High Court Karnataka High Court

Shobha W/O Srishail Shirangar @ … vs The New India Assurance Co Ltd on 24 September, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Shobha W/O Srishail Shirangar @ … vs The New India Assurance Co Ltd on 24 September, 2008
Author: K L G.Ramesh


THE Hmmm m%1′;ms’.:?$c;:§§,%}m£;At,?¥g9: £3?

W “§’.€>{§E=”: 1§~i§{j%}~§ {fi{§>E.EE92’i’ <3-;§:* ai»§:.A%:2NA*:'Am_' .
:;;:t§;m';:z;s':'-*1' E3§3?'é{;§§%–?£ AT <:s~E.:2;Ea,£xT::a$?»’3’i flay af _

E»’r:3sa.<::i§%;

wag; gawflm gm a§;.»:§°%3*Im ” L 3 ”

. 1′ SH

M:E:~:{E~.s’£V}

i”~:’:é:m==’.?€::»z::3;’;: A

S%1W:;z?;.:«2,gj§,~ ..s§g<':€.*i §f§*:8.a":3,
§3'_y.A 'N f fl';'3§_;3€:§§f%iI1il T3. '

T _E%;%E~zn;3ée.={§;«;z?§;:':;s.:t}"g3:3. Si1iv':~1;};1:=,:~1

V. §§'§7?§§ :3; Jiiaiié.

V V §”:£’$_fw§72iL£j” gi, Age: 612 j,»’e3z”:2:”3,
:T?–..<'::: 2 ;<:§:.:as.=,é,a':.::5::~;,

.Ra:»§.C1é1a'2».=w 3, W ,2' <3 }'v'EIaaE1.a<:ii3va_g7:;3:=:

" §%=§.?;1.im:;'1ggaar Haiii
* iismrzaaaggi, Ag;2,'a:-zzi J63?' j»,«"e€:zam,.

C3-titvti : E'{{)u3:’-;h<3.§.d :m:sr3z«:.;

Ail arc? 1′:::si{Ei.ng;j, mt. §r’2,1Ci1a§3u:* £39111},

Maflhadwax’ Rauaiéi, §~”§€.::~3i;ie):1 §%’f:32:~1r3,
Bijagmx’, §)§~5§’:ri<:€: : Bijzapm'.

}3’J

. (£§’;;§§}§3%3i3.3é3AI1.’:.i-5

in?

333;’ €;~’i:’i.I.*325i’::3 ii? E\:§£:1:.ag13:ie;i.a,, A.d.v.,’}

Ami: ._

‘.i’.1f1s: .”i’~$€:w §:fze:%§a A:a;:a:1;:;::anz:e £343. Lt:§.,”–.

}’:§a=s1′:a11z:e:;Ei’2<:'i:i:y E,%ui.Li<'iiI1g, "

(3-u:*'Lak:':M.:§ §%E0;«:<:§., 3135133133', _  .     --
}i}i:°si';1"i<:'i. : EE§§§:e3;:mr, u    'X,_-§"3f25}3§i3{}}"1di3X'3'§1

{E339 Sri .92. 'S. E§,$;3"9a}.E§.g 3' A

‘.1′}f:§3 3511}.S(I€i’3;§E2i’3t3OE,1’§ “”Zv”=””V.:fi’«:§A’; f”§§”;§’§;fJ6Z?.’§V’_iE’.§ “§7§£e:t(‘i u.m:3.«:-“:1″ S, }’?i%{ 3}
:31′ Mi?’ Act; ag:,a.i§7;’=5:: 1_:§7;.c j §_Ea§ss«:€*.s:i in 3% ;?V«4e§3 ;”;3{}<3_4 (334.31 if} .§§3.éVr:s:%' ms: §}§z~;:£;z°iCt «.3'w;igé:,
"§.\a»'.§e:m.b<:°::;, §§:§f§;§b233;a.fL;-.-tf,V"p;§§f£13r–.baiiarswmg §;§:1c :::”£:i’%.ia:m
fur <.:<.:m;apamsa€.i013.;_.a11d. _s@aki::;g_e:'1h;2a:aC€:*m::;a*;§: mi' §::1§-saiixgsriz
Wt’:£:Ei:. 1?’s°*}i;”:7(.:;?:::’i:*j::::-:.’t”‘fl: V

