K
K
31%;; me: mag»: (seam (>9 E<:§%;§%31'*-E:'%:'i'§§£§%iE1′
Efiaiaii this {ha 29th day 0%.’ Gcéabaa 2:::{:§;
B}§¥°’€}’E€E
THEE E§£}N’BLE: MR. JE}§*EfE’E(f’:E§ §,;2AL: §¥e;a~E’;AL N95525:? eggs: 2?%2::TT%a§2:1 8¢r§’;*gsisig
BEFWEEEE
in c:cI..,a. Ho.25?}2§fi§
$.hiva2.222mai’gf;:; E333i;*;%é;:?:;1:1″:’g3§[‘g%.é}’:T_a;iiQ-_ ‘
S 5!:;.VsI1ka¥’:a1fa1::?-sigia A€:%;3′;}:,;
Eagaéi e3§§501’2iitj’}-‘€a7′:;’S,. V
Eéf a.’F§;’:1;_a§EL;3*a;:g:r;:.fV > _
‘?h§m:z;a;:s;.::,§ Ta§:~’:§<I;{"~. * .
SE”:ir.:10ga §;T’3iS{r’i{:§; 7′ ‘ fi§)§§<':fiaI1?;
gL:%§?s=,%é_'~::;;s;"1i' §'f*}iwa:;i'é;E:,<:: ?&3$f{.::";._, ;:<:z;.;
–;§;–..«$:§..a ?€a..22%§2@@§
Sfiivu
A ;’ 0 Vsgifgfibhaiiraiah
Aigfifi’ abimt. years
Rf aZSv_f:§z€::aga:; Eéaiapgsa Biack
” .. AA ‘Tfiafigaéerfi,
‘ $§§.’v’i§a}? Eéumai’ égagg
Sfa Efifagaraj
fagtzéi &§§Gi};€ 24 §?€3;E’S
R ,3 at. Mafiifiraia
Ezfiaéuz” Tamk, Eéaiaz” Effisi.
,,».w..’..£.*'””””%
3. $ri.i}§::1eSh Rajesh
S ,’ Q Thimmagcwda.
éxgeti abeut :2′? years
R/at Srira:11pu}:
Bangalerfi. I
Eéative of ESE1waraha};}.i
Neal’ Kaisapura
Chickmagaiur Dist.
4v E-iumari Vija3″aiaks}1:3f{i..s:.<§2 "-.;"ija§.£La;–«
Dfe Ea$aVa}i11gappaj 'A . A ' } " A. "
Aged ab0u1:.2§ j,.='{?:8I’S__ _ __ 2 –
E/at Chikka,3§a3aVa;Qak{}p:pa .
vauze Nagaf, ”
Bangalore. N §i§p€§aI”iES
(B3; A§*é.%;}
‘V §nVfix-I§§’:.3€#}.’E§§’»2€:G§
mabgara a;s%.~’:s;g;sa.;%T::g:a.p§.:L:§
é.g§:é.ga.h<3x;t 25 §«~*=:%;a.:"s, V
' f é3;;ii%i§};E=:a;?;a$avaiiéz}i@ppa,
'if;€'i:?1:{:g E'-l§;aiga.;€,MV E Plmaxzi,
%%§3a::;ga:g'::g, * fi'2 5%}-3E3f1LLia.§'é§'E"
ggga? Sv__?#i:§"f'aii;:t€$h, 5%,:
. $ia3:*::’0i’Kam1a§aka
R?-;p1’e3eI1§e{i 233;
, ” -~’-§’~”§*;:i;1″*t.hai”:a§f£i ?{}i§C€f,
Sizimaga §}§S?.:’*§<:iH Respgndeni E53 c@m.ma:g:}<;'{7,Qt.m.»VL_ '
L Shimoga.
These iflriminai Appeais coIni1’1g1’o§3, f01′.:§if3j§:if§.i”ig V
ciay, the ccurt Inadfi thfi iblleiafkggz V
Theafi three {i1i1fii’§;éi– azfisen from the
331113 ajilfigiiivtifijfl. fifgfiiixgictioxi dated
2 1. 2.2€;}{>9 ;§xé§$%%%%iéy the East Track
C0urt~1,—i§hifi;€%»:g3::§:’1 tea as “trial fieuxt’
far $.E1(;I”:,}, ” ware s::ha::*g€sshe–A«’:PC;. 2333 {E16 fieveii aafizgaeii Wfiifii
%%’:gié§ b3;v~V;:::m%§}:a; Cauzt £31′ me said Gfffincfifi.
. 2. Eiéwavéi”, an apgresiatigrg. 5:7 ihfi am} fivi{§€m:§: af
u £5 21, éiht ::i£:€:um&1′;z’£s at Emfl ta ?4fi am filifisd
— fit? ‘£1216 “.§§”%a§ ifazzzi} by E13 éxngvzzgrgeé J azégsieni, magi
” “”{;§:’::§€;;:; aequittsaé aecased 3%.’? $32., E3 2% $E1%;2Ia:1ar:<i:§.
