Sharanabasu vs Sriheriswamy on 10 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court

Author: V.Gopalagowda & Nagaraj

EN FEE’-{E E5£§§}E%Z {.T;®E§?;’§ {FE-Q’ §i5%?;E5s’i'{€:’%EéZ;%

€ERCE§§’§f° §§:Z.?i€€E§ 5%’ G’§}’L’8z”sRi3s’%

E7″}A’i”§%iEi} “ms ‘me: W EEAY 92: mg? Eéﬁiiiﬁ’ 1j _

vkgggm

mg H§N’BLE ‘§éR.§8STECE x%.€;L€:;?g§§ :,;a; s<}2s¢'§;, X

V
THE ﬁgzwaa Ps£R.Ii§ST§€jEi…,5§R;sXiZ'?~§$5;G;a5§%é'g,§E§

MiSC.FiRS'}' A??3&:3;L §é.{:.§'§§f6:§$?;§3£'%:$¥?§;£%r'i

'§e§'s:s»'ae:'3;


Sgé S%3a%anaha$:':   " A
S:'a7,?v{§%:a$é§?é§§$ '  V' 'V

Ré€:=.Na§3"m:%aé--_ ' V  %    ' -

E’a:E::é&s§%ha§;A 2 ‘– % ‘ ” ,.f~’:§>;3@}§a.g:%:

” S23 .i§»i.§%2az%3é, 1%.§%;.}

%%%%%

E S}:”§§’Ee:’1§§’:z.sé12*3f;fy*V —

L'”Sfitai_?e:}§;§3f§§;:Gi§é§3;§§a Eﬁevagamaadfe
R;3::;_.M032a}g:a}~:’§:§m
Digtiéetzv’-.C}1§:§*ad§;§ga,

.,T:’E€3~}~§ﬁ%§a’: Iﬁéia. Assiifaiéaa C{:e.L’ic§_,
‘ ﬁéizégéeriai Qfﬁ-:33, E Fiﬁfjsé’

” __ * Eﬁéga Eiaséai Cfiiéiﬁiﬁx
….§,;”v€2:.:b§e 393$
Eeéﬁaryp

3. The Managing E}§z”es;:'{€:2*
NWKRTC, Hazblé’ ..R.es;;3{>;:1de:”;t5

{By Sr; Sazdarshan M., adv, far R2, Sré Shé¥&kum~:§:*_’S:..__’__L” ? ”
Badawadagi, Adv» for R35 R} Servedﬁ zznrepresentéd} 2.” ‘

mm»

This Miscfirsi Appea} ﬂied unde;+3ee_T1’%?3{§7 3 .:§;:’%:-.«r~.;

agaizzsz the ﬁudgmxzm. and A.wa:«”d’«–.da:ed ‘-§f;3,2QG;’é””;;:;ws§é £21
MVC }*§a».Z2S6f2€}§1 an {E33 ﬁle sf ‘£3:¢ ‘{Zév%i }ﬂége’V.{§§=r.{}n.}VVaz:d
Member, MAST, Muddebihaé, p_:7{i*i3y =.a_£10wi::g;__%;§23:? claim
gaetitian for campmsaﬁﬁsiz’~~._a3:1d”V sé6–}<:;iz3g"-..\en%z3n<.:€:ﬁen% sf
::ez11§%I:':sa':éo::2. = '

This Misc.Fi;fs'.i.__ A;'3j;éééi3"tV§(:3};'i§:zV}<g-_V€;r: «£6? dictaiéng '£313

Eudgment this dag", }$éga1?aj';" I, éc'a}£t£éIe§i«9':E':a fG3;3€i%'i§1g:

” = fkAJ:;’ef{;Mr::€T%

In ‘E§;i3′:;__s{ppeé;§;,_ Whié wag ciaimani ii”: MVC

Case N«gs.2S.6f0§.V ixzz, :§%i é 0%’ ‘$25 iaz;.:’n6& Civii Ezgége {S§”.I}:}.’}

§\,/iv.éc*;6b%}13E iizereinafiim 3*afs:°r:;>;d iii} as

}”‘ };vas’~.:;$é3§;ghE far €n%§az§eem€s§§’: (:2? G{}§}Ep€§ES&ﬁ{333

-aavafééé éi?._%’i§’s” fawn? $3: ﬁrm szaié ease 3:161:31′ {ha émpugnaé

“3j:;.€§ng$:;ﬁ:¢ﬁ%:.Vs3§3d agwazd éaﬁeé %3f§.iE9.2{}{}3.

2. ‘fie 3:32-=6 heard ﬁza argzzmenis 9%’ 83% Anasgd, Eeameé

‘i:913§}S’3} far $36 app:”:i%3::i-««cia§m5.ni 2¥%3:3 Ems aizéaﬁakcn {<3

9J§'t§!(§§if far '#325 agﬁpeéigﬂé anti 33% Sue'ia3"$haﬁ, 'i%'i{'3 Eeamaaé i:s;;::§§::4a§

X_,~

fit}: the End' ragpcmdent '-New Emiia Aszisurance C()mpan'§y; Sri

Shi%2a}<:::mag" Eiadawadagi, Eaarrzed mamas} fcsi' 'ihird :*es;7:r;;=:%__<§e§;:§.~».V

»~»N0rth»-§¥est Kamaiaka Rsaaé "f:*ansp0:"%: Corpiaratiiﬁ'-(£2?

