High Court Karnataka High Court

Shri M H Neglur vs M Balasubramaniam on 12 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Shri M H Neglur vs M Balasubramaniam on 12 December, 2008
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit


– …-gm.

” “f’.’-<'V:'-0"! vs euwnsumamaww NEW" MWUK! LN' KRKNAIRKA HEQEH CQURY <

I}! TI-E HIGH COURT OF KARNRTAIQ AT

namn mm mm 12:}; may or ascmza 2'£1':e§_' _'

PR.ESE1~1'1'

THE HON'BLE HR. 9.9. nxnaxaaaa,AcHififf¢us&:cs< x

AND
THE HGN'BLE Mm.JusT:¢£_v;é._5A§Hafi:T~~'

wax? vmrxrxu'u¢.119$3§éaoa,genécsnefiay

BETWEEN:

sxnr. n.H. Nmsnvggvsia 3.3; Nflfihfifi, j
A689 AEOUT 73iyzaRa,.’.’; ‘.1«V “W
‘G09fi§ARI’.€SiTE”HGg 14;~’=.”.’

19” mm, anynaaga aAnn’sa.~r,.. ;.

Murvan NaGA3,*aauEAaoa;as4 “~~~” … 9ET1TI9″ER

tagger: G} K3;¢nfiam§r§ny, Anvacate)

BN3:

__H.BAL&$3BflAKANifiH;

,f’3!0 hA@E,MAH;KvAM’§ILLAI, HAJGR,
‘»CDHTRA¢TOR,,3RI. VINARAKA ENGIflEERING

zyuusvazzs a suzpaxxc, conrncwoas, T” caess,
age, £xTR;}cH:fRA9UaeA~57?591 … RESPOHBENT

-9-a–e–e~

AA T’:’his.I…”wxit patiticun is filed under Artialas 226
‘ and 227 91 the Constitution of India praying ta
i&.*gs%.:sn’_,wz-it, order or direction in the nature at

-.§:ri*t restoring the §1’Xa’PEJ’}’.r£o.1G!2fit}8 on the £119 of
T”–the Karnataka State Consumer Disputes Radrnssal
‘n, Bangalare etc.

..-..-»..m..« –‘r-uuuva ‘Wm

wt-urIaI.muJII”%rMPul\l”E mnlunm wwwnn Ml!” NRKEIMWMWM FQHEWI1 MUUKE ‘.3? <

This writ petition warning on for prelimfiuary
hearing this day, 333}-{A1-{I'I' J., passed', 'the
£a.';.3.awing:—

This writ: petition is £iJ;ed_4;:a.i.£§”‘ ;;e;gjz;ié’i§:;ad 1* V’
by the order datad 2o.e.2?ace%%%zsagaaci.iL”%s::;}%M’-L2§i:»¢_

Karnataxa State DiAs”p1_1_ta§ v- AI§§£:i’ra§sa.3.’

Commission, Baxlaaloge. ‘2.§I).6..”2″9€3B .A..;$rhvaz:ein
tha «said Comtairmiofi the Execution
Petiticm with_ a.__ liiishirtjg ;i;S’«a:’.titiox:er to
move the take steps to

z:acovcr_ ..t:1:a_ award.

2. herein had. filed a.

c<:r@l§:i._z1t _:Cc1t::;)l§;ifii::.I*I<:.106/97 on the file of

,f tl'.m '§{;'£na.t&l;a §t:&t:'ibivCons11r:3.ar Disputes Radrassal
VAV (i:.er:einafter callad as "State
g:at:.t'I:fIfi.;4:=::VIsiV':::vL'%*..«'Ea-seeking £92: a direction to thfl

–:.f_jfv.- 4._’;a§panciaa§§§t to pay to the complainant a. sum of
along with interest at 24!: par:

from tha date of ccxwlaint till the date

payment alleging deficiency at service.

\s3*

mxmwamem. W

«now

‘ ‘A*€’_.”~4*Vf’«-N’* v~=..{:_~’w’fwsvmvnIv* Wewr! N-wuru ur” nnnlvnnnmfl Hwy?! UUUEU mr MRKNREMKA ?”EN.,:7rH €..’€.J1.§K’¥ U?’ ififlflwfiefflfik HIGH C

N-atica was czaused tr.» the wamplaimmt. Attex

enquiry, the said complaint was
mt-dean dated 1.1.2093 and the xaspcajiialifi’

d.iz-acted to pay the total sfLu*a~o.f

with interest at 15% p.a. :E”::Var£ ‘i§1.28–. i§.§§u

the data of payment and V>c_§s.ts “jwas ” L’

awaxdati to the petifiifoneg——-1;é’f=:¢:i1;., .f6::vv..¢2;Q$cuti¢n
at thn said _ the State
Cotmuission; §#.10/O9 New
311w. I1g;*’ :;:_h’1ge’: ,:,A.;41§:;v..’1i_Ex3e&n%_i’9z=;Wfietition since
the r!!6.l’.’rnw2:a.:§.a1_an&§1;a issued and the warrant

also coul&L4._._Vfiatse:§.’*v¢d upcm the raspendant.

air:-aaxiy retamzeci 1:43 the
fi§tn¢§i§’aioner to recover the amount :3 if

of land revenue by issuing a
under Section 25 at the Gamma:

Act, the state Commiauion dismissed
‘-§:::ec11tion petition with liberty to the
)”‘§ia;’*§:’Titi<3nax::.: herein-decree holder: to mcwe the

Deputy Caurtnissiorzer to take steps to recover

\93

— – — — »–V_.«-.:-»-~ w M–m-r-«w wwm w -mm-mum mm mm-um W mmmmm mm «mum we mmmnm mm; c

6:1

t the amount as per the award. Being aggrieved by

tha amid order dated 20.5.2003, t1;;3%j%%%%;;;;=

petition is filed.

3. we have heard trgp

appearing for the writ péi:-j,tiofia_fi”.

‘Q . The lea.mq<i…Vcou;1s%':iv}_:'–#ii.1:a;;1i;:i:'e<'3. tint the
Stats: Commission f_' j 11a§tifi9d in
dismissing t}.11es– ea;er:;;'iVi':V';L r:~_E:'rV::§ the said
ixqmgnad 13¢ aside.

ififixcafsafizl considaxratican to

the c:::z1t:A3#.’.-1r:;t:’:i.§:ax1′-s:§f–j. ‘t1f;ée:«._ :laéizned ceunael appuaring

for tlfw petu.i.’;:i_onér scmtinizad the mat-nxiai.

‘2’:.«’*V3?;g ‘T11iVz’:sn,t¢az:iaa1 on record ahow that the

é fiJ.od by the writ potitiaxzaz in
.f;§:g:i;,:’1iain§% No..106/9′? has been alltmed by the
Cotnsnissiazz by order datad 1.1.2oc3 and

Certificate has alraady 2253:: sent: to» the

Deputy Commissioner: to: recovery at the amount:

W

«mm mm am.