45 YE.ARS V

ASST, TEfi.Ci~fER ;' _ _ –
sow. :_;{,::"e5;:£.'»-12 P}§!£vE£i§{'i' sCHV<:;e0L-…..V–
CHE'I_.1%GfjPi?.A.,';'.HUNiNAE3AD"'1'£i.LUi~:

Bigag zgzsfmzcw.

ififi r§2’m§«;AN’ :锧;UL,g§”Ff??4; ,’£’I~§HULaP?A”1fH’::>M’:2E
AeE§;xA8.o:JT 4:3 mazes

‘ “ASST: ‘i”F¢AC’E+iER’

GOVT. HI'<:a3E:R PRIMARY Samar,

}.<§I{'2§\E'GAL§, BHALKI TALUK

"E"II_S'I'I§'EC'T

« V'§;é{}<.M:ii~f£v»:§/G SHIVARAM

A_Q§;{:.:_ ABOUT 44 YEARS
..{-;S3'r–." '1'EACHER

' .. C§if}V'T'. HEGHEE' PRIMARY SCHGGL

K}!

26.

DHANRAJ CEJANDRAPPA BIRADAR
S,/(T2 CHANDRAPPA BIRADAR

AGEB ABOUT 45 YEARS

ASST, TEACHER

GOVT, HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOQL
BHATSANGV1, BHALK1 TALUK
BEDAR DISTRICT
MADHUKAR E§ESHAVRAQEiARBAE~?{
s/0 KESHAVRAO E{ARBAI?._i ”
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS _ ”

ASST. TEAGHER _
GOVT. LOWER PRI§vi!§RY €sc:H’c3.r:§L
N§’I”I’UR~K, AURAD ‘i’_ALUK_ {Q ‘
BEDAR DISTRECT ‘

SA1~:GAsm3;f:*r§ BA:3;?éf?i5A~’§E«sA’C’1§%3..:s:z~zA

S/O BA:3AP§%A’BAC:HAN”NA * _
AGED.A?3vQU’1F..”§.6 YEAR’S.’ ‘ .
AssTjTE:.:a€::HER~– . ‘
GQY1’. ‘:{1c3§4iA:E’.,R PRIMARY’ ‘SCHOOL
MAVE r«m.1.;:L1, B”§iiJAI,K§.TALUE{ ‘
2222:3512 D’1s~’:*r::_1c:*;f . ;

RA:KUMA:%.V?;1AN:A;*:?§i’RA0 DONGARGE;
3,10 \;’Y._}A,NA’i’.HF€A.¢s(}».Q{)NGARGE

_ -AGED Az3_r::>:.;TI43 YEARS
A331: TEACSHER ,
§{E€3HER”‘F'”REMARY scmm

SEAR.’-ISRAPUR WAD}, BHALKI TALUK

” ~ _13′:.z3_A§fn;s*:fR£cT

& A §A123_ESH {KALLAPPA SAPATE

Sf O KESLLAFPA SA FATE

AGEIJV ABOUT 46 YEARS

z’\S’Z:§’I’. TEACHER
GGVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL

AA ‘ ~._BHEMANAGAE3, BHALKI TALUK

BIDAR SESTRECT

MAHAUEV}

Dz’ C) VISHWANAT’H S£§.PA’I’E

AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS

!§SS’IX TEACHER

GOVT. GERLS HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
BHALKE, BHALKE ‘§’ALUK

EIDAR DISTRECT

30.

VYJANATH MANIKAPPA

S/G MANWIAPPA

AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS

PE, TEACHER

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
HI’%.I..LI}{HEDx-K, HUMNABAD TALUK
BIBAR BESTRICYI’

KALLAPPA ANNEPPA METGE _
sxo ANNEPPA METGE ‘

AGED men’? 40 YEARS V ._ – A.
Ass? TEACHER
GQVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHCEQE, ”
MANEKESHWAR, B;~§ALK1–f1fA;w1< '
BIDA}? DISTRECT *

AZIZMA V
3,10 MA. sA'1"I'AR"»» _ ;
AGED AE%OUT42YEz'51.RS
AssT.TEA<f:2~:ER =

'§+;;:G§¥_t:+:§e P'R1M-ARY"SGF§&1)GL
NAGU yea, B19522 "Ef1XE.i_}£Pé;”E3駒1A;>1§iS;.-w::$EVANE

_ ‘ago E:’-AL§aPP1’a mvgwg

AGED ABQUT 4:2 YEARS

‘ _:s_.Lss<,!_: TEAch=I3~:2"

C}{}\fY)~HEGHER PRHVEARY SCHOOL,-
"(IyA'N»ESHP_U§ WADL BHALKI TALUK

vBZ'DAE'5:£?ViS3TREC'E'

s:3B§:3.A$INA MASFHANAPPA NAGa,121«:2z*m
/<3 MASTHANAPPA NAGARKATTE

' .. AGED ABOUT' 43 YEARS

':i,..£-}§ST. TEACHER
GQVI'. HEGHER PRWEARY SCHOGE,

HIMMATHNAGAR, BASAVAKALYAN TALUK

335V

BEDAR DISTRICT!'