€336 Cerpcxraiégxf} anti parussed the i::§;§§2g–:3;ed7_,Tuc;ig§%1é::iV'a3ié

Awayd 333d 3236 iése reievaﬁt €i{'I€'i1fi1€}'.$f£3:".3§Ti}¥}%'§'§€(:§, *w.i.'§;.1 "

appeal

3. Since the §i §1%::ﬁa§3§
seeking e:2}13.n«:;e::3ezf;_’: Bf ﬁat adaiert ta
téie iéstuzn Gf iatéash and negiigani
égéving by iii; airiiser 332%
the Eiabéiééy {vs pay iha cenégaenaaiian $0

ﬁgs ciaéiizani £:”i:1s;.2’2″mc%3._3;§,~.n{:..-aﬁpeai ﬁg fﬁad ‘$3; aéiﬁer ‘aim S}€€2{“}}’}d

:°r:?:3p£z«é”;fG’1;€§:;_§L-:%::::e;;§’e3′ <§3€"é'§3a:'%;*e'zi§a3€ invaivad in éha said acatrééeééi

as 'V"i§';§f{% _:§"a$;3z"é§::§é;2t~Cs3r§:m'atian eézaiieszging {ha imp::g:1ed

§aégm_;s:3':_.::xéé 'A1x'aré. '§}:{a:3'§iE':m, fha agzify queséiam $289: arises;

' 31;? :3;ei<§£:%*::r:§z3a"'€§;?;32 is,

"w}1ei£zer fﬁze €6??1§8'§Z§fi?§8f£ awgrdezl by
{me iii-4C2' irs favaur sf zfae appeilasziw cfaigyzgm
sgqzsirag éa be eaizarzrfea' mad if 39, is wizai
ex:e:zi?"".

3;. Wa agzswer ﬁzis gwém is the “3fﬁ:’:3;aié1-‘ez’ hiéiérizag §t§”:3%

{E33 aiaéiﬁaaé ﬁg azziééérzd EC? 3 Eﬁﬁﬁi eéﬁlazzéseii C€’3I}’i§?€§%S3;?§{?3’i

C_….wf”\-~*-“\./–

awaréeci by ﬁzz MAC? 222% ‘i’€§3″§;’ §”ﬁﬁ§}§.§§’§§ 8_E?}{§’ii§’3’Zf:i 2:_z:;{§ %%1<:}r

r%i:$*::V?: 223:3

aizzéméééas £3′; fiiiiife iéfe” arid ﬁ’;é33fe§€>z’i:”3:$$3;:ma%:’§e;:.’:g:i:§’ :’;f;::?:S–:§é'”‘a’: 3%;

be awaréeai aszéer ﬁéese %3€ads;.

1;: §:; reaszm (‘sf 1/;a,;V3;§,%§i$ aziaimaizi
mug: have sizéfereé 1v..§:§::nia§ agcsriy. 3333
MAC? ag:;:§Vs::%:_’,;*:§’§i’4;2::’:1′:i;3:* the E:-sad? ‘gfram and

3::§e:fiz}gs’_.”§}:£r¢f£?:fe, .§3€:§”é€§j¢ azasazéad a gas} 9%? Rs.3i},§8§;”

smciaz” ﬁéég Eifzaéi.’=?2%’:ﬂ?};z:f;”«–i§§6″ciaémagﬁ, ‘Js=’h€s was agezi &%§z:mi 22$

3:233′ 33;. géiﬁ iiﬁéé éaie :35 a£c.i:’§:5§§%, $333 is saéﬁéz’ 33%

. é%Sc’3:’§:2e:2%: azaé 3§}E€E1§?§€S iézzmzgéé e::’%. Eiés §f3.§i’:::”a Egée

: -2

‘wE3§’:a:}zV”‘:?;3af;*’ ma? he; Eggs 3.3133: 4% {<2 5:} fy'éi3E'S. "FR §'Ef§C'E' E33 ms':

V3¥§é.;'a;°;§$é $335 am:3§:’£ Gf €iC?§’E7é§3¥3ﬁS3ﬁ{‘3§§ maﬁa? ‘iééia. éaeaé ‘*2»=”%.;;L, ‘E353

ézfsf e§3§€:’§,=-‘::3e:2ki said i3£§§€?§§€§§3.*S is §iZ'{‘ii§’€ ﬁfa’. T%f2e:”a~:§%:;§”e., Ezavézig

regaré Ea ‘ER ﬁaiiéfﬁ aiaé ﬁéiiéﬁﬁ sf piijssséézaé &%53.%%.féi’jg 2-x%3%é:§§ £3
§T£(ff31’233§£E%¥E€;, 323$ ﬁéﬁ age 05 ﬁza séégaaia, we Ezersby an-‘a;”{§ $22 Eéég

§a%,-=’€;:i§° & 33:3; égf Pg, éi’§,{§€?€,’sf Lﬁﬁﬁﬁf €333 Emaﬁ.
(…._mg”~~m_.K_,,«,_,

cf?”

7,. Tisa §€:i&§”§”i€;’i§§ azaéziizsité £33″ ‘£28 ::§:;%3§§22.33%»{;%3.§:’;:za::i

:-;’z:’@§g%jax wzrzisziéeé éém in ‘i?i€’sI*=£ cf zizzéégpaieﬁ faési-«j%%3:ég*’:–«_é§2.i.é

céaézﬁaﬁi was 3 Siiﬁéad painéar havéisg paasaé Li*:w:;é;*”a2f2§3§*-§-£§§*;T:,.%_§*1 ”

Graéa ﬁrawizsg E>:3.:z:%§z&*:i<T::23 fsiéizéd' 'f:%'*Qz';–2 €313 }:}z";t:;:§3;é:3€sg

E:-«:.§'? £95 'E:z:.F8 :*espa~:c%i'2:e§j:;, mg: ;{::*ig%:':'.3.% i*szar§is C-3§f§§S'§E"E' rat;-§ée;§:i{

6%' said ﬁ'19<18§E3§i13'§;i€§§§S, mid 3336; €§1<s:% :*s:'a§ e2:§é';:2*:n'i:s;.:v-10%: 1i§?'W.2 ma?
'ﬁat he 'aged 'E0 yaizﬁ ﬁ?i;ff:*'D{iE%'i'&S§- .¢':§{{:…, MAC? £:;'r:mz:%"£t:3::’:’§a§%ﬁ{:§ éhaé ix: was azafizaéésg E%5.=1,%’3é’:.%iT2..»=”» €53′;

