IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED "ms THE 29"' my OF JULY,
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE MOHAN S:ff--i."\..I5§!'i"#\I_§3A'é'7-»f4)'Uij-aVR"=.1,_*é
WRIT PETITION NO.29V3f'6~{} OEEOO9 _(GM4vRES) :3
WRIT PETITION .'3N...On29'_3'€VJ'3 2009 (GM--R~ES)
IN WRIT PETITION I\viC3;~"§.S?36_;fV1;--__['L:9_aO(:3x9v_
BETWEEN ~ 1'
Murugesfyc 1I.;._ 3 * V
Aged a:bOuEt"33Ef,vea'i?3'
S/0 Ch't:nnappa'iy'«1n_V * _ '
No.189,'-GoI.taha.IIi'«.'Q '
Anjanapura Post '
Uttarahalii Hobli '
Ban.»g.;atOre~560"G6__2. ..PetitiOner
. :'(ay,"S::1E:i;rt§n.._D' Rozaréo, Adv., for
__S*r'; aJ'aga'd,_E:es?~..a '3.N., Advs., for Alternative Law Firm)
M/s,'I':1eru Cabs Company Pvt, Ltd.,
A. ,(F0r'merty V~Link Taxis Pvt, Ltd.,)
V Having its office at
"No.90/4, 2"' Floor
ORDER
During the course of arguments, iegairned
advocates appearing on both the sides _
matter be referred to arbitration and”**.:rj’:EateV”.Voifi.v”
arbitration be at Bangalore. it israiis’o..iag’iie’e’d:”by”Vbiogthgi
the parties that the Arbitra’i._iT~r.iV_buna!Vshaiii’.:Vde.§:i’de
question as to the ,.–existen~e-eh’f-_a’i’id va”i’id.i.ty_.:§of the
agreement of arbitration with other
questions.
In__yViewao~f1’Vrthe’afo’r’e’rne_Vn’tioined submissions, it is
not net-,es’sary to go into merits of the
matter. 2
the iiii “ease of the petitioners that the
i”a.g’i;eeiAn*i’er,.3;V___in’:;’q’uestion is obtained by the respondents
V «V by “‘i:iiay~Vi:ngv “fraud and that therefore matter need not
‘:g,b”e’iisentsfor adjudication to arbitration.
LA
M5,.
accordance with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1995. The sétténg of the Arbitral Tribunal wou.iEjdf:b*ei”aVt
Bangaiore.
The Arbitrai Tribunal Ls_hai.i..4éA.f’deci’cfe’*–:”ori».._JVE.t1s:’
jurisdiction first. Which n’.:ea.__ns, t’i*.e”o_uesti’o.nv_re!a,tinvg
to existence and the valEdEty_!4_i:o-fetaiibitrationlagreement
shat? also be decEdeo”*~b”y.AtiA1eggeaiérnsecipi’Arbitrator aiong
with the other _l*SS__U€s,-“”‘Th:ifs creek smgbiinot be treated
as a prece__dent_ fjtit’u re,
Wrétaioetitfléio aVr:eVV’Vdisp’o_sed of accordingiy.
t Sd/-‘-‘
…..
V*ck/1’1l{~._