§"§5g<'E£3:§ 'bui: <:<}1':¥zIc:€::i 3sC'iCiESs3£,"E §T~é':3$,,i E0 6% 5:3? Eiiia {;*§33f§{ZfiES
::':'"~*5\"""'-*""'
zmcier Seciians 1293, 3§5 and 448 §?C and ~ V.
they}; to uxiciergs E3} far a pamtad af five }?ea:_$”‘é:.;3cif§i3i%3 01′-
E%3S.§,I1}{}Usj» far this Qifafica itndfzéfi’ VS:¢::’-‘:vi§::1ii:s§;’~E%?§ f’:fV–“:>,:. :’§€1?”iQfj éf
3:613 wars and fine af §43s.’2(},i}{§’éE}.,§f’4 wit§: ‘<;ie'f9.;'x::}t. é~§iII"'£€I1C€
Q1' 81 far a przzéad 6i';._§§1jr.<: Eaazg Qfffififiéfi i.,1fi{i€:§'
8601:3011 395 E?<Z3,_a1'1d ._fQ3i f_m«;::»:,?:::;s:;_.£=:*::« the sfiemae
under V. V'
ii (1:21 A {3v§¥»j"%$:"'§;_§a:%<%.-' by a::c::,.1$€€i $13.6, <:"i:'L.e%
§a.2%%§G§__ $23' §i}$§i'a€§€:';:éé§=::i 5308,? $0 :;3 311:} {f';:"i.A
§!§¢.£:':$'?V§£3%@ i$V"§E}_$<i bis: 3.i':€Ej§.:§€f':£i ;¥'~i<2J E3; {ha :::.a:§{§ SC
E§§9;?;S."§§}2°:}{';§f;?i';'~–. 3:3} £13556 acczgsseai amsi 8;,i$£} 8:C{.':L3S€€i §'~E<':«;'?
"§§fE11;fifé£3;§§%I§%§§S% Eifigda {wilié is asquittaé} averfi aim Eyisd
by {Em '§'r"§aIi ijiazzzi in s :2: 2::as.234~, 256 ané 25? gr
A i?.§{1é"§._ far {:16 $33136 Qfffifiéfifi if; ra$p<:«::'i sf éiigfiffiiii
' itisiiiszgis Eéaasi ::;9::u:'*r<3:§ aiurérzg the Same; nigh: batwfisrz
3:151 Efifii a:2§'ui}«", 2{}€Z%'?.
C..fi___$””*’-4’°-..:…,_…..»
4,3 fyhe Trig} (bum, xecaxfieé the ea3efi¢e%%%~%i _
pmsgeutizm witnesseg in all ‘t}1§§,..,Vf$’31iI _$’és’$i:én ‘fCva”£;es..
seyarately, iihc:-ugh 311 {ha x¥ii;1€S_SeSi,
mmplainam, am {:£3E}31’E1€}I1V»:§.§:T§;” “%E”3:$_’ -‘me
m:~3°pec:t.ive witnessas hays dispééiézi as ‘V: set of
facts in afi the cases.”4”}§;f_;’u:é;*,L_,§’:3§%e,:.4 Wimagses
have been €xgm.§_§1€d ?Ws.2 to 23.
in an {:16 fividencte in all
E115: dacumamg have
baa: ::§=a:;+:a§d’ ;§4& in sc r;a.254;2aa7 gm
z'{~*:S;)€zf_:’§”. wfiéztsiéi’V}:v<1.15g–._§\$€2;'S3, fgm 9311:}. E56 er 223229 haw
«..f%:5€;-ifziiiifiscé Eras; Eiié active 3 ? €fi€:'z1'_?l{S ~«~« a<::<::.:s€.{% and
. . E} E}?
,{.:é.sf’it.1″§§fis§:éS 9? {be same éOCEI¥,Ii”1€i’§’£S am zzxafkeé
rfisggéefivfiififi-.V.aS EXSPQ 3:0 E3*=*%%.’3 in sad’; csf SC: E”‘€$5.if3Z§I§,
195’? {}f §€f}{E?. Sings: {lief-:36 {fires appfiaig are
A T: “§1fii€§§: 1–“§}§; {iiff€§’€§;:i acczgsaai in ES §€a,§:E§/208?, iihag?
.. .,,<ia§S§:x:3$€;d :3?' $3? Ehig iiaizimazi, &':m:{§;g§:"§fin'€;.
K-4"'""""'
:3» Beard {he azguments 0f :§1'if,»?:;1'a'i=1s§VV'. A'
Si*iarasc}*:am§.ra, Réijklfiflai' mraéi E9: (3 {;Z§':c1i[L?3;2é.':–:{,: 4.:;§;§ "
Eeaimeii A{£v<::x<::at€:$ £"€§1'€iS€I'i'ifE3Iig:"'» _.fhé: V -..i'&f~:s';[;;:rf9:'::f?:i%.:.<:T .'
app@}&a.m.$ ~» a{ZC1lS€1{3 £341 33 £':§&':–$§: §3.p:p.;ééz}s Itf~;;Ef§_§§ 25:
K1 §%a:;<3a§§2?isi':Iia, the _iea:'§:€{%____Pi,.i.g§':._» CQLEEE. G<}vé<:i'1m':€::*1i:
Pieadm fa}? €116 i"€Sp{)I";*£{;§F::§33;, §§;};;:«g,t:<§';'- f3é?é:'i;:s€r:§ me. <2m;i:'<3
@rigi:1a§ I"€3{ZG§'{iS_3.§§ :§'i€:"5:5a";1«ii"-i€§é:.SSi{§'I:.V §5.~:i$<:3, xésiaisiz 3:25:
{3b'€f3i}.'3€€§ f:'js:)':;15""i__i':ié=;_f?3"'§a3,:{§§ it-}fi;.~.." if V
6' ir'i_t.a§f:{iTA" _Ea::1 '3§i €:§',–4 '.{;E:t_:€: gage ef the proseeatiain 21$
aiéagéid ?E«3§.?5:é._ fig-3§;";:3 f§§§€3};f'i'i":f§§€{§ §i:s§; am': mmgainant M
vigiim" $E*:a:':%;.:a:;*23;"9% ":3" €;}<m;{§§a S €:a§iI§'i,'s.* :<3;';s*g}:g Cémafaia <3?
. E'. in
{§:fiéE~§_g::{ asigiigggii, "§'ai::.%: 'E"E1ir*t.%':3§':ai§§§ §}i$i:'§4:::: $f':1§.:';1<3g& i5
1";%.$'-ia:1@22?:.
am. an :5.’?’.2Gfi’?§ ‘ashiifi ms €£}§1:_§3§.a§;:’ia.2″1?€.