R§€5,{}{§§”‘f« 3 fa? maxi}: $2-‘ , iéxa ﬁivéséan Bemtéz {if this C{‘§’é§§’? iazig
i:Ea%:@:°aEe}§-‘ éaaéi wéﬁa £28 3:zz’s<:':.:::% 9%" :?,e::é:3:§e§::=;3.?.é£:a§ ':1; Es:

aaasarﬁsé %}§: ﬁée Tribuséaég is; §*€:s;'*:ec*¥a sf §;e§'s;€s::z§ §3:_%a:2"é§:g

A,\w_'__ __

sﬁgﬁﬁﬁiad 'sf; '$36 Viéiﬁifﬁﬁ ('sf %:3a:im' wrhicie €i{Z£§(§i:i3?S3 iI1=a13§'8

"saﬁicuéafl iiﬂdﬁi' ﬁie head 'R333 9? f'a'§t23*:e §3::<5<3.?_.1i%é"'*.v<s2*
1~ 3* .9 ..

‘reiiucﬁﬁzi it: eaméizg capacéijy” iriaving regayd §::*..’}£%*s§ {if

siaiiiaam, nature 521″ ﬁiﬁ injuries argéfiiﬁ .r::a’§fure;« a3j:’:3;_ sixéeixi $35

pemmnezzi c%§3a’G%§%’iy resuiiing in ﬁi;i5f_i€e'{§{§§’§;S§j”_ §’§§S&§ﬁi}§§f*;’;’.\§§’-.V

takéag fhe ii’iG(}I’E}6 af’:%2e c§a§n2a’.ﬁ*:..V;aTs em ﬁré&~b3:’:f%seé a”£_.1:3§t’*..i.i”a;:}*~’§”1s:’:«;..£’é”e::s:’§’*éL§’ze .?i2§&:=::£3«:%ié§”sL3 Eiéédéﬁ-‘§°i
‘ .. -. *3?’ .

“”” . _ “”7f%3§3E:3u:’*is ;2:as;’: “f:?%-‘:::’::;z::3;E:-:, £22 §§{¥f§§:’y’
%::j;:;f};9 «w%zé.§;é””3;g:;§:$;§§;g €}{?¥’£”i§3$§13&§§£§§E,
“:”:::%:€é:z_§5; {f,C{:€33.Ei’%'{ :”c%e%.*:3:2€
cé.:?€:Lu::3.stg::se3;” ,.¢éi*iée¢z:¢e Eegaé gwégeiggaig

_ gavégvéééag _§;-32a§:_ié§’~:;a%;i{m :3? £’;€%§E”ip9§’1$a'{§€§3’i.
” §?’:;r%.h$:”_,’ -1:§1cj; Eggve Ea a;3;3:2:::3<;§2 32$ issuzz 9:'
i.aw3'§é%:2;g ¢'{§:'§3§3an3a'ii:3§: 6:1: Eazgm'

_ pgzzfsgexztives :;::f §u's'{.§ces§ $§2;%t;§ am gmd
.,§f::~<:::'1srii<;=§3€;£ 331$ esclzew iaczémicaiééies is iha
as-.éiL::ia*§;2'zr;aé;i:2,g. 31:33:73 S}':ﬁE.£§,€1§ ﬁe reaiéxaiéw:
53': par? G? ﬁﬁe ?§"'i'm;%§2E3 333$ Ceuﬁs $33:

. ihe p<;sses:.si9:: :72§,'{}::e'S {mgr} bﬁdy' is $33 ﬁrsgé
"skid zrieﬁi vaiiéaﬁie of 3%} Ezzzizzaﬁ rigéafis, mad
that 3%; gagsssgsien and ew::e:rs1*§%§ are
aatafiensiaﬁs :3? tézis §i'§§'§'i&E'§z' :°'ig§}*, i'€%3§€
awayding €:~€}§3"i§}§E"§S3§é}§'§ ﬁx' %:n3é%é§: é§"§:::°§a:~;e
§G{§§§'§? %:;§%3§**§,-* is ':9 be iﬁzéﬁéé as 3
éep:*§_2-*a%;§:m_ *»..%:'E§.i£h sﬁiéézéeg 3. €:§%.§§§'i$.§E'§' ifs;
éiamages. 'E326 amaﬁaﬁ af damages ¥a3°i§;'s.:s
aseerdizzg :5: grag-ﬁg ééf égagsgréag. §}€.§3:'§_'s;3i;§;::!;:
gugéaézaad as 3; {Zi§§'%S€<"§%,¥$E}€i?: :;'?f§{:é§§§; aéfiésia
mag' §'3i'§§E§_3j., vgézéz it €;§*:§ee.: §.:7§;.":.:';€§::e:2§$;%j

.C"'\~"-~»._»~x..–»'

Y."""'–'""