MOHAMMAD ZAHIR AHMED

S/O MD. NAZEER AHMEZZ}

AGED ABOEJ1' 45 YEARS

ASST. TEACHER

GOVT' HIGHER PREMARY SCHQGE,
KAMTHANA, BEDAR '§'AE}JE{

EEEBAR DESTRECVF

3§~

E'?

38.

39.

-13-

MAEDAVRAQ B§%SAVAN’1’RAO ANADOFEE
S30 ESASAVANTRACJ ANAEBORE

AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS

ASST. TEA(3HER

GOVZ’. §~{EC§HEI«? PREMARY $CHO{}L,
KHANAJE, BHALKI Ԥգ<.i.UK
3EI3AR DiS'E'RIC'3'I'

MQHAMMAD ABDUL SALEEM
3,10 ME}. ABDUL AHAM;;9'«~.._V

AGEE} ABOUT 42 YEARS "

ASST. TEACZHER
GOVT, 1~ii=.:3HEE> PR3.MARY;.~$€31~§i§Oi;»?_
SIKENFEJR, i3£DA:’?_f1’1%LU1.?§ ”
BEDAR BESTRICT ‘ ‘

PRAB an R£x.O RAM£2S?§_E’¥’TEv–.P:$TI¥’f«§:. ; ~

Sjo RA;\«:,Asié_E’1*{f: PATNE; ._
AGED A{8<3t;;%?F 4:2 YEARS '
Ass1fi.«*V'v?EAA’z”;<.}:f;-'1s'rRi:}:;~*:' _ '-

¥f1&A?KiI§§4?;F§» .}§;m»f3§5L*ElP¥% MQLAKERI
gm r~»2AGA9vP;k.4;»§oLs=§1»;E_R:
AGED ABOUT 4;: 'iE',z§Rs

V _ _fiSS'I'."*?EA€i.I~i'EI%'."'.

{gawk H'i€'%HER PR3 AR? SCHOQL

' J&1¢'¢.SANG§;'HS£e'iNABA§ TALGK

:?2;:{'; '
'– s;'<::'.c:A1:mPA'§*APm svmg

BZ:}ART}£STRI(3T
😕 ;é~;~1s2.:?§:;éé:~:. §?:eANAPATAPPA suwg-2

AG~Fi_Ifi{'.ABOfJT 40 YEARS
A-SS'£g '{'EACHER

"53Cl'vV"?. §~~§I{'§B'Ef°? PRIMARY $CP§€}C3L

£i'E%§BE$A.$EGVI TANDA, BHALKI TALUK

gtmg DiS'E"'R'fC'I'

ASHGK NACKERACE BHARARE

S;'O i\EAC'%L}RAO BHARARE

AGED A866'? 43 YEARS

P;8ST, TEACHER

G{3VT. EEKEHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
MAV£I'\¥AHALLI, BHALKI TALUK
BEDAR Dif3'§'RIC"I'

43'

4»?

.    'V

-1}-

RAMESH CPIANABASAPPA KAMBLE
Sfi} f3?£ANi¥BASAF’PA KAMELE
AGED ABSUT 43 YEARS

ASST, TEACHER

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHCJOL
HUNAJI, BHALKI TALUK _
BHEAR DISTRICT ;

VITFALRAO EKNATH RAG BiRA;f3A§¥3 _
S,/O EE{N2%”£’HRACr BERA.¥3AI_~_”~2 ‘ ‘
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
A$S'”.F’,’I’EACI~i’ER _
GOVT’ HIGHER Pi§Hv1ARYV.s{:r~;i5mLAG1J
S/O SA:«3A?.PA I:;UBA;gAGUNQ-2:’ ‘ *

AEEEIDAB<1X?l5*1'V39"!&E£RS _' "
PE. '
GOVT. I»n'<3.;~£E1=:* PR1' $32? s:+cH:,

A’?TIV£;.Lfi_ ,i~1§3;I3A.:2″:e~,1,U;;…._W_

TBiDA’R..:§1_sTEe:§;cT_ ‘

Vire;Ar:»A?PA”~1″””L..%V 1.
Sjé? SHANTAPPA _ ‘–

AGE3E}_AI3OU’-E’ 49 YEARS

. – ASST. “:*E;A’Ai«2 SISTRICT

JERAPPA SHEKAPPA Dmm
S10 SHEKAPPA DABEDE’;
AGED ABEDUT 45 YEARS
ASST) TEACHER

48.