.. g 32:33 hi3 famfiy §;’3{?i$§§.i§€f’$ ¥€§’€i”€i afiifififp 3:”; Eiheér
:’e$§d<i;t:'§:iaE 3193335 $2: 131% gaiaié 'SE1:-age? "€116
<:<}:f§1pEa:;:':;a;"n%;, E16932? -'E§{)§'§§,fif <:::':€ '§{I';<;C§<:iI1g the {i<::3:’ sf
‘§’::i$ ‘§::<:3:§$r:?: zméi, 3.3.; 'iéiaii E§§E'i€3, 'éigsrfi wag {K3
iiE::<:i;:"%{:fi.§;' §:3E3§L}"§}§}*' in '§§'ii?: _'::<::;:$s, '$15 ;;&:~.A4
aaxalites. One 9? than: thr6a_€.~::-inéfifi .
C(}fl}{;1,§EiiI1£iI”}’i\ hay pultting 21 ssmali gLLf€:~f,z.:=.:”
Arxaiher one gaixxted 113$ gxlii at’%:i:§'”cQ3::p§ai1V::af1f.fs
Sim, ‘Yhegi mid tha CQIHpi8?}E:l£§f}§. t§”1é*£;_.,t.%’:,},;. ”
fart; p&rs013.s in all “‘~QfEi1e2*s w£::fe° .g114::Si::§.& ‘fiifi
3:fl()EIiS€,
{b} 6}!’ the saié and the girl,
0:ié’ :na7i}:?. p=zé€?§’é§o:i’».:87;f:<:i :53} gr} Xfifiifit inside {E15
%':é;1_:$"<:3f, 'iE_1I'<.éé}::t.°;::€3*,'$'i€{~T.__xiiijfi " <:m§3Eai:1am:A’s Wife and
8M8§{{i*{i_ $163′ gr¢_§:;=..?z:””‘f,E:c”:1/1: 1:10:15}? 33},-égfag ‘£1333; 5’18
;::<,:s:1f;pE2;i:i:a:"§fi;' 'E-*a$'= daizag $119215}? iémciirzg i:::;$iI1533.
'- ':§'E3e:*:. Sfiid mé3:3é'"pe2'Ss:}§'1 and aha gifi S§1z~3;':;::.'£1€ci {E16
*V'¢§§;1::e§ah fmm the campia:ir;ant:'s W353 afid
h=–.£a:}ii' 'C%i:::.?;; ffem aimerah, & yair sf ear ¥;€aI'$, arse
g:3§.f:i:**3T:ig with rad 5:036; £1320 pairs (Ff siivez" $133113,
f§:V.::= '$§§v$r glassas, Que {i01i§§€ Ehreadeai gala Qhain
Awgfié 3335} Cafiii as? §'~:'i3.'?',{}{}{}f». fhe vaiuc <2}? 'aha 333:3?
gaidf and afivfir §:'::a.2:;.€:':£s ass-2&3 agspmxixiaéaiaiy
§<3g».
{:31 Afi this 335152 §;€.”;°$c3::$ ihreaiifiizaéii §;%3€~:
£@::19§z3;::1a;:T3§: $31232, if he i,,&:€:<:"%: ii} i:':§{::"::': Q16 §;:-
w%
abaut the said :incidez1*:, may would §{§§E—- i”:siAi:j:£’1–[ ‘
his fa:11i£3: members. They had discu£:::i:e_:Vr:ié:éi *:hc_
aiectricity suppiy and also t.s.;éiepI;::40:é;a*’«g:£i}f11i£%€:*£§{:».g§ f
the com;:iai13am:’s house at €§:1_at._1:in;e. yf.€’i’1£::3j=’ 2&f*’=:i17″”e V
holding at 53511311 gun (;3ié3f;§§i§.. _ar1d sgeaKiVr1;g ‘£«:Téifi.I12ida
Eanguaga. .’
7?’, As cauié be seen 1′:-“«<;§1[1f:, i:¥1e?~;.,¢h$5:'g€.s'Afra:ned against
the accusfid in zinc saiC{"'Sé::~;siQi'3$ {ha case of
prosecuiien 32%,'? amused 15305.1, 3 and
'E' resp;:_;:ij3zé;'£j_<,»%_V"' A' .*§§hivaraIna A<:i1a:*i,
Shivakiimar V' E? Shivanarada E~i'é:g<;i&
ctmapired t6g¢ther a:1{£._ " tzfézag the 3321:} €:GflSpiZ"'8.C}-'", they
_..Vggreed.§:§:a1': a;.§f”§§.?’2{}{}”? in Baiehafii viiiaga in orfisr
to §}.*T’Gif€ thiS–‘ j§9;%:t:1m of conspiracy, the pra$ec::’1ti0n has
‘ gjziacsd “1*$§;ia_z1 ce an _£i1{=: avicienea sf FW3 Lskasiég {ha 532″
§Eéfiés19,” Rayikumarg a §:::0§m*ac’zm* at Theerthahafii
Vsnkaieah, an agficutufisz 3:’: She Said ¥fi_§8;g€.