§Ec’i§ZEﬁ§fy”‘, {3} Esgss. :’; ﬁg. §.3.2;%§ pisagureg zmaé
{sf iivizig. ‘§%’;:;:12g}1 E: is §§::;°:<::3Si'b%::: '$9 _ .
m_<3:;e;-«-' wizh mama}: 3::§'%'7s:*i<:3g;, 3§;:f;§3§,«'"
pergsszzai §€;3%"§%»*a'ii%':%i"i, ﬁza :Tri%3i,:5:;::.1$. °::§:§: sé;°’i~§::z’2§ ‘

aitaziagai Ea} awarai éamages as .§}3{}§E-€725 ”
$3.23. $%.}§’1§§€§ESaE§£}§’£ ihs 193$
and eaméﬁg séamsisé ~.._21£ia=*:{g_’uaié§f; ‘
eemgengatéd. ‘1f§aa§efé>§°£3’ ” eﬁszgéaééiivzzg ”
éegﬁvaéiaix, the ‘E’z_’%i’§:;:_;§:::E:<; {}i{:..::i"Es;_ aﬁmzaéd
haw déie zragaré is t§*%€ gs %i_*:;éVA'_a§§ig:::e ;f:'§
éapi*éva'i%;z.";;<2V as :.we%.;?f as <i;é;2;:fe§e {sf
aLva{e:;~e's.2g. _£3f §.§p:§:=;it;§§:a. i_';– .. é_g__f 'izfééﬁg :2:
awara§§:eg_; i:{§::3.%z1g;ra'::__,%i;._pe-sfsceigyaé igéjasajsg ﬁiiﬁfiﬁ,

ﬁgs: cawrggggzansé;:"i,»:*a;f§j'=f.';m.éa;2:¥.ed".§5%" Eéaa C:::z.::"t

AVvs§:<&::§'3a5~L_ 'bé'1I:;:A.s;z;bs.€$;z_t§a§;–~–.§§;H_ .:é%:a:2§<§ mi be

me:."$%5; 't:'3%:e:;r:£ '¢;§3i';};'£§f:S.7° _'
' . '.~J'v#V.'gV '. k 2 , V'_A '

IO.'%'§'}sﬁvBé:2c"gA'a§é'a%.:*a $6.}? in said case, Qzmésai 'EEK:

c:}?s~Sa¢:*vé'tiax§15%2f_§'§{;;3"%Ea Sagsraziza Ciwuﬁ 3; ﬁgs 233:5: (sf

' Vs. Z*~=~i;"§ Pest {:€3§i¥i'i}§ ﬁziéizﬁ} ?§*i*m€$

.' A{§iV:%§ite1£i'.V"'3;f35'Ue3i§:ei'S., §'€§€iI"§"£i§ $2 AER §9§§ S{f ?§i"€ *w':"2éc§2

$33.67 'i:§:':s:

“‘B§’=z;aéEjy* gpaaéiézzg axgézééa iéxiizg; as:
amamgé szzf sasggggeggaéiagz ggsafgaéﬁs as 3 ﬁcéém
szzf 33; a{:c.éée§§i, iéaa ésmages Ezaaie $6 éie
agaggggé s;e§s2:.2:2%ge§.’y as gag:-%;;::%3,:*§’ £i%§§’§§&§éi’S
ané sgarecéai ﬁanzagas) §¥’ee’a;:3ia:*fgs’ éagaagag
gaff: éésaaae %>;ir2%:.’:§§ ‘aha: ‘%:;%a:'{%§’§ Ema 2§£:?;aéa.§§ ‘
iaezzfzad 351$ whéaéi is eagéahia 532%’ baézzg
cziémiéaiizii in ‘ierms {sf §if’§@§’i{?;:’~gZ ‘vﬁééﬁzezis .zm:*:+
pa§u:”:.ia.:j; damag&:i«:; gm: iézssgga “:¥§’§§€~§§ ant”:

urn

.§i§£§’;7§B§6 is’? éeéﬁzg agsegasé ‘i::j;=° :ﬁ’%%§zmi*;%§:::§’ Er; syiisr Ea §:;>§:=§e€:,§a§’s:: Ei-%.5{“:
azamcézjgais pecuniary éamagas 3:153; §§’§i2»§i%s’§~?3. _
§i’={§}ﬁ§§§§€E=§ é::a:z13°:’e£E ‘ztsgg {Em €:§a.%.ma§z’: ; (\%};”‘”–
gtizzzﬁicai aiéenzéaizae: {ii} Ems sf e3…r:;%§2.§g” V
§’§§”&T%f§’§ wt; ’51:; Eézea dgia af {gig}; {iii}
mariayia} 3033. Sag; fa? naiiawpaciéiziafy’ £%5a3§§aga”:*3 “”
ass ezmsemadﬁ Ehafg %§,§.._:€tr:{‘§;;>uE{(:§§:§/l:,:V>.’§%»’;:§
ciamagea fez’ iszamai a:’:a§§>_%2fysécé:;% 37:32:-sk. g}a;i_:’; ”
Suéfayéag, aéreaéjy’ Szgéﬂzfséi-…Va>§ 2%’§:<;é::}}_;.§<é'
3:::fi%:'eé in fzﬁiifai; <§a1'*;i.*:»%;§;:;:-":3'* –71§:':=
€/{§%'.'§'.'s§}€i1$€i'{.é§ fa: £235 §3$V.<:;§:".2;':::é§2%:%@s 95:'
whisk: may-' iimiésdéfa 2-'§_1i"§€;i§;i '"<;;;%f ':'::'fa€"is2'3, is,

mi; 332933? «sf ir;j::a*§=* .t§:€»':”>?a%,::::; z1%.:@r1:§$d;.~ E3: ‘$’1::34f%r:2:<3:;ia:°:ce3

.,;.: ;; 1, d€3g€:miLs%L;–. V ,é%sap§}:":§nimas3*{,
§':°2.2;sf£:A'73';*€s,:e:.";_«Va=;::3d 'm: e';:1$&§ gt;-£33 in ﬁfe."
I?' A: pi::*zi"«{;'\;?:"sb__2*§ 1:";§ iizez méii §%2C§gma:2€;,. 333%: ';"}%i*a:§3%{:a;2

%§s:;§;:c§:*.h:»3;3 q'L:.s::§;%;é€% w§?.%1 apgérwaé iéia :;:'s3er*.:a§éa"§::'2 sf a:';«s:§3a:'

' '§;}§"$:%3;§(§:t; 'ﬁésaeh as? Cami? égz $36 cage 9%: gféﬁi-'£'i*"€i§"'€§j ~»~ $3"