‘§;’LE’=2_7§.S’ }j§;’Eiss::3li};;~1″:v;’1fi:i:’;1_§%§T’TA.3?§’f§§31.’i5s’J; Appaaéi a::)::3:3.1′;g :’:>.zT;. far a1′.::i fins:
,’i’3:231{2’W§.3:1§:« , ‘ 7

“= ‘E’§”.:iS’V–%:;>f:€:ai is “i;>y {he E;§,sfi£:s:fi wi§;§:’:

j their %;:j{i7:2? hf; ‘i’*JEA.%II3’§T¥L£’x!, E;%ija’53§.13* iii: 2i’vE’v'”(?3 3\§’z;,:«2é’%2 {£1.34 in

.. :é;*v=.’é’:a:1j<§iz1g ‘a:1’§;><.%:;'1sa€;I:.m1 as?" 3;3$.§,5{},'C}C3§}f ~~ <s.

2. 1%<:{:@1'(ii2':g; to %.E°';sx:': <':iai1i11:g~:m;.s, <.:m :£Z'.i;33.;;%E.i.i1a«r§» w'.§:1§1z:t fjéfm

{§.5;*.er.::e:zm::r.:i §%"3§11';:'~sE"1z3.§i exgatcié ai3<2»m.. §_;J1'(3€’:ij§..i1″i§’; aim

-a -«Iuuau-vtIvvUIlnV?vfi’I\fF’l. amend!» ‘

ism’:

Elia ‘FE/’$ ZTi1()3;{3£'{itf§*’Ii?}€3 bx:-:m’i:ng§ E\§}:’:s¢§;%: a;::m33;’a.<:E .,m_, .23 §i:’L:<:k .–;}t:?3£%§"§_3g':§.g.:.

;' :3{)9£Es {':éii_{l§€.Tfi :€:'3*{:sm p;g3s:;r:-:.it’s:2 cii;rs=:<_:?;i.z31} in .;i'a-:ié~;'%?;~;} .:f;;;ia<i" :t1f§.::gVi§i;g;€:1'i2.A.'

:i::;3%:z1'mE::' amxfij (Em-;3m5r<;': "airs T§:371€: ds:2c.:::=,*::;§,2-:§:t'a;"i, u
%rg'§'m"§§;;

i’:’éta¥:,:Eng thz,-1%’: éihrz <iéa<:r«:é;;:.sc:’§:§é”s:i:”:.;:;;;:’§t;:fir::j£< ma;"11:facm.r='§::";g
.E<:i..i.1'1s, S'§3«f.',¥Z{1E3 <:::'1;;.sE'::?§:3:=::*,V– zg;£1<3; v§-;':*:a'._Iv:,:;"}i:'°..c:23s.«::.i'*:.a;E§}~' m;::"'2_m1ng
§§§.(§i§€353§'1WE£E1 and s'L1'g;§;;;Ej§«'i:3g %;:<2s
{§}£3w::"z%'111;ae;1E;;V <3s;211E1":1:':&t(3:"s sagmé wzzsse;
gzattfiiaé aazfi :'9%s.E§ §akE::~3 and am -.:~3..(:<:<::1%m%: 0? hm
:1:':t§:11fiIj2',' dziaiifi i:'1'&r;3zaz";3.'%3.§:3 .§{)i:?s$, £:;:1e <,:iai2t:1

_;x:*:'2:i'2T;§;:2».,t1 1w;:s3"§T:.Zi€:<'i;' "'E'"Iz":é: Tr£§;s:.ma.§. 1":.::1*az§n§; ;m;~,:<3 '3;i§;?s:–1.*é;. i.§:}.<~:: .:«:~.::<':iflz:*:*1?;

– iiiiéi: §:éi;:..§:..%;.az’€:. :11?’ $3365: <:i;:*i.w=:r' <m:+;:»a"i;§.<:z.§:'; }%12*,a:v§;:1g,'

:':i.;»f;§:3£§ ~i;3":..t»i«2__Eff Aj'..'i1§;1fi =.i."fL':1i'fi1;'§I}.'ii5-3 havti: "mas: j,I}I'€3{T§,"L§{3€i{.§ £€i}"13i z:%:2g~;;s:vi(§::iia.a::_=?3- rc:gz–:2:*diz1g Eihfis igaczzzvma 11:? am: <;i»::<:§::*ém€:;L i'3()'%%£?'£;t'V{i?i'
a?::sa_kif:";:g irmtsc; <3€}3T}$}§(3.ffi}"£3?§.f;{fi§'1 am: :§'a:13.§1y b:~3(:§«::gg;a'z;%.;z§1,~:i'E :–:-"£215 V$:§<"':<:

1§ai:2_.u'*§: of '§:.:us;:é.;":<:~,s3:~; {:z:z.:*riet§ ouni; 7§.3§{ifl§_.§ 'mz: E.1"§£7c".f1,§}ff$.i'3 0%' Kim

{ic:::€.”;3,.i”.3€iL3£j3,7m pit? am”:’L;..:’;;2. ai’3:e:” {f’i€:d:1a:§.%:’;g 2;,’ 32%-

tmxxac-raz*d:: pszrsmsaai :€:;~:.pra%:”;:a.é:s; iixaté; e2w.:a1*ci<'~:e:i 1:2 'i".€C}.'£'£:fi :€~:m;_:"3 <33"
'tssf

,. .. -..- -.— o -uww-mu war auumx we itflwhfiflfiflfiflflfi ?'§l'§-35"? kn-;'a3E5fi;§

¥3,5€”},¥()£_’3i3j–. E3e3:§z::g .z’1m; e:~.:a€_i5;fi.<a2d. 1%/'i'i'§T': i'..i'3{":f V' Elm':
<:§.ai:nm"ats zmis §:asi"'<3:"<3 fl1i:°'.'~.1 fiij':0u::*tL.

P
L.

*1′. .%§a:a1″c§é,

P
…j,2-.

. E4; is 1;§’:.«:e uiI€iE§€:. of ilgzatn :35; g3:–::::*
§’:’és::<:%'ija');:':«. 1€§3{a} mi" '3£ii"§€Vff§}*§:.':';f :;1:u3§;:Z'g3'£i::%z* :V..:.;;;£’:TE;
51:; .’i1;:wfi i’3€=f:”Z’3ii% t’£,.%..;1¥/3}’; 933:: inCz’>m€ ma?’ é§.a.r::
d4s:a;=.c:a.s::~:d. s.»sj§:?=3_%::4 at i~?3s.$,{‘}i’},€Z2i}£;3j~» 33>:-_”:.:*
z@:::1;:’n;zm. zafrszzi in mi-.<izM1;; 'i';h::*t §.3.'1€3{}'2";"I€i'3
z3;:":;3[y Rs;_?3€f};.if%{}{}§:st::E»_a%f;;n*au.:;, wiaiazh i3 mi: :g~3gw:1"§=-* §.{}'§»W3i' 5-;3,s;i.«::

..fw::=<::*<i§:':g;1fy :=::<f::.'2.;w2,?}:A2;'€;. 1??c:a:"" i%:j:E3:ii1";cexzm1i:'§;.

. ' Pé£?+cz3$1’a, 3:316: §3:>3z”11&%d C{}En1ZTi€~}f33. fifii’ ma’: ;{‘s€iS}i3»zT}m”?;?afC}Effi3{“:$.~-

ii11;?e’1<::'{§sV%;§:;.:z3';E'i:t¢3z:é meat EH1»: e:ie3:i:zua::.".:%:s;: E';a.1;m beszczza :g;2Wm"<fEc3af§.

-:%~:ai.;§4§:abija!- im:;o <:=::a:t:zs;'icic::'zat:;s;3a': aha'-3 '§£iIi'1§3.§? ba::}{g;;r1z:a3£i <::§'

ms: d.%:é:§%}:;1*5:e{?E ever} in the zflra:-3m;"15 a;:agg;m”2€ ;f3r<t:f mi" :5:;':::*':1izi1g2;

'. ;md'''Ai.E':i:; .i:~; :30? 3. ctasse iiitn" iifl'£h&3i'E,<'2€3.iTi'§E21111.

