High Court Karnataka High Court

Siddappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 17 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Siddappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 17 March, 2008
Author: C.R.Kumaraswamy


3% mg %~%I§:~=% saga? £3? %<,&Rff\§.&:§'A;i;L5:j;s;E:L%V% “‘

m:2°”§§ THIQ “meg 1??” airs? :$_’?;:* ~:;ém§:z&;:::é~%’ ‘-7

§E§’M§

‘E?-éfi m§»:*%§…E §%_’j§R.Eii$f§’E.£iE..£’.’Rf§<L}§¥§;fi;R§;S%?§A§¥?{

CREMESQAL RE'az'ES"E-{$5. 9?§f::%}*:jmExé%"§~2%fsVf,,::53? §§ 2&5

gsmsgai

2; %

sga R£%§'%§;;5;?§5;*%.i§§;:a§.i;E%<+?z.8;

_ _§s§§':::._é;aé;f.::;:Jfs" 2155 .';_'EA??;fi_fl_
gain::é~.§2,:i:,%a:%.,':*s.,sARE

2 §§::é??g *
35%;} E%é%.§¥'E3'-%{??;'{% %fi;;§.:g:<;%§

_ _ A$§::» _§Es*:3.i'JT""£§ 'YEARS
::::£€: ,$;:Z;R§é£§%.,?i$R§

§:"%gi5@,§§£
2 VVj%.~:¥:3 §?%§%.§'=§fE,&?P,é waaiagag
;%;;§v;i2;_§~;s;g£:z;#' 3g "¥EAR§
;%s§;zc:;a?a;§;§
" _§;;; ARE RESEQINQ $53'
"E§aéEé$E?s§&E..§.,E 2z::_;,A§§
'?§i,..§}§<; gagfiizxa?

s:$”%”§:£”:” Eéfiégfifi? ,.§E’?’E’?;”f;$§*«é§R§

ifiir’ fig? §§~%§%§?’éfi?§¢.% ?*E§C§”§’%.§iF?;f fiifiiii}

a/

“gm
AEQS

“?§-{E §7§Zé3’E G? %{§;R?§§§’°§K§z
E’? E;.%§A§.,,%<(}'§" iQ£JR,e5s§… L'
PQEJCE S"§"A'?"E$?*é H?;E§§§F*§§:E?a§'s"7 .. :2. b «

{BY $3: a $§¢.A:<a:$%%&;g, :»–§€;,§§; .L%[A_ifLV " " %

CRLR? 2% FELES z.:;$.3s%_? A§§é§_ é$;»Q1 T.:;§:; ;:2 ;"% 8%?

ggzfgcwg %'$a THE ?§"§":"s;":'$£':%s%:§'::2$ §a.ma:s;%a%?;:g2% Agmg
mg Eassgmgm" A§:;:%%.;aa3g&" :}sg*a;?ia'a% :9.?;::–§ éaggag 3?
T%~§E RS. F'§'€-§§, Bs,a§s:;::;';:::.;’;;%e;}?aé€;5:3;s§ mg Aagg
“‘§”§-%§ 3¥;..fi§$?v%£§*€’T§’ ,&§’é§…€i}}?;Q,E§’1″§.VA§§’?Ev§’§?§;§;—.’2.€}§ gaggaas 3′?
mg :3 A3m;.’2$g3E~*£, §1és.€%fi*§%i.;;;:%”§§.

_ “§”%~%E§ ??~¥§?:”f§féf’:a:;4§~:%%AV%::@:*:;§(?4@ 3&3 FQR. 3-§EAREE’§S “‘E”%==§E§
@232; “§f’:~:;E:’:*:s:.::%.fz’=:%§;:$’§Lé’§%;% gsaagzaszssa:

QEEER

_V”§*%”;é:2:$?§§”:2§§:a% §L§%fé$§§?§ :?%*et§E§§§’2 is ffiaé iifiéfiéf geaifizzg

fig iha C$:.,m§ei far iéée §%:§:§a2*:e€§

§’%’e.:gfE§:%§§ fiat §S§§é the jaégmafii am may éaiad

A. :%§a,?;’*§£:’§:@§ ggsgad $1; Efia Eaameé E ?”3″$ ESE, $a§a%$<§: Efé

2_ C':%';§a, §%E§.i,;'§§§§ gm aégs aha jségrsaafii am aréar daieé

' ~' 28§2,.2§G§ Qfififiéé 32;: {Em E: figédé ,'§§%"§?C; gagafieifii is': Cg

;?**é$,3281;'§§¢

W3" . .