?W3 ieflkgfih hag Siataci in bis €Vi{§f3E1C€ ihaf. 0:1: 9:36
(Egg, 8i§.”20i§i a year g;::’iar {.5 E%’%.9,2{?{}8 {I313 {Eats sf his
W~
evi{i:3z’:c€§ whiiéz E16 was at {‘}£}IV§{I§§’1i E33232″ 335 §§afég;é3fix€%rE:«– *
{:§§.’1{.}’, acczased E\£as.2 and 3 zsjiz, _ §:3£*1i3;*é§E{t;2:rf:;314″‘ V’
“%£’ij&;y}m::;ar rzmzi £311′: ami, at 3:i’1:i;»1::; Qeciiséié
Shivajmmar Enid $21112 éifiiai. E:€:_ ‘1§g11tféti ‘<:a~;'* 3&1'
g0i:1gt«::a 13i'1ar:nasthala;_;and his
car. He has f12ri:h<~:r deV;;i'{;.:V:sA£:j:a'?£ éEf;g231:f:i'car%§§;.'}',g§%g«'s.fiierfiafier, at
abaut. 11.00 s;::,;":1~.,_. acgziiéiscff; fa" '€og$"€her irrsfi.
?%2’3a1:zgaIora }j>f1ar::2astF:aia,
the saici _a.C_.C;1f:’;2;e~;iéi {hag}: bad game wark at
Si3i1n0ga:;…g§:1–r:§ 43¢} gm, xarhazz {ha car
réiachfié fiféifiéxgéga 3_1:;{:2._; “€§’3{;:’:1 in <i'§3_z'1&s_§":
. gigs? 31$ :}f"§Ef1:%t:.r1;: Stagmd {here 33: that (Egg. Ha
V"Ef;&s.V§';:;*t}1<::§r~Agévstfiasfli ihai he aise stayed :11 {ha said
LQé'gii:':§ o:viti?:j:;:§..[:?fia3r and at abeut 5.36 am, 9:: 'Lbs? 315$;
'dag, iifiiizey fiva ascugaeé [A2 ta £6} retmfied £33
in his saié gar: 3% has f:,i:*{§2e:* {§;€§39SEi{§ {hat
531$ saié nighi, tiéefg hazi takfirg his (:3?
V ‘ ‘ . _ . SQH}€Wh€F€ in Shimagaa
ft!/*9-.,–r
ii}
9′ NW4 3 K Ravikumar hag Sigma in E113 etgiaigsizcsz
that 611 (me day at about 430 pm about 3 35638,?’
2i3,E%.:3{)€}é§ (the date 01′ his favigisncs) wlaiia h§_.;§V–a$: ~
Stepa £168.33′ TB Hespital in §3″‘I”1iI11<:rg2.'<1~£i.if,f;, gm s€§1i&*.-VI£~':<i{::1.:'f:§;&€E-,_V V
$10,? fikiivagxanda i-iegde
Shivaramachari, aiaxzgwitii i,§5%j1i:'d gm ta " '
each 0t:h-:31:
14%;}: ?’W5 Venkatesh i:1a$. ;s:.~at:::d} :.i:1″.hiS”‘§é:;*ide1’1ce that an
0:16 (£333: &bCé§7éV: .;2§ pfiagf to ;22.9.20<f}'8 ime flats sf 11:3
fividencé} Vat. abagéi £1, w%2i§.s: he 2%'-'as 21?'; the Bus
_ <3}? L""£'a;i§%_§g;{-:1}?-._ fiéiiiagé as ha wag €19 gs Ea
V. A_ '£'i";§Vf:1f:ifr*a.;§:_3§§::E.1i, 311$ "'TI§<8,"sa_'§3_'f'£,TvsC€,""-E.1S€{§ §*=é'::;.E Shi'varan1a::har§ am}
:¢:;fe::t::;3<%;15 V§4e.».j?–~.,S.hivara;::a Hegde mgeiher mmifig Eiisreg
"icaI_)."-5%; }.11::v{£*.s»’}5 pan. at Eagambe
V’ ‘ «fiéiiarad.
c:'”””‘-‘:2-“w””””*
‘LE
13.. {Hz ¢a:’6f’a11 reading 9:’ the above eviéence of
to 5, it caulci be seen that the said evidence <i€;eS._:i1:z§-5"?
any way estabiish that accused N0$; 1, -:i01g'é§i:';x¢:* =
cansgirad arid agreed betWeenV.tE1¢131séivé:: t11at,.2:§:'é:1:sec§.4 V'
NGSJE to E» sheuid czommiti:
fiuring {ha night; betwet;::1 °f– @307′
Since it is specifia ‘$33; of C31′, that
a1’13.n::<:used §\I_c*:..'2«.,§'-;1V3.';' 1A:A::*{_s: :§ iegjt a.m. and
reached csuld be no
Qccasi0r1: '-@732" ta 366 any 01" ihesa
accusad at }}'s.b;Cca;Si£::1»§e:§§: _\i’e:’1i<:ai:esh is see an}; of aceuged $03.2
is .563 yéiftftié 0%' Gujugoiii village at 11.8%} am,
'G31 £ha£~~:§&ft.eV aiang with accused Ema. E & 7' W '§'h=3ug,h it is
" éviéenca af E3§§?$.3 anfl 4 that they Saw accttsad.
E«%{_§$. 3 and :2 mgsthfir 2I:':§:§:1 3 thiré person, tbs "'§ri3§£
£33134: has fifiqifiifiéd amztuséfi E~éaf?§ Sf 2&1 the Qifences
Zlfiiifii" Ssctfmns §f3{1%{B7), 4485 335 and 427. Thig Easing
c…_§""*"'\//A
E2
239, E 83:11 af' {ha <:0:1$.iciere:£ opirzzian that the "i':'iaA%vV.i;':_;%:3:*t
cozizinitted serieus errsr in cauvictmg aC{:us3$:§.""}:§'£3:e;.–.f:: 'fig;
6 far {E16 (;fi%nc:€ Llncier S€<:i'.7:Q:'1 1263 ER: " '
3CC'L':8{i{i 1'i'os.1 to 6 ~– 'who grist; a.:3§)gii1a3;ift.s.' E353' E};-*1_::$:: .'
