Sharanappa Kallur vs R S Jayashree on 3 July, 2009

:3»: THE i~i'E{§--H CQURT OE' KARNATAKA HI' BANsg:;;§R;
HATED THIS THE 3"' DAY 016' :m.~; ggaé A' %

?RESENT _   A' n '
THE H€}E~I'BiJ:§ rs«1;%..IL.¥s"1*zc;::1¥:.»AAI§»'q;.:1:;.'xxggzsyq-:;;;§éi*;gV_ 

{WE _  .  _ _ 

Ti-£E3 1~§{)N'BLE MR.JU3ri'<;§"3.M,$A*$?g?:;§R§{§§:A

M1SC2:LLANEot.;'s..}}f1RS;i';é;'14I:<5;:»;':;-.N0.5é2':i'20{:5 L F5)

BEVYW BEN:

A ._{;';:%;g~%."s:~;4i:~a'g§:{;é;;f;*zi;r~2 PER§}§LKz%.R, gmv}

1 sfiagaéigézéria K;§,L;i3.§.2;

[S1 0 "S§?;:a:3A§«::fi:::5Ai?§iA KALLU R
VAGEZIE At;«:;a'z:f?*%4;7'-Vi<gI<--:s ' -
<;;::c:; C}§;;\:'i':?i:%L' <;";%§3'*»f§:.;<e:~::~.x:E;x:*r SERVPZZE
{N ':1:;a¥:P;b;:2"1*'s«:1:«:«:s:*ii»%.0§«' R31 LWAYS
_ CLASS :1: .SER'¥'E._&?€'i"',
 'mo M3 259,14, F' RAILWAY QUARTERS
 §§}§';L;§§£fi;f\E§{A'**?%E§¥K? TGWN
:--;a5:~:.Ga_LG§2E 64
 *  ' ~  APPELLAN'?

fi;R"§--§___;  ' -. 

 _ 1 .R73¢.:A¥AsHREE

" Wf G S£"Efi;R&§i?AF'?.:% KEKLLUR
" AGES ABGUT' 42 YRS
QQC PR"£"'s?2§"I'§ Bi} SWESS
RXC} N3 57?, 2333 BLOCK
R,z%.}2'3s.JI?§AGAR,
NE%R §*=5AVfiR.%E'~¥G 'TH EEATRE
BA§'<¥{§2§L(}¥%E:? Ii}
 RESPONSENT
{B}? SRE GEPHSB B §BAL;%i3IAi%l'E, ABV}



'EH13 MFA ES FILED {HS 159 O9' §?'fi.Ev'1ILY CGUNTS AGE'
AGAINST THE JUBGMENT' AND? DEGREE-E DATED ..l.'3_;2'QQ5
PASSEEB if'? MC.N0,1161/2083 'SN 'i'§~iE FILE €§;'&--?¥'u'5'_I'"*'ET.E"i"A«IE

A{)DL,PRL.JUDGE, FAMILY COURT, _B A'NGAi,Q£f§{_E,_
msrv::s$mG THE PE'§'i'i'i(i)?;\3 FILED 6/3 13 Q)' {3Ia)_ {i'i)'} .<::;' =

HINDI} Mz%RRIAG~E ACT SEEKiN(3~ DEGREE;  '

TEES PgPE'~'i"E;AL HAViN{;}   

.'¥3'(}§? ORDERS QN I5 I'&.9.@0"5 ,T'H"§_S i'T}fi{*r' SA?'Yz§fY;"§f€:'§;E{5§Jiié_

J4 PRONOU§'~¥CE3 THE FOLL-QWiNG';A_ 

 JUDGwh,4.i§E;;i§«¥;'1f"

This is §('){ifi{}I1fEI"$   tbs jucigmezat

and decree:   ($11 the fila 9f the H

fi:€i(iitfi);£#.év}""  filauri', Bangaiog-5,
iiismiés-izig. t%1é:--  .r.-iscree iior divorce. in the said

p6'€it;Eon iI':_7e~.E1t1sb;§--nei'--.;va;éLV the }3(:'€ifiO}'.E€}f' and i:i"}.§3 msgyenécni

 "  W-'3:i'9'"€hfiLVw'%fe. " ~ _____ 14'V

  .i2f'='«.i:';:€Ii§;is appeal the paxriies am :"€;fer:'e<i {G Ezsjg thsir

  {jizmrt for 'me Saks; GfCOI1V€13.i€I1(','€.