. " £53, ILR E§§? {£1-dig 33%? 17*€3;"1§€}'T1 miziég §E::'::e:

.. "if 'iéyat €F§"%§§§'i&§ ggaaséiéaén €:a§':;:<:~%;

""'§es%m*aa:§ 3% §§'§§i${§§ in p€:%s':.:€2:12":§ ézgﬁgg.-7 £22'
fgiai aeeiéegai aasm it €»Té.§'1I'1{'.!'£ §:i3'2?§e':,1s§jg-' E36
iéfiéiz Ezm' imigi a:§";r:.,%:::a*:{::'2:* éac: gévs 3. §:1.%:"
£q:§%%;aE%§':. ii: E"%'Eéf'§iE€'§1 3.9 333:' ::2€:§_e§' am: ix':
3:': éaqiiévakrzt ané izéﬁéée gaisci 'SE32:

§a::§.agef*

zﬁgfaeéiég xvii}: iﬁézt amve £.T?§33€i§”‘-.f’3.’£§{?§§, ﬁe Six»-“és%::>*;’: E3339};
i%;:’%%3e:* <';§§§~;<°.s;"*«.-wed :5: {:a:'agra;:s%»«26 Eéézssi

§""""v'–«-"\.p»-"'""'

("mm

¥::i4%%3&:z', ihéz §3en{:§3 Ezag aim :"ef62'f@<i :1': garaaﬁ

'?h{:z's:fe2°<:, §§}::': génafaé §'?§"%§"§§3§§C.é§$ w%:éw:1:§_€1 ham keg: in §.fH§3.€ %’;2′::;§;””:”:;*a::{
szgsiaézzad ‘{}’:§§ iiajmées. 333%,. E3: $;*:é;:2§§}:é;§ 33:33 ‘

2.29: ﬁ’«£%’3£f’$ {Ff §T£}.(.’§i”‘§$:%”‘ 333% §a};<;s;i§E*;.-35;'

an §§}:§"iii"ﬁf»{.Ii mar: Sfiii §'*«E2§T}%.";%'iﬁ§_ 3 s§=13'§:§<:3?ead §'1m:::é:s'*3 A " "

£:'2':a§":;e;. V V
If 2 . Ea? p3.rag:'zzp§1«-:?;§}' (if ;:;%j§§;:v%*é'* -E§,1g:%ij;3f:"3'2%;:';*;v€,. E :3» §'-Ea§'aE;:%::2%:a

Eviﬁriézffs iiiifiﬁ, 'ihe §}§¥'§*S§8§}'§3'{:E}§f§§V %§_f§;§"–€ffi§§%§$§f2 this :;t:§”&?aiém::.


atsf }?ée}é,.¥. §§'2':z""ii€.*"§«7.,    Fate: Sméfiz E/¥£s§e*§*sz
.Rzz§Z:»v£z}?    'Y€€i7€§S $3123:

1 _ . x”‘Y’m;_ “<:.:%i3m§'£:-,v';32:i _' £13 pﬂéiirméff égsaéiis:
Esgiéiaa %§;'a'_z;§§*:«_%'<,:~gs;*'i§;:€::3é§§:;§::, 23:3: '§~'€;}i}:. §¥E?;3:€:E"
iaﬁéig ~7;e:ﬁ::' %":§f'a:;a;é1;*%_:'5"§e -i':{}i'§3EEE{'%iE S6§'iS€ K:
. _ %§§::§;*,"-gagéiﬁ §%§é,a: :'{;:2§%~':§E:a='a§-=':~; §<2:;<.é§§{::££ E223:
gs $233 £'3f1§§:'Z{¥€$3.S?:(3§} {zen :=x2E1é§:§1 c0mg:3:1$ai'i::
?+i:.3:z”~–?’;e g§a:e§é”.'”‘{ T§2e gééaizétiffg Céif} iéfié»-‘€§’ 3%
._ag;.;;.i:”; “ff:§_:” ii. Yam ézavatﬁ Ehezvefgsfsf §::f.:2zx §i§
‘ V. };;{“m§se::s3iai:3z*i, game 21:25. fat’ 3}’: Ea’:
§2:;3″;c¥}:,”,:§:§ﬁ 3:} armﬁzzg; be £233 §:3§§’$§eé a aéggzmg
gﬁ’ 131$’ %:a::§:-2 sf $36 észfsriaiaiﬁs ané ffiéii sziazgi
iaéga safe is givs him f’:.:,’:i fag’ camgeagzszieﬁ
“E50? ﬁéai *»¥i’3ii.:§”2 Eze E233 5;s.zﬁ”e3’$é.”

I”;

{#5 £33 §:ie’§g:33{::”;’z,

u ” %:%:::: §?..’:§S€i§’ir”§i’§§{‘§EE {Ef §§§§;§E:]»’€§ IE3 FEES LE, 5: #59 53:23:: {if

%’7£{}i%”‘§§E vs §§;»’§€i§:T {E §?§} 45.1% $351 3g 2′ Q3 i%’§E%€§’§ rz’:a:§S §§::.;i»;:

.,D_”_g”-~ ~»-.n,.,._,..m

“£4; is maaéfesé &i§’§§f 5;? %,%3e trééy “Ea? $1′

give 33 §€E’§8i§'{ 3 Sam’: as wag 2sa:§€E_:%§: ﬁrs:
pawef”. “fiaew are many §é:;3s;:;°::~; 2%:§3§c§1 cagiaai
easﬂy be expraagaé in tgsfrag 945 mzmajg. ii’
§’i€fS{}i’i, in an aaciémﬁ, $363 §2§S Sig%’:7%_; ‘ .
haaaténg 35*’ gmeéléng iéauiig’ :33: 33; 1i§§§.:; b
Eff sue}: éapfivaiima e2m’sm’%i his éssessﬁé fizz
terms {xf magket araéga beaa:,é:.~”;e igfgars §_s».A::'<éx _ "
iiaafkei $353.36 313:" the §}€3§'S(¥E}3}"— a§§'S€fi v=€%ﬁ;i.§3. A. "
223.5; been 303: %z; the a.cc§d{:%'2i:._ ::.::ai'§§2Vera jg
€33}; way sf eXp:*essing'VL'%§S$' €:qué2:é;§s3;i§T 'ﬁr: :
{arms :25 moagefg, '%}%§ever:%3§%;erwi_se3 {Em éav-5 v:_éz;?;é:§–.E§a’:” 3§;$§iE:+»..;:§:£ 1&9:
3&6 ‘int: give €E’1§i’:{;”i*€’;i¥i§:9€f’é:’§~”– 5&~’€i_ “”‘§%§3€3:§g}§
aeaafagfg’ é:_erE§3£2.f=.§j; *:.i=i;;a:¥:f’-=.b€::i’§:a%¢§f€f,_-.’_ av ﬁ?a§iz”= __ass_s::$:’ﬁer3§”mmzsgﬁt ‘sa
made. .;z5;E_§%é{>::’gh4″‘V–£§’§§<.;:{§:?{eé:3Efe"' §§_1€§'§ age
_éiéE%;iii%:?'§é3'1-1;<:;?:;é -.§§i:3;:§'€;*§2:é.::;€Vi§§.2=,i§ E22 assasgéaag
a_da:n3geTs;_..%;:& ;§§r=s.Qé':g§ §§E§é:'€}? $3.333, {E333 fast
§}3<é'z:%£'z307£ §f§§$cVE»§§;§{t:__;3,"§; zésﬁessmeiﬁ 3% bag':
aéizg £13, tééa:-.;si§::§;:rr§§§z;:§j§€f$ be 3/;5';3d@,'"'

I3' . gaam 35.3? zzﬁfézzz Eaégezmszzi ii: Eézziz 31.2355.

"saga. %§a§ £%'€::1§:i:..E:as qmtﬁd $26; isbgeﬁsaiéaaiés 3% gzaa § 9% Eéze

.%'a.§§ga:m..:§%' j_.§§z1 2- Vesﬁiaiesﬁi 'vs. PK Sar32:a§:a:*: arsd i;';ﬁ'§€i"$

_;epm1:e;§*ia 2582 mg 22:43 323% :: $8516 @3333:

“A3 3 E°ﬁ§$Ei§7’i {sf 33′:1;’:’z2ia?i:3::, iiéza
céaimaxaz: 223$ 13%;: fﬁﬁéﬁféé 2; gﬁggia
iis feqﬁérea ﬁw; E33? $5 ayuiahea :3¥%::*.a
fag” waikéag, Hg Ema. bacamza 22%.: §%:~:*
$33′ kéﬁé af mazami wazik, £33 ha: W325
eafiéaif a Esaésr éeézzg :”:’:3§§::?;?§ wa:}§°§a:_§
ﬁtaa 3§’§§§’%E§’i’.&§£§{‘t=§§ Q’? izig 26?? Bag %€:§§’$§é 5&5: zszsfﬁ Ekﬁ” :§:’:j=;

<"**—'W"°'"'""'"""'"""""""'

§<ii§'i& Gf mamiaé vs.'{3:"'§\:. ﬁg: E233 mi;

agiuggﬂszzr £2″: gzésh @3355? ii’ is; “wag
Ssiéieé that $36 i~:i;<;':1:a:§2§;:

ﬁi§é=5:§§€:2§§2§§ £é3;::§”é%%t*;* wééi 233123 is he ”
ifﬁated as §£2′{ai {ii-“6§i ﬂ3::mg}3 ﬁne _
gégjggéeai é§4:«a:ah§E%§§:’ S 369 _’g€;=:%””‘
C8133,” I 4′
{A–. A? 3333 Nag. S} e;:*f__%f:s iiéiigisimz

j?V§::r%§*}:jg:°S case raferraé $0 sazzpaa €§’::3:4;
£36323? cavilgiciezeii ﬁiai §}§§.f”§§{}Ei’é’? {if
égtikzéféﬁg iass éﬁfﬁéfgére fsifw isiéaci
aesmagszg’ 0;z§_;:fI£:§§ é;4§i4f’_5j:%e:?:.V5}%.”%§%§”%:$§é2£a§ﬁ{e£aiﬂm§z€} {Eff

She 213:5′ {g,=’*’ ésijs 1’£:’€-‘£’*§i};i:i:g:3 ;’:*%E2§22:’§é:ﬁ;*i(:s2v ﬁr {ﬁg emgrf Sgwggﬁd eiziw
miae §§i§§’–.gsc_az£§§ ;£fi:égfz;;€;§fa?_f}:*«}3g3éa*£§ {sf ﬁlm apﬁéiézzsaf garﬁiﬁg
fffﬂff izzsmsie’ $1? é”-K ‘;:3%i§dé.mz§ iﬁgrgﬁzéﬁﬁﬁﬁ. 3% “gigs?

gifﬁﬁéfiféﬁfiﬁ, f&zvési3?g§ _ §}7_§&£&§3?: efzf”. gﬁfiar yefézzrézzg ‘ii: {ﬁe

_.-f;a;:’im;:£$-A: §fa;,%;$s W §:J’%i.§E§Eﬁ?%§ gxggg $35 g;%g.z 83?}; mg

-~–%.:§* »_ §?’}§§”?’E 52%’ Eggs} §g*2§§§2; § 355 3%

% .7′

§%;’;::2::*3:?: _s5;–‘§,’:&:~;s;;3:’*=.>eé $23?’ “‘w%§§§a €’iSs?§’§E333ﬁ§.?2§ ::;:§ imzmzzzg.