)/h/

W"-W'-' –'wen vwwwwm W3 !n9*'BU&.!i'i£J"9&9"&F§£"8« 5"'5§§§'§"3 LUUKE

{jg

6. in 1.33:: iigjzt of .’C}”.§.ff.% ::urgumé:::”ai..:~3- «C-1£3’V£i1i’}(:f:{§,, i:%”–:§%’ pé:3«§;:§:.._”&:E’1::s£.
‘2m;mi<ii .m:§.$<3 f<:21"* «:::<:s;:zsi=:£6:*za.§.i.th€:* ‘§;’£’:*..-fit7<:§aié:§;.;éé;;'2%.;E:"'

f;'fi';{EL§E}.t3(§. ifaz" f37fi"l§7i¢':§.'§1{36EZE"}\tE33'"i§ <'.:«§' f.'I?(}£1'.'s ;;§~::1sai;ix311.'? '

"3'. A3 is x"1::;t;ie::.:f:<i, z.a.E."é:§1<3;fig§.§*:….§;§3a
Ezritziz ma11L:fi%;:, but @111 Km:
(§{}Ci,§’§”.§”i€3<I}'iiS $t£'§,3:'IlCi ii"; §E:32'.-%;i7:a:$:¢§§ iamzd 'i'.E'::.4:: c:};;si::;§;;;a:.;t.:-;
hava p:"()::.?%;mit::=::E mgjsi " exact §.z'1<:m:::E: 53.3?"
¥L§'_'3.f'i s:i%.::{:e::«1:f:~*.;:i%{*;, aS$§:$f~;1:3e:11t.. 31:: iijéiaéa
a?3s:::a§;t:_V§:'§g'=.. mE»;<:::1 imp ctc;11s5i{i.@r2";1"€x?<m
:t:§*;':.§:%"«v«.::jii:*"':@:_a:«:*;"-.<::z"i i':avimg;' :'£:gz:mf£ to h;§s:: femiiijsi
§3ackg,;;r'm.':;{i<iA in cmrying 0:33: §;n;:.§si:1<::-;~:~3 emrzi by

5::3k;::'1gg_§::is Ii'1'(I_€3iI}f': art Rs. 1:"f:i}»Tf£{}Uf~ 336:' 2:12:15; zagmi a.Vt;:rag»::

e':§i","«._§%S,5§{3QG[ m ;3:3;1' momih, z:»1f{.m* decitactizag ET,!f;%='<1

. '€;:'.':e'*';"a1"£:$.1"s';T§'§:f3?'« éawxgwamsss ?}:§F appijgiziagg; am :+3.§::;7a1'«m”{j.s3 30535; mi”

AA<iT€:;3z;%1t:£%é:11arj,*. .Ap:au:1:. frmzz that t:'v<'::=r: 0:7; 'itisf: imad <91" E0553 of
" mf€}{}j ~ £1523 ‘%3e:=.e:1 z§:a7:%:’c§;e:<§ axaei a110t%;ais£*

___}§=3s5¢13i3,ij3fZ}£3,!– is"; ezvm.r::?.::<fi '§:0w'2:wd:~:~:. 103$; 03'" {3i('3}'i1S€'3§."'£iL1131 a.t1<f'i

§?»?:3u;'§:,£Z3-i')ij3,«'~~ i.am-'e22;;°<:i::§ fi;§1."i€ii°€:"§_§ {EX§3€i1"EE§€.',&§. Elvsm 0.271 fiat:

{Z{}£1L'€3i}?3(§i"§£§.§ heaiis, -3:315: e::Ti.«<:».g:a:z.;»,§13;':::~; fzzzzvaf 3C?P€fi':£'1 awm'*<ic':¢'3,

32""

. ,.., W g…..,.v.»’.’..»…….__.A-;u §.;§.”‘,mmn:umxm:mM mm-2 adwuru us” manwmaaax nuurz sauna; ur mxmasam fiauw LUHRE ur mmweamaaax-3 r-an.-ma 2.

6%

s;1.:§§i<:§m1§.33?. in me (:i:*<:u;msm1"zi:§;t::’z§:%£:». 2:33;” 7a1’:§;

::z::.=gg::::m: 43vi{%.€1″1a;~<:: 'j£.3I'(}{§ uegzeafi aim re:::(:s3fe:E, Wfi ck: i1€}E' fi'i1(i..§3§:"}§} "~:;¢fi€31t1:%:~.

"Ea iz';i:£:rfer{-2 vviigh ilhffi aw'ard. 'gaaafiseaii .};§j$'v'*J1{3'Ti7'E*\§"§')i.§,V;f':£éEi*;?' V'

!%<:<:m'{i§;"'a 5:, 2'i§)§'}€3é§.§ iI$::.§f3§it:zni:é;S'r-_:r§V,

.. ."….,,,,, –

335;},