 x «V 'fi}1~: facis isaémg {Q this agpeai 33% 'shat 233::

" .. x§;=€?ei_§i<}:a :er ami 'rim rsspamiam: wars: married 0:: 22.13, 33989 ai:

 Kaiyaaa Mantaga, Maflefiwayamfi Eéangalssre as peg'

V ' E~§i:1{§u cugffims am} Ifiss. 'E'E3$ $3163 mamiaga was 31"}i'€:%Zigfi'{i





"3-

and attanziéd by the: eiders, friends and reiatives sf both
famiiiss. After the marriage, petiticzzzer and mspazzdezzt
started Eivéfig tcsgethe? as husband and Wife in pafiiiignerk

house at Yeiahanka, Baragaiatzsra. accortiizig E3 

the mazried 13.11%: was happy fer the first tame f;"éi:'.."§'S,' :1;'1':éi*€é;i'iér V' 

firm troubifi started. it is his case'; fiiéit' ?;{1é«.r€:Sp€§fi:i€1_2i"Vasé£i

35:3 quanei 25:11:11 bin: for 31133:-" :feas<);ti::t,_ §{);{C{1€Ii13i}§;;f.'§ :V.37}'.1C;1'1r:*:;'z L153-h€:»L.:1ev€r ':1:-;;3s§  ta mffirm

him far What p':.;zr;::::>3e  'int? '§;:{3»i1fi7g~V0u*:.. She aiwaysr.

1:83:21 éjce ggive §a2::?aj,§_iarg'a«v_a§:;z:>':3.Ii'Ei cef mane}; ta her §3are11ts_ azzd
£316 mfimbérs 6%; E161 .fi;2nfé':its' iémfiy'. The said 32:': was

Q;:;§;s$a:<;£ *0}; the "3_:%et1?fion&r on sever-'a}L accasiorzs, :i:3;s§;it<: af

   ré:::p0n:i€:i£«C£id {mt hsififi :0: his aszivices 'i'"E3ai 'w'h.€z;

   gming WEE §<:iwe€m {hag}, €iU;r'§z:g the €138:

aim;-fik §i~l~.¥a§::2i&:f; 19%} 'the rasgaandezaé without alqibmgmg $116

 pfititicvxgér :31" without taking his zrsensent Eeft the fixammaaiai

 hqzisa arzii Want is £161' pamnis' b01236. inspiia 9%' {he

gaiitimzar making sexism: mquesigs is her ':3 came flack ':0 me

mairfzmeniai Ezozzse the: }i'€SpOfi{§fi'I3,§ (3316; 23.9% dis.) 3:}, {.311 ':'h{:
Coiktrazgx She Qihuatzzi him wifh ffitfigy wardfi mid mafia

<i=:3m§::::%:i0:: $53; '$125: public: is izzzmfiiatzi 33.13:. E:-Eézzxrfi the



_:;_

msponsient 16$? the matrimoniai 3162136 ii": J'a:3::;a:j§ E£~§'§§'
there is rmbady in his house to take care of hjmfihe is
stayifig ail al-3:16 Witheut proper ffifld anfi care. AC¢G§'§"§ig. :Q

him, 2211 these amzaunis to mama} c:r:;s31ty,.. £is héasi" "?.sé€;31 

subjected to same due, is thr: b_¢hras§fj0u:" J 'E1335 €..'=-";i'éA,  1 z

 That after the 1'€:$}3o::1i:i€:.: fiiéft 'him  

 

,}999 ha filed a pefition  hjs€{iiciz:'a£. '

separatien. Accardiug ta him,___L:fl.-1; sigma  waT$: {iisrfiisseé for
Wain of iimitaiien. V '-4.§if:c01:':ii1é;ggv. %;;a_"$iii27;, even after the
dismfisal sf his._1aeti2icsr1..ifi_€*V.::aa'€n"€- :0A'§1:?aght~:.:g3 in

   af Bangaiem, hence dfamandeéi for madam

§u?§{iIy jéquippfifi with cgiour T1 13' ., fridge and she must

 be §1'{':$.;%:Z::§ 6& with car 331$ 06$} phage {£3 Iivé Wifl': him, it is his

 cé;é£:, that the éemami cf regpmiéazxi is bayaizfi his means

A' he is uzzabie :0 meat the game. it is alga his (raga aha:

 = ...----€he respaiadmzzi statsé that the artist 9:' the Qkmri: is ii} 116:?

favom" ami SE18 wiii qiecézia whezz 3&5: Shfiiiifi 30%;: me
W2



*5",

peiitioxmr. 'Fh€:r€a1"ter, ii; a qfaarrei 'taem-*:z€I1 mam she alga

baa': the gvstitioner with Chapyais in the mimic: the

presexicc of fasiziily membars ef the IESp0I1€§i€:£}"7L'«! VV1'>;f..Ei~:.>:%3

breught about 15 gunfias to baa': thtf:  ;x;~'}i:ié:5hx 

rasuiied in bath physicai az1::1   t6:Tޤ'&--

petitiozasr. ii is his fuzfthsz" cam tk1§':gthr: :€sp:;>§,;:i$:;a¥: u€3.<:{':i~ 22:3'

a'buSe him with vulgar avordé». _ph§s€iCaEj;" aiasauiz him

with chappals. Tint: reV3"p:gnden'img'ai%{¢ 1;{i:§,*:nat€':$';jtié§11 that if a
sum 03%' E€s.5,00,{){}{}/-- i3  i;:;;£*iIj;_c:r maizltenazxce,

Sht? W133 'Se :we,a.§"i--§;j   iivté with him in the

}fiE1'§Z3'i3Cii1O@'i}}:EijAVEj1{}11é_§%3j,"-K321};Vfifiii ;é_:ié:*'e:i€,i%:;ner's iifs is missrabifi, he
is s€a;3r;':z3$g' :::l<31i€:'V"-31;:   'image wzitheut tilt': campazzy cf
3njfb0d3?,V'i:sv. hizacasé <'{.,?l";£at C'-36$} '#31611 the "mspeiicient was

}ixVzi:i;gv$%éi:.E;  s}:€;_§:;a3 mat ccxhabittd vaifiz him gxroperiy 331$;

» Shape _*é§?a$ no grape: Cczhabitaticn betwmga them there

' ~w£-£6: xiv 'ié_::$i3:.:S' in the weéiock ':9 them. in ibis backgrauné

 pefiiéfier has saughf: for deems for éivmrcfi an the

  *gr;*:3un<:,§"F:3f'$:2th enmity and? fifiseriion.

: 4. E32 {E16 gait}. pzmssémga, rsspondént. '$.¥;<'&$ {E231}?

 V ..--;~;;r3:x?%§r:{t'é3;Gm$. £21 £216 Said obgecéiazzs, she admits

W



.17.

me prfisem. petition flied by her husband is not mairzntainabifit
amé {ha same is hit by the: }:)I'ifiiCipi€S Qf res~}11£iicai:é:,T 'E'i':1e:

greed of pafiitioner Eb? ziowry is the causiz: for jg:

the marriage, 3116 had ftiaid. 51 _p{*:"E}:€iOI1  

dowry ésamssment, in the said :pi;€>ée'§:%i_.i1;gs.;«t.h é«_petii§;i:3nE.r

was canvicteci, the jpsfitioner ;'€f1IS€{}.__ té:3_tak'e rftg-:3:;:;»z1d<?;i':f( é:2$z<é1:_. u

though Shf: was rasady" and tfifiiiiigg to  .a11dT  

Silt': tienier}. thfi ave:";1m}1t 017' 'i:hQt":~:eub"s;6q2:€:1t to
dismissal of MQN0.   attempt to {aka
her back, she;     aieng with her
breth$rA.g1x;§' 1:is....T§v;§ouse to settle the digputse
,%¢i¥E7f% €fl  Eefuseti to take E161" back 3116;
th&reea.f%«€:V:',L  this peiifiaza seakizig d€C1'€€ for

{ii$itj¥Qr33 §IEI.V:E'i~§?*.'fv...fi-i:£3.(;i friveiotls groumis. it is her C886 ma:

 3£31~f';f£§.€.§1'i§ii;§EALi{5;¥,}A.'t:*i.{":f{S}I°i was also made by fix: £3031": bfiiow and the

 .s:%§;& 'd'i§i"_~:1{)i:V.[~:§?iéI{i any rssult.

" tfiased an tbs aforesaifi gieadifigs, the Seam §61i3'§¥--'

 frafififizi the fgiiawing £33353;

1} Eifigathér {ha pzitiiioner is enti1:i€& fie» {ha éfiétéffifi cf
divorce as soughi againai: the I'€Sp0I1d€I1if's§£'if{i?