fE,i§3}fI}6.'«3}S; éese:-ve to be acqttittecg sf tghg-'said
3:2, '§'he mmpiaj;}.a::€:__£3as bee§ViA'*€:xé3::1in£5ci '3,S it is
110%: in {§§.S§'é§t.€§ that *.:fE*;€: T i:iC_id%::if.:t.4 . cie:r:_,oi%:y occurred
cizirégrag the 1'}ig§'}§v'§O_€f'€K¥if'3é1:3. fig» jug}; 233'; in
the reSids:11:i%;'§7EaVc:;3§é';¢ compiainarzt. It is aéso 110?;
in <iiSp11§fc.V_ €{:at'£§1ifi ri"g:_4iE3é'*sQi{i eiazeity, me {ie::@i?:.s task
away: f:£::s;m that A§ 11{:sé’ sf fix: sempiainmxi :»’::-aggm gaéké &
}$i:«3:£§é’:T of*;i;2fiia:1t$ and cash, As cmzid be saga ffflfll the
é..3;i;t§__evitiéyzcegiid ths stantzfirzis 35 212% said mmgaiainz, if
V VV _ ihé”i:0m.§3iaif:an€, has aiiagad in his said cgmplaimé: ihafs
3%” ‘.:3f;@ fifiuf parsans, “§’§’§’iG emterad mm big E61336? three
– §ss§e::9é§m;aIe perasns 311$ mm wm a giri, quite izzccnsistéizi.
” isfith ihis ailegatign, he has szatad in hm €Xa;’€fiif18${i0£E–
§:”;;~¢%1ir3f that. twa af’ them were maié persaag ami ‘£216
mw
other two were females. Bésidas {$113, {ha afiegations in
{$56 czemplaint. {EXP}; 3.115; file evidence cf PW .1
::;;uite cazzatmry :0 {ha charges Eevefled agains: ~
$333.2 :9 6 izzasmuch as? it ig st/3;_t@é.__§3″1 Ei: éK::”2*:%é3rg%:
the accused $633.2 :0 6 1.13. th:*eé14Am:§ie _*5£’*a;<§
8.(3Cl1Sf3C1 siémtered £1133 C0n1{:i:.v_””1.a:1t’S” §} 0t§$€f:’- {i’I;!_:1V’§iL1i”}v’g “the
said night and <:oIm:1itt.§:d rQAb¥:–2€iij;., _'§'hus§;, * €.h{€::£*é»: afises
serioug cieubt as to %:E1'e1mzf;:fi:)¢é:r V§0f: aCc1,1S€d W119 am
aii€ged.~'E;{}"§;1a$Jef: Ciiizimiiied 1'»:ibE:@1§;' in 1:316 campiaixianifs
11913.33. "
£_:%. E’: j£%’:r:% «.:-3&3; ” ‘£3223 g;>r(3s€cu?:'{>:{‘: $2133 ?¥%5E
._{:{m”iL_’;}iaj:}.a:;_t ‘ic£€}:’1ii§;3;s3:*”i Aacusaci fies 2 {G {>3 if: %:h@ ‘E?
L_pai”:a€§§: E3}-7 ?W1% Tkizzka Executive yfiafistrate
‘§he_ ¢o1:1p§ég:¥ia11§., fiasides smtixzg Er: his gramfgéajfit
<.,Ex,,?§,'~ 3:33 3333 sigiied in his aviéssiisa aha: tiierfi wag §:<:=
s¥..1§}p§§: in hi3 hfliififi {Ewing {ha said Ezigizqii
: %3¥'§}€Il {ha égczcidant acctirréd, Ha Ems §'1€%7€h6i"' avsyred in
V' §i?:éP,§ ga:i:'§3§ai§:a;z::*:: :20: has hi: géatfiii Er: E33 <"::r';::§::i%:":<:u.:”e:::3: sf }_igi1t in ms }’1{:~u§3<~:—- _?,i:':;;;i;"
iifllfi, '2§"ihe1"r:=i"o1's;. Ehfi identity of the a::cL1S¢{i..i:$;"~ 355.' "
me: '§'&I"}=" game pe:rs0:"::s, witm ei1_£t31fi%:£iA fii:'itQ" hig ";%'r;e:V)}:1s;€=, f
£im*i:1g the said night. 831i': -.{:.§:31":1'ii*xif '€t:<iV ézés
becefiae Sfiiifiufiif; »:im1b*§;'f"zfi i11z§.%{:3:n1V'3§i'<:?::_» t§i%;i:'$ was
1510 eiac:"£ri¢ity and ii":ef€i– §é; '%;<:§ the eifecf. tlrgai
!:her:*: was am; 33:9'-:1;'c@ $2:-ii' at ihéii tuna,
ihsye c0ui{_§_ _':€}§3%}§%§f:E1_%f}i§%f%; ijifif' V' to Qb$e1""s:'e L316:
p§'i:g'S}3;{3f'iiH A' '§§%:g~',;é:;:1s, £3£"E"3.fi aammiimd
§"'§’;>€;::”*§;’V”–;<;:§é :35; §:<"2 €G§'}"€C'{;}.j£ i£i€m'tif§: '$13111,
'§"§:i$ é'}_~f::§'§';g .€.E*;:: §.;ié:"£::i%§; <3? 2sC<:m;<:d ;'T**éa1xa.<:i6 muizi :15}? hays