25 I mxge heard the Eeamed Cea;V:1.$ieiVV’:’f%§;¢”‘i§:e

gsatétimafs 52 Wei} as ihg marneé §-Sigh Ci5§;;é”;-*_::

Piaaéer fer the rasgiszzéent,

3: “fine raéavani fa%e::t__g E$a ‘:’§§ra”:; :9 F;§i’§$ ,:’a.s=;=a:’;a§r.ia €afs

faimasg:

Thai an Q: fiaszgendi
\;’§%§agg, iéwe a5c%.z_:s;,»=92<§, _ ' 1 ;~E'%§éarr$E with the
Ca;*§':®§a§z'§;3;§%€?l:,5g§'§*:L§?$%?:éaa'¥:3%§§;'%_.%¥*§::§§5 E§:–<;::5::éi takes fycm the
§an£5.._%f_'$§%é§.a¥.3:{é;' ::G;é:'§:§V::i:h$§ than aha gégier Q? the
a::::;+A$5e§§L,:':.§a éasarzaé between the amagsaé and

:%'gje"a:a:}:e":§§§'§'::$is'§§ arzvid Q: aggaaséteé iha {:§)f°'¥'"%§§%§%"–:&§"%t wétéx 5::

hégfif £2 agsazgétafi :%*s& C§¥"%"%jfi§§§:E'¥&%"*;§iI €33; maang

V_"-é::f a' ~i?'%§§Véris-:"bag' fiack am i;%§§?:'2 sné A3 gaggfit Ma Q?

'§;*-..:fi;,..__};; -fzéézzgaztvai ?;?":i;§§'&?§'§f 2%: bgngéeg vggfe '?am%<en and

.. ,;a;i:e':'*:*:§%$::é; %::: sasfirage §'%§?' rmsjagty by gagiiéng has" Sayea

V' *as€§ when 33% §:e%';;?§a r 9? 222% £m*:z§§ais2§;';t rzggheé Ea yegcge

;?:a2'j, {Em aasaggaifi aggaisétaé %*2:%:":: aeagiizh; 2229;?" %:a:":ag avg
§i?%e:*a§;I effaaagg §:s:':%$§*;a:::Ee mafia? §%C§§€}§"§$;
323, 324, 3% am 5% 212%; 3:24; Q? 359:.

U

Wém
é: The gurrs am sumianae 5? the zgféa

tréai Qeur: are as amfier:

£33 The Eéjzgries $;;$ta:§.séég.§”._§g{‘=–. 9§’;i:§§:,,_ fas”§n..

mrrabgrateé by the medégaé ‘éasfiazngeg$z§%?§,’:’_§<':e§fi:§.:* V§:. 'i¢$
apinaé mat 2&3 irsjaggéag ééé'-r: :§f§:..%':r$. ;§§2§ cam be
msgéség if the §eE$_';:.n and 2;

‘§’%:ese ?*r§Qs,§ aim fiwééd–§”y:vV.’§§:é;§§;’9ns$ Tfierafsre

aswsaci asfig ig.._g;§;%:::~,§: if E:%:$”é§:f1ie:z;_:’e=}’ ‘;+;-Méésizabise zmées’ S@€§§§§’%-

