IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CWJC No.1647 of 2011
Shiv Shankar Sundram SON OF LATE PROF.
PARMESHWAR PRASAD RESIDENT OF C/O. SHRI
JYOTINDRA NARAYAN SINGH, WARD NO. 28, IN
FRONT OF HARIJAN SCHOOL, POKHARIA ASHOK
NAGAR, BEGUSARAI.
Versus
1 BIHAR PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, PATNA.
2 THE CHAIRMAN, BIHAR PUBLIC SERVICE
COMMISSION, PATNA.
3 THE SECRETARY, BIHAR PUBLIC SERVICE
COMMISSION, PATNA.
-----------
2 01/07/2011 Petitioner was one of the applicants against
Advertisement No. 1/06. His failure to make it to the
select list has now compelled him to file this writ
application alleging many a things including the way his
so called copy has been marked as well as the marks
which have been given to him by the respondent Bihar
Public Service Commission.
Petitioner applied under Right to Information Act
seeking break up of marks against every question which
was provided and now he is trying to make out a case
that the marks have been given to the questions which he
did not attempt or may be the marks not given to the
questions which he attempted.
These are wild allegation not based on any
-2-
material as such. It is not the business of the Court to
scrutinize copies of such a candidate and go through their
answer sheet only because a person wants to say what he
feels like on the issue.
The Court will further not delve into the matter
for another reason because no regulation of such kind
permits such re-appraisal. In addition to that, exercise of
recruitment is way over as the matter relates to the year
2006. No purpose will be served by re-opening the issue
at this stage.
With the above observation, this writ application
is dismissed.
AMIN/ (Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J.)