-_jb%:<::*:';»;:<;:fé;::;:;}:és:§_E:§;; the 'i"r§;a} €j';&:.;1r:,
34[""— B€%'$idé5S tiaig, Ehazzgh it is aiiegaii in the cs1:';p'§a1€§1t
:Ei:'i£§,_ i§i "'_%_S ah:-ass iiepagrm bf; €316 c”:11p}a}.ma:’:t iii E233
{:&:i{i3€An<::€ Eéiai: {X38 sf fiie ;'§3€"E'$Ci§3S '€.E3};'€:a:e:1€{% his
2 '"$1§:e:*:;, *;:s.: zfifiziz-531:3 $}:1a€t:ch&si5 35%: Kay sf E316 z3.§:§_:&ra§’; ffzgm
MS *é5%_%’€§ :’:€ii.h€r 33$ i’E:§{}§’i :13: hiss ‘£’«2§.§E’: §””:::;S Ejéiefl iif>§Z3§?(E§}”i€3{§
@W
as wijmsss for {he ;3r0s@<:u.'{,i0:';. "_E'}:1e§; cozzid ___'?jj.é*;:*éé..'_é::.fsfi:_a:§:33:_
E3€:tt.er persoms ta ifi€I1tif.3:~' the aCcu§e{E as-'e:.':'1=:::"
1115116 afici fiamaie gsersoras, I2;-*§1o'».._'£0{;s14:..–:'az*g2g:;fg. ii'1"r3:;s.t{f-LL._§E'":e:;~
almerah {ha gaid 33:16! sflvervt:1*1€3;aI:3em<s§ 3:adTV';}§1.~:«;;..<;gTs,3:: of
§§sf?,{)G('}/ ~– a3 afiegezti the 'file Triafi
{hurt has East sight e§"5f;';i$
15. it :3 n0t:_”‘ii§’jA:€i:it§p;:§£’e “{‘¥{)%§LE;1’I’€d rabberfg in
the 1:191:56: gt’ diher Ezonseg in {ha
viciziiizg;-f: in azrdfir ta {:0m1€<:i':
a£:CuSe<i'?§_§3 . E i'i_’ r3%)b:::’}? E21 {E26
E’§G’E,iS€ ” 3%” ¥}’§=£;§j “$11 V’ {E16 gaéé data amt? €:’£§£.§€$ 33$:
‘ §?.7§}1éiE*i3Z.§§{‘E1{}”{i1.A”,§}.3S piaged raiiamca an {$16 §T’€3e’:0V€f’§€S cf
LE;:?;;:§§1’§:1″‘3§f’i,§<:}.éj;::;;" gash 311$ 3330 3611115: '1i"1eI'i1?I1§;3;T:3Ei}§1g
ar§i€;£esv-..':!5e'§:3:1"1giz1g ta {ha resyeciivé campiaiztaazzts in 33
}:ii:<.;:..fSt3SSiQi1s iffiasss, iii 33 {ha Case of mosectztiezg éilat.
éxiéfifé {if :he ggid antci sihzer QE'§"i8ji}€I".i'£S that was mbbai
V' H§}' 3:6 acsagaé in the respective Eiéuses of_'€:31:1p1a.'1:1a;1%:s
in 2'2}: $26 Séfiifl 32:21:' $€S$§;G§"1 C3865 izicézidimg Si':
»:~"—-(""'v'-…,…__
3%'
30.255/1290? were melted and goid and siivcir ingets
wera prepareai by the accused and i:I*1e1*6f*o:j:*~:1:.._ t?:f;€
resp:e<:t.ive complainants could 11:): have 0pp{;éf1*t¥.1isI_if:3§'__"';af§__%_
identify' 3}} the geld and siiver frQ1n
{hair respcéctiva hausess. it is f'2_1f:i1ér <:;«f~
grasecution that MS Nos. 14'[13.11:j'i 16 ;c:f=:?s;33ect3*§.?:eé,i;g§=L'Vgiifirar 8; *
gold ingets are the _sa,m6 x1;.hieE1_ afére got
prepared by {he acéu_xs$z:<.i j. _3:naz'1j: f tha
0rI1a:11(:’fiifsi”i1:§at €é§éf:eI1″»*w:’ ‘r§é’bbe<§ 'fri:11": the: 21011333 af the
respective €:o::1§3ia'i%:;:«§;fi Ea: .. . 4' M
£6, ,1": is '{fi.<:._ $}:2«&Secu§i<}§; Iihat {ha
. ware §§%é§af€£i $5; ?¥L§.1 vishmz §"a;*;;fi 3125:,
I ":'~:Viji":.zé:' Eflgat has; 13351"; mcevered by 238, {E13
Foiiae E::$'p§3;:i0r fzmiz $1313 ;3€1'$Q:1 sf accugeé N34 flizzash
V "::.§1V;:if§r.. gazichanaina EXPS in {ha pffififififié 0? pane};
W29 Safiiish ?00_§az"i am: MG Eéa. 25 geid izlgai has
~~§'3é€::: §'€{i'®'JfiI'€§§ Eiiidei" E3X.?8 panciiazzama by {he same
iii} in iihfi §fES€f£C6 53%' {Egg Sama parzzth {?W€§}§ fffiiii E318
c:–~v-…§N""""'""""=-»*
ii?
peI’s<3n cf acczised $0.13 Vijay Eiumar aiangxvith M03. 1?