32%ffVififégg-.:j§és”” §%,i$§S§§%&;”f§ E35 :¢%.v’\§-3 are gigs

g§:r;*3§a:*’fiéE:§e:;vé”§§§ iiéé §%2ad%a§§ eyigéruza 593$ tgwe éfijwies aye

:2a%:§”;?é§ §%;%»”~3 has fiamsgg’ ihat érsjzsréas

4®%”i..;?§%:w3 {:§§*:”§§:2:’atas with {ha meéicgi &:s§§a:”a:a

‘ $525 §§2:§ ‘;$i~:§§V§f §if’§§£,§§”§§$ sgaserg caiggaé §§% the aémgseé by hitting

§2:§§§*:___1?i~%2a%;” éarsfig, T?”§$§”£§§E’$ zhe iriaé §§i..§§”§Z Ema _%’;e.%é fiat

V’ v __a§’;€;c;:5€§£ are ggéétzs :3? ma asffggaéa p:::’z§$%:a?§§g ijfifiifi? gaciiess»

323 3? E?C;

Q/’

_”g_”

3 “?”%2E$ Cam: En sréer ta $%tE§fy_.’§”%$e§A§’ ;§§– «t§§:——-.%i%%§

éegaééiyg cwracirzags 322$ §¥’S§3E.’.§.9;§;_’;I’ Q?”£E’%ée– .’;vf%s€%:;2%v:ég§’L-Va’§§’iai_

genzanca recsrgeé !;:y iha Cmsézg; §’;::é§e:.%’%;2: §a%;’& ::3%%;:$§–~.§§*1:.%:%*:a

tréaé Cam: §’§C{}%’=a:I§S 35 2rvSa_:3%€”‘a;$ t%3a§’v-3V;;:.s:_§%§§;销;a::s.§fi:–~1re£§;<z:§Ls,

am axgméfiaé tinsV_§*s:§§e5s£§':%';::%'?%;'§"2_ge gr¢sa£_;:t§:?n asgétaasgas

am aésa {ha §;§z:;2;2"2'é'&;~s':%:a2'3%–e§%–§:§e§':§m._

:3. 'm%§;: és '€:a5%%€.§J§v%§_¥E:é€3i~%€:3as§$§, She figs

gtaieé $9": Ezgsazk$53;¥::—!:*s.r:§ééj'j':;V'§w': §–§'z§a:::a;§a§ baieng is '£19 sama

"z§§§§f§§§1 §%'§?:;–V:§§ §;§.5é&-.§:s.2:§:" sgzak, gha brsasght. mi? farm i%"E$
Eaafi'-«Q? ét%€§ an :h& max: éag; 3: amat 533%

am? ;%;Lz?:.g%§:vvs%ée :é~;.;§§=.ééé 2% %:@%.:$$,. $3 is $3 was: EQ %":&§"'

,§"%:i§§i§f%zi§: Vhezniiéai an :59 gratgégzsg fisay, gm QiJ§§'°;¥'=§:§$;'

_ }ir:i§%.:§%" ':?2tLé§§_ §%$€;Q%;m&i§"§€;'§ A::«$§:;;%:3;a§§a gggassétefi :?°§&§" %¢=a§?;%'&; as':

_T§§:f_ %;j.*:3&z;%;g $2 Eagagga azsgazfiizeé §”§&f E3? maang 5? g
?::%%é…§b 5@s’;–‘ j$f’%§§:*”? baak ancé imgéz aszé $3 Evéaééggga cazggééé; §’:£Ei§é mi’

é”!%?””§V”%-§%’.3:’z;:”§.V,; §§’%€§’e§§3§ mg” hgrzgéeg zaégra §r§§<g;'2 332$ aiiamgiefi
AA _::2 @.%:,:§§'a§§ ézaz" r":2@§$$i:%g £3'; $%£§§§§"é§ §'§€? Sazraa 33$ amen ha;

=.,_%;_%%'§§?é§§" same is fie? regcaseg fifiiiééefi $432 aggazgitaé him

%'¥§§?§'i %2§:s"2§§g; '?%:e:*: at gags: 113$ gm Eaejgm a

€/

Hg."

€§§’?’§§§§¥E%”‘%€Z i1*§?£>§’ei§’%% fiagaiiést ?Q2%:e ag gar §g§i;E5V”14§’V$i;:%22g

he: cgasgmaxamingiéays, 3% states, é:E’:s::” .:’?é»;§ra:”‘:%§ _:=«£’::__

partéag Er; thew véééiagai $§;%é§’§2’€3;<;?ég;:§a;«_§;*'*§§j?a;a;'§§ L'§*€'%e:%j A'

§$§Q§°§§S is fiat; §;3,z':'\g, £."g15;«;§,,"-_§'%i'a§ia§§%§'~..a¥%§:"£v;'g'gi3f

gaarasagga $53 beg-%§rs§ $243;-§~}:¢ j'§§%'és "§'e:%§ag the

gagggestézm gig: is; %:e;' t%:aj;-"'§§*§.£=;::'–§z'é;}%"a:;";£ :a'iL:'s£:§w-%i§ ézezr was a

$;#§E§nénf'§égE:e§ §.?'§j;:,3§";«*" $

EL ?}1'%;*;,_§§ %2§?§e~&;&§%E:.z§§';%(isév,–~—-~§~§§ 225$ gzaiaé 3": his

a¥.%§§;%'E€5&f'i:§$VE2€_§ViZ¢LE5$饧g_.?*'§§§§5;%§§a €';«3::E§?'2'=:. ma $2' mg @353 $5

the"{':§§:":§§§::::é;€:'.'§,é*;%«_n§.:'§%fi:ag €:¢::sa:;L;azz:§'y*, her mszgiag

%«%'§.%°'§ %,:§*{;E{_§aV.v;3::::' he aim aizgmgzgfi :3 f,}%;.%§;Zf'§§§ fie:

'*L:?z%5§{:§§s§:%g..&?§:«* §:.é§§'é;'ré§ fig? figree, "?§':@2;g§': '§§'E§S zaséészaga figs

'V'_.%:§'T»:;%$'§<:_§;:é$:*f2§'{i:&§§ §"'§§i%'2§?%§ $5 aéézziieé m fiésfiaééaxze %:§$

A .._5éa€§§&:3:Lé;

_ *:2, §,’:!%.;’,;% 35 3§’%=§'{§§€:F” ifijiéffié wétnagg, imég gates

= Mg esgééengg gggramratag 2%§::§: ifsa $\§§§§€”¥£& 5? ?,%’§’,:,

“%”§*:@:.:§%°s %.:§%:§:?; %fié’§’§§”*;@§$ wag £m§§;~e:£as”s2%€’2esi, rssihing $3

éiéfiiéfi it} éégbgééazfa mg avéfieagefi

9/

Wig”

thgm, ‘§’?:$ éréaé fiaasrt figs agmagiaiad $22 e%;§:::§é;:T£§ aaé

gaszaséséaé ‘{§”E€ miétégmrga ‘$3 agpeflaza €£%~L€?T”§_&’§§’:;?’f.§€§VV”i?’;§'{

the at§iE@:2e;’s have fiaan 5% E22: mmsééfiegfi Eéi’ 1§;§”;é*{;”§’§5a’§=_
$ Q ‘g’ _ .3′ _ ._

Cigasytg Yhem $3 cqzsszairrzéski: §§m:;§:’:§ N93? «f;é’:::%-i%;’i!%§é”::3V §>éé:”‘£E3e:’:g.__ “V

zaxzégégazai §:;s’§§é§§¥;ée:§,, €:Z?%§3 Cé:@r§?’–..%:a$ §ie::s§'”x;§§’%;* ‘§’§{*r%§:=:=e§

ggawar ta’: éaiaafgfe with ‘it;?:<%;é"=:a::2a:§é*:f:a§3A%=;.-fégzééégzg cat? Fasix

Lérsmar tfia <";::;r:*,:,.s:"2'zs;;;'i:;,~2.:ja£e::'; wT§j5§_i:?2e :§§§§%§e§% that we

?5§§'§€§;§§"'§.§ rezgyéeéj Q3; §2"é{e é:5%:::§' {f:;=;2~r§":.§2~:*§__éize a§§e§§3.tg mg:

is Saga! 3 3233 'C€°§§%'§£§;

ii?’ iézai arégeg 53;’ my

€§€3§E?;§%;§§%*e”%5£§%¢%”§ $55 ag wfiaifigr 5% safitagzae émgzgsazé 2:2

_”;é§’i%.a__§é;,%é’f*iv§i%§r:A;é§’§…._§.a5er”‘§$$ is be rgfigaefi £§?”§S§d$§’§%?§ iéza

‘ }’§s§§:: i§”‘;€ gatézésmrg éfié éfzre fismgéaiaaaz» E’: is aésa 2%

ma ezzédagrése £3? ;i’t’=§&;2: %:%:a?: 5% 3% bimsgééi sgiééa gm fmm

253% §§?’§§§ :31? ?Z§”:€ aggzggeég time zaéag 5 szgazarrgé §»3€:2«*s;e€:3;

§°*%§5’§€§’§ afifi {fig eaégigg’ £2?’ iéta aigasgeéé aéné 35%

W,

“13-

fa: 5 gggésé cf ihrwe §’§%£::¥”2:%’%;§ fa: £923 Qffaflifi e;;L§§2»iT5§2ab£g

Léfiéfifii’ ggsiéasz 35% {E93 3:; EFC,

2%, Q5: carefszi e:<a:*:":§:%$t%«.:;»s': sf :§:g;_éa:,i%§'éA§'§'§§_m

£335: 5%;-E am 93-2 gazzgaé gémgié §§:§ §§r§;§$';__ '§{e5’s
am atiamgtaé tr; mgéfage .§’%’;L’a¢.2%”:””s”:a::.;§e$*’i§:*_ §’;:«V-igzgéééégég Ear sari
An: wag 5:3 jaéé fig %,t%;%;e:,*sA_da%;’§* ” f:”%”:éz*g’s;§’a ,£%.}%i E$ ggrszangeé

is pay a G? 9&5-?;’:,Q,5’%’,”‘é%rz’:_.&z§vT§i;Ai’§ge_§§2f ifs: rag affanaea

§u:’*:%s%*za§§g»– §;’:2,g:%jé:%:* $§¢§’:§a:::é§» sag 334 Q? 3%, égz;

§a§’a;L:§%_:3 Emgyégérzmeni far 15 daggg T&~;-3
$53 3a§:%i;e锑:<:§§V.7:§–:§;%*g?"—g 't?§§%e S?' Qgki?fi$£E;[" €:L%?"?§é.é§ai§%_$*§§§E €92'

t§iaé%_ égfféfrétfig %;:§g§:ig":2a§:§§.e iéfifiaf agatésgég 3233; 32%; mg: 3%;

in de:"é2;:%–:§—-*:} i§§'i{7§§§"§% fiémgéa E;*2":§;r'§s€2%":%?:g:2§ 253:? mg

' – arafaaé: &::t is; aiiféfiagiagé aggéggt $3 mageai

" A ':;§'2E:§%a: »:;é%§?§f:-2&3 §,§j§'?§§§' ggstigrs =1 3% 9% 3%, "§"%2&:"a§e:"& §x"3 is

§?;&v:'i::i.'&a p§::é§§aa§%:s:% zmiéar $$£§§§§'§§i 323? 32% mg 35% Q?

n fiéfaagéi 5:1: :.§§°"§$%%' 3 gémgéa E??i§§'%$£§§'1;§'§'%€?'%§ 2%!" %§

M35"

gaggg 2:5: j ~
am 35:; 5?’ W43′ %

324

323;

‘ {gggfi 5 ‘
gmgzzsw

A g,..a?’:”~2z’=«£w1: ‘
, Eg§;fE&f?§'”~, ¥’
y gzza €95″w* ‘
Q3 9555 :3