49

50.

GOVT’ HIGHER PI%§MARY SCHCJGL
G§€A’T’EORAL, HUMNABAD TELUK
BIDAR DISTRECT

NAGARAJ RAMARAG KULKAFENE
3/0 RAMARAO KIJLKARNZ

AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS

ASST, TEACHER ~. A
GOW. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL- .1

TADOLA TANIJA,BAsAvA;{Am*AN1$ALuK”‘ -. ~. ”

BIDAR’ DISTRECT

GEETA BANDEPPA BIRAD;£%.R”~
D10, BANDEPPA BIRA1:>A_R_
AGED 42 YEARS,’V.__ *
ASS’I’.’1’EACI-IER,’-,j’_
GOV’E’.HIGI-{ER PRIM:’§RY {ECHO
sHAHAGANJ,319AR_1*ALU.K ”
BIDAR’ IZ)IS’f’.._ ‘

BAGAr+.m1T§.:”.;;}Eé:4_n.§tj’1§AP£§A 0;§KE
.n;’-<:x.m:sHM;r~:<AP9A-rs:1<x«:;~ '

aAGE}I_) "40._–vEYARS,*«u .

ASST. TEACHER», _ _
GOVE'.HI{3-HER' i?'Ri§{I_A'}?.'f SCHOOL,
BH'I«:4NmA2, g1§1.m;z TALUK,

_ _BIDA¥<' 3313?.

‘ ‘PRABHUSHfi’I”I’I MASIMODE3

SfO._ FRABHUSHETT1 MASIMOIDE,
A_{3’iE1I;3«.5€§ -YEARS,

‘V ‘ Asst’. TEACHER,

‘ G0′-.33′-. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,

B;~1A1;;g:’, BHALKI TALUK,

~ a1:::A:~2 DIST’.

E3H?xRATH SHARNAPPA KALAMBRE

s/0. SHARANAPPA KALAMBRE,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER,

C§OV1′.HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
VITTALPUR, HUMNABAD TALUK,
BIBAR DIST.

VIVEK MADHAVARAO PATIL
S/0, MADHAVARAC) PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,

54.

56.

ASST. TEACHER,

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
MEENKERA,HUMNABAD TALU K,
BIDAR DIST.

SHUBHASH VEERABHADRAPPA KUMBAR

s/0. VEERABHADRAPPA KUMBAR,
AGED 40 YEARS, _
ASST’. TEACHER, : ” ._ ~
GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHQOL; ..
DUBALAGUNDI, HUMNABAD TA.{,U’K,
BIDAR DIST. ”

SHANTA VMAYAKUMAR ‘i»~1:«:PUR}ixc:-%I§’,_” ‘

w 10. VIJAYKUMAR GODMWRAGE,
AGEIZ3 ABOUT 50 YEARS;
ASSTTEACHER, – ; ..

Gov*:’.H1GHR PRIMARY SCiH<j'a(3E__..-,._ " V
A'1"I'IVAL,H.UMNABAB.T;ALU«K,"»_ '
BIDAR _.

msaizé. RAm:E;sf{E1*T;A,1:>z5A BONE

S/O. TR”AMAS’§:IE’TTA*?_PA BONE,

Ass’?-. TEA.CHE;R,, ”
Gem’. 1.0W’ER’Pl€§M};RY SCHOOL,
CHIM’EGAON’TA£*:3DA=; AURAD TALUK,

AGED ABO%31fA4a»E%vAR~s; ‘

‘BIDAR 3133*.’ ‘

réjA..:A’MgT1 SRREALINGAPPA TADAMPALL:
D;0.’smvAL1NeAPPA TADAMPALLI,

– Air:-.}3.1: ABQUT 49 EYARS,

Ass.:§*._1’=§:AcHER,

GOV’F;–.V.I{[IGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
P?ALi3KHED–B, HUMNABAD TALUK,

.. £f;n::sA12 DIST.