to 19 respectively cash of 12.3% 1(},<){3£}/~ and Ewe
phorzes and aise MG Nofil pawn. rahit. far i1aVi_I;'g"§;ig§§.géix:2 _
the goici chain
1:2. PW11 Vishnu ?atil is said ;§::ax:e
$308.14 and M016 irltogs, Bé_ i':§:s sifiafczi.3111;E;i$fle2r%<§.€;;{1<:e = L'
that accused 1510.1 Shivfaram §:;§]/)…§~'§:§fii1J&;i.7f¢§1II1Ei'C'l§,1<E¥IfAi gzive him
gmki chain, ear W€3I'S é;:;;d[ W1 'fisjeighiilg about,
6} gra§_;1s._ :mVéi'i'-".2:2–iifé:2:j .,..1:1″:er siiazéi” , e’%:1a%.::§e33fis_.”i{§$a11y aveigixizzg abaut :2 ii’)
gr3I1″;S,_ &E1{§’4f1i’§f I’£1ff3.§’§{.€€.i’. Efié saié G}fi’13iB€I1Z$ mid §1’€par€:{1
” E*%¢:3;$.. if: resapecstiméy the Sfivsr & gaid
_i:€:g{_:r”::3A ‘3.’:ji1′::i..”‘%g;3’-:s;*¢ $16 same ta amused Na 1, if this
e’§£éd7€191cs'<§.5§5E*"§?';5'V1 1 £5 ac*{:€§*i€«:i§ it gees ta 8};"1{}"J€ {hat it 1%-fig
–V 3cc:;i:::a¢:’£?* _§*4f?::»; L wha gave him the: staian t*31″”I18fi§€E1€S§ £35;
. mf:§§,i:1g'”‘i%zi:§;<:§1, MG §'§aS.f:4 3% E6 i}T}.g€}'ES ("£81335 ':0 E16
_ A' gfaggéregi Egja Ffififii 3216 21% gave the same {:3 Accussd
E. if Ehai; was $0, 331$ 333$ %ng<3'?{.s s§':e':_1}d have §'}€€§f1
¢,—E-=–..§""*"-~–»~
racovered from the p€I'S{)I1 01; Gr at Em: i11s3'i;a:j1g::§__%' l=.j:.:_f'_,"
accused N0. 3. aniy. But mt: case ef £I1e_§;2rt3Sc§:ii¥ii<3:1 is"
"mat the said ingots cazne '£0 be:=.':r€c9§jeré<i .:1:f§is–}_:iéc;€§§zVc5§§;T f
Rom the person of accused N'<;s.3 3:12: *
18, it is pertinent if,a:}~.,;r1ot€«;AV'1i1"1::i: éi"c&:j_L1Sed"§*$10;A'i4 is not
aflegéd to have a<:c0mpa;ji:¢c'i'v'v.§§;cCu:§;€c?§_ ~V?§?<;~s.2 to 6, who
are alieged t05~v}:*1z":3.f§e– the houses of
the respsciive Said flats and time.
Besides ~–.(__)f the: siiver and goid ingots
does :19?” of the Si}??? 331$ goid
0I’I}{5¥$Ii€fiT=S said vi-L} have been mbbed from: 131% izougeg Qf
_r@$§::=3c£if§?’e. fizcmpiainaxits. “1’he:°r5:fa:*e, bassci 011 {ha
‘§f’t2§i.(;xr’e:;iI€’i§”_”g::i”A[§§.d’§} N03. 14 and :6 raspectiveiy ths siiver
3:1dugs;}1éV fiiéats it could not be hem? that the Said ingcxts
VA ‘.. »r::aW:j:{“i:’%;»é {Q be p:*€pared by melting mam? 0f the; orrzantgeflts
‘ éiiégsa ta ham ‘been mbbed by accusefi $30.2 tc: é {mm
the Emuses 9f the resyectiva canizpiaints. ‘E’heref:*€, E 31::
@f the CQ§1sid@i’es:i View {hat an 1116: basis 0f fsrsoveréafi €31?
¢:~*-~–~§”fi’fl\”*-“”‘
ES?
there ingots from the p€1″S{)I”i (}fACCl1S€d fies. 3 & 4, it
ssouid not bfi held that, either ascused No.1 :}:f..fi_§{:2§}~:;:£”
.1-
accused Nasws and 4 conimittad mb’beI*y in iiéixisaéf .
the eompiainam; in this case.
19. Insofar as SC Hc.255f20(§7
aiiegsd; in the camplaint ti1é_f§”‘e::. pair’-di’ -awzétrs, = L’
one goid rirzg with rad storm, Vsilfihar Eeg c£ia:i1<1.:rs, fiiie silver
glasses, (ma goki (:¥1a§ifi: sf %~2s.'?,()0O,!-
were fabbed . f'iu"C¥i"i'1_ '€}iEi._:3E£)¥;ifS€ af conzpiaimajls. Tfze
<:8n2pi3;i:1a5124:}A%i1aé' Gui}; EKG Ha,25 a pair {Bf
§i§E?€:1"§«{_§€ig {::E'1aii1'*S-v;a_._$___A¥:ET3_€ same '€Js:h%.::th ware Lakan awajg"
Vhisv 'im':u}s7e it is {E16 ease cf the prssemitiszl ma:
of sihser Eeg chain is iéiaiztififié by PW}
'.Veompuiai§1aI;;V'§ as the 331116 mbbeci arzicla. 6:1 sarefui
V' 'V~:%:*:€Eafdii:1g Caf ihg avidséncfi 0f ?'W 1} it maid ha saen that
§':¥ii2;I1e 0f {ha accused in SC; N0.2$E3/238? has Qiaifized
MG N035 Eeg shaiizss. Furtimr, it. is pmvad h}; the
prosesxiiion €313: Evié} $30.25 avers E'€€OV€I'€& by ?%?sf2€} ii}
r"
in the presefice of PW9 paach under thfi p3;I3L{§i:{i:§;’i?}:1i;£:«;§”‘
EX.P8. from the possessien 5f accugefi said: u
She has 1:191; given any expianaticyn ..5:0731s3wV”-ahéf-Ls§;a;;A
feund gossesgeci af’ the samr::’J.