{.mNr”*””°’\-r

?;*:::”ziS%z2’§;E:é:’ %

E3
ﬁae Cami”? can mks him accmmi éﬁza fiiiasri: ;}ms;:«e<:'a3 :.:sff{%:e
:%:':j1a:z'eé 03' ﬁéﬁ deaeasﬁd, :3? aamézig §}§€?i"ﬁ %§":c::m€ by ~ia};1;§f"-«;§f._

;'}F{"3E§1E3{§{33'3S or afizerwise

I5, A5 the abave C:h=;e3"v"a'Z§{':33:;' 7éé§""%.?3is'._C:3é3§f§;" *sJ2%.;"m%:s

ether Higﬁ Cmzris, ﬂee Szgprenie _C0ur't zz13{:i'.:.§1e

quaieé by '$26 ﬁiviséozz Bench z:":§aj{}"1"i5: {LTm:'r3 éﬁ-§;%3e v;:ase 0%'
Narasrinaiaa i'33L1'{'€}3:;«' z"efe§"§"e{i'%:§ 32z§§:*;a_ §:*;;=sf;}}fy* ta ﬁéé facts <3?
{he presem sage.

E6 . “§’}1e_Vé_.E.ai:9§:a3}V’£ h4:3:ré:£;’:V3;v§1_?:.;._ ‘§éiisg””an ymmg §f%»:%§E€é

ariési, was deéﬁg ii’-:s«;?.;_;fsaéaii %2’3.;;.z, ‘:j”€’ arzé cﬁher portraﬁis, has
I03′: his V:<£gh'%: '}1ar: 'e'~'%;m§§;§T: ._*§.é«%-sﬁiiié 1%: was dcuéng his saié wark.

?§§QEEg§} p§"ij§:§;i::_a } €i§S:&3£,?i§ifT'fy': 'svhicﬁ he has §aeei2 sziffésring is

" < .133': EQ3?/'§,__jAizegfeﬁzéiﬁss.frza fnnatiazzai désaéiiiiy-' $3 'ifs L313 exiem

=i:{f=§ §i"i'%"§-;r.:_ia':<.;';1*i's13:§;ii:..a,s 333 Car; 1{}€"*£EiI' paixzt. aﬁytﬁiizg ﬁimughaui

his' 'fja.§iurev_ .1'§'fé.V: §'%}{:ugh {kc MAC? has taken fi23}_2'{é{m3,i

-‘«<_ i§.§S&}?§§§ija',§?t' E{3§%, ii Ems wziimétieé 3ez'%_:::u;<; €E'1'"{"%§' in takiﬁg {E23

T §';"1r;'.'€2::'i,'1;€':§–'<:':f ihe {zéaimarzi a":::§j;~:' 3% 'ﬁgs faée :0? Rs.éé3.:'~ per <33}: far

ere;t§m&%':i:3g the has (:2? fﬁﬁifﬁ éﬁE<: §iE?§{%%§i§§ is E;':.=?:' ":.;:;a;2;_%;::' 2,

fifii' éiséiiziaééizg E933 széf §%i*::'a%.:*e imzsrrms Ea; iizif, a:Ev3}'iT:?;::Vz*;12i€§:.T'

Aémi?;ied§j;., '$26 {:§a%s§::m.'{ ax-"as ageé; bﬁxweééi'.?:§':f@=i?;'?. jy"z':asj$"as

as a

as $36 dais <3? aézeéiieiia ﬁaafefigisi, i'a§§§a::¥1%;%*§':g!; {E36._?–%3.;§g§*23é:'2€3s;*;f

ﬁéés Caaﬁ ii: Giziam Kiéadefs case $335
prapar muiiigéizlar {:3 'we ':a§$:»7 ‘»::.§m3m3 ’53: {ﬁe

;@§ ,§2;§i’g§I§i:*§i;%}f; vT%’:%,2§., {Em i’;~£’:”i}Ef?t’:§}S3′{§{§33

Tr§E3uI1a} E21 imp’
Ea: be -3-wafﬁﬁd .§1;*:;:A..§7,aa:ﬁ;%;:;%__ts? &~;;s§i*:§?:§§2i;:%: {}§é%§§7{33;:’3i uiaéai $23
iaeaé ‘lag:-2: ‘sf V%”és’ii%3’~°’e –§3ii;a;_:§i%;s%” ‘ mmag iﬁ R§.§.,§2,§{%{%§««
{_3{:%{}{E€§’>:3 agaéisai § :;»:wé:J”:;%:a;% ‘G? $36 §’:’%%-23:23.? is’:

éhe §;z3;§::gﬁ$€§ éé:’a€ é§; ‘is§’e ?;€;:§{:?”;:}* &*».%’§§’:i tfrésé game E2′: i}aa~’a2.::* {::f€%::e

” ‘~ .§§a:?mf3:§:'{, ” -V A ….. .. e

‘ 1,7 .,_;:.:;::§g*::::;:¢ S%§§331§§{€é ﬁg %;:3ma:”:i§ £{3%.if:E:€§ far 1338
§és:’:n:a7i’2.£_§«ré3;;’§{::”:;iﬁ§§’i¥§:%Surat’, ﬁtaﬁ }¢’§3i€? {7(j?i”§’323’§}§?i8& 3:2 €;’:E’E’CiE’ ii’;

zazaféiiéng V3: ‘s’:f:z:§’: {sf ?;5;5,§G{,§§m Emasariig §{::§:~<; cs? esiaée :é§:as:2mcE:

<:{":z}3§;;:-;~<:V§§'%s;a€%{;:": uﬁikti' $35 haagi kiss :35 esiaia aaziizecési Ex:

'~.?§'vi:afi;§L€:<é £3: 3 §?€E"E§{':§'}3:§ é:":_'§'i;.r§; CEEEE. §'§{%i¥§%'€?. {ﬁrm 323:}: {sf

-ff.-Ré’;§}IZ%§{}.5- azwarésaé E3»; ‘iézéz “§’:°§3:>z,’::’:;;2§ %i§E’%€E’ %}y.-3 Eéead ‘me:{:§§{:::;§

‘__rJ«…/>:_,,.,m:…….—-o

axgzezases §2§e:::§::s;7€0wa2’&g Aa%;t€:;:::~1§i::c;’a’?:;~_ ”

nmszéshgzzargt, £<:rxve:yaz3c:2:., et<.:.,.