SHANTAKUMAR

S/O. CHANNAMALLAPPA,

AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,

ASST ‘TEACHER,

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
BASAVAKALYAN, }3ASAVAKALYi’–‘xN TALUK,
BiDAR DIST,

GANAPATHI CHOUDARI
S/O. NARASINGARAO CHOUDARI,

62.

-14-

AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER,

GOVT, HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
SEDQL, HUMNABAD TALUK

BIDAR D3S’I’.

VYJANATH KUMBAR I ‘
S/O. MANIKAPPA KUMBAR’,

AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER, _ = ._
GOVT HIGHER PRIMARY._S”L3′.HOOL’; V

DUBALAGUNEDI, HUMNAB’A1;’*rALuK;

BI DAR DIST.

ARJUN

S/O. SAMBANNA, _

AGED 43 YEARS, V

ASST. TE,ACHERg ‘ ” _ –

(3ovT.s_HIQ::{-£53}? PRIMARY S<:1~i'c:='.I..,,.«
lE§AS_AVz’% KA-.LY.£\N’, B5§.s.avA..mL¥Ar~.I TALUK,
BIUAR .

V~’SHTk’£M}aNf”§é:AN:’x.:§}=*PA §’A;m;$URE
s/oi MAf{i–KA?PA..R1kJASURE,
“AGED 33 y=E;m;>s,’ ”

A:3s’r,31*EAcH.’e:r2,_ ”
GOW’. m<31~1ER.p;2.::s;;ARY SCHOGL,

— .. c:H1TKfrAvH–UMNABAD TALUK,

13~mA1a>Dis*1f. _

. «.53.

_ iRAE’J1§NA SEDDAPPA
_ “AGE1’3.f12–YEAE2S,
‘V ‘AE:1S’I’, .*1=EAcHER,

GU’.i”}’..THEGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
f<'3£Ni3AGAON HUMNABAIL) TALUK,

.. E3}Z}AR DiS'I'.

VVMAHETABPATEL

‘E3/O. MAIBUBPATEL,

AGED 4′?’ YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER,

GOVT HIGHER PRIMARY URDU SCHGOL,
GHGDWADI, TQ. HUMNABAI3,

DIST: BIIEAFE.

MAHIYODIN
3,10. ABDULRASID,

66.

67.

68.

AGED 50 YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER,

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
PEERALPUR,

‘E’Q.B.KALYAN, DIST: BIEJAA.

PRAKASH SALAKE:

AGEB ‘}’8 YEARS,
ASST. TEACHER, .

GOVT. HIGHER PRiMAR_Y”‘«$CHO{DL, ,

KAMALNAGAR, .

TQ. AURAD, DIST’: BIDAR.

SAIDFATIMA , f
S/O. SYED eons; —

AGED_A*2*~yE.ARs,,
Ass1§.TEAcHEA,–.

GOVP, ‘e~:1C;i-EAR PR§«M£’~’:RY” SCH0.0L,

T.MIRJA_P§Z;JFE, ‘ ‘

_.’.:%Q.A.~,’ a1s’r*;1A§r.1:>A;é} ‘

M1.RJAiAiA’YAi{L;:§E(:;””= ‘

‘ACAZD Se 3! E.{¥.RS’ ‘ -. ” ~ «.
As3T;A ‘1’:<:A~c:;»1;3:}<e, V
GOVF.E4ii'GH'ER 'PRWEARY SCHOOL,

' 'V :_MAMBA.1::i~:ALL:, TQ. As DIST. BIDAR.

E*SIi")f}~E}_{1 NAYAAAUNI SUBAGAM
.. ,AG,1e:;: 57 YEARS,

' – ._A–$ST1'TE}ACHER,

, jzo.

G<:£vfr;~T,AIIGH5:R PRIMARY SCHOOL,
ENKBR,

v–i'IfQ,BHALK1, DiST.BIDAR.

"KASHEPPA

AGED 47 YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER,

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
TALMADGL

TQ. HUMNABAD, DIST: BIDAR.

ANITA
3/0. SIROMANE,

AGED 47 YEARS,

ASST. TEACHER,

-;5..

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
FAIJAWRA,
TQ. 815 ms? aamm.

DHANRAJ
s/0. KANTEPPA BIARANJE,

mag 47 YEARS, ~
ASST. TEACHER, 1,
saw. HEGHER PFHMARY SCH(§QL;:__ T
Mumz, ,
:13. 85 DIST. BIDAR.