20. Since the pra$é(:1a1tio_if’:’W§iz§§§. Vé?$;3:,abiisf17?€£i'” beyond
raasenabie {$013 bi. that ti-1e: s:é” Fig Wars tabbed
from {E16 house’ j;::i§-.1′ ‘£>fi;5J1i<:f=af1’1§,r»Téxj_3}a:;a,i:ia11 by accusad $330.6 as :9
hmv §s}”;e”‘aga11z::a ‘ f1:ti:,«::«~ ;§’§ss€s3i0I1 ef ‘aha Said stolen
_ i3FGp¥%§I’é;ji€fS§ it jig bf; half} Ehat she must flaws rczaaivad
.,;sa:;;§1s:a ‘fikagajmg that {hay were stcfian properties’
‘§’§é:*»€;f§re;.”;.: 0? the Qansidered View that. though the
p}:*3sé::Lifi0fi has :10: ‘men abizst to place an rmord an};
A C_’ *::1i:it::§i1i:1g evidence fer sannecthig accused N032 E0 6 1:0
‘ tige mmmitfing of mbbery in the hausfi ef PW} riuring
the said night, thfi I”€C{}’§F€I’j§ af M0 E’=&’o.2.3 ieg chains fmm
‘aim pGSS€SSiOE1 Q1’ agcugeé $9.6 An1’bii{a gieariy gsaes ta
g°”‘~—«(q””””*==~.._..»-..
3%
s§1e:}w thaf. sshe committed an cififencfiz u:z’3.{ie:’ section 411
cf IPG. This bezirzg SQ, accuséid $103.} to 6 ci€s:i’I*%._»”5_ 3:1
ardfir, acquittifig {ham 31E, of ithuii {)f3’€éI1C€~”:$’ i;:;£”i{‘a:£:éI’;4
Sefrciiergs 395 and $48 :93, but. a{:i'”‘{fz’1«~:-?: &’fiT<%:j:r:é"*;::_,'$41
EEPC,
Far the reasons aforesai&L«, }t':r}.A .N0s .:22_vi'3I fiied V
133-' 3::::u$€:ci N03,'; :3 'agiéi fiiaii H%?}j§?"Vve:::<:1:s<:¢:1
E358, E. riifizl' £-':§é'$?s:';v{:$:} {'§§,S€:_ §€§§f}2;3:3_:}'Vi2'€i}G'? are hereby afiewefi.
The i1z;§§%:§.*3em?i<_':'Eim1. am':
senmzscae as§;£e;d§' 2:2.;1.29fii§§ gasseé Ea sg §€o.25§f2%§'? %:sf§
°fijati"Ei?a’1~.,.§gaE;;’»a; .§§1 1’e$§:§.’E:.€$ Ea ceiawisiizgiz Qf accuseszji E’€@$,§ Ea E}
{Sf {$216 v_{3§i?é.;f:?€A§es HEEQEE” Saciicma 12%; 395 and 443 §?€
“a:’1:% E335… éaié aacussd am hemby acquittefi 3:” %:é1::=: gaié
_ ?:;§§%::°é;€i€$.
VA §?’2;:ri§”:er, 621$ !§o.S4§23$9 ffisd $35; aizeizusfiéi. §*€s3′{‘;
V§:’§§ZE”€’….g%i’i1§3§§{fl $3 aiiaswefi in part, T216: aim §;%..1.g:r:fi:’§
C””°-=«<.€m°'\"'"'*\,®.-.-
Judgmant and Grder {If eonvictioza and 3611:3306 insofar
as it i”€ia{€S to her cariszictian for the <3fii3n0e$:;'~.§i11Cie:'
Sectiona I208, 395 and 4-48 IPC is hemby ~
she £3 acquitted 6f the said ofi?eni: <:s.. __I~:{o1x.%'c:'i% e'1*,'AT %5f;ir:£':'.<~:%, sh<:_ V'
is feamd guilty of an Qifemse undé: §3;é_CVi:iOIiTT
is canvicted for the same. Eafing réga1;fd~:Q'hei'i.;ég€ find
Qther facts sf U15 sage, S113?—1-Si"Sf3.i}3;€I1C€a"ii? Lizaderge
figarous irnp:isanm€nt :1:ar'tw'9V f§y§5:ar's'–v tixxee months.
As on fhiéviiaigaf if ' t1N*:_ijS;*.,é_,'c:c*;1,.a<§Vd? V§=§.6 Smtfiznbika has
aireadj; <:.:1:§3Ee£r%;;cVif’ of isnprismninerit far two
years ;1?;1§f §§Ti2f’i”$ rxmnfiés ézzfi, if sht: is 119?: rfiquiraé is 3:6
‘ “‘:.i*,..é:«t,a”E.%1éée:i-.”*;f,r: ‘é:Qz1n{=;cti53§1 with 3:1}? athsr case, $316 shafl be
u’:%:…€’i ai fkirrihgzifil.
_ giii; “”_¥’he;: i,fi:’j§u§1eé ardezr izisofar as it rélates £0 thfi
. “;ii;i$;;g:.$ai%f’ Material éjfibjecia: is left madisturbéé. if my
.’_éTé’;€i£;««% afi1@:1r3t has hem: {iegogiiiaé by any 3?’ {ha aceugcfi
” 1 :0 5 ihemizl, in cempiiance with {he iznpugzed
arder Sf Sfiiiifififlfi gassed by $216 Triaji {imam the Saiflfi
Shag bfi refunéad ti: tbs respeéttiva ascused.
.««—»….C”\”~r’\______’_”I”
5?} A (:91); Qf thig Qrcier Shafl ha Sent f9:”ti:tx%:i€§i”‘ _
Trial (;’§{)”€3.:”€. 311$ aim to the SL;p€1fiflt€$i§€I}£;” »§jZ::::t:ra.§_
Prisca, Baiigalore fer iI1f1.é_z3.;3b:;:T,T f
Grigina} 0:” this judgmerii: p£a(:§:tc_i A fizz” L
;’?€0.257/2899 and 9; cap}; tiieféaf in” €§1fE.3%,_’E§§<37$} 874' 'V
$28 of 2{){L}9£
bkm .