2} What demsa sf Qréar'?
W2



6. 'E"hereafi&:r, the Com": beiew }3i'€)C€€f{i€Ci to 4re§,iéz:sfG.V'§i1€

evééance ::>f petiiirsaner 'W.E1€1'€iI] peiifienm éEXaIfliI.1=3}§:i"i1if1;';«$§?§i,7§i;::N_

§3W.1 312:5: I'€fSpOi};{i€3T1t sxamnzsd herseif .. 

the p€'i:Eti(3:1:':r {iii} not praduce am}, mark  C.§¥:}€?;3:.13:(l':'~_'.V'"i"1;..'_§_;S,~.:A§'.§"7~:;'"°,'

respmzciant produced Ibur CE::'*..;gé;g""c0me up in this agpfiai :31: the
f9}i§:~"*=.v§s1g g1§f;:;nd;~.:~q'

  '§'}7.§: i3<:::ii5'tmBei0&v has :19: aypiisd fig mimi, ii: 313.3

  'Vfmf,ié:;£ fg:.:::.a_2i;;:gVc;'*srg<.":_fii3t& the avidance an recsrci am}; dismigssd '£325

 fiéziiifiui pmpatr 1"fia$<;a:m. 'I'E:L€: Ieamzazi trig} jticige has

 faiiszé its Iiaiica £316: ofisfirvaiizéns maiis £1: szariiez'

  §3?8j 199% zvhezmin ii: is heid 'thai $215: wéfa 323$ Eéfi

"SEEKS msmimgniai §1C»iZSf: wiihasui: the kfiowiecigs sf Eaéir

hazsbasxai, stayaci ix: bar parizzzis %1<:2usa'::, whenever hm?





ON 3: M
husband askfié abaut her absencé in the mauimazziai Emigige
she used to tixmatttn him and brilzg {}0o:1(ias to .s1t"£géC'--§g: E131'

hugband an-::§. aiso gave threat is his Iiile. He 

in the said MC.E'\§o.}3?8[1£~399 his wife was xe;~:;:I_;{§ a;:s§"¢.%}:*2'a 

£0 give éivatarce to E11111 by iaiqixlg 33 Qf'T.&R$.«+'?$;{3€3_,{}:f£}'{§:}'~« E2155

peimaneni. aiixjnorxy and it was h.i.s'§*.aS£f that 3:: was. §%§.f~:§i"i§ii:gV

as {llassfli empieyea cira2vi:i§:§.;§{"9%;;zag;e":' 

he ofiéreé {<3 pay a surigaf  as'I«i.:1?1:;3s;1:}é:;:3: amoral:
ibr {E16 iifataime I1}£§iIif:€i:}£%:i}'..3::C€"'€T#fE:':V§;:';€.' anei this said
fact is not a§3};2fi=:r;§laie:§iVV' ;§1::I'};    H6 .2133 aise
urged      :0 $66 {$131 "SE15
;*a$;3ié§:§ i}3,e '2:ttxi'£:3_dVé:. o::'._§:::"bLVr5s§3e::€ie'::z£ wfaisiz wouici 11:31:. f%1<:}p

§%9.i"}.*te.u;i:an axis?' tQ...E.i%;'€ Iwrmal marrieé life in Visa": 01" {heir

, imfxg sépargaifiizgi 333%: far a periofi sf mars: than 7' years and

  %3'€lig;;~1:j¢:;:?::"'*«::;f  manta} harassment that the petifisxmx' is

SA'zI':§3}j€€3§"ifi§,.VA"i§Z1 bf;:§SfiI'V€3f£iGI1 in {ha sarfiifir judgmant that {$.16 rfispczzfissnt

Vhas bacame iika 3 éeaai 'god?' ':0 the péztiizwnézr said Qléffiibffi,

H at 'ihig mags rm mC01:§s_é<ji'§t3:" fl1€i=.4éa;z::;ie--.V

and 1:0 set asiziza {ha judTgm€z;:{"V--and "(i«:,~r;1f'r;::::T :.§?3%1~.'E'&f:;*giVVVi$}' thd

Court beiow in MC.N®,..1161.;"2'G{5§§  tr.)  g:j'a11t' {'icCr6€ for
fiivorce éissolvisng the  '§§et§i2'::i«:'i:sL 71116 ptttitiener anti

respondent. V é