REVANASIDDAYYA
s/0. BASSAYYA SWAMY, «'”” -.
AGED 47 YEARS,’ . »
ASST. TEACHER, ‘
sow. HIGHER PRIMARY :=:..c:1-ijr;:>M2.” V.

KASHiEf5155″w ” ”

$ixo.T’MUI%QEP:::>A CHAMA, _
1%;GE£).58″f’1*3;A_R’S;. ” _ — .
ASST. 4’I’£rl;5;.(31-I§}§;-.3′ V’ ‘
a{3vj1*.I~z1R1M;:~._RY SCHOOL,

PALAfiPAL.LE,. ; ‘

_ TQ. HUMNABAD, :a:s71i~, BIDARZ

“32::-E21 s3wvRAJ”p;1<:I$zA}2Ao SH RIGIRE

C/Q. SSW. HIGHER PRIMARY SCPIGOL,

' NEELI{IikN'I".?TQ.BASAVA}siALYAN,
4:3vi'3fr=.»3I:1;x;i<<*.(A<3E13 42 YEARS),

S}£v§%2'.§i{UMP;}? ANANDRAC) BIFEADAR
.333?' TEACHER, AGEB 44 YEARS.
C;{}_'<f"i', H,RP.S.BELGAUM,

V n TQ. BELLARY DIST. Bama

"ere: CHANDRAKABFTH

S/O. SKFDAPPAHUDAYE,

AGED 4'7 EIYARS,

GOVT. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL, JAWALAGE,
TQ. BHALIARY IDIST. BIDAR

.. . PETYYIONERS

(By Sri, V.LAKSI-EVENARAYANA, AQVGCATE}

-13..

9. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF’
PUBLEC INSTRUCTEONS,
BHBAR DIST. BEDAR.

10. THE BLOCK EDUCATION OFFICER
BIBAR ‘:r;s.LUK,
BIDAE 13:31’.

12. THE BLOCK EDUCATION omcm j;
BASAVAKALYAN TALUK, = A
BIDAR 3131′,

12. THE BLOCK EDUCATION OF~E’i{3.E;R
BHALKI TALUK,
BHDAR $131′.

13′ THE BLOCK EDUCA’i’1(}N 0§’VFV’IC1ER’ ‘
HUMNAEBADVTALUKL V
BIDAR 91337;’ *

14. THE E>,__:,–<)§:i44i»:iii';:i::)I;_I(:::1\;'gfI':-.\_I. 0.§§r+*:ir;:.1é’;;2V
AURAD ‘mv_.g:._nA1ss*3:_. V

15. THE ZELLA PPfi~!.CE1AYAT}{ ‘ ‘
RES’? 8′! {TS c§«::j;~:.}? E.§;E»<:m'-Iva OFFICER,
B1i:aA~:2_ £313': '
_B_§DAR'~ ' '

* _ zsfl i'~':':;~1 ':"i JZJLLA §Ar:.::.;iAYATH

' REE? F3Y'<I_T"S CHIEF EKECUTWEE OFFICER,
" Bi._DI§E?'<v£)I"ST.
131:;-AR.

‘- > ‘ RES?ONI’3ENTS

{Bi?”‘sR1=–;:§,s;’§<UMMAN, ADV. FOR R1 TO 14)

This w.P. is filed uncier Amcles 2:25 and 22:7 of the

Coiiéfitutien ef India praying to quash. the Let.ter
fiit. 2 1. 1.2008, issued by the Under Secretary to
V " "Govt. Education Separtment, Bangalore produced, as

Anz1e:x2:m=:–J and Notice dt.29'L20{)8, issued by tbs Block
Education Officez', Bidar pmducmgl as Annexu1'e-§-i, as

unconstitutional, ultra vines the: powers C0'i1f€:i'I'€d under the

10?

.}Q…

fact anti the Rules, arbitzmy and violativf: of’Artic1es§’.”:’£§’E», 16,
and 21 cf the Constituvkm of India and etc.

Thasse two Writ Péxtitions coming on

lzéarjng in “B” Group this dzéay; ._t}1e ” “the «

fo1}owing:~

QRDER M

Tim learned V ;–*uns::i”” file “f):éi;it;ies not survive for
consideration.’ is d;ismi$:~3ed as it has

becomg iI1fZ’_”tLt}$’;¥§{:].(_).i.15″sVv. No’ §::i:11..e:.as to costs.

Sd/-3

Iudgé


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

93 queries in 0.174 seconds.