18. Fe: $15: mason aftsréséié, jt}*:::g:C:'{a§ améfaum sf

c{1mpen3a§ie3:, §§%§’:’i’:3:;’j’§§2€: ¥i3e*i§::43:,t F §’2:32i}°é:*%,ii§:..d§2 €§é§fe:’e1ﬁ haads QGEIEES ta:

R$.’?,G2,é}QG.:” sag
{E} Tr:m:a2*ds..§:ai§3 323$ ?:«;*:.iifs’;’é:_i’i:3_§1§”s;

{ii} T§>§é.?2:’€%:; E033″ sf é3§j£%}922;A :.ﬁ{{%’i%§13;§§iS’v§§€§.}5$}S€S {sf ireaﬁzzeaé

‘– A and £§t§3us:._%::§:§’fdent:1§ axyanses

‘ . V {iv} Tésgxréréav kygs (:2? fiﬁ”%.}.3″€ §32c{:;3§e

?E’:’££3§

ﬁgs R5.§,:i”}8iE:’l« “K: be éeieieé

V’ ‘iamfarég 1:233 in eaéaie

‘E'{}Tr%§ A

(_._(“\_uwu_~–~*_,»~

Rs.

$%g,geé.;]¥;Ak’ag:;a:~dg<; hf; the Ev§A{3"§".

3{},€3€§§:"?~

Rs, xi§{},{I?{}€}f=

Rs. 25.%{}i}:–»

R362, E2,8€38S~

mmaw

mmmmuammwmuunmm

§7{3:,7¢{}?,@{}{}.5–

§,{}{}€’}:’~

$$wm&¢m&&wmxwﬁm

‘?,€}2.5§}§€}_:’«

Eé

(«*5

|*”3}.. The cézaimarzi SE33}? 58$ esziééiaﬁ ii} §:2’i:res€f{é:2T ?;he

a’-:2’2§§ané.:ei§ Campeizsaﬁaiz 533$: 21% 8% pa. 33 awaf:ie:iV’.?Q§’VVl’

Tﬁbuxxal ix: ﬁg impiignsé .}”?.?.£§?;$}}€§ﬁ’ Tim :s::::;c;::df~:’é:S§:§:maie:§é~-«..

ii’3Sz’z:’a:* 0:2 Whiiﬁi E133 iéahéiéﬁsx £3 fas*i€;12{:éi”§:s§’ “§}Ti’;”; ‘E*;*§%,i;:zi€:%.§’-LL.i_§2

impisgmd Eaégmeﬁt 3.m.i :’§w%L:7:i”*~g§3&§§ éspizgii

:33 campmsaiiaﬁza xvii}: §jﬁ.?€f€SiV§:?Eé?§;6Gﬁ’ –~’a§e’iT§°§§23″ €313: jazﬁeais;$ §§°at:;”:1
thsa éaiie {sf maadﬁéeé :%wa%:%_,” =

Q0′ Af§:£}’°AE§2e :3:§:_’;3;a§§;:«:3é-.¢V é£{ET§’§:1%’i;§?.§i Va? e;:_.-‘§§::eV’%i{i%::**{‘%.%%§-fr?”‘i1″‘i§£?é:5’§ 3.§’a”}§”€Saé&, 5§’3% ‘?£%3€§’€r::f
ghaié éégizaﬁéiaé §§;’:?.e*:_{‘%z£;”§i:si::»£§e§a;>§;%i Acazazzzzé in $36 mama
9%’ ?§1€ éﬁgééééani 2%;’%’§é’a2’§é:~;”—._§éé”:ii’€;z°;23.§fé3*eé 9:” acksdﬁéed %33:}§<; 9? E253

e%3<:;és.";::: far 3 péfiéfié 0? .E€§"§;ear$ msiséz a. difeaéian 3:: the Eaniszar

,A '$333: '§:<~S-A §.i§E"{if{*':Si aaazmaé §}ze:*e<§z1 ahaéé be geizixéﬁaé 'mg %a

' ~.a2is§?f{E§&i"" _J793é; iEée ciaiizzaﬁi if ﬁg"; 39 éegéfas, imé 'es-"§€%: 3, §3§:'"%_§§::r

é%§*%:sf;%i{:::: ﬁéiﬁi 32$ szaéai am<;:2;:2'§: {sf éemaéé 1"}? 3:3? gag"? i%:e:°a<§

3§§'a.%§ EEG? 'Se gﬁsamséﬁed {:3 ﬁe §¥§f§?.a'§E'3.§-35$? by him v;i§:%}§:z:i §fz§'§{'}§"

ipeﬁﬁiasisﬁ <3-f%:§'zﬁ :"v§A.{I'f <::€r3*2£€:ﬁ':a:{§.

(—-..f""'""x__.»-»-»-

3′:

ca»/’

EU”. Appaaé is zzéiewézd in par? in “§3{: isms. T}::;€;;~

paéﬁt raigeé fa: an; dei¢3:”mi:3a%§a:m £53; a§§gz>.*=;:3*ed aa:::<§zjé§.z:g2§?'; "

Awaré 332333 ha _mﬁéé;§%ed i3: 332% ailisiesazfé éaims,

"$39

sag:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

Sharanabasu vs Sriheriswamy on 10 July, 2008

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel