3″‘ ”
,p
EN THE: EEEGH CCEURT (3? E~{ARN_R’i’A§§E. A’? BANGAL{;}§i§.
§fi{§”E{) ‘{“HE$ ‘;*m: 32% gAY Q? NGVEMBER ;2:<::z;:9V:'__'__%-
BE§3'()E~?.E
"i'i~iE §§{)l'€'BLE rxai§2..;L:s*§IcE:;'§§é2§L; ..:é';ac:A§Q§;–
CRIR§IFiA.§. A.P?EAL 1:03.253, zézgafin sskbfif 2&of§.f.., "
B*E'i'E5JE;E:N:
in ::§€L,M~I<3,25sj2:::::§i" _
Sshivazamagéj Shiva:'~31}f_j:a Asfsifiézii. _ _ ~
Sit": ?sfm1katarm£ir:2£"[r'i€hafi. i A V
Ekgad abeut 35_.y.:'g;s 'V __ .
Residing at: TE;a§iz.;25″a,n.g§:ii ‘
T:1::~:ha11a1:;3fa3m; 2, _ _
Shmlaga ?)ist:*i;”;*L.. 5._ _ 3. &?PE:LLAE€’F
{By Mf 3, E>ié:e=V.<a}3<a:~a' &. 'és'siss;';";§{:'xé:s.}
E32; '::§e.L,A. m,g2 if géeg
. 'S.:i;'$h12t3§§:1:Lqéz".sgs,"E Shiva
–.Si«:> V%:6:€2§} haiféf€*:iah
Ag€d.VaE)0:11:’ 33 iy€a1’$
1%} at fixmaggr, Eiaiappa Eiock
-V Bangaiéxicg ‘
_, .. . , lSi”i.§{%i§a&§Vr’H. iéiumar zifé figay
* $3 :3 Fifigamj
2′:-zgslézi’ 32301;? :24 yamrs
Rfat Maflivaia
-~§%.*ia}12.r ‘E’ai:,1i{, Esieiar Qist,
Sri..E}§.:1&sh Rajmh
Si 0 Thimmcgotvéa
flged abcsut 2? years
R,’ at Srirampar
ii-fiarrzgaisrag
Nativf: of Eflshwaraiiaéii
Naar iialfiapura
iihigtiimagalur Sim.
4; §{'uma3:'i Vijayaiakshmi Vijaya
{Bio Basavaiingappa J b
Aged a'hut :23 }'£if:lI'3 V' '
R} at Chikkabasavannakoppa
- Vitto Nagar, i{.R;Pu1:*am _ A ~ '~
Bangaifira. * '.-._. AE3i3EE;L;$;f{-3%fS$
(By s;m.M.sharass cshandm, Agar.) A'
in cm-.A,NQ.85;200~3.. "j;~ _
Ambfiia B] G Basalglaagagwpa 3'
Ageé about 25 years fir ' -L _
Rasisiiiilg at Chji{Ké;b3Qs..:¢:S.?:3i1akQ}§;3_a '
Vetto Nagarg ¥<I..E~'_',.¥3"--.%:_:1V*:.~:2m ' '
Banga1Qf€_vVv . . ' . 'I ' ":':I:;:' ' K!
£83-= 8fi.T¢s«Mahmst€éfi%s* %
ARE):
State {}i°~§§ia;f§:ata}{3§ Regjgfsgeixtéd
" AV B39? f§§1ii'f}T1E:L}:i'a}li ..;P9Zi<:E:
.i3h§;mQ'ga 533.353 V _ ., §E«S?0?§f)f§NT
(COMMGE £3'? Eiii IQAPPERL-S]
{By Matjagag %§'€G§3'}
” <The;sé Criminal fippfiais am filed ufléer sectim :3?4{;2) 31'
«.$'rx_P'..{3. :pra§*ing fa' 'set asida the judgment af conviction and
._5}:;11'a–;e:ici€: dazed 2§,1§QE%€}§5 pagsaé by fiiifi $€$Si{::I13 Judge; E"Z'C;–§,
Shimaga in SwCuF%E€;.25§i§$QG?' convicfifrag the appafiantf acczmeé
–._ E’€sX3 ‘£0 3 and accugfiteri Zfiiofi
mspacfiveiy am sfimteizcsfi ice tmderga R}, few 5 f;’E8I’$i ésezid to gm}; .3
fine ef R3,:-;g9:3@;’ – in éafauit af }§3}”;I}1€§fii fE1I”?h€3;’ he ghaii unziargg
Si» Em’ 6 fi1(3fL}{fi§§ for {he {sffencfi pf 21;’ 3. EQEHEL 53:9,.
‘M”%
‘§’hes<: Eippealg (romilxg on £231' %"§€2';i1'.§13§ {Ens iiajg, 1:36'? ileum:
maiifi the fii02s:’§:1g:
.§E§§§;_GE%§i*3§i’i’
“E’i’}.&§:?: fl’}3.’f:{:’ éirimixzai A§pE:a3s have aliserz §1fi(:3::3.’ .tE:s.;~:L. é.§E?£;E’¥f}fi3
Jififiigillfiifi and {_}rd€;:” Of {,’G1’1ViC’ii{3B Kfiéaieai. 2§.3.;23§§. :§3.’e§.tS;:5é:iv.”‘_;§1}.’V’
$.C§3’%’c>.25$;’2€Jfi’?’ by the F933: “E’:”a§~;§ C,§51ii”‘:’;i’,. b
‘:’é:ib:r.*r€:s:E E0 as ‘Trial Court’ 133:’ S}}{§§’§I:E. V’i’Qi:é:E_l§«-‘ aevén. accz.,a.S§;:;i’~v;é::'{:
}:a:’g€~§}’.1€€t€{i ii”: {he Said} $:’:~Ss}T.i;>_:i”‘~t::a-18:: for 3.;-E-‘EC ¥:>ffi::i€E€isss uI1€i€f
Sézaétiezw }.2{}-£%, 448 emd 3~’§?? 5 0f 1&3.-. ‘;”#11 ‘%h€: se£%&:1…g13:’:E§§:sp%%:jV§ézti@:é._’xiii'{he Gm} E3’i.%’i{i€i’Ii{§€ sf PWs.1
is 2:, :i1a”g:s::.:::mm3«:.:;; *;:~’;”%, §$3;.§,,, §.i ta 946 am: §¥§as.1 is 33, me
‘T§:?22i £1{‘:2_i::”1;., its’ Juiigmérzi éfilii Qriiézéig acquittefi.
‘Va¢;efi$€::§§”‘¢§*§€%_§-5? Efiz, B;}%L–§§§.:iVat:zi:i{§a E-ifigiisi, Eat camiriateé 2’£€T(3EZ$i3{.’§
§é’Q55.z §; ‘ §£3j%E$..V4io§’ ‘?.§i€ -. §;}§i§:E1{f€’:S unéfiz’ $&:cfi.:::11::; .352{}~B, 323:3 Qiid 43518
§E3€f ‘a:15{§LA gfiiizéiiztééi {Exam it} u§1{i€:”ga:> RE far 3 giééiifirti {pf iive },»’S€5J’§
313$ .£ifi{: z9§” ;E€ s§,f55i}G{}f ~» Ear the efiancs :..m{ier Secfion. §’£Q~B sz:*”§’£;§1
V’ §:§£:£’$§1:;i§- ._$ra::1i:a:;2& fif SE far six marithsg RE far a pegiad cf 116:1 f{€HIS
af §$efi£}§B€§fi; « wiih siafauii. s€z:§’5::{‘::: 9? Si far a grtiréad $1″
“~fZ:.V3f.1 x’f;” jgsar far Ehfi aiiffisncs: Lifliifiz’ flegrzien. 3%?) §§3€f; anti: E33; fin” six
u fi;€;EEE:$ fer §.§”ifi {:«i§’.e3;z3.C€: Eiiiiliifii” Sfi{?E’§i(}?£E @538 EPS,
1%. €:°§§&aE’i@.3§§§§ £5 fiisiifi. E3}; :»:§a:”:<?:;z$::{§ ?€<:s:€§s3 §?§»é:§$§§$§fiB§v_3;§§
$32 §'sé,’2 {<3 z:%;§':{.'§ $;*Egg%,i§§$;2§$§§§ ééa §E§.§:%{§ Es};
«:t"-~—£"""*-*–»–~«»~
W4"
accustd N9, 1 in {ha Séiftii $.C¢§3-63.236/’28fi’7′, A31 H1636 acétufifid and
actczzs-sari Pém? Silivagziz-aiifia iiegde {WE10 13 a{:;;11itf$:i).§§ét:;§é;T.§_isc>
ffifid by the samize Triai C0311: if: SC 3:35.254; 235 M
far ths sama ofléxzces in mspfict 0f difiEmr3:…i:ic:;£1éfit3 ir1i%a’–‘:u
occuxmd {Eating the sagne, night beixsfgéen: i§f3″ :a;1%§_’i_;%3,i::~;
239?? , 4 1 ' V A ' 4. The Trig} aaurz. e£%i'§;i&Vé<:& af
f)I’0S€C1}J;i(}1’i aaviirxesges V _3}iV Safiaien Cases
Separateijg *::haug}:_1V …’%,§§§E except PW}.
mmpiainalitg and the re$pf:<:1:;i¥;e
*a:i%:n6s3es…§1a:sse {fii€$?}L'}§'}.S:€i;i{_ é;s ¥.:::: the same set of facts in aéé 'aha
casas. 'F_ha:s,,_ %.':LE3$ ?2%:I9§é'4V.A$;*3:f;i§;"é§?it:1esses have E36611 fixafliilifiii
_fs:s:* 'me ,;:~:"':7as<;'~:ci}2%_:§_. GI1-g-3:3 Fwéfifi ta 21 in 3}} fiche fzmr Sassiaris
"C3s&s'éi'1dA—Lihéiir fividéiiaé in afl 'am 53368 is ifienticai. £3 thfi
::i;c::um e:::s have been 1:1a¥°k€é as Em..P2 ma ?4& in
393' ;z;aa.% 2s»a1;':;*.¢6%VV+V%{§:: Emmet Whe:*@@f' £Z:rZ.!%';. $33.33, :23? am
256 §§__:2§§f}§ §:§i.~ai?€ fiafin fiiasi by the I'§S§3€:€:'{i"i?€ aggpsséiarxés ~
'~..,._a!::f.g:u8€§}" cartifiefi cagiés af the 831316 §0c11311€:i¥;5 gm
:§i&:i;ké:§..'r€specti¥€§§ 53$ §L?:»:3.§3"2 ta £346 in €36}: cf SC'; ?~é'a$.:2$f§,
Q5'? {sf 2€}{}?'. Sirsrzsa 'mega {Eras 8§}§}€8iS am fiiagé by
C
dii'f%:r$1'1t accxiseii 311 SC ;?'~k2.25é§/221337,, Lhe:};' «ffifipfisfififi. sf $33:
3:13 {:(}fi1I}"i{}f} ~.§'i1€ig{Ii{"3§1i.
:3.
Heard the argumeats of Sriyuths M S£1amsch,a51:d1*a3
Eéajkumar and R G Chouhagis, the iearned. Acivecates ré:3§r’c::;é:€.:i”t§11g
the reagecfiive appeiiants, ~ accused in ail {E1636 a§1J::;é:aMi&*2T:V§*£:w#:i
Sr: ‘Jijaya Kuznar 5/iajagag the 1eam1€5E”‘”§~figh ‘iicxéémimétzi. «
Pieaciezr far the respandaxzt ~ State. .}”eri:;*_$€’ai tiié: é;–3_”§:ii”:
rezzords in 2111 the said 85331011 Casgsi whiéh 31»? _0i5$:a1Lt”” é3′{iV Vfzém this
Tria} (hurt,
6,
;§[ta€e;€I:.x£fi; §:f1*i$f«ih€.._éa$e .317.’ me }Qi’0S€{‘:3}{iGI3 as aiiagezi. in
§;x¢PT£ <:am:p'ia}.:1§7 ' fiiéif" ~}, <:omp}iai1"1::m§. -« victim W
"§Z§L}.S3é1'§;§f;.;éaa§1;. $2; £'7?§:£a1'1§1a'V'§a§z;1(§it£a1a3 msidemi. {if Saifihafii zfiliaga,
V""'.£'§":.ir"E€A§3:a}ilaa§i, Shémsga is as i}.IE{§€Z"Z
«6::7";:;v;41,";*~§'::g§a? at abeut 8.39 gm, ma <:Qm}:21a.i:1aJ:"1't,, mg
f}3'3:"fiE1;¥:i;:"35,A his eiéifil' Sistm' $m§,E§ha§hik3}.a, 831 mask: their
AA Eéfi am.
meals and then, want :0 sissy. Afitzr midgight, at about
an 7i§,’?I2{Z1€C§’?, G16 compiamaifi. hearé.
ffinmebeiiy Cafiing him by iakizig his game from smtsiaia
%§
Ens hangs, Thamfbmg E18 wake 2.19 and vszmaiiz is gwi%:<%i1 9:;
the Eight biii found 1%: riaticeé that fizsszt was 1:23
a1ac'{rici':.'§; $ug:s§3§}:
W355: E35 3%: kerésssne 33333:», héfi fathm: smpfiziefi itiiis zttaaizz
ziziai’, {W6 mafia gemans aaé twa fémaia prerscns isgeiher
C*~$
€f§17i.§f1″€€;§ itfio firm house and caught hesid cf {E16
(tflsmpimiixazlt, maqia mm 1:0 31%: 351 ms .h{)i1f:’-26′ h§;.é;E1.{3\i2i11g
gm: at him£ ‘E’h€:j.-7 said mat: may wen: §’J3x:1ii’i;-zJ:.€§’;_V.”‘5if§3e
twfi festmaie gemaxzs tizmatsned comp}airég9i:t§:é_’ jj :1J__{c;–‘:’.§f1£:iv
and p’.€”€SSL1I’iS€d her to give {ham nzonegzigiiii {}3:ff1af§fl€IiiS’.VV
Being aiiaici «:3? mam, “the y;fz:i¢’pi:ai;t1;?;:;£f:=; :1irg?i1ef ‘gé3;:ze
{hem the key sf the aimerahfié'”£’3″§gé:;a’th?;:e._aé:i{;i
gfiersczns Gpéflfiii flit: aimejrah aixfi ‘wok ff:r*i3″:'{; 3 Sf.
Ear ‘wfiar, {:iI’},OT}.’l€Z’ paif”:=2czr u§é?{§””Ai7;?:§{}Tig§I”IE;é? ta $3/ze
Chiftireng Qfie ga§d..C}:ain icgf’§§fig?é».§?1:rsa.€iZ’ ring with
rear? fzavafa, £09; firigééj ESQ €,’§’.:»’,§é§#3,;§’&;-_V$v3T.(A:;:,”,;~.fifihfij’ iagk fmm the
pockat of £113 <:9::1pVIgi:3,:§:3§§iV_€§:z%si1":3f' ,1 ~ giser, After
<:0:.m31ittj33g r@bb€:jv, £6121' ypctrsmzs {ixzwfiatsnfici
t%i(é"'r:<3:3;i;§}:«1iii§2';:i;E '"E'h;%£t if E:§r;:*"\a%23rc: ta iniézm the Paiice er
$3.213 3'1eig,hhséf:;:f s1; ._t}.1éf–,:A ;'=m§i;3i:::a:1t 322:1 members 0f his
§am3;;% wcxiiiéi §{‘$’–‘»,”AfV’r;’.§§i’)’.§.’w3.’:”,% ‘?£i'{;§ d€~:at.'{L
§§ ‘§”‘§5:e s”:_::r?::i;’v ;;§::’3z:m–;a- EH’:-::*e waaxting }:aa::;§ 52133:: anzi ugerkin
énii §A’%mj§V’?é:s:”§§___;:3;ii. gpfiaiéing i~:Za11:1a::ia iaggizagfi ami Wars
f§Z%€?:fi§:’i3’i;?’€£i’I}; ;2{} 321% 30 yearg. Whiie Efiavmg {has
housfi, they snatchsé fmm, the
‘V«€:0vn&1§’§a§i’i§§;a£nt his mabiie pfzone 3%? 3:30. Ths 22231116: <3? afi
ané sfiver ornaments that was rgfifiefi 'wjg file
fggur §}€E"'S:§0Z1S was ahem §%S.é{}_,G{}0,s!~2 T315 saifi
'jpar§;@:2$ Egefzr ix: Ehfi s:':0mpEaina:::t'3 image: 1f_}I3;€ gzsamgaixiet
H aigcx '§'%1~:: zjempiamant amuizfi 3¥de:1Eifj_,: {hrs gaéaé parssens'
'E"E.1€1*eaf:er, fix': :;*:t31:=*;r E16333}; §C§GEiS€S alga.
?, £3 <Z"=f3ifi{§ Em 3:333 fE'{}K1 ¥3:.:::'-: chargfis f:'a::}<:<.§ Qigéifiéifii
Em? 2%.{.'<'::5é:%<§. $3': '§;§'.:s::: §;£«1é(§ §'.§ffS=':§i€}§.'§. ifiméséz figs €I'Ei§i-sf? {if §'.}§'€};'$E{I."2§."Ef§{§§'§ £3
éhaft 0:2 15%.7?.;2§}€}'?, .:ssc<::nge:% Nczsg 1, 3 anti '2' i'€:S§3€:{?'EiV€i}»' Sizivaram
Sh:Va'2fm3:2.a ,5§§?.§1ari, E§1:i*¢::s}{11I11aN:b Shiva zmai 3 Sisgfiagizigacia
Hsgtie;-: ctaizggjmzeé tcigfifixm' 3351:} {iuxézug {ha saiigi c03§;:é'§f§ir¢éz.§:t§«f, "'{._%_7g:":j;
agrfifid that ae::cus<:tc£ 3193.2 15:: ii Shscztlizi (3G£n:fli.'§i.«-»€i_%i§€;§'1§}V:% an tEic:, ‘1.K.:”_f’,(L’3-.f§1T{Li\3§;:H3i§},i:§3
faaéitzm 01″‘ c0::s;§3i1;”acj§;, Eilfif pragacmiiaaxi 1133 p’£a{:_§” a }?€i§’j; .’:§33f1§_&EvT!:’£’.”§{} ._:’ié*..<_9.f3£}{)8 §E;E3:= (Eats vi" his sivésgimaitteg
E-%?3}i§.§."'. ht: 'g¥3:§ at: if}:2:';::{iE;.§' ~E['i«i::;:.::5;':*'«%.T:'.i E£§a1":.ga.§<:sr€ {7;i'::j;, ac<;%':;Se:<;i §'€<::s:;,;.Z
éuzd 3 ;?é::a*… fiiiifiaégaimaz" éésiiziv "§='.%.}5a}F_§~;1:.:;fia:" ma': him ;4':i3":é.L at mat.
{i:1j;€:3 :é§;?{::';;;§:é£ 4'T%3»:3,2§ E§hiv;a:§<§11iEa3' miii iitim iiiai hi? 27'£€i{1§'.{*fi{'} if; mrfi ii
<'_£3;' _gi;§;1g.Vi£;a§§i?;a3°::::::$i%1aia aZ':{i§i %"%E?:§ agrfiftsii {.0 givf: Ehtziii iais
§:<:.a::'~,~. §~E{ér1%:.92:s'_§*;?;:"%;§::é:' siizpassgséi Elia: izzga {Eggs thereaiiar? :95: atmui,
_§1,{}€§ ::::..:m,..3_;',2§«:%e"::'£i1ss:;%$;2 Ea é Eagetimr igfi Bangaiauz: if: his car
‘ §fi'{‘§.? an E;§1:E_.*%*a:§ E9 §}h8l’fli3;$’§§1§3}Ei§ ‘figs Said; a::={?’::st:*{§ iaiéi him the}:
._%§:é;4jg,haii_« 5:91:26 ‘i7’é’OZ’§<; 8;? Sfiiiémizga 312:3. ?_23.é3';;"€§<3z'€ 221%: aésmzt ~'~'%.3{} fgxm,
__ "2»"x;ET:€1?; 23:6 2"e:a<i:%:€{§ §§§2..é3+31{3g.2: .:é:.::::f.%. *é.:E1a:-:3; Emaii 3 13532311: Er: Géflléai;
"~L«:§;igi:'1gi {<?5§',§{"§ 83 if iiaiizu s'£a§='é3{§ €.%':€.rf: 9:1 §'.§"1£?':E' aiafg. B :3 E'2.£«:a§; Jfiiifiéfif
%iii*§3<'::s;€:% ':§3:.»:%' EH': zjzigi} séiézfméi gt; E,;';i.:.? séiiaé .§;s:.1su§.’ ;?}J%€.’} :/E=;:§:}>< 533:3 '€§"§.%ff :':&:<:'€. :.§:.z:'_%1 55:2; iézsi: fiwi :'%a'%<*:;§e§%{§ {$3 353 ;%{éf;
e:"°*=«"°"""'~M'
«;:rs:sm:nii':4 -:§ac<:si§y at Efiaiehalii ssiilage c}J.3.ri11g thee Eiighi: %::[é'€.2s;€€11
3.4%}; mad E.iSi'3'1 $131}: 239?. Si11<:€ 31: is iépecific say .'
driver of aha Car, that. 3}}; acesuseii §\I'c3s;,2 is E: 1ei't."'-Sz"11fi.:_g;aa;:ié":::¥3T' V'
£1.88 3,31, am} Itiachfiéi Shimoga at 4${f§CiV '§§,y.31A_,
{3CC3.SiGI1 §:".):{' PW4 Ravikumar {:3 see a"51§; –_(3f iihesét ';2:r:fi’»:1::r P§}if§”‘J€’1i:k3E€Sh 11:3
see an}-* sfif a£ZfCElS€Z{‘§ N932 ‘iii; é1~?:v.ii;jE$ae S’t*.:?:3;1fi af Gujugaili
Villags at-, 1 1,{}{} a.mg :;n ihgzitéatéfi Vgviflxvféécussfi. N93} 3% ?«
fiaozzgh it is %:;§:’_: *% thaf $1133’ saw gccused
N03} 311:? Z7 tgfiégttfifzer ivitizé :is:.._thir&- person, file ‘”E”‘:ia1 ficrsuri hag
aéfqtliiiifiii ;_*u::r.:?’s:’1;1$~r:”:€i é:i§ ££:»fi*”0§%%:’:c::2§ uncicr Sagtiéczzis 3.;£’;i}{§%};
448? 1 %}:”‘§.;::nd <-'%i£'?. 'E'}1i:~"s iieizzg $0} E 3111 of §.§%1:f: €;§(}11S,iE§€*.1'€{§_ <3;;33?:1i@:.s.
E335 n{j<mf:« "é:;é¥mmiti{:d $a:'féo'us €E"§'€}F in ztemgiciiixg
.:=;1}:'::;_s}.?5;€}gii"' T§€:é$5'f§.. ':;«:a fifjvi' {Em igfiiezgce Ugfiliifili" Seciiazz lfilifi EEK)
' VV " §"§(i:'1t€'f'€',_. 8:;'§§ E}V:<:";§§:§»::1§};3es.i §ig:;&ais, é-egéerve :3 he acqaitteé of the $ai& affeace.
V’ * ..E file scgkmpiaizxam E2331 E363: $§~I3;I3.§_Z1€§ in $313 said
VM ‘=S=;*e3s31§3::$ figs: as §3″ée” 3.. fi$ Cfiiiifli has Sffififéi fi’e:}H§ 33133 avigiezimg 3&6
f€i”{fi’§E3f={i”id in his €i”=J§€§€X}<Z€ E216 324336 iaeis aééagzzzé in hi3
(I:€}1LE§}§_é"iE§}§ agi %3I;x.§3'E. $3 to the iéentity af {E16 a<:<"rz.18::’§.2$, :%;*E”;0 €?.'{}il}§’l’,E§§§£{‘§, ;’:>%>§:€::}? {isxiiyag é:.E’::3’E. gigégizi ht: Ems;
::%;E:»-:%<.=<.§ $1. %::§<:~'; €:'E5§f§€"§'%i"'€? $3,323; an: Eé'vEg8E€Efib? E22? 'isrzéiarzz 12.; };.-«':.";§ 3:;
fl_
-33-
pa:”£i<:1?g3atcé ii: 'E'€rS*:. idsniification parades While}: v;;z~:$ C0:::.im:?§:ti(i in
the pI'€'£EiiS€S 3'33' 1116 faiufia Exectitive §iIagi$t1*ate.V TE~i'éT..Vh21s
fE2«..;{'ihf3i" Sta ted £1'; his evidence that he ide:1tiiied.;""':}1ré.:~:::__I:
zaccvusegi 331$ Eva iénxaifi aitcuststzi 131 this T' E p3I':'€1f31ii'…, _ V * V'
iii Tile acizargc againai the accussd §_;{1T':}}1e E"-age :§;:z__ that,
an {ha said ziatfi 331$ tima, all: the aéi:;:_,£$eri F-§¢'S.A.:'; jg_;V3 ?i2:._, 9
Shivakumar Shiva, Vfijay E{';zm::;:f'V4 .;g;'ag,":}i::'é's.h Rajash,
Vija};aiaks§1mi Vijaya' ifiitspassed into the
rcsidfintiai imuse Qf' PW 1 CQfi:fl}.§3i3;:i:].€i:Rt,':V~CQifi;mi{f€£i rgbbtsry.
'E'i1us it is m§Ea}’:1’E. that it was we female pztmens W219 thmatazzsfi file
‘1’r1;9i}:er sf ma ctaziiggiaizmni, smatcizsd thfi kg}: 0:’ the aimerah agzé
100%: $316 Séijlii geigi and siivm” Gmagnezats {mm {Em aimaiah’
§°—=57\””””*/
_§1¢.
14. it is p€.rt;iI1€11t :53 210% mat the C{3111§}§§.EiiI1é211Z’?3 bsyjztiier
has met ham: cxaminéd as; 03:: efthe 13I.’€’3S€{311ii0I1 ‘sx;?i'{;t1;€:s3:;e:.s’ ii’: the
hu$e at that iime. She ccmlé hava been {£16 bé?§;:er j;;¢is;é:;
idenfify the accused (‘$03.5 and 6 as ;fi1€ Sé:’;3′;_fi€’f; t\>m::.j;i2€;;:r1eét1 ‘xx?ki.<3
{mark from her kg}; of the almarahjand f1:§t:i"_'§a;20k »t.}'1 _.':f go},c.1
armaments frcm it Fmmer, it is 'vfiiefe W35
:20 eiectxicity 51119131}? and; :;pj:cor::§ViiigA. cofipiaégxéant, 1513 hit
only 3. kerosmze E33113. Tijéifiz-g did net.
have gufiicient .. feamreg at' {£16
persons, who these factg, i am (3%
am: (3t§}§$,V__E§’€ 3 Cfimpiamz hag giatfizci in his aasizicrice
~.*;hé:;’i”f it _wai§VA.;es11xy–..Vfsur wmeas, {mm maie arid {W0 femaie, W110
‘e;ré’;3§;2:;$$eaZ’» :”‘§_1}%te3m;§iair;ag;t’:;i§.§i€ns ta haw identified 33 the accused $03.2 :0 6
” i_;;:«:z.,A fsva §:t:3*;s0ns as flag cuiprits. Themibm, i am ef the fmihar
igipx’i;*gi(;::j’:’A.f£ha€£ {ha ‘friai Qatari East sight sf {his asptct Sf this cam
K %?;fi’;i.iiz§: rmezfimg éia finééiig that {ha pmsacuiiofi hag pfI'{“.3¥’€fi its
” _ :<:a$€ againsi 3.3 mg a::':cuse3.:§ :9 6 far the ($311963 zgrmer
Ssciierls 443 and 395 9f
153, in mzier fig conaéct accaseé Eric»: :43 5 xi;-*i.fi1 €316
=:::;2::1:3:aiéi.§.11g <21' rs:«§b€1"}-=* in thii 1:;<;1:$s 9%" {E16 cr{:»11:§':"iai;1::2:2_;:::?'_: "s1i’~.t}1e
zeiaizti date &Z”.id fiifiii’, the §1″0S£3{311i’iC}I} héifi piaced 1*e1i,£3″:1%:*<:.' '§§1._té
I'{fi{?(}i?€I'i€f§ 91' stoma a1*t:i{%'ies, cash and saméév' ~-i:j2gc:*§i::.1h:;1ii11g""
mticitzs heriongmg {C2 fiche: ffifipfifitivfit c@m,_g3ia;'i113;:}s_ts';_§f.;-i§"§fig }:;:¢;s1i.Se:r23.”i:i01: that mazxy 9f the gabifi a:a:3<_:§j;%ie Egelzsfis 0%'
c6mpi:5s3i:1a:1t.s 3311 aii the 13:3:-'_ir §§.€7S3.i_m:_1"'«f'3as€$ §;I}<:.1u:’:iam£,3:§S’ :.§.§’£Z¥;§}:;v1?:;iVZ’iV”—f}’iC{1I1 their rasysctiva hguses; It is
1326 fm”€E1€:r %:§;§é’v Q}f.”.§)1}?i3$é:€?'{};'{;i£3£1 that .M{} i’\E:::«s._%;4 and 16
*’;?E$p€cVi’.2K§:::£”:1y__T$i;§’§;e1′ & igs::§.:§…i::go{s are 1&5 S.*£%3Ei,€ §_I}g{E?.S, which was
Végcgt’ 3f§f€,}§zfaf~:r Eran:
V persazg §;§a<::::us€:*i Féafl Efiinégh mxdez' ihfi pancizanama E:xi,I%'8
$1 13:6 garegfinzzté efggancix viz. §3"*»?£§ $aEh§$§1 §5'0<::ja;'§ 331$ Miii} ?'§{IL15.l.:}
ggié égzgzzzt hag bean i°€:€f.'G'§'€i§'fi';'d5 uzigigir E«§<:=,§'$ _§£mc%sz::':ama §'_'§}=' 'fiizgi
fiams Eé} ix: EEK? ;}§'€i:§:i=.tm:::;=, <3?" Efimi SEEIEEQ ';'}:-ami": {§3ii§i}§§ frazgzz '{.§'.§€?
<.W..4r""~*"'-»»-
»E5~
pzargzrszz 0%.” ».’:3.£’-§.”i1i~§{E§’i §’é0.i§ ‘gijay Eéumaz’ aizaxzggvsiiiz i’s.e’i{}s; 2?.-~–:Q ii}
1″{i§;psE:<:7%:iv€:i§;* Casi: &1. if this €Vi{i€I}.€:{3
_ –. 3 . V.
af $2911 is §»’:5?_,€)$§._f}’§i€::i’,. §:*«Vgas;:§«.._::: igkzcfiw t.E’1£»:i ii wag a{:z:7’u$fi{i E’§«3.E,
§%?§YA{.} ga*_;<:i" §}i1§1 ii}; s§.§.§:§E€::1?: {}E'.E}.?£i_"{fl€§1§S, mésliimg wE1§i.3 :0 ‘ix: §repz§:”€& Elrjg FWEE and $6 gave
§€<:;. .1. E? that. veszas $9, iéie gaiii imgets Shifiiifi;
hays £3.33}; }?Gf,?§§§g*€I’Eid fmm ‘£216 §3€:;:.8<:a§1 GE', 5.3:' at $16 §z1Sta:1<::€ GE;
-‘gggczaséd §\§.yE is ram afiggrizi
ta: .§;L:¢:zé’€ :§ ;a’i%$§:>§;:<?ii*J§: {f:'j:£:'§§}EE£iFTE£iE§E1S
.. fgéf-
{:51 131$ saisi eziate and. izimca Besiciss thi$, {ha We:gE1I <;:ffi1:: S-fl3;e'r
2331:: gala? éngets zines fiat $333: wifij. 'ilhfi weight cf {ha §iii}4§:*:- A'
gfikd 0r:1aments saici ti) have 13323:: rmfibezd from $116: has
"$63 'iii? uth;e* : "
res ectivs cam iaizxanta, Tlxereilara, ba:aé<:§; 1:3:r1 €16 ;fc€:«;;:néir:1;i<%$".<:V.;;V:_f€g'::z;:A:;r:r}; V'::~§?"'::§1ci;E§11g * L'
35113113; 0:" the emamezzts to «?::aw% _:bé'€n_ Ff)£Z)§5€3\'I§.,.I:}:§,r:§€£C£f11S6d
E§:::.;?; E0 é fitom the 'hQ11§é$ 'fif §§C»€iV& compiaiixta
'E'h£:r5f%:n"€:§ i am thé basis': Q»
iE{?O'€3€i'i€S *€}f§§1E~T'é p'€ir*é§Lc ,::§V Q$gGCfiS€d N03. is': & 43
it sank': 110:'"§33%:'v his" 3 0:" 3313-' sf Ei€C'£1$fi€i
'§€0s.:% and —iii '€116 house; <3? "she. <:emp§3§.1::an':
in $15 cage,
Téflsigiggix fi1fiVv'§'§i{';§0:f°§=i*:€3':;§§i{}13~ 3133 net. heart. ahia 133 pmare
E3é§%;;h:t {ha charge };.ev:~:’§£eé against $11: accugezti
Eéefig €03: 8:18 ssffanesg zmfier Section 395 read wiih
” §§éi:%f;ia:: «::sf?;¥3C and aiso tbs fihargm Eimsaiiad ageing: agtcusezii
é fer ‘ihfi §_fi§f€:::c€$ Eiilfiflf Seciziems-. 448 33231 ;’f’~?§S Qf {PETE
.i§§1e;V:::; mad. wig}: Sesctéiszm 1-2&8 sf 1’93: it is estahiisheé 33; aka
grasamatiaoa besra-nfi rtaastxnafie éauhi that 353$ 3932 me mabiie sat
3:-aiirsiggmg ta iéjifé fa c{:=m§:iai§12mi Caflllfi is 13:: recmzemé E3? §>’§!’i?:€}
Em:€$§’T:ga’:.é§2g i§§:’ii{:€:’ {mi}; €316 §3m*3€.>:1 cf é£i€f'{?E’§_Sfi€.’§ $33.2 mniim” EEK:
§;:§.:1.(:§1a:1a§z1a. §f::3<:,§}E§ ii} aha §§E'€:S€'£1{:€ 9:; §*'€£ 9 §§8.E1{f§}.. figs 383:":
ex-_*-C""'""~'""'
-§hf§w
mohiiae SEE has hem: }1<'i<:z':§3'fié:{i '£33,; §""*Jé E as {ha SE18 Eyzzizyzzgigzg {§)i1:€’*::§§;»?.. V”ThA.;1s’L- u
is zéiaar 22333:, he gsassesgeri {ha Saiii m-::§:;.iiet 1§€§eé.’3k::C§\>ip._g §tu£:§’*§;.é?
s”E:;:ie::1 €iI”€i{“fii’f, ‘E”h€1’t:f€:s}:”€, I 311: <}f"__£i1a¢ gpi_"cz.ie3I:.. §Eié3_3:., 'v£;_fm.z:g;E§. tE'1i§;- '
azzcusezi ?~é0.2 gizégexvas to $36 a<t£;:1_i_tiL=$:§,_c;f\_aii _:3i'£€é:_fi3:es Lixztim
Sacifiszk 12€}»»B, 395 31133 4-485" i_¥:'?£; ifgif; vié $9 be C011.v31<'.f£.e:ti $91'
the 012231106 :.m.:i€:1" §§€:s:1.f170r: 4:E;i"a3f"::E'§3{Z; " K
E3231' me 1fe«a.~€€»gns5AIj:é;gi'§r3r'es: is;i&fi; §§peai fécméfifi ef' 269%
{ffieii hy A;–;m:.;as: §V'€':;§..VE;j¥._v§ae;3.::§i."»'.1_if5 gas? {fiiisci 33:; Aemsea saga} are
aiieweé €5iE}.{§ i.§;:;.€: i1!;§;:::;§::&<i" ;§':,i€§,g.m€nt am': {}:"ii€:' sf S€:3§;'1€€§1i3fi tiaieti
;?,E,§.:Z€j§€§€?' p;1$$&::1$ C386 ?§G;.i.E§€§f:;Z€3:fi’? E3}: the E3-‘agi
‘V’.§V’z”aé::fz}: $5: asiiifi §’*'”é_;:”‘§hz;’§§§é3Z%v:v£}fTfi§§§ iiieé by éifftfiiififid E? @3413; “:9 $ in {$153 gsiizi
V V’ t’°”§ess1?.9:’;a«:$ aiioweé in gartg
. AA iii} Ziixfi accusagi $333.1 :0 5 ax: h$:I:*(=:i*:§; a=f§'”€*;::_:<V7rév..”:::m:i giziitjg {if an
“<3§E%:;1<:€, Lmiisr Ssgftéam 4}} {if £§?'C_§ he is Erisirrsiiisgi <:m':'a»*:{f{::i."i fin" éitm
samsx §"'£av:'33§ rfigard E53 hig aggié ami {2'§iI'if:7£" Eiiffffi {'3}? Egitw: saga; 316 £23
;<;:zz1:%:.:~:§';:;'%:e;"E ii} a:m:§,<=::'g’a:s Emgfiiifiiififiiifiii f{3’§”‘ twa yearg fifié
“”~
ifireg menths £61″ ‘£319 saieri 0f£%:§1:=: F533 03.’; ‘i,11iS’% aims, if 611$ &§.{.'{‘?'{iS€2(‘§
i”$~:;g2 has z4i11’€:a{iy cgémpiaizéti. {Em pm*i0<i of :i1:{3p1'i%t:3Im:.:1t. :.ib,r"–§é¥*
}:’€Z%§2″S aifkd E’b;£1:=::: n:1{:a3i2fi1sa and, he i3 E1633: rv:q’a1:i3;”t:i”i__–:,~;x bé
31:1 €_’,0I}11€(‘.ti{)I1 with 5:11}? Gfijifil’ case, §ha§}_7 .fb”€” “Sift. éif ‘§;§E3t;.§°faj§””»
fzsymxvith .
{ii§§ /§~vf},£3 iinyzxzgrxtci Gfdfif’ fi£sQ§§}:.ag :”e=>1§%11;«:=:.é V5{Vi,3*.’Vr’:Ts;:§)¢:;sg-:’;V}nV
Qt” Materiai {‘}’i}§Ec’:i:3 in iizevsazigri E’-3«¢A:a~.%éi§e\»,:%%3§5’r§ $3533 isfi «E€:}%’ iiiiififiiflfbfifl.
if 3113: :fi3:1e amaurzt has Qf {ha acctzssizgi
Séos, E. to 6 i§1€r&é::1.,, éi’:_ u Efiipugned Qfdfii’ sf
sczénéemzs passtfgi’ sggzzgcg $1131} fie refuiacieaii {:13
the res$p€,{5–:§;V$._ a:>c7i::}*;£::i. .1 V’ ‘ M
€19′? «ea; €:§§§?.T?’ x}i” §§1,%.sv%?.§f§~????£’;..’L’$i1ai1 E33 fififli. Ei’s:”EE§.W:§If: {<3 this: '§'1'iaE
_..{'..7'l0m": .:2;:j;(§ 43330 3:2; "1';;§<25_ Efizipsiiigziazlfiiatii sf 933303, §§a31galG:'r:%, §.I:31'
'§:::i?{z:f:::1: ‘3n:i é:é{} mpE:a11€ffiy ifkyigmai 0%’ thig _§iIifigfli{‘fZH. siiaii ha
pié%:;!i€i’ -.__.§:1 258 gig QGEEQ am”: a (:<3p32' iihsreef "ii:
' s::;~2.fi;,:«é'fgs";:;2§: "gig 85 a§2{}{3§,
sd/~
JUDGE
'~.,é::.?~éPsrE§~»